The 2002 World Cup Thread

JazzManJim said:
Okay, football fans, I have a question. Okay. Two questions.

I've watched all or most of every single match which has been played thus far (either live or after I taped it) and I've seen at least two teams which, in my opinion, don't even belong here: Saudi Arabia, Tunisia, and China come to mind for generally uninspiring and often really bad play (though maybe I'm being too harsh on Tunisia).

So how did these teams get here? Which teams perhaps should have been here which aren't?

Jim thats 3
 
Re: Re: jass1960...

jass1960 said:


Sad but true........

....not going to be popular unless they can dominate the sport - and that ain't ever going to happen!

It is a shame 'cos our cosins are missing out on the 'beautiful game' and are so out of touch with reality in the rest of the world

I think it is more of a case of competing interests rather than a need to dominate. Middle aged America didn't grow up playing soccer. All that has changed. We haven't even gotten to the second generation of "Soccer Moms." If USA World Cup soccer was a stock, you'd have a nice nest egg if you bought now and held for 20 years.
 
it's done by geography so there is a wide spread

Europe 11
N/cen America 3
S America 5
Africa 5
Mid/Far East 5

That why some poor sides get in - USA finished 3rd out of a group of 6 N/Cen American countries and got in
 
Re: Re: jass1960...

jass1960 said:


Sad but true........

....not going to be popular unless they can dominate the sport - and that ain't ever going to happen!

Well, that's not entirely it (though it's probably part of it).

There are also a bunch of other sporting events which have bigger draws happening all at the same time. The Stanley cup Finals opened Tuesday night. The NBA Championship started Wednesday night. The French Open is getting extensive coverage on ESPN and ESPN 2 (especially with the Williams sisters doing so well). The US Open golf tournament oppens very soon (and it's all Tiger, all the time).

Most of those are personality-driven events and by God we love our personalities here. Soccer in the states, and especially the "we're a team and we'll play like one" attitude of Coach Arena just won't play well to those who love a strong and flashy personality. It is a shame and I hope it changes.

At least I'm paying attention, and ESPN 2's coverage is pretty darned good. Their half-hour World Cup tonight shows are done live and the commentary and highlights are more than I could have expected. I'm rather pleased with them.
 
Re: Re: Re: jass1960...

WriterDom said:


I think it is more of a case of competing interests rather than a need to dominate. Middle aged America didn't grow up playing soccer. All that has changed. We haven't even gotten to the second generation of "Soccer Moms." If USA World Cup soccer was a stock, you'd have a nice nest egg if you bought now and held for 20 years.

You could be right - I had a game when I visited the States a few years back and there were lots of young people playing - it was a mixed team game enjoyable if a little niaive
 
Re: Re: Re: jass1960...

JazzManJim said:


Well, that's not entirely it (though it's probably part of it).

There are also a bunch of other sporting events which have bigger draws happening all at the same time. The Stanley cup Finals opened Tuesday night. The NBA Championship started Wednesday night. The French Open is getting extensive coverage on ESPN and ESPN 2 (especially with the Williams sisters doing so well). The US Open golf tournament oppens very soon (and it's all Tiger, all the time).

Most of those are personality-driven events and by God we love our personalities here. Soccer in the states, and especially the "we're a team and we'll play like one" attitude of Coach Arena just won't play well to those who love a strong and flashy personality. It is a shame and I hope it changes.

At least I'm paying attention, and ESPN 2's coverage is pretty darned good. Their half-hour World Cup tonight shows are done live and the commentary and highlights are more than I could have expected. I'm rather pleased with them.


Good for you Jim and WriterDom
 
Re: Re: Re: jass1960...

WriterDom said:
I think it is more of a case of competing interests rather than a need to dominate. Middle aged America didn't grow up playing soccer. All that has changed. We haven't even gotten to the second generation of "Soccer Moms." If USA World Cup soccer was a stock, you'd have a nice nest egg if you bought now and held for 20 years.

I was part of the first soccer craze in the 1970s and I'm 34 now, so there aren't going to be folks too much older than I am now who have much interest in it in general. There was a die-off for a bit after that until perhaps the mid 80s and it's been very slowly growing since then (between the death of the NASL and the founding of some of the indoor leagues) and it's only been the last five or six years (with the popularity of the women's team) that soccer has made real inroads again.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Red Card for

bluespoke said:


Damn! Missed it.

Still, no surprise, he plays for Arsenal!!!!!


booooooooo!!! it's world cup. check your club allegiances at the door. :)
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Red Card for

Gord said:


It was way too harsh - first 20 mins of a fairly clean match - it was mistimed and clumsy not dirty

mexican ref - says it all why have a South american ref with a south american team playing



mexico is part of north america. It is a latin nation though and i'm sure that's what you were getting at. And fifa really should avoid letting themselves in for such criticism. Europe vs. North America, so let's just have an Asian ref, ok? That way nobody has a built-in gripe.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Red Card for

fanzee1 said:



booooooooo!!! it's world cup. check your club allegiances at the door. :)

Club allegiance has nothing to do with it. I don't support any English teams.

Arsenal have a dreadful disciplinary record.
 
jass1960 said:
for our American cousins and Bluespoke



Can the US now progress from group D? They may do well against Poland, but South Korea are fairly flying and Bruce Arena’s team will not be able to afford to wilt in the latter stages.


He's right about that wilting. That's my biggest concern against s.korea. They appear to be incredibly fit.
 
WriterDom said:


hmmm. cool. US/Mexico would be huge.


wouldn't it be? Mexico is the closest thing the u.s. has to an actual grudge-match rivalry in soccer/football.
 
jass1960 said:


all over mexico and in the minds of u.s. soccer fans. And since we'd be playing one of our neighbors, we'd pick up some fringe viewers, too.


Americans love winners. Look how quickly we embraced the women's team once everyone got a chance to see how good they are. If the u.s. men start winning big at the world cup, which probably won't happen until 2006 at the earliest, Americans will hop on the bandwagon, i have no doubt.
 
Re: jass1960...

p_p_man said:
I found your post a bit sad. I didn't realise the ignorance of the game was quite so deep in America.

In that case it's going to take a bit more than winning the World Cup (dreams sometimes come true:)) for people in the States to take to the game like the rest of the world has.

At least your women are World Champions. Maybe that's why there was confusion on the chat show. They didn't realise it's a game for both sexes...

Well, we'll keep on plugging its popularity...

:)


No, that report went WAY too far. I don't have time to get into all the inaccuracies but, for one thing, the report says the women's college softball championships "merit considerable coverage." That's a tournament of about 15 games and espn -- our family of all-sports networks -- showed about 3 of them, including the final. They were on in the middle of the afternoon and most sports pages had nothing more than a box score in agate type on any of them. I guarantee if you polled 100 fans AT A SPORTS BAR, well more than half of them would have no idea who won. (i know it was california but i'm a sports sicko. i have a problem:))

The world cup on the other hand has been aired, in its entirety on espn's networks. Every single game has been on. Most of the games have been live. Radio and TV stations report the scores of all the games and many of them have run features on the U.S. team. The one i work for ran a large feature on Brad Freidel because he's from our area. And anyone who is a sports fan is well aware of the outcome of the match, simply because espn has covered it so thoroughly. They may be shaking their heads saying "who cares, it's just soccer," but they know about it.


For whatever reason, some people are almost militant in their opposition to sports they don't understand. Perhaps the author of that report falls into this category and was attempting to mock soccer fans for their interest, I don't know. I just find it quite unfortunate. To anyone who doesn't like the sport, i say fine, don't watch. Why spread animosity by trying to belittle the sport and its supporters.
 
JazzManJim said:
Okay, football fans, I have a question. Okay. Two questions.

I've watched all or most of every single match which has been played thus far (either live or after I taped it) and I've seen at least two teams which, in my opinion, don't even belong here: Saudi Arabia, Tunisia, and China come to mind for generally uninspiring and often really bad play (though maybe I'm being too harsh on Tunisia).

So how did these teams get here? Which teams perhaps should have been here which aren't?


they qualified, like everybody else -- except france and the host countries. And i think you are being too hard on tunisia. The thing i love about world cup is that you can't get in on reputation or somebody voting you in because your nation is richer than another or something like that. You've got to earn you way in on the field, it's as simple as that.
 
fanzee1 said:



they qualified, like everybody else -- except france and the host countries. And i think you are being too hard on tunisia. The thing i love about world cup is that you can't get in on reputation or somebody voting you in because your nation is richer than another or something like that. You've got to earn you way in on the field, it's as simple as that.



Only the best get there in theory. Unfortunately theory doesn't work in practice.

The teams get there on the basis of geographic groupings. Thus a team that comes through an Oceanic group is unlikely to be as strong as one from Europe.

The group system ensures that there is a geographic mix it does not ensure that the best teams are all there.
 
jass1960 said:
it's done by geography so there is a wide spread

Europe 11
N/cen America 3
S America 5
Africa 5
Mid/Far East 5

That why some poor sides get in - USA finished 3rd out of a group of 6 N/Cen American countries and got in


CONCACAF qualifying (that's where the u.s. qualified from) starts with 35 nations in the first round and narrows to 16 in the second round. Only the last round contains just 6 teams. Your statement is like saying england and germany qualified out of a group of 5 teams in UEFA qualifying.

Can you see now how misleading your statement is?
 
jass1960 said:
it's done by geography so there is a wide spread

Europe 11
N/cen America 3
S America 5
Africa 5
Mid/Far East 5

That why some poor sides get in - USA finished 3rd out of a group of 6 N/Cen American countries and got in

And btw, europe got 15 teams into this world cup. 14 qualifiers plus defending champion france. That's 5 times as many as america's qualifying region, so i'd say it's fair all the way around.
 
fanzee1 said:



they qualified, like everybody else -- except france and the host countries.
There scrapeing that for the next worldcup and having it so that the host and last winners have to qualify like everyone else.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: jass1960...

jass1960 said:


You could be right - I had a game when I visited the States a few years back and there were lots of young people playing - it was a mixed team game enjoyable if a little niaive


that's why i think that soccer will be popular here in 20 years. The political term "soccer moms" didn't come about for nothing. There is a huge, bulging generation of yuppie offspring being raised on recreation league soccer -- boys and girls -- and those kids will grow up to be quite knowledgeable about the game. I doubt the sport will ever rival football, baseball and basketball but it might well give hockey a run for its money (sad for a big hockey fan like me). And it most certainly will develop a following large enough to remove it from the fringe. There are just too many people playing it now for it not to do so.
 
fanzee1 said:


And btw, europe got 15 teams into this world cup. 14 qualifiers plus defending champion france. That's 5 times as many as america's qualifying region, so i'd say it's fair all the way around.

It's only fair if the countries qualifying are better than those from other regions that failed to qualify.

For example, Holland did not qualify in their European group.

China, Korea, Tunisia, Japan, Costa Rica at least would not beat Holland but they are all there because of the geographical qualification system.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Red Card for

bluespoke said:


Club allegiance has nothing to do with it. I don't support any English teams.

Arsenal have a dreadful disciplinary record.


relax. i wasn't serious anyway. Your comments sounded like you were needling someone. I figured i'd needle back, just for heck of it. No harm done.
 
Back
Top