The Godless

lol, getting more agreeable in your name changes. I wasnt sure, I usually am getting fussed at when someone quotes the New Testament at me.
 
It further amazes me that many people can quote whole passages from the bible as reference to whatever point they are trying to make. But I often wonder if they have stopped to think about the psalm or whatever they so glibly spouted out. Did they ever stop to think what was being said and what context it was in? Did they study the bible as a historical text as well? Have they considered that the Gospels of Matthew Mark Luke and John were not all written at the same time...and in fact very greatly in their context...of the same story. And what of those gospels not included in the bible? There really apparently exisits a gospel of Mary Magdalene. Boy, it would really suck to find out that she wasn't some whore that Jesus was trying to bring to salvation now wouldn't it. My point is this, God, or whatever name you call God or even if you don't call God at all is not a random collection of clever verses. I would suggest that people who are able to do such things are just as much non-believers...
 
Oh and just so you know, that had nothing to do with Heretic's post response to brokenbrainwave. I just got to thinking about all the times someone has quoted the bible at me in justification for something.

Yes the greatest tenet of all is love.
 
Ok, one point though, one of the parts of Christianity is gathering more to the fold right?
That to me is a trouble maker all on it's own. That's what starts wars.
That is why I don't believe in religion.
 
thats also the function of the Local PTA and the Elks Lodge sunny.

I will disagree with you here, its the humanistic values, or lack thereof, the converts bring to christianity thats the problem, not the idea behind it. Unfortunate one cannot be seperated from the other.
 
sunstruck said:
Ok, one point though, one of the parts of Christianity is gathering more to the fold right?
That to me is a trouble maker all on it's own. That's what starts wars.

You're right about the first part but wrong about the second.
 
brokenbrainwave said:
thats also the function of the Local PTA and the Elks Lodge sunny.

I will disagree with you here, its the humanistic values, or lack thereof, the converts bring to christianity thats the problem, not the idea behind it. Unfortunate one cannot be seperated from the other.

So you think the world would be a better place if everyone was Christian, so long as they all followed Christian values.
 
Rhys said:
It further amazes me that many people can quote whole passages from the bible as reference to whatever point they are trying to make. But I often wonder if they have stopped to think about the psalm or whatever they so glibly spouted out. Did they ever stop to think what was being said and what context it was in? Did they study the bible as a historical text as well? Have they considered that the Gospels of Matthew Mark Luke and John were not all written at the same time...and in fact very greatly in their context...of the same story. And what of those gospels not included in the bible? There really apparently exisits a gospel of Mary Magdalene. Boy, it would really suck to find out that she wasn't some whore that Jesus was trying to bring to salvation now wouldn't it. My point is this, God, or whatever name you call God or even if you don't call God at all is not a random collection of clever verses. I would suggest that people who are able to do such things are just as much non-believers...

Oh true about Mary Magdalene and Thomas and a good many more. The Gospels, Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, were written upwards of 100 years after Jesus lived. I do not state Christ as Jesus never considered himself this. It was a title bestowed upon him many years after his existance. I like the questions you've posed here. They are many of the reasons my path changed.
 
sunstruck said:
So you think the world would be a better place if everyone was Christian, so long as they all followed Christian values.

I do. Love your neighbor as yourself. Treat others the way you would want them to treat you. Honor thy father and they mother (NOT unconditionally). Don't kill. Don't commit adultery.

Which one of these things do you find disturbing?
 
RawHumor said:
I do. Love your neighbor as yourself. Treat others the way you would want them to treat you. Honor thy father and they mother (NOT unconditionally). Don't kill. Don't commit adultery.

Which one of these things do you find disturbing?

The one where every other religion and culture on the planet is dismantled and dismissed.

Conformity scares me.
 
And by the way, the ten commandments are not Christian exclusively.

AND they aren't realigious ideas. They are common decency.
 
My favorite example is the Crusades. Instigated by the Pope to purge the Holy Lands from the Infidels, groups of soldiers, noblemen, townsfolk, farmers, beggars, thieves and children, crossed into The Holy Lands to fight and die in the name of Christ. Sadly, the Muslims, Jews, and whoever else the Church had named Heretic that day, were actually few and far between. Most of the people they fought were groups of soliders, noblemen, townsfolk, farmers, beggars, thieves and children...all of whom had been converted to Christianity but were unwilling to give up their scraps of land and what little wealth they had to the Church.

Nauseating...and still going on to this day.
 
sunstruck said:
The one where every other religion and culture on the planet is dismantled and dismissed.

Conformity scares me.

Culture? What culture is dismissed?

Just because a Christian believes that our way is the only way to Heaven doesn't mean that we (should) look down on others for their beliefs or pretend they don't exist.
 
sunstruck said:
So you think the world would be a better place if everyone was Christian, so long as they all followed Christian values.
no that is not what I implied or said. My point is that of if one chooses to have a faith (ie love) based value system, then live up to it.
I agree with Rhys that there are many many flaws in the Bible and in Christianity in general. However if someone wants to disregard them, and believe in the core of this religion, then thats great! Just dont tell me how its right to kill and maim in the name of a supposedly loving God. My arguement is practice what you preach, nothing more nothing less.
 
RawHumor said:
Culture? What culture is dismissed?

Just because a Christian believes that our way is the only way to Heaven doesn't mean that we (should) look down on others for their beliefs or pretend they don't exist.


But you just did.
 
sunstruck said:
The one where every other religion and culture on the planet is dismantled and dismissed.

Conformity scares me.

Diversity has been around since the wait for it...days of in the Bible. The fact that each religion feels a need to disparage another is a sad state of affairs...a complete contradiction to the "Love Thy Neighbor" ideal.
 
sunstruck said:
AND they aren't realigious ideas. They are common decency.

That's just it. We're living in a day of moral relativism, where anything can be explained away if you try hard enough. Common decency is ceasing to exist.
 
Rhys said:
It further amazes me that many people can quote whole passages from the bible as reference to whatever point they are trying to make. But I often wonder if they have stopped to think about the psalm or whatever they so glibly spouted out. Did they ever stop to think what was being said and what context it was in? Did they study the bible as a historical text as well?
Most don't. Most don't look at the big picture - most take the easy way out (humans are lazy) and don't look at the context, muchless explore the entire contents to get the big picture and context. They take isolated scriptures and understand them only in a limited context as explained to them by people with their own agendas. This is one of the reasons why the church did not want Martin Luther to publish the Bible in German so laypeople could read and understand it for themselves.

You see the results in such simple understandings of such basic concepts as to whether the Bible condones killing of humans by humans or not. People to this day still quote "Thou shalt not kill" even though the proper translation is "Thou shalt not murder" which is quite different in its implications. One little word - something that anybody who read almost any aprt of the Bible besides that one verse would know the intended meaning thereof regardless of which word was used.

Have they considered that the Gospels of Matthew Mark Luke and John were not all written at the same time...and in fact very greatly in their context...of the same story.
The variances in the different Gospels are at least partially explained by the fact that they were written by different people with different perspectives of the same events. Any time you have eye witnesses to any event, you will get widely varying accounts of what happened and what was said. To me, the amazing aspect of the Gospels is that even given that fact of different perspectives is that they are as consistent as they are.
 
brokenbrainwave said:
no that is not what I implied or said. My point is that of if one chooses to have a faith (ie love) based value system, then live up to it.
I agree with Rhys that there are many many flaws in the Bible and in Christianity in general. However if someone wants to disregard them, and believe in the core of this religion, then thats great! Just dont tell me how its right to kill and maim in the name of a supposedly loving God. My arguement is practice what you preach, nothing more nothing less.
]


I agree with everything you said.
 
Back
Top