Phony diversity

Lavy, some of these people haven't got the word yet that Individualism is dead. It's like that old, broken down fleabag of a dog that used to be so cute and made you feel all warm and fuzzy as a kid. You know in your heart that you ought to just take that sucker out back and put a bullet in its head. But nostalgia makes you keep it alive, even though it's outlived its usefulness.
 
Hamletmaschine said:
Lavy, some of these people haven't got the word yet that Individualism is dead. It's like that old, broken down fleabag of a dog that used to be so cute and made you feel all warm and fuzzy as a kid. You know in your heart that you ought to just take that sucker out back and put a bullet in its head. But nostalgia makes you keep it alive, even though it's outlived its usefulness.
LOL. I guess somebody missed the memo?
Sometimes, I could just kiss you, Hamlet. This could be construed as a threat, I suppose. ;)
 
LOL - there is no kissing in academe. You know that. We're all too busy converting Republicans into collectivist drones.
 
Hamletmaschine said:
LOL - there is no kissing in academe. You know that. We're all too busy converting Republicans into collectivist drones.
Well, no wonder people on campus look at me so strangely. Too much kissing, not enough indoctrination. Gotcha. ;)
 
Shy Tall Guy said:
I did, until your snide remarks deriding my point of view.

Later - or rather, so long.

Where the hell are you people going to school? I've never experienced (nor heard of anyone experiencing) emmense gaps in their history education. I'm a bit of a history buff on my own time, so I would have noticed if huge tracts of information were left out.

Whenever I've had a prof that gave their opinion - they stated that it was their opinion, and asked for opposing ones or other thoughts/comments. It brought out a discussion.

Sorry fellas. This sounds like the same old witchhunt .. the same old *the Liberals are ruining our Grand Old America!*

Do you realize that you sound so far removed from reality and common sense that it's just fucking funny? No, of course you don't, or this joke of a thread wouldn't have become 5 pages long.

Where in the hell was I attacking you personally? I was commenting on the fact that this is such a trivial issue, and it's been turned into the same old *liberals suck* thread that's been done over and over and over.

STG, I'm sorry if you personally took offense to what I said. Lord knows you've said more snide things than that to people. And I didn't pick out anyone in particular.

But then you, someone who has known me fairly well for nearly a year, gives me a smack in the face. Basically saying that I'm an ignorant ass because of my age.

That hurt coming from you - someone who knows me, and who knows how serious and non-fluffy I actually am in RL.

I make one comment that offends you and you dismiss my intelligence. Sorry, this doesn't seem anything like a rational reaction.
 
Very Impressive Debate

Hamletmaschine said:
LOL - there is no kissing in academe. You know that. We're all too busy converting Republicans into collectivist drones.

Wow!!! I tips me lid to you all!! Leave the discussion for bed and the intellectuals romp in and demonstrate a very impressive standard of debate!! Well done, eveyone . . . I shall have to revise my opinion . . . thinking is alive and well and existing in US education . . . perhaps it is too early to think about sixties style social change, but the seeds are there, being planted and waiting to grow . . . lol :) :)
 
Never - I read your post to say the students at your school don't get drunk or get laid more than other people.

Students want to get drunk and get laid as much or as little as anyone else. Most students don’t lead hedonistic lifestyles, more than a few would have no idea what that word means, and most are very concerned with various ‘ism’s.

Looking back, though, I see now you used the word "want," so I'll offer my apologies. :D



The essense of liberal - intellectualism is the willingness to have an open and critical mind; one that doesn't follow a particular dogma, and is willing to consider the possibility of being wrong.

At the schools I've been to, liberal - intellectualism has been - pretty much - alive and well.

There has been a tendency for multi-culturalism/diversity/oppression ideology to harden into a kind of dogma in academia. There are cases were people who have questioned it have been shouted down, name-called, and prevented from speaking.

On the other hand, UT, for example, has a professor who is famous - or infamous - for his stand on affirmative action. And yes, he is tenured.

The thing about a liberal arts education is that the fundamental guiding principle is deciding for yourself. That's really the point of the whole thing: the development of the kind of mind that can sift issues for itself and reach its own conclusions.

The politics of your professor really just don't matter that much in that kind of environment. In fact, if you hate 'em, it's that much more reason to study harder so you can show 'im that he's wrong. Yes, a good liberal arts education will encourage you to question the teachings of your parents, your religion, your politics, and all the beliefs that you bring with you.

That's the opposite of indoctrination.
 
Osculation Classes Anyone??

RisiaSkye said:

Well, no wonder people on campus look at me so strangely. Too much kissing, not enough indoctrination. Gotcha. ;)

Hi Risia, may I enroll in your next osculation class? lol :D
 
Originally posted by lavender
UncleBill -

I love how you turn an ideology into a mentality. I do not believe that there is any such thing as the *liberal mentality*. I think this is where I find your opinions incredibly biased, pointed, and misplaced.

The way you view politics makes it very hard for anyone with liberal beliefs to think that they could possibly be your friend. You group all liberals and claim they have some immoral mindset. You say it all the time. I think this is the most absurd of all of your arguments.

Because your worldview is liberal does not mean you are immoral. Simply because one's worldview coincides with the beliefs of the democratic party does not make them in any way, shape or form morally bankrupt.

When I argue about conservatives or libertarians, I do not attack their mentality. I attack the tenets of their beliefs. There is a difference.
By "Liberal mentality", I refer to those who ascribe to and advocate the political implementation of the values and ideals represented by the leadership of the political parties. These advocates virtually all advocate the use of force, i. e., law, to implement their beliefs. Since the initiation of the use of force is the most generic, most fundamental definiton of criminal behavior, it then necessarily follows that the morality of those who advocate such actions is in question by anyone who values and respects the concepts of rights and freedom. If this is absurd, please explain how you arrive at that evaluation. I have stated with pretty good consistency the tenets of my philosophy and political orientation over a fairly long period here.

That I expose the morality of those beliefs is necessary in order for me to convey to others the basis on which I reject these tenets and offer them an intellectually honest basis for choosing my position rather than the position of those who would enslave me along with everyone else. Otherwise, there is no basis for rejection since without reference to a moral basis, one set of tenets is as good as another. History has proven that capitalism is superior to collectivism in terms of societal success. America is the absolute perfect manifestation of the moral validity of capitalism. The corruption of capitalism with statism has brought about the current chaotic situation we are dealing with today.

The collectivists have set one faction of our society against another for the so very noble purpose of their own political power.

When you argue with most conservatives, you can't attack their morality because it's virtually the same as your own. Granted, there are a number of conservatives who differ but in most cases the difference is seldom in principle but more in the degree of collectivism to be inflicted.

When arguing with the Libertarian position, their moral basis is consistent and reason based where collectivism's is inconsistent, irrational and emotion based. You can't win the rational mind with such a philosophical offering. You can only win the support of those who either have abandoned reason or who have not learned it yet.

As to those who have Liberal beliefs, I have no problem with them believeing what they will. I have no problem with them living their lives as they see fit. I have no argument if they wish to create their own commune and live in a society of their own design and organization so long as membership is NOT mandatory and any member is free to leave at will.

But the Liberals are not so accommodating. It is they are determined via legislation to coerce my subjugation to their tenets. I do not seek to impose my beliefs on them at gunpoint but the reverse cannot be honestly offered.

This is the case with social welfare. I'm FORCED to pay although I know it's morally wrong and societally harmful.

This is the case with government regulation of virtually every facet of our lives. It is the antithesis of freedom yet it is the primary thrust of the Liberal political agenda.

Social Security, if practiced by a private citizen, is called bunko, a confidence game, a pyramid scheme, a Ponzi scheme and the individual would be prosecuted for it. But government practices this criminal behavior with impunity and the Liberals as well as Conservatives keep arguing as to how to save it. They should eliminate this criminal theft scheme if they wished to do the right thing by the American people. And note it was CREATED by a liberal (or Socialist), FDR.

As an Objectivist (and Libertarian), I see man as a heroic being. That his judgment is to be trusted and his life and his right to it is to be respected and valued. I see man as the achiever who leaves each succeeding generation with more than he received from the preceding generation. I see man's life as an end in itself.

The collectivist (and Liberal) seems to see man as a beast of burden whose purpose in life is to be yoked into involuntary servitude to his fellow man. That his right to life, liberty, property and happiness is secondary to his obligation to support and provide sustenance for those who cannot, have not or do not wish to earn it on their own. They seem to view man's life as a means to the ends of others.

This view of man legitimizes slavery despite the Liberals' cries against that abominable institution. Yet what is socialism if not slavery? What is Communism if not slavery? What is any variant of collectivism if not slavery?

I make no secret of nor do I obscure nor obfuscate what it is that I believe and advocate. The Liberals can't say that with any honesty. They mouth sweet smelling platitudes about helping the poor and downtrodden, the disadvanteged, the oppressed. And what is their solution to achieve this? To tread upon the property rights of those in society who earn their way and who produce most ably. To oppress the producer as a sacrificial animal on the altar of collectivism.

As an Objectivist, Libertarian and Capitalist I offer reward to the producer, the man who carries the improvement of mankind's general well being on his shoulders. [To clarify, I am not so arrogant that I actually mean that I provide some reward. By reward, I mean that I (and my ideological and political affiliates) respect his right to ownership of what he earns or produces. I do not advocate or hypothesize that anyone is owed a free ride on his ability to produce. If he chooses to provide said free ride, it is his choice for as many and as long as he sees fit but there is no obligatory mandate to provide it.] He earns his own way in society. The excess earnings (that beyond what he needs to support his own life and family) he invests in business which provides jobs and opportunities for others. Other parts of that excess he may donate to charity to help the truly needy or the unfortunate of the moment.

That he does so voluntarily is admirable. But to have his property stolen for the benefit of these same beneficiaries is an unspeakable atrocity because it relegates him to the role of slave since the tacit declaration is that he has no right to dispose of the property that he earned by his own efforts. This tacitly implies that he is not the owner of his own life since it is by the pursuit of sustaining his life that he produces this property (wealth).

As a Liberal, the offer is punishment for achievement. It is under the guile of benefitting the underprivileged of society but after 40 years of the Great Society and the War on Poverty, it is obvious to anyone willing to take an objective analysis that it has failed.

Socialism (collectivism) once again has failed. The purveyors say it's only because we haven't spent enough yet. But we have pissed away over $5 TRILLION. How mich more will it take? No answer other than: MORE!
 
Re: Re: Re: Phony diversity

Ishmael said:


Hmmmmmmmmm, another intellectual giant heard from. Sooooo, if you have an employee that is NOT doing his or her work at an acceptable level, you propose that giving them more money is the answer. Regardless of whether thev've earned it or not?

And giving a teacher a raise is not spending more money on education. It's giving the teacher a raise and hasn't done a damn thing to improve the education of the child.

Go back to your playbook HSJ, Bobby might want you to inflate the football or something.

Ishmael
ok if i had an employee who was NOT doing their job no i wouldnt give them a raise i would probably outright release them however i havnet gone through every teacher and america and evalitaed them the way you have my god man how do you find the time to judge EVERY teacher in america and come to the judgement that NONE of them are doing their job you must be the master of time management

increases teachers pay scale does in fact improve education beacuse it attracts more applicants and makes the job more competitive therefore teachers have to work harder for the money when you dont pay an employee a fair salary they look for other employment and it becomes more & more difficult to replace the employee who is not doing their job 'cause you have no fresh applicants

RAISE YOUR TAXES BIOTCH YOU JUST GOT TOOK TO SCHOOL!!!!!
 
Hamletmaschine:
"And a big Amen, to you, too, Risia. Excellent points, all down the line."


Ditto.

Wait, ditto implies that I’m a mindless idiot who can’t come up with their own thought.
Risia rocks my cerebral cortex.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Phony diversity

HighSchoolJock said:

ok if i had an employee who was NOT doing their job no i wouldnt give them a raise i would probably outright release them however i havnet gone through every teacher and america and evalitaed them the way you have my god man how do you find the time to judge EVERY teacher in america and come to the judgement that NONE of them are doing their job you must be the master of time management

increases teachers pay scale does in fact improve education beacuse it attracts more applicants and makes the job more competitive therefore teachers have to work harder for the money when you dont pay an employee a fair salary they look for other employment and it becomes more & more difficult to replace the employee who is not doing their job 'cause you have no fresh applicants

RAISE YOUR TAXES BIOTCH YOU JUST GOT TOOK TO SCHOOL!!!!!

Great post HSJ.

In Oz about 30 years ago teachers were well paid compared to the community and held in high regard. Since then the purchasing power of teacher pay has declined markedly. Consequently, the quality of teacher training candidates has declined markedly. Well, you know the old capitalist principle - pay peanuts, get monkeys!!

Now a starting teacher earns $A35,000 with high school tenure after probation. Meanwhile a footballer earns over $A100,000 pa at the same age. Now, which career would YOU recommend for a keen student, with brains and academic ability and sporting talent - the ideal student that we see too rarely?? Remember, corporations look for trainee managers who have achieved, and establishing small business requires venture capital??

But our Ishmael would have teachers being paid even less, school hours increased and class sizes made even larger, thus increasing the already overwhelming after hours work load on the profession. The Dickensian working conditions shall, of course, encourage our finest young academic brains to bust their guts getting academic qualifications to fill these many positions left vacant by teachers burned out by an uncaring education administration balancing an underfunded budget . . .

Thank goodness capitalism rules and the best brains have enough sense and talent to do any career except teaching . . .

Get a life Ishmael . . . try getting a liberal education . . . you'd enjoy it lol :)
 
Last edited:
Sandia said:
I want someone to praise my posts now please.

You've had good day, Sandia. Made less of an ass out of yourself than usual.

You set yourself up for that one. I did like your posts on Lav's cocoa crispies thread.
 
takingchances42 said:


You've had good day, Sandia. Made less of an ass out of yourself than usual.

You set yourself up for that one. I did like your posts on Lav's cocoa crispies thread.

Thank you. It's what I strive for.
 
See based on my recent personal experience, I think Ishmael actually has a point with the bias argument. My 4 primary profs were close 2nds to Redwave, PP, ralph nader, and al gore. The Redwave guy taught political geography and had two pillars, organized religion is the world's greatest evil and an owner of a factory with 99employees should slice the pie 100 equal ways. That guy is my favorite alltime teacher, fuckin' hilarious and he rarely was trying to be funny. I don't think the bias changed my outlook, I've always been a lib. Really, I think parents have more to do with it. Ishmael, conservatives always have the option of sending their kids to Bob Jones Uni, lol.
 
Good post, seventy.
Your posts on the Brady/Bundy thread really kicked ass though.
 
Sandia said:
Good post, seventy.
Your posts on the Brady/Bundy thread really kicked ass though.

Why thank you sandia, on the sexist thread you were right on, there probably should be romance novels for men. Stay away from the soaps though, much of it is already geared toward guys. We are all in danger of being trapped in its labyrinth of comas, bastard kids, amnesia epidemics, multiple personality disorders, gunshot wounds that kill only 1% of patients, the most trustworthy teenagers even experiment with illegal drugs, and the average marriage is 3months. I think men have no natural immunity to it, so not one episode can be watched.
 
70/30 said:
See based on my recent personal experience, I think Ishmael actually has a point with the bias argument. My 4 primary profs were close 2nds to Redwave, PP, ralph nader, and al gore. The Redwave guy taught political geography and had two pillars, organized religion is the world's greatest evil and an owner of a factory with 99employees should slice the pie 100 equal ways. That guy is my favorite alltime teacher, fuckin' hilarious and he rarely was trying to be funny. I don't think the bias changed my outlook, I've always been a lib. Really, I think parents have more to do with it. Ishmael, conservatives always have the option of sending their kids to Bob Jones Uni, lol.

Well Bob Jones may not be the school of choice, but more and more parents are sending their kids to more conservative schools. And more and more of us are opting out of the Alumni support programs too. A recent campaign by the Alumni's has put tremendous pressure on the Univ. of Chicago. It'll be interesting to see if it works.

Ishmael
 
Originally posted by 70/30
I can almost agree with this statement Bill, except I don't really trust the masses or an overwhelming military. . .
Care to elucidate? I'm at a loss as to your point, hence, I have no basis on which to respond.
Originally posted by Don K Dyck
Am I correct in assuming that in America it is wrong, or politically incorrect, to teach students to think analytically and for themselves?? . . .
An informed, thinking electorate is certainly inimical to the present political environment in the U. S.
Originally posted by Sillyman
So, do we need to institute affirmative action then? I'm sure the market will certainly eliminate this problem when the Universities realize all they are losing from their discrimanatory hiring practices.
Worse solution to a bad problem. Rather, take away their government subsidy. Make the institutions compete for the education dollar in the free market. Then you'd see this malady corrected quickly or the institutes would fold for lack of patronage.

Never,, thanks so much for tickling my thought process. Let me ask your question a bit differently:
Am I the only one that gets tired of people trying to pass conservative politics off as bigotry?
Originally posted by alltherage
Both sides worry far too much about the influence of the right and the left. It seems to me that conservative thought and practice are quite strong in the U.S.
I read this and could only wonder where you've been. With the rampant growth of government, you construe an expansion of convservative thought and practice? Wow! I'm in awe of that thought process!
Originally posted by alltherage
It could be argued that the the past 20 years has seen a strong move to the right in american politics. Even Mr. Clinton was no traditional liberal. For all the rants about college campuses being too liberal it would seem to have had little impact in the country. I think what happens is that those graduates from the top universitys begin to make very substantial incomes and suddenly all the ideals they held so close in college that now might cost them money( in the form of taxes) become secondary.
Perhaps Clinton was not the typical Liberal. He was/is a hardcore collectivist and America-hater as well as a criminal. Perhaps that is a bit beyond the typical Liberal but the mindsets are not all that different.
 
UncleBill, the power will go to some group that can't responsibly handle it. John Adams is my favorite American. My take on things his stance was the central government can't handle too much power, the aristocracy can't, and the people can't handle it. For sure the military can't handle it. So look for a better balance. What I am for is widespread campaign finance reform-maybe some honest legislators with real ideas can be elected for a change.

While all other sciences have advanced, that of government is at a standstill - little better understood, little better practiced now than three or four thousand years ago.
John Adams (likely has digressed the past 200years)

Remember, democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts, and murders itself. There is never a democracy that did not commit suicide. John Adams (if a true democracy was instituted)

I have accepted a seat in the House of Representatives, and thereby have consented to my own ruin, to your ruin, and to the ruin of our children. I give you this warning that you may prepare your mind for your fate. John Adams

Liberty cannot be preserved without a general knowledge among the people. John Adams
 
Adams was a radical firebrand. He had a deep and abiding distrust of all forms of government, but none the less recognized that there was a need for it's existance. His distrust was well founded and reflected by none other than G. Washington who upon his farewell speech to his troops said, "Government is like fire. A useful tool but a fearsome master."

There are two observations made by A. de Toqueville that I always found interesting. The first being his observation that the power of the new republic was to be found in it's communities, the meeting halls and churches. The second being that the downfall of the republic would be when the electorate discovered that they could vote themselves the largess of the national treasury.

Ishmael
 
Originally posted by 70/30
UncleBill, the power will go to some group that can't responsibly handle it. John Adams is my favorite American. My take on things his stance was the central government can't handle too much power, the aristocracy can't, and the people can't handle it. For sure the military can't handle it. So look for a better balance. What I am for is widespread campaign finance reform-maybe some honest legislators with real ideas can be elected for a change.

While all other sciences have advanced, that of government is at a standstill - little better understood, little better practiced now than three or four thousand years ago.
John Adams (likely has digressed the past 200years)

Remember, democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts, and murders itself. There is never a democracy that did not commit suicide. John Adams (if a true democracy was instituted)

I have accepted a seat in the House of Representatives, and thereby have consented to my own ruin, to your ruin, and to the ruin of our children. I give you this warning that you may prepare your mind for your fate. John Adams

Liberty cannot be preserved without a general knowledge among the people. John Adams
That is the beauty of a free, capitalist society. Power is in the hands of the individual. Government's purpose is to suppress the criminal element which is to a free society what disease is to a living body. It is the occasional exception to good health.

Power is only harmful when it is accompanied by the use of force and that use of force is legitimized. The only power the individual (or group, e. g., corporation) has is to deal on a voluntary basis. Private business cannot force customers to purchase their goods or services; they can only offer them in free exchange in the marketplace.

Government, on the other hand, has the institutional legitimacy to use force. This legitimacy is based on the principle that it acts as an extension of the individual's right to self-defense.

So long as government is constrained to that limitation, it is not a threat. When it exceeds that capacity, it becomes a threat to the degree that it expands the scope of its control.

This quote says it quite succinctly:
There's no way to rule innocent men. The only power any government has is the power to crack down on criminals. Well, when there aren't enough criminals, one makes them. One declares so many things to be a crime that it becomes impossible to live without breaking laws.

Ayn Rand
So for you to say that the theory of government is some unprobed mystery, i. e., at a standstill, it is not for lack of information. Rather I suspect it is the desire of the statists to suppress such knowledge because it undermines their political power.

If I have the information I do, it is certainly no secret except from those who wish not to know it and those whose livelihood is threatened by said knowledge becoming widespread. i. e., the career politician.

To make the statement such as "the aristocracy can't, and the people can't handle it" is about as arrogant as one can get considering that in a free society, power means freedom. In a free, civilized society, the ONLY action prohibited and punished is criminal behavior. Thus to say that "the people can't handle power" is to say they can't handle freedom and is so offensively patronizing and condescending as to defy belief.
 
George Washington hated few people more than Thomas Jefferson. John Adams hated Jefferson during the time in question but not as much as Hamilton. Madison lurks around somewhere in between. Frankin was on his own while he was alive. Average 'em out and that is basically what the Founders intended. I don't like picking Jefferson as a model, its an extreme. A reason true democracy won't survive is that is exactly what Redwave wants. There are more have nots than haves, we'll vote to fill our own pockets.
 
Back
Top