Supernatural!

Lucifer is the only one talking directly to Adam and Eve that's correct however. Genesis 3:22 And the Lord God said, Behold, the man is become as one of us, to know good and evil: and now, lest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever

To me it's a bit harsh to punish someone who by your own definition didn't know the difference between Good and Evil prior to committing the sin.

I guess I can see how you come to the conclusion though that if they weren't expelled they would have been permitted to eat the fruit of immortality though.

They had ONE rule. Don't eat from the Tree of Knowledge. They didn't need to know the difference between good and evil to know that their creator gave them that one rule to follow.

Eve allowed Lucifer to convince her to break that one rule, and Adam allowed Eve to convince him.

Why the hell God would put the Tree of Knowledge in the garden is beyond me. My only explanation is that he intended all along to kick them out of the garden. What parent puts a tree that means death should it's fruit be eaten with their children and then leaves then unsupervised while a serpent creeps through their paradise? Then kicks the kids out for listening to his OTHER failure (Lucifer). Any parent knows that telling a child not to do something is the surest way to make sure that they do it.

Which is why I consider God to be a dead beat Dad..
 
While I would argue that the "original" vs Cannon is a debate worth having I think you might have missed that Revelations Chapter where God promises to come back and smite us all.

Also rainbows were a promise not to smite us with water. I think Faith covered this best when she said "You got your four basic torture types, hot, cold, sharp and loud. We already covered sharp so what's next?"
 
They had ONE rule. Don't eat from the Tree of Knowledge. They didn't need to know the difference between good and evil to know that their creator gave them that one rule to follow.

I would argue that if you don't know the difference between good and evil the concept of following rules is kinda beyond your capabilities. Breaking rules is WRONG but if you don't know what wrong is how are you to judge?
 
They had ONE rule. Don't eat from the Tree of Knowledge. They didn't need to know the difference between good and evil to know that their creator gave them that one rule to follow.

Eve allowed Lucifer to convince her to break that one rule, and Adam allowed Eve to convince him.

Why the hell God would put the Tree of Knowledge in the garden is beyond me. My only explanation is that he intended all along to kick them out of the garden. What parent puts a tree that means death should it's fruit be eaten with their children and then leaves then unsupervised while a serpent creeps through their paradise? Then kicks the kids out for listening to his OTHER failure (Lucifer). Any parent knows that telling a child not to do something is the surest way to make sure that they do it.

Which is why I consider God to be a dead beat Dad..

He was the first parent. He got to make all the classical mistakes all parents make. "This is going to be a blessed, reasonable experience where...what...what the hell...why are you doing that? What?! WHY! ASSHOLES!"

Now we have parents and books to tell us this crap. God had nobody. Not even the Bible yet.
 
While I would argue that the "original" vs Cannon is a debate worth having I think you might have missed that Revelations Chapter where God promises to come back and smite us all.

Also rainbows were a promise not to smite us with water. I think Faith covered this best when she said "You got your four basic torture types, hot, cold, sharp and loud. We already covered sharp so what's next?"

Revelations was one crazy dude on shrooms and hate. I don't value his contributions to the Bible. Anybody can get that crap from a racist family member at Thanksgiving after a little too much alcohol.
 
While we're on the subject of the Bible anybody want to lay odds that the new Pope is the Anti-Christ? If I so much as hear a hint of him going to Palestine I'm visiting LJ and his bomb shelter.
 
While we're on the subject of the Bible anybody want to lay odds that the new Pope is the Anti-Christ? If I so much as hear a hint of him going to Palestine I'm visiting LJ and his bomb shelter.

I think he's awesome. So of course, he probably is. Not having expensive cars and stuff...what was he thinking? Caring for the poor and the destitute and keeping us from arguing about stupid stuff all the time. Who has ever heard of any powerful world organization doing that crap.

It probably does mean the end of the Church.
 
While I would argue that the "original" vs Cannon is a debate worth having I think you might have missed that Revelations Chapter where God promises to come back and smite us all.

Also rainbows were a promise not to smite us with water. I think Faith covered this best when she said "You got your four basic torture types, hot, cold, sharp and loud. We already covered sharp so what's next?"

Only after Lucifer and his minions have had their way with those who were left behind for a thousand years. THEN Christ will return to Earth with a host of Angels. Then Lucifer, his minions, and any who are not written in the Book of Life will be cast into the Lake of Fire.
 
I didn't say I don't like the Pope, I said i got dibs on him being Anti-Christ. Remember step one for him is bringing together the world in Peace. If there is a current world leader who seems to be pushing love and tolerance it's the Pope.

Unless Lauren Faust (fitting last name. . .) is the Anti-Christ in which case all I can say is bring it on bitches.

Only after Lucifer and his minions have had their way with those who were left behind for a thousand years. THEN Christ will return to Earth with a host of Angels. Then Lucifer, his minions, and any who are not written in the Book of Life will be cast into the Lake of Fire.

That's assuming you put the Rapture at the beginning of the thousand years and not at the end. Which is a relatively recent interpretation. Not necessarily wrong but nobody seems to be able to point to anything in the Bible that clearly states that the believers don't have to suffer for the thousand years and THEN get taken to heaven instead of the infinitely easier other way.
 
I didn't say I don't like the Pope, I said i got dibs on him being Anti-Christ. Remember step one for him is bringing together the world in Peace. If there is a current world leader who seems to be pushing love and tolerance it's the Pope.

Unless Lauren Faust (fitting last name. . .) is the Anti-Christ in which case all I can say is bring it on bitches.



That's assuming you put the Rapture at the beginning of the thousand years and not at the end. Which is a relatively recent interpretation. Not necessarily wrong but nobody seems to be able to point to anything in the Bible that clearly states that the believers don't have to suffer for the thousand years and THEN get taken to heaven instead of the infinitely easier other way.

If this stuff was important, I figure Jesus would have said something about it.
 
This is a case where I'm quite willing to accept that perhaps having a different and longer point of view might be a bit screwy. I can easily see torturing someone for 1000 years if I know good and damn well they have one billion years left after that. I might not even mention that in my plan if that's the case.
 
This is a case where I'm quite willing to accept that perhaps having a different and longer point of view might be a bit screwy. I can easily see torturing someone for 1000 years if I know good and damn well they have one billion years left after that. I might not even mention that in my plan if that's the case.

It's all just made up stuff to scare people into towing whatever line. It's got nothing to do with logic and everything to do with fear.

The Bible for me is valuable for the words of Jesus.

Modern Christianity in America is really, really far from the original tree.

The Pope is actually bringing back the words of Jesus and not all the grafted-on fear. Good for him. Bring it on!
 
I don't argue that. While I think in many cases even the word of Jesus is pretty damn brutal that's not exactly the point here. It was all about fear and getting folks to do what needed to be done according to whoever was in charge at the time.

Which is all the more reason why I'd prefer people who get their morals from Star Wars, Harry Potter, My Little Pony and 24. At least then when you argue that you don't believe 'x' it's because you're using fiction as a guideline. Otherwise you turn into JB.
 
I don't argue that. While I think in many cases even the word of Jesus is pretty damn brutal that's not exactly the point here. It was all about fear and getting folks to do what needed to be done according to whoever was in charge at the time.

Which is all the more reason why I'd prefer people who get their morals from Star Wars, Harry Potter, My Little Pony and 24. At least then when you argue that you don't believe 'x' it's because you're using fiction as a guideline. Otherwise you turn into JB.

I do like My Little Pony, but in general Fluttershy is going to get squashed when she flies up to lecture a dragon. I do like the guidance of friendship, but if they're like the Amish and only have fellowship to go on, they're getting mowed down. Sorry.

Harry Potter does pretty well on the good and evil balance and the realistic expectations one should have about the world. We can't all have a horcrux in our foreheads though.
 

Thank you! :)

And yes - spoiler alert...uh...everywhere!

Indeed... but that's fine. My wife and I only acquired the Season 1-7 box set earlier this year, and we've done well to get to the middle of Season 5 by now. We're not expecting everyone else to wait for us to catch up. :D

I've just read through all thirteen pages of this thread in one sitting, and I found it rather an exhilarating ride (and much more wide-ranging in topics than I was expecting). I thought that it might be best for me to announce my presence and then catch my breath for a while before seeking to pick up on any specifics.

*returns to lurking mode* ;)
.
 
Thank you! :)

Indeed... but that's fine. My wife and I only acquired the Season 1-7 box set earlier this year, and we've done well to get to the middle of Season 5 by now. We're not expecting everyone else to wait for us to catch up. :D

I've just read through all thirteen pages of this thread in one sitting, and I found it rather an exhilarating ride (and much more wide-ranging in topics than I was expecting). I thought that it might be best for me to announce my presence and then catch my breath for a while before seeking to pick up on any specifics.

*returns to lurking mode* ;)
.

I hope you and your wife have a lot of fun with it!
 
Yeah, Lit's spoiler option sucks and only RoryN knows how it works anyway so they are all over the place. Fortunately most of them don't

I do like My Little Pony, but in general Fluttershy is going to get squashed when she flies up to lecture a dragon. I do like the guidance of friendship, but if they're like the Amish and only have fellowship to go on, they're getting mowed down. Sorry.

Harry Potter does pretty well on the good and evil balance and the realistic expectations one should have about the world. We can't all have a horcrux in our foreheads though.

Oh I don't debate that Ponies would have highly limited shelf lives if they didn't live in a world that was focused around them. Just like I'm not sure I would advise people to take Yoda and Obi-Wan's "hey we fucked up the entire galaxy, better retire!" lesson to heart. I can easily get behind the fear leads to anger leads to hate leads to the darkside and then point at Modern US politics and those lovable scamps the RWCJ and say with a straight face we'd be worlds better off with more Fluttershy and less Jack Bauer.

And that's from someone who'll openly admit that if God (or a sufficiently powerful being to make the claim believable) told me that world peace could be achieved by sacrificing an innocent baby girl I'd be halfway through burning down an orphanage before I stopped to ask if there was a specific baby girl and if I got bonus points for volume. I'm ultimately far more likely to adhere to "By any means necessary" Malcolm X style than "Turn the other cheek" MLK jr style. Which I only bring up because it segways nicely into Professor X vs Magneto and at least Xavier seems to understand that self defense isn't evil and considering he hangs out with Wolverine he clearly is only so heartbroken about lethal force.

Of course I also admit that I'm quite the prick so there's that. Ghandi's not only a better person than me, he's a better person than I have any desire to be. Of course unlike at least MLK I'm at a disadvantage since I don't believe in an afterlife. If I die obtaining freedom I'm still sorta dead and I'd rather know I took some of them with me instead of leaving them behind for you lot.
 
Yeah, Lit's spoiler option sucks and only RoryN knows how it works anyway so they are all over the place. Fortunately most of them don't



Oh I don't debate that Ponies would have highly limited shelf lives if they didn't live in a world that was focused around them. Just like I'm not sure I would advise people to take Yoda and Obi-Wan's "hey we fucked up the entire galaxy, better retire!" lesson to heart. I can easily get behind the fear leads to anger leads to hate leads to the darkside and then point at Modern US politics and those lovable scamps the RWCJ and say with a straight face we'd be worlds better off with more Fluttershy and less Jack Bauer.

And that's from someone who'll openly admit that if God (or a sufficiently powerful being to make the claim believable) told me that world peace could be achieved by sacrificing an innocent baby girl I'd be halfway through burning down an orphanage before I stopped to ask if there was a specific baby girl and if I got bonus points for volume. I'm ultimately far more likely to adhere to "By any means necessary" Malcolm X style than "Turn the other cheek" MLK jr style. Which I only bring up because it segways nicely into Professor X vs Magneto and at least Xavier seems to understand that self defense isn't evil and considering he hangs out with Wolverine he clearly is only so heartbroken about lethal force.

Of course I also admit that I'm quite the prick so there's that. Ghandi's not only a better person than me, he's a better person than I have any desire to be. Of course unlike at least MLK I'm at a disadvantage since I don't believe in an afterlife. If I die obtaining freedom I'm still sorta dead and I'd rather know I took some of them with me instead of leaving them behind for you lot.

I am much more like Captain Kirk. "Why would a God need my ship?"

Being chosen sucks and any God should be doing their own work including healing my migraines. If they only have power if I have faith in them then I will skip the middle part and have faith in myself not being a dupe.
 
More power to you. Plenty of lore is filled with Gods who are far shy of omnipotent. Hell that's fairly unique to Judaeo-Christian God, most of the rest have sufficient limitations that they might very well need you to do something.

All I'm saying is if Crowley shows up asking for a deal I'm already two steps ahead of him on that plan. We're just haggling minutae.
 
More power to you. Plenty of lore is filled with Gods who are far shy of omnipotent. Hell that's fairly unique to Judaeo-Christian God, most of the rest have sufficient limitations that they might very well need you to do something.

All I'm saying is if Crowley shows up asking for a deal I'm already two steps ahead of him on that plan. We're just haggling minutae.

In the last installment of The Bard's Tale there is a town where every passing adventurer is told they are the chosen one and sent on a holy quest. They all die.

Crowley is probably worth it though. I have safely navigated my urge to save the world and it would take a lot to get me back in that head space. David Bowie would work too.
 
More meta...in the psychic episode I noticed that they got an "orb of thesaluh" which was the orb to give Angel his soul back in "Buffy The Vampire Slayer"

"Made in Taiwan"

yaaaay!
 
Back
Top