Supernatural!

Have I mentioned the angels in this world are bad enough that I would probably seal up Heaven long before I sealed up Hell. Hell I think Cass has betrayed us more times than Crowley and we expect it from Crowley! He also never tried to end the world and has on more than one occasion agreed to let bygones be bygones.

And that's where I get the idea that the writers actually consulted the Bible. The Angels are not nice creatures, they are righteous and smitey.

This is why if I end up in Heaven or Hell I plan on rebellion and taking over. The selling point? Well...guys...you know if you stop believing in these suckers they lose power, right?
 
What Lore (actual lore not modern retellings) does Lucifer lie in? In the Bible he has like three appearances and he's 100% honest in all of them it seems.

And yeah Angels are pricks. Even without the excuses for being pricks I'd pick demons because they are generally nicer than the Angels and more importantly they are MUCH weaker and MUCH easier to deal with aside from that one Knight of Hell who is every bit as bad as an angel but I I like blessing the water in my sprinker system a lot more than I do having to bleed myself dry to write a symbol the wall and rock.
 
What Lore (actual lore not modern retellings) does Lucifer lie in? In the Bible he has like three appearances and he's 100% honest in all of them it seems.

And yeah Angels are pricks. Even without the excuses for being pricks I'd pick demons because they are generally nicer than the Angels and more importantly they are MUCH weaker and MUCH easier to deal with aside from that one Knight of Hell who is every bit as bad as an angel but I I like blessing the water in my sprinker system a lot more than I do having to bleed myself dry to write a symbol the wall and rock.

Well, look at the Bible. Was he straight with Eve?
 
Well, look at the Bible. Was he straight with Eve?

Yes. God was the one lying there.

God: Eat this fruit and you die.
Satan: Eat this fruit and you'll be smart.
Angel commentary: If man eats of this fruit he'll be like us knowing good from evil.

Result: Eating the fruit people knew they were naked and sought to cover up their nakedness. They also did not die. God shows up, gets pissy and banishes them.

I've heard people claim that eating the fruit robbed us of immortality but seeing how there is a tree of Life that grants immortality and is guarded after that I think that's a bit of a stretch. I have a hard time chalking THAT up as even misinformation.

His next apperance is Job and. . he's an insufferable asshole with God's permission but a real dick but I don't think he communicates directly with anybody but God in that story.
 
Yes. God was the one lying there.

God: Eat this fruit and you die.
Satan: Eat this fruit and you'll be smart.
Angel commentary: If man eats of this fruit he'll be like us knowing good from evil.

Result: Eating the fruit people knew they were naked and sought to cover up their nakedness. They also did not die. God shows up, gets pissy and banishes them.

I've heard people claim that eating the fruit robbed us of immortality but seeing how there is a tree of Life that grants immortality and is guarded after that I think that's a bit of a stretch. I have a hard time chalking THAT up as even misinformation.

His next apperance is Job and. . he's an insufferable asshole with God's permission but a real dick but I don't think he communicates directly with anybody but God in that story.

Satan called it Knowledge but it was shame. They were good and now they knew evil.

Regardless of the fact that it's really a metaphor, there was actually nothing there and this is a story...granted, God was pissy, and the tree was a bad idea to put in the middle of a garden and then say "hands off!" but for me it's the equivalent of saying "Try that white powder, it will make you happy!" ...for about 10 hours, and then you'll crave it forever and it will ruin your life.

There's always "truth" he leaves out. Lie of omission, always.

Is it "knowledge" to think nakedness is shameful?
 
Yeah, while I was rewatching I was wondering who in the hell did it, demons or angels...but I am not sure demons can do that, angels can. Angels would have the omniscience to know the message happened and to alter and replace it.

There's no sign that Lilith did much of anything and that Ruby was working on her own so she had no actual minion in place to mess with the phone company.

As evil as she was (baby eating? Seriously?), Lilith seemed more like the pawn. Twisted by Luicfer, just to be killed later on.
 
As evil as she was (baby eating? Seriously?), Lilith seemed more like the pawn. Twisted by Luicfer, just to be killed later on.

Lilith was pretty much a free agent. She was the first intended mate for Adam and said "FUCK THAT" and I like her for that alone. Biblically anyway.
 
Lilith was pretty much a free agent. She was the first intended mate for Adam and said "FUCK THAT" and I like her for that alone. Biblically anyway.

Did not know that. Need to brush up on my bible reading lol
 
Satan called it Knowledge but it was shame. They were good and now they knew evil.

Regardless of the fact that it's really a metaphor, there was actually nothing there and this is a story...granted, God was pissy, and the tree was a bad idea to put in the middle of a garden and then say "hands off!" but for me it's the equivalent of saying "Try that white powder, it will make you happy!" ...for about 10 hours, and then you'll crave it forever and it will ruin your life.

There's always "truth" he leaves out. Lie of omission, always.

Is it "knowledge" to think nakedness is shameful?

Assuming it is a metaphor, in the Bible it's meant to be taken as "fact".

Within the terms of the Bible yes nakedness is shameful. There are plenty of other stories that specifically cover dress code and what parts of your body should and should not be covered especially as as a woman.

It was the equivalent of God sending a bunch of children out naked and he was probably snickering the entire time because it was hilarious to him that the stupid apes didn't know any better.



Lilith was pretty much a free agent. She was the first intended mate for Adam and said "FUCK THAT" and I like her for that alone. Biblically anyway.

Vast over simplification to the point of ouch, you kinda missed the point. She wasn't "intended" as the first mate. Not exactly. She was intended to be his bitch. And she said fuck that we were both made from the earth, we are equals. Depending on the version you read God either banished her because she didn't know her place or he told Adam to check his bitch and she ran away and he sent three Angels who's names I can't pronounce let alone spell but all have way too many 's's in them to chase her. She eventually becomes the first succubus and she's the reason for SIDS, nocturnal emissions and occasionally the mother of all monsters most notably the the Giants. Who are strangely absent other than Goliath.
 
Did not know that. Need to brush up on my bible reading lol

In Supernatural she was the first demon, so that gave her power.

They didn't do much about her history, maybe because that would make her more sympathetic, so they did something about eating babies instead.
 
Assuming it is a metaphor, in the Bible it's meant to be taken as "fact".

Within the terms of the Bible yes nakedness is shameful. There are plenty of other stories that specifically cover dress code and what parts of your body should and should not be covered especially as as a woman.

It was the equivalent of God sending a bunch of children out naked and he was probably snickering the entire time because it was hilarious to him that the stupid apes didn't know any better.

Vast over simplification to the point of ouch, you kinda missed the point. She wasn't "intended" as the first mate. Not exactly. She was intended to be his bitch. And she said fuck that we were both made from the earth, we are equals. Depending on the version you read God either banished her because she didn't know her place or he told Adam to check his bitch and she ran away and he sent three Angels who's names I can't pronounce let alone spell but all have way too many 's's in them to chase her. She eventually becomes the first succubus and she's the reason for SIDS, nocturnal emissions and occasionally the mother of all monsters most notably the the Giants. Who are strangely absent other than Goliath.

Naked is good. Nothing wrong with naked. You're a mean person. Yes, you.
Christianity made nakedness and women evil because the religions they were co-opting and opposing had as part of their tenets, the power of women and the power of fertility.

Lucifer took something good and turned it icky through the means he had available. All knowledge available in that tree, including the fact that he could subvert nakedness into something shameful.

Too bad they didn't learn a damned thing about farming. It was clearly not a fruit of knowledge, or else we'd all be really smart and that didn't happen.
 
I don't argue that naked is "good" (considering you can die of exposure especially in the areas the Bible was written. . .) Anyhow when observing a myth you have to assume that the rules of the myth are consistent no? If the rules here say "Thou shall keepeth a bucket full of Borax lying about" You better fucking do it. The stuff's been useless for thousands of years but damned if it didn't come in handy when it did. Which is short hand for if your taking the Bible as a mishmash of stories glued together fine, but if you're treating it as official lore (as the show attempts) then you have to take it at face value.


How do you know they DIDN'T learn anything about farming. God is never shown teaching them how to farm, they come from a garden where food is provided and yet their sons both spontaneously know how to farm. Cain tends to the fields and Abel to the flocks. Cain also founds the world's first city (quite a feat when even a liberal interpretation of the Bible at that point places the total number of people worldwide in the mid double digits. I think Adam and Eve have like seven or eight official children but even if you say times that number by ten founding a city is still quite a fucking feat.)
 
I don't argue that naked is "good" (considering you can die of exposure especially in the areas the Bible was written. . .) Anyhow when observing a myth you have to assume that the rules of the myth are consistent no? If the rules here say "Thou shall keepeth a bucket full of Borax lying about" You better fucking do it. The stuff's been useless for thousands of years but damned if it didn't come in handy when it did.

How do you know they DIDN'T learn anything about farming. God is never shown teaching them how to farm, they come from a garden where food is provided and yet their sons both spontaneously know how to farm. Cain tends to the fields and Abel to the flocks. Cain also founds the world's first city (quite a feat when even a liberal interpretation of the Bible at that point places the total number of people worldwide in the mid double digits. I think Adam and Eve have like seven or eight official children but even if you say times that number by ten founding a city is still quite a fucking feat.)

Fine then being cold is not shameful and there was no cold, it was paradise. Irrelevant. They didn't suddenly say "brrrrr"

Well, we're observing that both the Bible and Supernatural are inconsistent.

And yet there are places where Cain goes after the mark and there are other settlements. When the hell did that happen?
 
No they didn't just say Brr. They specifically were shamed by their nakedness. Which with the exception of nudists is a tradition that persists to this day and judging from looking at world wide populations including those rare South American tribes we keep finding that "taboo" seems to be universal and not thought up by spiteful men. Which you can accept as it just being common sense or there really being a God and him setting down similar rules world wide.

I never argued that the Bible or Supernatural were particularly consistent. Only that if we are discussing the Bible as Lore and not psuedo-history that it's a best a little unfair to bring in similarities with whatever that Z-religion is that I can't remember right now. Nor is it fair to bring up how all the people in that region have flood myths. Noah's Ark is fact if we are talking Bible Lore. (I'm mildly amazed that they don't seem to have brought that up like at all.)

I don't recall Cain going anywhere specific after the Mark but that would have happened between his leaving his family and him founding that first city. There is a lot of shit in Genesis that makes negative sense at best and less than that at most. Like I said I'm still working on how you found a city without people.

And why is there only One Giant ever?! You'd think those guys would be making a killing traveling with a horde of murderous basta. . .Israeli freedom fighters pre-emptively killing ara. . .look there should be more of them!
 
No they didn't just say Brr. They specifically were shamed by their nakedness. Which with the exception of nudists is a tradition that persists to this day and judging from looking at world wide populations including those rare South American tribes we keep finding that "taboo" seems to be universal and not thought up by spiteful men. Which you can accept as it just being common sense or there really being a God and him setting down similar rules world wide.

I never argued that the Bible or Supernatural were particularly consistent. Only that if we are discussing the Bible as Lore and not psuedo-history that it's a best a little unfair to bring in similarities with whatever that Z-religion is that I can't remember right now. Nor is it fair to bring up how all the people in that region have flood myths. Noah's Ark is fact if we are talking Bible Lore. (I'm mildly amazed that they don't seem to have brought that up like at all.)

I don't recall Cain going anywhere specific after the Mark but that would have happened between his leaving his family and him founding that first city. There is a lot of shit in Genesis that makes negative sense at best and less than that at most. Like I said I'm still working on how you found a city without people.

And why is there only One Giant ever?! You'd think those guys would be making a killing traveling with a horde of murderous basta. . .Israeli freedom fighters pre-emptively killing ara. . .look there should be more of them!

I think you're missing the difference between nakedness and ornamentation. There are plenty places where bare breasts and penis cones are the tradition.

Ornamentation and clothes are used variously to protect and reveal. In some places clothing is only to cover the bits that are soft and squishy and owie during stuff like pounding manioc and hunting. I think most people have figured out that exposed genitals attract bugs and dirt and such. Go camping naked and see how well that works out for you.

The Nephelim are a mystery, but I've seen a few series written on them. "The Stress of Her Regard" was supposedly about Nephelim...and the new City of Bones series by Cassandra Clare has demon hunters that are called Nephelim.

But really, it's just a cool word with a whole lot of WTF attached to it.
 
There are places yes, I'm not sure a lot is a fair discriptor BUT we live in a world where the majority of the world was influenced if not outright conquered by groups of people who can culturally be linked back in one way or another to the traditional Abrhamic religions. Pretty much what's left are the places they didn't bother or couldn't get too.

Yep, clothing serves as protection as well. Which may very well have been the ACTUAL reason. Kinda like there is a reason why pork is declared unclean, prepared wrong it can be very bad for you. Regardless point made.

Yeah Nephlim do have a fuck ton of WTF to them. They are the kind of thing that you would love cus you love teh lore and for me it's simply meaningless information. I don't mind information overload, I enjoy picking through Supernatural and Buffy and trying to cess out how all the rules function and occasionally asking "hey would this work?" but I don't like stuff that has nothing to do with anything. If for no other reason than somebody will remember it and when you try to do something else they'll remind you of rule 3,234 b, paragraph three, line two which clearly states.
 
There are places yes, I'm not sure a lot is a fair discriptor BUT we live in a world where the majority of the world was influenced if not outright conquered by groups of people who can culturally be linked back in one way or another to the traditional Abrhamic religions. Pretty much what's left are the places they didn't bother or couldn't get too.

Yep, clothing serves as protection as well. Which may very well have been the ACTUAL reason. Kinda like there is a reason why pork is declared unclean, prepared wrong it can be very bad for you. Regardless point made.

Yeah Nephlim do have a fuck ton of WTF to them. They are the kind of thing that you would love cus you love teh lore and for me it's simply meaningless information. I don't mind information overload, I enjoy picking through Supernatural and Buffy and trying to cess out how all the rules function and occasionally asking "hey would this work?" but I don't like stuff that has nothing to do with anything. If for no other reason than somebody will remember it and when you try to do something else they'll remind you of rule 3,234 b, paragraph three, line two which clearly states.

Good book...Cows, Pigs, Wars and Witches. It was more about the fact that pigs ate the same food that humans did and were high maintenance, where goats and cows were ruminants and didn't compete with human resources or say, get sunburned.

I do love the lore! I'm pretty picky with fantasy, but obviously fantasy is open to interpretation. I can deal with rewritings of fables.

That's why fantasy gets more of a pass for me than Science Fiction, because that is LORE and you do not fuck with it. Newp.
 
Yes. God was the one lying there.

God: Eat this fruit and you die.
Satan: Eat this fruit and you'll be smart.
Angel commentary: If man eats of this fruit he'll be like us knowing good from evil.

Result: Eating the fruit people knew they were naked and sought to cover up their nakedness. They also did not die. God shows up, gets pissy and banishes them.

I've heard people claim that eating the fruit robbed us of immortality but seeing how there is a tree of Life that grants immortality and is guarded after that I think that's a bit of a stretch. I have a hard time chalking THAT up as even misinformation.

His next apperance is Job and. . he's an insufferable asshole with God's permission but a real dick but I don't think he communicates directly with anybody but God in that story.

Actually, it wasn't God who lied to Adam and Eve, it was Lucifer.

Until Adam and Eve ate of the tree of knowledge they were perfect beings, meaning they were also immortal. They were deceived by Lucifer and corrupted by the fruit of the tree. This is supposed to be the origin of all of the evil and death in the world. The fruit didn't impart only knowledge, but also death and suffering.

Technically i suppose you could say that Lucifer didn't actually lie, he just didn't tell the entire truth.
 
That's still good reason to avoid pigs though I'd always read it had more to do with worms than anything else. Still there was a reason behind the reason given. People are stupid to this very day and if you have to tell children that the Nazi's will eat their parents if they don't remember to lock the door at night that's what you do. Of course sometimes they grow up to be the Lit Right Wing Circle Jerk and they don't understand that Karl Marx didn't actually fake his death so he could steal their Oreos nor was Susan B Anthony a plant so that in a centuries time they could pussify Football and turn it into ballet. (Wot, I see that look on your face. Have you not read what they say?! I'm barely exaggerating here! Ask UD if that's any less crazy than what Ish and Vette are undoubtedly bitching about right now!)

I get bored of lore rather quickly. I can love it if I'm in the mood but that's a bit rare over all and I generally find it to be pointless distractionary stuff. I think the problem is that I'm not a huge fan of my fantasy being open to interpretation. To me if two people read the same story and come to two different conclusions that is (except if that was his goal) the mark of a failure on the part of the author. Same reason why I often reject a large part of the books>movies argument especially when the author is involved with the movie. If you aren't seeing what I'm seeing when I write I failed you. Doesn't mean I didn't entertain you Reefer Madness is hilarious. . .but it was meant to scare people away from Pot.

Which I guess leads to my next part. Sci-Fi and Fantasy are grouped together on purpose and while I'll occasionally call out Sci-Fi on shit that shouldn't even work that way in general other than that nope. As long as you are consistent within your own lore I don't care if you come from a place where faster than light travel is common or Dragons founded the four great nations. It had better stay that way and if it changes down the road there had better be a good reason why so many people were so fucking mistaken though.
 
That's still good reason to avoid pigs though I'd always read it had more to do with worms than anything else. Still there was a reason behind the reason given. People are stupid to this very day and if you have to tell children that the Nazi's will eat their parents if they don't remember to lock the door at night that's what you do. Of course sometimes they grow up to be the Lit Right Wing Circle Jerk and they don't understand that Karl Marx didn't actually fake his death so he could steal their Oreos nor was Susan B Anthony a plant so that in a centuries time they could pussify Football and turn it into ballet. (Wot, I see that look on your face. Have you not read what they say?! I'm barely exaggerating here! Ask UD if that's any less crazy than what Ish and Vette are undoubtedly bitching about right now!)

I get bored of lore rather quickly. I can love it if I'm in the mood but that's a bit rare over all and I generally find it to be pointless distractionary stuff. I think the problem is that I'm not a huge fan of my fantasy being open to interpretation. To me if two people read the same story and come to two different conclusions that is (except if that was his goal) the mark of a failure on the part of the author. Same reason why I often reject a large part of the books>movies argument especially when the author is involved with the movie. If you aren't seeing what I'm seeing when I write I failed you. Doesn't mean I didn't entertain you Reefer Madness is hilarious. . .but it was meant to scare people away from Pot.

Which I guess leads to my next part. Sci-Fi and Fantasy are grouped together on purpose and while I'll occasionally call out Sci-Fi on shit that shouldn't even work that way in general other than that nope. As long as you are consistent within your own lore I don't care if you come from a place where faster than light travel is common or Dragons founded the four great nations. It had better stay that way and if it changes down the road there had better be a good reason why so many people were so fucking mistaken though.

Oh well, I'm an editor. It's my job and my nature to notice discrepancies. I make money from it. If I can't enjoy crap TV because I'm busy noticing all the discrepancies, it's still worth it.

I do try to keep it to myself a lot of the time but given an opportunity to geek out, you betcha I will.
 
Yikes. I'd go insane doing that as a job.

Actually, it wasn't God who lied to Adam and Eve, it was Lucifer.

Until Adam and Eve ate of the tree of knowledge they were perfect beings, meaning they were also immortal. They were deceived by Lucifer and corrupted by the fruit of the tree. This is supposed to be the origin of all of the evil and death in the world. The fruit didn't impart only knowledge, but also death and suffering.

Technically i suppose you could say that Lucifer didn't actually lie, he just didn't tell the entire truth.

I must have missed the verse where they mentioned people being perfect prior to that. Of course the angels are whispering that if Man eats the fruit he'll become like them so were they corrupt prior to this?
 
Yikes. I'd go insane doing that as a job.



I must have missed the verse where they mentioned people being perfect prior to that. Of course the angels are whispering that if Man eats the fruit he'll become like them so were they corrupt prior to this?

I love my job. I like minutiae, I like trivia, I like stories, I like knowing how to spell things. So if it means that some crap stuff is unenjoyable, it's comparable to the fact that I cook well so some crap food is unenjoyable.

What I don't get is how Angels don't have free will since they obviously do...or Lucifer wouldn't have complained.
 
Yikes. I'd go insane doing that as a job.



I must have missed the verse where they mentioned people being perfect prior to that. Of course the angels are whispering that if Man eats the fruit he'll become like them so were they corrupt prior to this?

The only angel whispering to Adam and Eve was a fallen one, Lucifer as far as I remember.

They would have been immortal had they been permitted to stay in the garden of Eden with the Tree of Life. As far as being perfect, I meant that they were without sin until they gave in to temptation and ate the forbidden fruit. The Tree of Life is said to have been located in the center of the Garden and they were permitted to eat of every tree EXCEPT the tree of knowledge.
 
Last edited:
I love my job. I like minutiae, I like trivia, I like stories, I like knowing how to spell things. So if it means that some crap stuff is unenjoyable, it's comparable to the fact that I cook well so some crap food is unenjoyable.

What I don't get is how Angels don't have free will since they obviously do...or Lucifer wouldn't have complained.

Yeah, I love that my computer knows how to spell things and I only have to get into the right ball park before it'll happily take over and go the rest of the way without me.

I love knowing stuff and and "Trivia" can be fun but it often gets in between me and whatever I'm trying to get at.

The only angel whispering to Adam and Eve was a fallen one, Lucifer as far as I remember.

They would have been immortal had they been permitted to stay in the garden of Eden with the Tree of Life. As far as being perfect, I meant that they were without sin until they gave in to temptation and ate the forbidden fruit. The Tree of Life is said to have been located in the center of the Garden.

Lucifer is the only one talking directly to Adam and Eve that's correct however. Genesis 3:22 And the Lord God said, Behold, the man is become as one of us, to know good and evil: and now, lest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever

To me it's a bit harsh to punish someone who by your own definition didn't know the difference between Good and Evil prior to committing the sin.

I guess I can see how you come to the conclusion though that if they weren't expelled they would have been permitted to eat the fruit of immortality though.
 
Yeah, I love that my computer knows how to spell things and I only have to get into the right ball park before it'll happily take over and go the rest of the way without me.

I love knowing stuff and and "Trivia" can be fun but it often gets in between me and whatever I'm trying to get at.



Lucifer is the only one talking directly to Adam and Eve that's correct however. Genesis 3:22 And the Lord God said, Behold, the man is become as one of us, to know good and evil: and now, lest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever

To me it's a bit harsh to punish someone who by your own definition didn't know the difference between Good and Evil prior to committing the sin.

I guess I can see how you come to the conclusion though that if they weren't expelled they would have been permitted to eat the fruit of immortality though.

Well, since I get a paycheck out of it, it's a good strategy to apply to other things. My brain's just built this way. Might as well cash in. Most of the people in my line of work have a heavy load of OCD. My OCD is mostly limited to narratives and stories and spelling so I lucked out in that way, not many jobs that pay for repetitive washing of hands. I'm good at details when I focus.

Genesis is part of the Bible, but a lot of the narrative and other books and testimonials were kept out of the Bible and edited later on to make things seem much more "pre-ordained" than they were originally told.

The story of Noah is still left in though, where God realizes he's been a douche and agrees not to smite the hell out of us again in anger.

The original gospels had God and Jesus as much more human and much less all knowing, much more allegorical to what it is to be a parent or be a child, and not about being perfectly divine.
 
Back
Top