Supernatural!

I felt they wasted a lot of quality points with the Lucifer story line because they did a real half assed job of trying to create grey area. I mean they start off with him making a "quality" point about how God is unfair and his Vessel didnt' deserve the shitty life that he had then from there he's just a prick for the rest of the season doing all sorts of horrible shit. Then they get to the end and he see's his brother and he's all "Fuck this you're my brother, I love you and I don't want to fight you." And never before had they given any real hints that Lucifer was at all reluctant or had any feelings left for any of his family (and he'd already offed Gabriel by this point and there wasn't much evidence that he was upset about that either though maybe he just couldn't risk fucking around with Gabriel).

Just so much waste.
 
I felt they wasted a lot of quality points with the Lucifer story line because they did a real half assed job of trying to create grey area. I mean they start off with him making a "quality" point about how God is unfair and his Vessel didnt' deserve the shitty life that he had then from there he's just a prick for the rest of the season doing all sorts of horrible shit. Then they get to the end and he see's his brother and he's all "Fuck this you're my brother, I love you and I don't want to fight you." And never before had they given any real hints that Lucifer was at all reluctant or had any feelings left for any of his family (and he'd already offed Gabriel by this point and there wasn't much evidence that he was upset about that either though maybe he just couldn't risk fucking around with Gabriel).

Just so much waste.

I think they did okay with the consistency of the character...who always hated mankind and wanted to exterminate them. He lied when he said he didn't lie.
 
I think they did okay with the consistency of the character...who always hated mankind and wanted to exterminate them. He lied when he said he didn't lie.

You might be right. I don't really buy that though. I didn't think they really screwed up with the consistency, I think at the beginning and end they tried to establish some gray area because it's really obvious if you listen to the speech between Lucifer and Micheal that it mirrors almost word for word the argument that Sam and Dean had when John showed up to help them with the vampires. I'm paraphrasing here but it was basically.

Sam/Lucifer: Why are you doing what Dad said? This is the first time we've seen him in forever!

Dean/Micheal: He's my Dad! And I'm a good son. I don't want to do this Sammy/Luci but I have to because that's what it is to be a good son!

Sam/Lucifer: It doesn't have to be. Why don't we just walk away. Forget this.

Dean/Micheal: I can't do that.

Sam/Lucifer: Bring it bitch.

And neither Sam nor Dean were really wrong in that argument but if I had to pick a side I'd be Sam over Dean in that fight and never look back. Absentee people do not get a fucking vote. (And I make the same argument when people want to bring up the Founders. When one of them climbs out of their coffin to speak up they can make demands. Until then they can set examples and nothing more.)

Yeah he hates humanity but he has every fucking reason to hate humanity. Granted in the Supernaturalverse this really is the "standard" belief of angels that humans are stupid monkeys who deserve to die but I forget who put it this way but God punished Lucifer for the equivalent of your father disowning you after he brought home hundreds of rats, set them loose in the house and you had the nerve to be upset that he wanted to bow down to the rodents shitting on your stuff and ripping the rest to shreds. Most of us would be far less forgiving than he was.
 
You might be right. I don't really buy that though. I didn't think they really screwed up with the consistency, I think at the beginning and end they tried to establish some gray area because it's really obvious if you listen to the speech between Lucifer and Micheal that it mirrors almost word for word the argument that Sam and Dean had when John showed up to help them with the vampires. I'm paraphrasing here but it was basically.

Sam/Lucifer: Why are you doing what Dad said? This is the first time we've seen him in forever!

Dean/Micheal: He's my Dad! And I'm a good son. I don't want to do this Sammy/Luci but I have to because that's what it is to be a good son!

Sam/Lucifer: It doesn't have to be. Why don't we just walk away. Forget this.

Dean/Micheal: I can't do that.

Sam/Lucifer: Bring it bitch.

And neither Sam nor Dean were really wrong in that argument but if I had to pick a side I'd be Sam over Dean in that fight and never look back. Absentee people do not get a fucking vote. (And I make the same argument when people want to bring up the Founders. When one of them climbs out of their coffin to speak up they can make demands. Until then they can set examples and nothing more.)

Yeah he hates humanity but he has every fucking reason to hate humanity. Granted in the Supernaturalverse this really is the "standard" belief of angels that humans are stupid monkeys who deserve to die but I forget who put it this way but God punished Lucifer for the equivalent of your father disowning you after he brought home hundreds of rats, set them loose in the house and you had the nerve to be upset that he wanted to bow down to the rodents shitting on your stuff and ripping the rest to shreds. Most of us would be far less forgiving than he was.

Yeah, that is what I see. Plus the idea that Lucifer means "Lightbringer"

The character is consistent with that level of beauty, power and hubris being twisted into a new thing. He loves the Earth itself. His contempt is reserved for all thing rat related.

I have sympathy for the character and the source myth. I just don't think he would ever do anything but lie to and despise the rats themselves. And those lies would be convincing and effective and dripping with insight and understanding.
 
Oh, she's more fun for me than a hot cat familiar on a leash.

That's because you have the wrong set of genitals love. I don't hate Felicia by any stretch of the imagination and I found her first two appearances great, her third was a waste of time and her fourth was one of those. . .seriously? The Wicked Witch? You guys are really just trying to see what bullshit you can get away with before I just decide to murder you all in your sleep aren't you?

I like her! She's like the baby sister they never had lol. And the wicked witch was better than the fairies episode, but that's just my opinion. Dorothy was kind of bad ass :)
 
I don't even think Lucifer lied and they certainly attempted to make it seem like he wasn't lying. Sure he was manipulating the universe like the prick that he was but still.

And Dorothy was all sorts of Bad Ass, I kinda prefer my Dorothy and Oz a little lighter and fluffier. At least for me part of the fun of Oz is that you are waging war with Chinadolls, Flying Monkees and Midgets. There are fields of flowers that can put you to sleep and in Soviet Oz Tree Picks YOU!

And that's just in the first book. I've read Return To Oz and whatever the third book is as well They have gnomes and talking chickens and. . .it's no Wonderland but it's nice.

Also yes it was better than the Fairy Episode. And the Dragon Episode. And the Cthulu Episode. Super natural has reached a point where it has enough crap that I no longer use "it's not the worst thing they've ever done" as a benchmark for not crap.
 
I don't even think Lucifer lied and they certainly attempted to make it seem like he wasn't lying. Sure he was manipulating the universe like the prick that he was but still.

And Dorothy was all sorts of Bad Ass, I kinda prefer my Dorothy and Oz a little lighter and fluffier. At least for me part of the fun of Oz is that you are waging war with Chinadolls, Flying Monkees and Midgets. There are fields of flowers that can put you to sleep and in Soviet Oz Tree Picks YOU!

And that's just in the first book. I've read Return To Oz and whatever the third book is as well They have gnomes and talking chickens and. . .it's no Wonderland but it's nice.

Also yes it was better than the Fairy Episode. And the Dragon Episode. And the Cthulu Episode. Super natural has reached a point where it has enough crap that I no longer use "it's not the worst thing they've ever done" as a benchmark for not crap.

Understandable. I can't stand fluff but I get it. And I agree but then again there is a lot of supernatural myths of there that are seemingly stupid. They have to touch base on most myths, even the stupid ones. However, some episodes make me wonder what the heck were they thinking lol. Seriously, dragons that can pass as humans? :rolleyes:
 
They don't have to, they choose to. They haven't really done any alien stuff unless you count the Trickster/Gabriel and they've done pretty much nothing with African Myths, not much with South American or Australian either.

As for Dragons passing for human that's quite common in Asian Myth, most of them have a human form and they tend to prefer that unless they are trying to make a point, the point often being several rows of teeth but still. A point.

I don't hate fluff if it's good fluff. All the episodes about movies being made are always good fun.
 
I don't even think Lucifer lied and they certainly attempted to make it seem like he wasn't lying. Sure he was manipulating the universe like the prick that he was but still.

And Dorothy was all sorts of Bad Ass, I kinda prefer my Dorothy and Oz a little lighter and fluffier. At least for me part of the fun of Oz is that you are waging war with Chinadolls, Flying Monkees and Midgets. There are fields of flowers that can put you to sleep and in Soviet Oz Tree Picks YOU!

And that's just in the first book. I've read Return To Oz and whatever the third book is as well They have gnomes and talking chickens and. . .it's no Wonderland but it's nice.

Also yes it was better than the Fairy Episode. And the Dragon Episode. And the Cthulu Episode. Super natural has reached a point where it has enough crap that I no longer use "it's not the worst thing they've ever done" as a benchmark for not crap.

I am pretty sure he lied whenever he felt like it, didn't he make Sam see things that weren't there? If making someone hallucinate something that isn't real isn't a lie, not sure what is.

I've never really been an Oz fan so I could not care much.
 
Understandable. I can't stand fluff but I get it. And I agree but then again there is a lot of supernatural myths of there that are seemingly stupid. They have to touch base on most myths, even the stupid ones. However, some episodes make me wonder what the heck were they thinking lol. Seriously, dragons that can pass as humans? :rolleyes:

They needed to make the dragon funnier anyway. If they could make pagan Gods that eat people at Christmas hilarious, they could have done much better with dragons.
 
I am pretty sure he lied whenever he felt like it, didn't he make Sam see things that weren't there? If making someone hallucinate something that isn't real isn't a lie, not sure what is.

I've never really been an Oz fan so I could not care much.

He barely spent any time with Sam at all. I assume that Lucifer in Season 6 was all in Sam's head and not actually Lucifer and prior to that I don't think (though it's been a while since I watched Season 5) any lies. Sure he told people what they wanted to hear but that's not really the same.

They needed to make the dragon funnier anyway. If they could make pagan Gods that eat people at Christmas hilarious, they could have done much better with dragons.

And they could have made Cthulu at least kinda scary.
 
He barely spent any time with Sam at all. I assume that Lucifer in Season 6 was all in Sam's head and not actually Lucifer and prior to that I don't think (though it's been a while since I watched Season 5) any lies. Sure he told people what they wanted to hear but that's not really the same.

And they could have made Cthulu at least kinda scary.

Well, then we get down to "what is a lie" in more concrete form. The demons say they have to keep their word and can't break a contract, but the contracts themselves have lies and tricks built into them as a matter of course.

A demon that possesses someone can lie while possessing that person. They are not against lying.

All the lore about Lucifer is that he is a liar. Angels can lie, Cas lied, Balthasar lied, Gabriel lied about his identity. Angels can lie, Lucifer can lie, Demons lie although they are all compelled to keep a deal, though they twist the deal every time.

Even convincing his first vessel, he said he wanted to get back at God and that's not even what Lucifer did, he just wanted to win a predestined fight. He still loves God and God's creation, just not humans, and certainly did nothing to help his vessel get any payback, he was just gone.

Telling someone what they want to hear is definitely still a lie when the individual telling that is only doing it to manipulate.

I think Lovecraft was just flat out crazy and not scary except that crazy is scary. I can't get through any of his stuff.
 
They needed to make the dragon funnier anyway. If they could make pagan Gods that eat people at Christmas hilarious, they could have done much better with dragons.

Yes! That episode I enjoyed. I think they may have switched writers at that point. Plus, they lost so many people by season 6
 
Yes! That episode I enjoyed. I think they may have switched writers at that point. Plus, they lost so many people by season 6

I'm rewatching the first episode of the Leviathan season and although yeah, it's not the best...there's still stuff like smiting guys at the corollary of the Westboro Baptist Church and that's a good thing.

I still think bad Supernatural is better than most good episodes of other shows.
 
There is no doubt hat Angels and Demons can both lie. I'm not sure Demons really have been lying much but even when making deals it's clear they have to follow the letter of the word not the spirit of it. Though Crowley seems to think in general you should follow both. He got pissed at that demon a while back who was arranging for people to die early.

I don't think demons are against lying though they don't seem to do it very often. Though that seems to be because the truth is just more useful. They certainly don't seem to have many qualms.

I'm not sold that loving someone means you can't want to make a point and from his POV humans aren't exactly "real" so exterminating a lot of us doesn't mean shit to him.

A lie is an untruth. If the only reason I'm telling you that your hubby is cheating on you is so you'll sleep with me out of vengeance I told you the truth. I did not lie. I manipulated you yes, I had my own selfish resaons for telling the truth but that doesn't make it a lie.

Lovecraft is hit and miss I'll grant you. I think it tends to work a lot better as a sub-plot than the main plot because it's primary two story points are "crazy" and minimal information so basing an entire story around it tends to get real messy real fast.
 
I'm rewatching the first episode of the Leviathan season and although yeah, it's not the best...there's still stuff like smiting guys at the corollary of the Westboro Baptist Church and that's a good thing.

I still think bad Supernatural is better than most good episodes of other shows.

LOL. I forgot about the Westboro people. I just kinda liked Cas making everybody kneel and then later coming back to apologize because he realized teh difference between love and fear. . .as if that's a complicated subject.
 
I'm rewatching the first episode of the Leviathan season and although yeah, it's not the best...there's still stuff like smiting guys at the corollary of the Westboro Baptist Church and that's a good thing.

I still think bad Supernatural is better than most good episodes of other shows.

Oh that last point we are in totally agreement! Lol and that first episode was great. Cas was totally in the wrong but that church scene was great!
 
There is no doubt hat Angels and Demons can both lie. I'm not sure Demons really have been lying much but even when making deals it's clear they have to follow the letter of the word not the spirit of it. Though Crowley seems to think in general you should follow both. He got pissed at that demon a while back who was arranging for people to die early.

I don't think demons are against lying though they don't seem to do it very often. Though that seems to be because the truth is just more useful. They certainly don't seem to have many qualms.

I'm not sold that loving someone means you can't want to make a point and from his POV humans aren't exactly "real" so exterminating a lot of us doesn't mean shit to him.

A lie is an untruth. If the only reason I'm telling you that your hubby is cheating on you is so you'll sleep with me out of vengeance I told you the truth. I did not lie. I manipulated you yes, I had my own selfish resaons for telling the truth but that doesn't make it a lie.

Lovecraft is hit and miss I'll grant you. I think it tends to work a lot better as a sub-plot than the main plot because it's primary two story points are "crazy" and minimal information so basing an entire story around it tends to get real messy real fast.

Okay, think of when Sam was going to go after Lilith. There were any number of lies told by demons. Someone even replaced Dean's voice message of reconciliation with something vile.

And maybe Sam was hallucinating Lucifer, but it wasn't from any delusion about Lucifer, it was about having intimate knowledge of how the guy worked and what would be believable.

I've tried a few passes at Lovecraft and he's like Lewis Carroll to me...these guys are high and/or mentally ill and I'm not getting anything but crazy off this.
 
And Ruby lied like a rug. . .at least once. Like I said demons can and do lie. They aren't really known for their scruples.

Even if the delusions were about an intimate knowledge of Lucifer (which is debatable) that still wasn't Lucifer and it was after an undetermined amount of time stuck in Hell with two Sadistic Angels who hated him. I suspect Dean's stay in hell was was like a trip to the mall by comparison.

Lewis Carrol is high as fuck, isn't that what makes him fun?
 
Okay, think of when Sam was going to go after Lilith. There were any number of lies told by demons. Someone even replaced Dean's voice message of reconciliation with something vile.

And maybe Sam was hallucinating Lucifer, but it wasn't from any delusion about Lucifer, it was about having intimate knowledge of how the guy worked and what would be believable.

I've tried a few passes at Lovecraft and he's like Lewis Carroll to me...these guys are high and/or mentally ill and I'm not getting anything but crazy off this.

I think the voicemail replacement was the Angels doing actually. They wanted Sam to kill Lilith just as much as the demons (some) did. More in fact.
 
Have I mentioned the angels in this world are bad enough that I would probably seal up Heaven long before I sealed up Hell. Hell I think Cass has betrayed us more times than Crowley and we expect it from Crowley! He also never tried to end the world and has on more than one occasion agreed to let bygones be bygones.
 
And Ruby lied like a rug. . .at least once. Like I said demons can and do lie. They aren't really known for their scruples.

Even if the delusions were about an intimate knowledge of Lucifer (which is debatable) that still wasn't Lucifer and it was after an undetermined amount of time stuck in Hell with two Sadistic Angels who hated him. I suspect Dean's stay in hell was was like a trip to the mall by comparison.

Lewis Carrol is high as fuck, isn't that what makes him fun?

It's an interesting idea and when I rewatch I'll pay more attention. All the lore about Lucifer is that he's a liar, and I think that's part of the fun. If he can say he isn't a liar then he throws doubt on all the lore about him and gains trust. It's an obvious thing for a liar to do, so I read it that way.

Since there are many layers of truth and we as audience don't know what those are, it's an unprovable thing unless we asked the writer specifically what was the intent. I saw it as one of the only ploys he had to gain trust and get consent.

The induced hallucinations where he showed up as someone he wasn't...he made his first intended vessel hallucinate his wife and hallucinate the crying of a baby. He induced a mood of horror and the he manipulated the horrified person into some intended payback, which he never delivered.

Unless he needs consent, he never bothers with truth, he just makes people explode or kills them. True, those aren't lies, but they are a little worse on the sin scale.
 
Have I mentioned the angels in this world are bad enough that I would probably seal up Heaven long before I sealed up Hell. Hell I think Cass has betrayed us more times than Crowley and we expect it from Crowley! He also never tried to end the world and has on more than one occasion agreed to let bygones be bygones.

Yeah they are politican status bad lol. Demons act they way they do from centuries (for them) of horrible torture, Angels have no excuse for being that two-faced. That new angel in Sam? No way in hell I trust him.
 
I think the voicemail replacement was the Angels doing actually. They wanted Sam to kill Lilith just as much as the demons (some) did. More in fact.

Yeah, while I was rewatching I was wondering who in the hell did it, demons or angels...but I am not sure demons can do that, angels can. Angels would have the omniscience to know the message happened and to alter and replace it.

There's no sign that Lilith did much of anything and that Ruby was working on her own so she had no actual minion in place to mess with the phone company.
 
Back
Top