Phony diversity

Sandia said:


It all goes back to the words of that great bumper-sticker: "Not all conservatives are stupid, but all stupid people are conservatives."

Seriously, I'm about 60% with you on this one, Ishmael.

Defining "diversity" in terms of race - exclusively - rather than in terms of background, experiences, ideology, or thoughts... is mind-defyingly stupid.

And I have enough experience in academia to recognize the rhetorical rigidity of higher education when it comes to race, affirmative action, tolerance, and "oppression."

But the true nature of liberal - intellectualism is critical and questioning; you will find more tolerance - on most issues - on college campuses than in any other place.

Where did your son go to school?
I completely agree with sandia.

I scare myself, sometimes. :(
 
A point Shy Tall Guy, tell me all about Calvin Coolidge I want to know why he is so great, specifics of course. If someone scales back enough (or studies close enough) maybe Reagan's theme(GWB does a knockoff) is the right way. Personally, I don't think so...maybe the high intellects just don't like the idea of slashing taxes, building the military, and then finding somewhere to fight. In my opinion the adminstrations are too consistent to prevent a large number of people from simplifying it to the above.

I think the whole American dynamic lost its chance at a pure strain-when Adams, Hamilton, Burr, Jefferson, Madison, and Marshall didn't work things out. It has forever become this side vs that side and it's not sexy to be in the middle. I'm not surprised that PROFs lecture bias because the statement above. However, I'll still say get better conservative leadership figures. I think Jefferson was a borderline menace but it's more interesting to study him than Reagan or GWB. To many Clinton is more appealing to analyze, there is a personal conflict involved and he makes varying judgments. I'm in agreement in that I say teach the middle, I wouldn't teach that Reagan was all together great but he had some effective ideas.
 
Shy Tall Guy said:

Everyone hears history profs talk about how the terrible facists under Hitler massacred 6 million Jews (and 14 million other people), and the Left often associate the Right with facism - spitting it out like a curse word - "FACIST!".

But how often do you hear any of these same history profs talk about the 40 million that Stalin murdered? If it is mentioned, then it is quickly followed with the excuse that Stalin was a disturbed paranoid (of course, Lenin had no such excuse for the 4 million he murdered), and then in the same breath they say that this wasn't really socialism. No mention at all of the 37.8 million killed under Mao Tse-tung.

There you go again... using facts and logic to support your reactionary views... thereby creating a hostile and threatening academic environment...

Am I going to have to kick you out of school along with Ishmael? :p
 
If Hitler was responsible for 21million Soviet deaths and Stalin 40million, it is something that the USA still had to engage in a 50year Cold War. As for the factual information and profound logic that STG presented, how can you prove Stalin and Mao are treated lightly in lecture halls everywhere.
 
70/30 said:
A point Shy Tall Guy, tell me all about Calvin Coolidge I want to know why he is so great, specifics of course.
I don't understand your point; I have never said anything about Calvin Coolidge, nor have I held him up as someone to revere, etc. :confused:

I'm in agreement in that I say teach the middle, I wouldn't teach that Reagan was all together great but he had some effective ideas.
Excuse me if I miss your points as I am having trouble following what you are saying, but please bear in mind that I am not a Conservative, I am a Libertarian, so there is much that classic Conservatives say that I do not agree with, and much "liberals" say that I do agree with. This comes back to what I think should be taught in schools; the truth. If you teach the truth, and let people make their own interpretations and reach their own conclusions, then you have done your job.

FWIW, I am no fan of Reagan; he was behind some major infringements on our civil rights, but then so were a number of other presidents, left and right.
 
70/30 said:
If Hitler was responsible for 21million Soviet deaths and Stalin 40million,
Where did I say that Hitler was responsible for 21 million Soviet deaths?

I stated that "Hitler massacred 6 million Jews (and 14 million other people)". Certainly some of those Soviet citizens, but I was speaking mainly of civilians killed outside of war operations - such as people shipped off to concentration camps and gassed there.

it is something that the USA still had to engage in a 50year Cold War.
If your point is that there were no Soviets left for the US to worry about, then think back; Stalin was in power from 1929-1953. That is approximately 24 years. Need I say more? Or can you reach the obvious conclusion for yourself?

As for the factual information and profound logic that STG presented, how can you prove Stalin and Mao are treated lightly in lecture halls everywhere.
Evidence: How many people have heard of the 6 million number for Hitler? How many people have heard of the 40+ million number for Stalin? How many have heard of the 37+ million number for Moa Tse-tung? How many people go to college? Why do so many people know about Hitler's massacre and so many are ignorant about Stalin's and Mao's?

Could it be that somebody is leaving something out when they teach history? Why do you suppose that could be? Can it be embaressment that socialist regimes murdered twice as many civilians as a "facist" regime? Can you say bias?
 
Last edited:
Administrations and wars get studied. Maybe the overall conservative, liberal, and libertarian stance should be taught instead. Coolidge supposedly was the closest president to a pure conservative, I'm not surprised that he gets little airtime. FDR however presided during an interesting era, it gets studied throughly. Truman and Kennedy had exciting years and they get studied. I think everyone knocks down LBJ and Nixon isn't chastised so much anymore, so maybe that isn't consistent with the DEMs vs the REPUBs in the classroom. As for libertarians, I think you've received a blessing that Thomas Jefferson is glossed over. Maybe you need to claim Madison and Monroe more, if you want in depth studies on hands off government. In my opinion until administrations stop becoming the focal point not so much will really change in the way history is represented.
 
Shy Tall Guy said:
Where did I say that Hitler was responsible for 21 million Soviet deaths?

I stated that "Hitler massacred 6 million Jews (and 14 million other people)". Certainly some of those Soviet citizens, but I was speaking mainly of civilians killed outside of war operations - such as people shipped off to concentration camps and gassed there.

If your point is that there were no Soviets left for the US to worry about, then think back; Stalin was in power from 1929-1953. That is approximately 24 years. Need I say more? Or can you reach the obvious conclusion for yourself?

Evidence: How many people have heard of the 6 million number for Hitler? How many people have heard of the 40+ million number for Stalin? How many have heard of the 37+ million number for Moa Tse-tung? How many people go to college? Why do so many people know about Hitler's massacre and so many are ignorant about Stalin's and Mao's?

Could it be that somebody is leaving something out when they teach history? Why do you suppose that could be? Can it be embaressment that socialist regimes murdered twice as many civilians as a "facist" regime? Can you say bias?


The 21million Soviets that died as a result of WW2 was something I added, not to debate you but to show how the COLD WAR could have been blown out of proportion. As for Stalin and Mao, they largely killed their own countrymen. It's their history not so much ours, it doesn't get studied as close. That doesn't mean professors approve of Stalin and Mao tactics.
 
With texas conservatives hijacking the writing of high school text books teachers everywhere will have less and less freedom to explore issues with their classes. I teach a college history class and it amazes me what kids don't know. I think the masses of Americans hate history. We bastardize the truth to fit the MTV generations view of the word. Fast cuts and a love story. What I know absolutely about American History is that we continually change. We done did our conservation sunday come to meeting less means more and let the queers die era. I am hoping for some sanity.
 
70/30 said:
As for Stalin and Mao, they largely killed their own countrymen. It's their history not so much ours, it doesn't get studied as close.
Many of the millions Hitler murdered were Germans, yet we hear about this all the time and rarely hear about Stalin and Mao. You would think that 40 million people being murdered would be at least as significant a historical fact as the oft repeated 6 million number for Hitler.

Could the reason we rarely hear about the 40+ million (almost 43 million actually) Stalin murdered, and the almost 38 million murdered under Mao be because conservatives and the right are often called facists and compared to Hitler? That the millions killed in the name of socialism and communism could be used in a counter argument?

That doesn't mean professors approve of Stalin and Mao tactics.
I didn't say they did - I inferred that they may be embaressed by it. Why? Because many are socialists (they call themselves "progressives" or "liberals", but they are really socialists) and the millions were murdered in the name of socialism.
 
Where the hell are you people going to school? I've never experienced (nor heard of anyone experiencing) emmense gaps in their history education. I'm a bit of a history buff on my own time, so I would have noticed if huge tracts of information were left out.

Whenever I've had a prof that gave their opinion - they stated that it was their opinion, and asked for opposing ones or other thoughts/comments. It brought out a discussion.

Sorry fellas. This sounds like the same old witchhunt .. the same old *the Liberals are ruining our Grand Old America!*

Do you realize that you sound so far removed from reality and common sense that it's just fucking funny? No, of course you don't, or this joke of a thread wouldn't have become 5 pages long.
 
Hitler didn't rule very long and much of it was during hopefully the deadliest war mankind will ever see. He was the aggressor on a global scale and was a media whore, it is always going to be closely studied. Stalin and Mao tried to make 10's of millions of people disappear with as little attention being afforded as possible, the situations can't be compared as easily as you say. We were at war with China and Russia during much of the 80million person purge, they actually did us a favor. Maybe you are right, we need more diversity through less eurocentric studies, then Stalin and Mao will get entire units based on their evils.
 
It's remarkable that those who have spent little or no time in the education profession all feel like they are experts on how it is and how it should be. Rather like me presuming to tell Bill Gates how he ought to run his corporation because I own a computer.
 
Hamletmaschine said:
It's remarkable that those who have spent little or no time in the education profession all feel like they are experts on how it is and how it should be. Rather like me presuming to tell Bill Gates how he ought to run his corporation because I own a computer.

But Dr., you're turning your students into socialists .. you just won't admit to your evil, evil plan to ruin the hope of America!!!!


Oh, wait, you didn't buy that one, either?

Damn.:rolleyes:
 
celiaKitten said:


But Dr., you're turning your students into socialists .. you just won't admit to your evil, evil plan to ruin the hope of America!!!!


Oh, wait, you didn't buy that one, either?

Damn.:rolleyes:

I don't plan on ruining the hope of America. I just hope to win the hearts of a few coeds. Yeah, that's evil, but I can fantasize about it.
 
Students are as they always have been. They want to get drunk and get laid. The only "ism" they're interested in is hedonism.
 
Hamlet and Celia, I'm spending my time trying to get Ishmael, Miles, and Shy Tall Guy to have some realization it is more complicated than the opening post stated. By all means, make a comprehensive post that STG can't find a couple of phrases to knock down or take my place and do the sparring. Much of what I say is conjecture, presuming you have extended specific experience, naturally you would have a better perspective than a student or corporate type.
 
Re: Re: Re: Phony diversity

takingchances42 said:


That would be perfect if that was what was happening. Students should be taught to think analytically and for themselves. There should be an objective discussion of ideas and government policies. There should be a free competition of a diverse range of ideas -- that is what going to a university should be about.

That is the direct opposite of the direction that American education has been moving in. There is no real debate -- if you disagree with the current belief system that is in power you are penalized in your grades, you are never hired as an instructor or professor, and if you are hired, you will never make tenure. A real debate and analytical thinking is not about just questioning government policies. It is about being able agree or disagree, freely, and to be graded not on your conclusions but on how your arguments are expressed.

No student should have to learn not to say things agreeing with half the country (politically speaking), in order to get good grades, or to later have a chance to get hired by a university.

Never said she was never penalized for speaking her mind, even though she went to a very liberal college. My question is, what would have happened if she had argued for a stronger defense, for the 2nd Amendment and against the Roe versus Wade decision? I suspect there are some areas you are allowed to disagree in, and others you are not.


I can't speak to your experiences, Chances, but I went to the most liberal school in the United States, and diversity of opinion was generally respected there.

You're right: It is about being able agree or disagree, freely, and to be graded not on your conclusions but on how your arguments are expressed.

This is the essence of liberal - intellectualism. Except for the "graded" part. You don't really need the grades; my school didn't have 'em.

If you were racist, sexist, or homophobic you probably would have been ostracized by at least part of the student body, but otherwise it was pretty much everything goes.
 
Hamletmaschine said:
Originally posted by Ishmael



I've been involved in dozens of academic job interviews, as both interviewee and interviewer. Never once have I asked to see or been asked to show a voter registration card. Never once was I asked about or heard anyone else asked about 'political leanings.'

I suppose such things have occurred and still do occur, but your assertion might lead one to infer that this occurs routinely in all academic interviews in all academic fields. That simply is not true.

This "tenured radicals" idea which has received a lot of popular press since the late-80s and has become part of our doxa is rather silly--like those urban legends about giant albino alligators in sewers and Snapple being owned by the KKK. It asks us to believe that "The Sixties" turned a bunch of middle-class white kids into fire-breathing Reds, in spite of the fact that their teachers were not.

Somehow, though, (the legend implies) when those "radicals" took over the halls of academe, they were able to neutralize or innoculate the students of my generation from the influence of "The Eighties"--which by the logic of this myth ought to have turned me and most of my colleagues into fire-breathing Conservatives.

And here's a news bulletin for you kids: those "tenured radicals" from the '60s? They're retired--or getting ready to retire--and they're more concerned about their 401K plans than they are about turning your kids into Commies.

Damn.
That was a well-written post.
 
celiaKitten said:
Do you realize that you sound so far removed from reality and common sense that it's just fucking funny? No, of course you don't, or this joke of a thread wouldn't have become 5 pages long.
I am glad you find it amusing, of course with all your years of experience with colleges of universities over the past 50 years you have much more informed point of view than I. Oh wait, I forgot, you haven't been around that long. Nevermind. :rolleyes:
 
70/30 said:
Hitler didn't rule very long and much of it was during hopefully the deadliest war mankind will ever see. He was the aggressor on a global scale and was a media whore, it is always going to be closely studied.
Agreed.

Stalin and Mao tried to make 10's of millions of people disappear with as little attention being afforded as possible, the situations can't be compared as easily as you say.
Yes Stalin and Mao did make people disappear quietly, but not without notice - and still little is said - it is virtually ignored.

We were at war with China and Russia during much of the 80million person purge, they actually did us a favor.
I am glad you can be so cavalier about 80 million innocent lives, but don't think anybody with a conscience would feel the same way. Certainly the Soviets and Chinese actually did themselves more harm, but at a huge cost to every human being, not just those in their countries.

Maybe you are right, we need more diversity through less eurocentric studies, then Stalin and Mao will get entire units based on their evils.
All I am asking for is that colleges and universities teach the truth and as much of the truth as they can, not just the truth they find convenient and non-embaressing.
 
Hamletmaschine:
“Students are as they always have been. They want to get drunk and get laid. The only "ism" they're interested in is hedonism.”


Students want to get drunk and get laid as much or as little as anyone else. Most students don’t lead hedonistic lifestyles, more than a few would have no idea what that word means, and most are very concerned with various ‘ism’s.
 
Shy Tall Guy said:
Evidence: How many people have heard of the 6 million number for Hitler? How many people have heard of the 40+ million number for Stalin? How many have heard of the 37+ million number for Moa Tse-tung? How many people go to college? Why do so many people know about Hitler's massacre and so many are ignorant about Stalin's and Mao's?

Could it be that somebody is leaving something out when they teach history? Why do you suppose that could be? Can it be embaressment that socialist regimes murdered twice as many civilians as a "facist" regime? Can you say bias?



Yes, yes, yes. I've heard about the forty million killed under Stalin (though last time I heard seems like it was twenty million.) And I heard about it in college.

But among other things, these people are not people who were killed in concentration camps, they're people who supposedly died due to Stalin's economic programs, right?

These numbers get thrown out because they supposedly prove something; but what do they prove? That you can assess the relative merits of conservatism and liberalism by the number of bodies laid at the feet of Hitler and Stalin?
 
Back
Top