Rape victims...

alexandraaah said:
Not knowing if you were raped or not does NOT mean that you weren't raped.

I think the state of mind of a woman (as you yourself admitted) in an abusive relationship, is skewed.

I won't make a judgment one way or the other, but I'd suggest counseling to stay the hell away from men like that in your future. It tends to be a pattern and you need to learn how to fine-tune your intuitive skills when meeting men.

Best of luck to you, and I'm sorry for your hurt.

Which seems like a very sensible thing to say -
 
Emerald_eyed said:
Since they were in a sexual relationship, how can one say she was forced? How can we say she wasnt?

We cant, thats all IM trying to get across here.



Down girl, Down!

Easy girl.. Look Pretty dress...
 
Emerald_eyed said:
You are correct, but no knowing if you were raped or not does not mean you were either.


Im not for one minute saying she wasn't Not for a minute! Im not saying she was either.
If she isnt sure, and doesnt want the baggage, maybe everyone shouldnt be trying to convince her she was. She doesnt know if she was or not, she has doubt. Thats gave me my doubt.

She needs to talk this over with someone close to her, someone she trusts. Someone who knows the whole picture, we do not know the wholoe picture, thats why Im saying how can we be sure?

I understand your wanting to be absolutely sure due to what sounds like grey area.

However, I think the people in this thread who are adamant about her situation, are that because they know from firsthand experience that she probably was raped, and is scared shitless due to her history with this man.

Rape is more of a black and white situation then you're making it out to be; fear is what makes it fuzzy.

I agree with you that she needs to talk this over with someone, namely someone objective to whom she can give all the details and hash this situation out.

The bottom line is that she's horribly uncomfortable with an act that took place without her knowledge or consent. What an awful place to be; I sincerely wish you the best.
 
Emerald_eyed said:
Ok everyone, you know, instead of trying to comfort this woman, or have her talk to a professional about it, why dont you all convince her she was raped? Why dont some of you just insist on it without knowing everything?

hell I dont know if it was rape, it might have well benn, but lets all jump to conclusions without knowing the whole story.

Lets put more baggage on her! Lets not try to help her by encouraging her to seek counseling, lets just try to make her believe what you all do!




Nobody sees my point here, nobody welcomes my opinion, so I will bow out of this thread. Im obviously the wrong one here.


Hey I agreed with you - I even said so


and I welcomed your opinion

I am not a nobody


I am a person
 
Emerald_eyed said:
Im not going to argue my opinion on this matter anymore, as state earlier.I will say this though, I to have experienced rape first hand.

Hon, I assure you I'm not trying to argue with you for the sake of arguing.

I think you yourself have brought to this thread the most crucial point to be made, that your own experiences have perhaps clouded your perception on this issue.

I think that's worth noting.

I'm sorry for your experience as well, really I am; I think women can learn from that when it comes to their own situation.
 
EE, I don't know how to make myself any more clear. I am not encouraging the woman to do anything at all. She asked a question that I answered with my own perspective...and oddly enough, my own rape in no way influenced me.
With regard to my "it's that simple" statement, what is simple to me is that she told him PRIOR that she did not wish to engage in anal sex. He engaged her anyway.
Just out of curiosity, what do you call that? Answer for yourself...ask yourself what you would feel if you had told your lover (regardless of the health of the relationship) that there is a particular sexual act that you wish to not engage in, and he engaged you in it anyway?

I am not here to argue with you, or anyone else, and I regret that you feel because I am stating an opinion that differs slightly from yours, that somehow it is perceived in any manner other than we see things a bit differently.

I am not encouraging her to do anything at all. I only answered her question as best I could with the info she provided us. In no way do I feel I am "in the know" as to what exactly happened, I can only respond to what she addressed. Even if she enlightened me and went so far as to say "should I prosecute?", I would decline offering an opinion, its her decision.

I can say that if I were her, I wouldn't make decisions of such importance on the perspective of strangers. I would know in my heart if I had been raped, and would react accordingly.
Since I never saw her post as a "should I file charges" type of post, I answered her question as it was posed. I did not instruct, coerce, or encourage her to do anything at all.
 
Good lord...

Im not trying to press charges for this. He has already done time for stalking me after I left him. I stayed with him because he wouldnt let me leave...may sound stupid but to someone who is in the situation it maks perfect sense. I know what rape is...like I said...I was raped when I was 16. This is more like a repressed memory...I was out of it when it happened, but I remembered it recently. I am not out for blood, I am not trying to be a victim. I just want to get all the garbage out and get on with life. That is all.

I understand this is a very gray area. I wasnt consious and I had taken a muscel relaxer...there is no way he couldnt of known though. I am a terribly light sleeper and would of woken up the second he walked in the room if I hadnt taken anything. I just feel like first I should figure out if this is something I should even bother exploring...right now I am still sorta numb to it. I dont want it causing problems in the future though in my current relationship, which is very good by the way. Thanx for all the advice...you all gave me something to think about. And I am glad that this sort of thing amuses some of you. Thats just great.
 
I don't believe that she's thinking about prosecution so much as getting things settl

Thanx Raw Humor..:)


Im not looking for a pity party...more like some others who have delt with the same thing or something similar...I have yet to find a group in my area for women who have been raped.
 
Re: I don't believe that she's thinking about prosecution so much as getting things settl

:p
 
While in college I was raped by a man I had previously had a sexual relationship with. We were at a party and he and a very good friend walked me home. He followed me into my room, pushed me face down on the bed, pinned me down and raped me. The whole time I was saying "no" and fighting to the best of my ability. Nothing helped, I couldnt get out of that situation.

I never told a soul until later in life. At the time I couldn't. I was high and drunk, and in college on a scholarship. I thought if I went to the police, they would blame me. So, for 15 yrs now I've grappled with it, I know now what I should have done, I should have reported it. I still see this man on rare occasion, and at my 10 yr. reunion he had the balls to sit down at my table. I left, and swore I'd never go to another.

I'm sorry that you are experiencing the pain of all that your Ex has done to you. My only advice is this.....

Realize that this pain won't ever go away, but with time it will lessen, and don't allow it to control your future relationships, or sexual endeavors. Take each day as they come.

--a7
 
Thanx itchy...and your right. It does take time above all. I just dont want it bogging down my current relationship. i dont want him to deal with all my baggage.
 
Back
Top