G
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
intrigued said:Pardon me, but I have read her post several times now and just don't see where she states that he did not know she had taken a muscle relaxer. What I DO see is that she said they had an abusive relationship, PLUS she said she had made it very clear to him that anal was out of the question. At what point do you feel he still has the right to take her without her consent, and perform a sexual act ON her that she was unable to deny him the right to perform?
well..emerald...I was alseep, not touching him...I didnt even know he was home...he usually took off to go do drugs. We had tried anal in the past. I hated it and told him never again. Then I woke up to that...I understand what you are saying. I dont want to be a whiny victim. But on the other hand, I am in a good relationship now and dont want to carry baggage along forever.[QUOTE/]
She was asleep
She didnt know he was home- so he wouldnt have known that she took drugs would he ?
She also didnt say anything when she did wake up to stop him - it is only afterwards that she thinks back
If I wake my partner up by having sex - I do not get consent - so am I a rapist ?
I am just trying bto get people to look at the bigger picture and think before leaping in and shouting rape - maybe it was , maybe it wasnt we dont know nthe full facts - only a hazy recollection with blurred facts
Emerald_eyed said:Im glad you do, because now you got me confused.
What I am saying is, I have been raped, and I knew damn well I was, but she just "realized it the other day" and came in here asking our opinion.
My opinion was,
She said he came home, Im not so sure he knew she took the pills. A lot of people get "naughty" with a lover when they are asleep. I know its happened to me. There are times I would smile into my pillow and play it up letting him have his way with me, showing him I want it, but yet still pretending to be asleep. It can be fun.
Do we know what really happened? No, and she doesnt either. He may have explored her anal area, and ahe may have been showing signs of excitement. He was NOT there when she took the pills, soow can we ay he knew he was taking advantage of her in her drugged state?
intrigued said:We can't say because she did not address that in her post. What she did address is that she had told him prior that she did not want to have anal sex again. We know that she stated she had taken a muscle relaxer and "was out of it".
That is what matters. I took mr's for years and I know for a fact that my body responds differently under the influence of mr's than it does when I am simply sleeping and NOT medicated.
Why is this so difficult?

Gord said:here is the bit
well..emerald...I was alseep, not touching him...I didnt even know he was home...he usually took off to go do drugs. We had tried anal in the past. I hated it and told him never again. Then I woke up to that...I understand what you are saying. I dont want to be a whiny victim. But on the other hand, I am in a good relationship now and dont want to carry baggage along forever.[QUOTE/]
She was asleep
She didnt know he was home- so he wouldnt have known that she took drugs would he ?
She also didnt say anything when she did wake up to stop him - it is only afterwards that she thinks back
If I wake my partner up by having sex - I do not get consent - so am I a rapist ?
I am just trying bto get people to look at the bigger picture and think before leaping in and shouting rape - maybe it was , maybe it wasnt we dont know nthe full facts - only a hazy recollection with blurred facts
Thank you, I stand corrected, but it changes little. First, you are assuming again. She said "then I woke up to that..." She stopped there, she did not tell us what happened next, so we cannot assume that she didn't stop him, PLUS, you're also assuming the muscle relaxer had no effect on her whatsoever, and she had full capabilities to behave in her normal manner.
You are also overlooking the bit about her telling him PRIOR that she did not want anal.
Everything else that you said is agreed on. I like waking up to sex, too, but not when I am at the disadvantage of being medicated, and not to find myself in an act that I had stated previously that I did not wish to do.
Sex is about mutual desire, mutual consent. In no way did she give consent, nor was her intent/desire to partake in the activity he forced on her mutual.
Thats my take as well. I feel she isn't weighing this in terms of prosecution, but to reconcile it within herself.RawHumor said:I don't believe that she's thinking about prosecution so much as getting things settled in her own mind.
Emerald_eyed said:We can not assume she did either can we?
Ive been on muscle relaxers. I know they make you groggy.
How many times have you had sex drunk? Does that mean you were raped?
You say Im assuming? Im the one saying that I would be careful about what to call it. Im the one saying Im not so sure.
You all are assuming she was raped and telling her so WITHOUT knowing the whole story.
All Im saying is SHEESH, be careful. WE WERENT THERE TO SAY WHETHER IT WAS OR WASNT!
She was unsure, and that made me VERY unsure. Like Gord said, we dont knoww about their over all picture here. Did she wake up to sex often? Did she have a past on drinking where they engaged in sex? Have they had sex while on relaxers bfore?
All Im saying is LETS GET THE WHOLE PICTURE before saying its rape.
Emerald_eyed said:With you agreeing on the above statement, how does that make it simple? By you stating that him not knowing is of merit, how can you end your post with "It's that simple."
?
Emerald_eyed said:Rape is definatly a very strong word. You should be 100% sure of it. She wasn't 100% sure.
Claiming rape on someone can ruin their life. Im just saying one should be DAMN sure it happened.
Way back when, in another life, "muscle relaxers" were the drug of choice. we called them sopors. As I recall, the next day was always filled with questions., such as did I do that? or was that a dream? either way forced or coerced sex is wrong.Emerald_eyed said:Me too.
She admits she was all drugged up, there for we cant say that she may have been "rubing" up against him, or softly moaning to encourage him. She doesnt know at all.
Anal sex would be enough to wake me from the dead. If not repared it can hurt, if she woke up in the middle of it, then she was very out of it and may have been touching him or moaning without even knowing.