The Godless

RawHumor said:
That's just it. We're living in a day of moral relativism, where anything can be explained away if you try hard enough. Common decency is ceasing to exist.


Common decency had nothing to do with religion.


Caly, I agree totally.

Rhys, not only do I agree, but I'm glad to see you posting here.
 
It is interesting to note that what is being said is pretty much the same thing by each poster, only I think it is so often that we need to argue our point of view that we don't see what lies within the words spoken.


RawHumor said:
Just because a Christian believes that our way is the only way to Heaven doesn't mean that we (should) look down on others for their beliefs or pretend they don't exist.

This is very true...and coincides with what Sunstruck wrote. However, when using the term Christian, all those who believe in Christ are lumped together and there are certain religious groups within Christianity who believe THEIR version of Christianity to be the ONE true way over other Christian groups.


brokenbrainwave said:
My arguement is practice what you preach, nothing more nothing less.

I like your argument!
 
RawHumor said:
That's just it. We're living in a day of moral relativism, where anything can be explained away if you try hard enough. Common decency is ceasing to exist.
is this not more a comment to the woes of society and less a comment as to the lack of religion?
 
brokenbrainwave said:
is this not more a comment to the woes of society and less a comment as to the lack of religion?

It's both. It goes back to my belief that if more people acted Christ-like (as a Christian should) then we'd all be better off.
 
The Heretic said:
The variances in the different Gospels are at least partially explained by the fact that they were written by different people with different perspectives of the same events. Any time you have eye witnesses to any event, you will get widely varying accounts of what happened and what was said. To me, the amazing aspect of the Gospels is that even given that fact of different perspectives is that they are as consistent as they are.

The truth is that some of the Gospels were not even eyewitness accounts of those writing them. They are based on letters of an original witness or stories told to them, written by an interpreter of said words or stories. As stated words can be taken out of context and twisted to meet the desire of the person trying to make a point.
 
RawHumor said:
It's both. It goes back to my belief that if more people acted Christ-like (as a Christian should) then we'd all be better off.
and what room does a good, honest, faithful, loving, non believer have in this eutopia?
 
brokenbrainwave said:
and what room does a good, honest, faithful, loving, non believer have in this eutopia?

Again, love your neighbor as yourself.
 
The variances in the different Gospels are at least partially explained by the fact that they were written by different people with different perspectives of the same events. Any time you have eye witnesses to any event, you will get widely varying accounts of what happened and what was said. To me, the amazing aspect of the Gospels is that even given that fact of different perspectives is that they are as consistent as they are. [/QUOTE]

I think the oldest is Luke...its whichever one tells about the crucifixtion and ends with Jesus saying "My God why hast thou forsaken me?"

I read somewhere that historically, scholars thought that one was probably written within 50 years of Jesus' death. The others are consistant because they are retellings of each other. The extreme cynic in me says that this is the work of several clever editors...both in the original writing and in the selection process of actually including these in the bible itself.
 
calypso_21 said:
The truth is that some of the Gospels were not even eyewitness accounts of those writing them. They are based on letters of an original witness or stories told to them, written by an interpreter of said words or stories. As stated words can be taken out of context and twisted to meet the desire of the person trying to make a point.

Wait. This isn't something that you, or anyone, knows for sure. You can't state this as a fact, because it isn't.

I take the words of the Gospel authors as being their own words because it makes sense to me to do so, but not because I can prove so empirically. There have been attempts to do so, and to prove that they weren't the authors' words, but neither one has any firm standing one way or the other.
 
It doesn't matter. No one is ever going to agree anyway.

It's historic fact. Religion, like any absolutism in a world of diversity is going to wreak havoc.

It's also an historic fact that there's nothing that can be done about it. You can't fight faith, no matter which side of the line it falls on.
 
RawHumor said:
Again, love your neighbor as yourself.
naw, Stan aint into that.

okok all joking aside, I have no problem with this, its how I try to live. However, this really has little to do with religion.
 
JazzManJim said:
I take the words of the Gospel authors as being their own words because it makes sense to me to do so, but not because I can prove so empirically.


Which is why you can't argue with a zealot. You can place scientific evidence at their feet, walk them through historic fact step by step and they can discount every drop of it.

Because they believe it to be so. The mind is a powerful thing.
 
calypso_21 said:
The truth is that some of the Gospels were not even eyewitness accounts of those writing them. They are based on letters of an original witness or stories told to them, written by an interpreter of said words or stories. As stated words can be taken out of context and twisted to meet the desire of the person trying to make a point.
Whether you accept that or not, overall the Gospels do seem fairly consistent given the different authors. The variations themselves do not infer an lack of validity to the accounts.

Moreover, the important lessons to be learned from the Bible are not learned by obsessing on the minutae, but rather looking for the overall messages. As already pointed out, from a Christian's perspective, the main message is to love God and to love your neighbors. Any interpretation of parts of the Bible that is inconsistent with that message is either a misinterpretation or taken out of context.
 
RawHumor said:
It's both. It goes back to my belief that if more people acted Christ-like (as a Christian should) then we'd all be better off.

It is more that people should follow Jesus' teachings rather than to be "Christ-like". To be such is to be a Messiah. Too many people are bogged down with the need to be that which they are not. I believe if Jesus' teachings were taught as He meant them to be, more people would embrace Him...I can't say Christianity because Christianity is not what Jesus created. It is what Constantine, a pagan emperor, and the Council of Nicaea created nearly 300 years after Jesus lived.
 
You guys are talking about religion. I'm telling you what I believe as a Christian and what the Bible says.

Just because it's "common decency" or "The Golden Rule" or "common sense" or whatever doesn't mean that it has nothing to do with the Bible or religion or whatever.

Whether these beliefs existed before they were written in the Bible or became commone because they're written in the Bible, my point was that if we, as a society, acted according to these beliefs, we'd all be better off.

I'm not saying everyone has to be a Christian for us to get along. Not all Christians get along, and there are many "Christian" religions that are 180 degrees apart from each other. There are assholes of every color and creed.

But again, if we all acted more Christ-like, I think our society would benefit.
 
JazzManJim said:
Wait. This isn't something that you, or anyone, knows for sure. You can't state this as a fact, because it isn't.


JMJ. The Editors of the King James Version of the Bible did indeed change passages in the bible and the language used (hence the thees and thous) to suit the King. We still use this version of the bible today. The Catholic edition of the Bible contains the Apocrypha...a kind of "extra" section that contains other Gospels and various writings. These things have been noted historically. I attended a Methodist University and I took Biblical History because it was a required course to get my degree. She is correct.
 
The Heretic said:
Any interpretation of parts of the Bible that is inconsistent with that message is either a misinterpretation or taken out of context.


Completely in agreement right here.
 
The Heretic said:
Whether you accept that or not, overall the Gospels do seem fairly consistent given the different authors. The variations themselves do not infer an lack of validity to the accounts.

Moreover, the important lessons to be learned from the Bible are not learned by obsessing on the minutae, but rather looking for the overall messages. As already pointed out, from a Christian's perspective, the main message is to love God and to love your neighbors. Any interpretation of parts of the Bible that is inconsistent with that message is either a misinterpretation or taken out of context.

Exactly.
 
I will agree with you 100% on this one raw. We as people should treat each other as Christ, no matter if he was real or fictional, treated others.

Its our silly animal characteristics that seemingly muck everything up...
 
Dixon Carter Lee said:

<snip>

In fact, atheism has appealed to a small portion of Western Civilization for millennia, Hecht says, noting she has found records of religious skeptics dating back to 600 B.C.

<snip>
A bit off topic but "she has found" ?

Makes it sound like she has unearthed some obscure fact. What's the big deal, it's no secret that some ancient Greek philosophers were atheists.
 
God, thank you for allowing me this day to utilize my brain with thoughts of you.
 
calypso_21 said:
It is more that people should follow Jesus' teachings rather than to be "Christ-like". To be such is to be a Messiah. Too many people are bogged down with the need to be that which they are not. I believe if Jesus' teachings were taught as He meant them to be, more people would embrace Him...I can't say Christianity because Christianity is not what Jesus created. It is what Constantine, a pagan emperor, and the Council of Nicaea created nearly 300 years after Jesus lived.


I actually agree with all of that. So many people forget that Christ did not create Christianity.
 
sunstruck said:
It's historic fact. Religion, like any absolutism in a world of diversity is going to wreak havoc.

This, also, is untrue.

Religion, even as a set of absolute beliefs need not cause havoc and, indeed, in many circumstances has not caused havoc.

I can think right off the top of my head of the Quakers, for instance. The Amish also serve as another example.

It's my firm belief that the greatest problem with most organized religions, and the varieties of Christianity in particular, that they forget a basic tenet of their own belief systems: free will.

People will believe what they will. You can introduce them to your belief, cajole them, even, but it doesn't mean that they will believe. And you can't force them. All you can do by going further is to spark enmity toward you and those who believe like you.

A lot of religions have forgotten that, in the end, belief is individual. It is (if you follow this belief anyhow) your soul for which you have to answer. You can only be responsible for sharing your beliefs with others, not for what they do with it once you've shared.

I have a belief system replete with absolutes. I believe in absolute rights and wrongs - in black and white and very few shades of grey. I understand, though, that everyone may believe what they wish. It is, after all, their own lives and souls for which they'll have to answer. Oddly enough, the only problems I've ever had with anyone over my beliefs are with those who tell me that I have no right to absolute beliefs. I find those people get very hostile toward me, which puzzles me, because hostility seems to fly in the face of their own beliefs. It's as if the very notion that someone should hold absolute beliefs is offensive to them, no matter what that person chooses to do with those beliefs.
 
Back
Top