The Godless

Rhys said:
JMJ. The Editors of the King James Version of the Bible did indeed change passages in the bible and the language used (hence the thees and thous) to suit the King. We still use this version of the bible today.
futhermore, learn some Hebrew and read both side by side. Not even close, not by a landslide.
 
sunstruck said:
It doesn't matter. No one is ever going to agree anyway.

It's historic fact. Religion, like any absolutism in a world of diversity is going to wreak havoc.
Not all religions are absolutist, nor are all religions practiced/believed in an absolutist manner. Even if a religion is practiced as absolutism, that does not necessarily mean it will wreak havoc (although historically is usually has) - sometimes it just means isolation of those practicing the religion because they are in a minority. Quakers and similar sects (Mennonite, Hutterite, Amish) are very absolute in their religious practices and , yet I would say they have wreaked much less havoc than much less absolutist sects - indeed, they are often held up as examples of tolerance despite their strict beliefs.
 
brokenbrainwave said:
I will agree with you 100% on this one raw. We as people should treat each other as Christ, no matter if he was real or fictional, treated others.

Its our silly animal characteristics that seemingly muck everything up...

We're not perfect. We shouldn't claim to be. I'm certainly not.

What gets dangerous is when people put "religous appearance" ahead of what is right. For example, the devout Catholics kicking their daughter onto the street because she got pregnant at 16, or the uppety Lutheran calling his sister a whore because she is Methodist or whatever.

These are not Christian principles, even if they are "religious" in nature.
 
calypso_21 said:
Not all animal characteristics are bad. ;)
oh you just like my big beak. The rumors you can use that to guess are a lie, unless its proportionately inverted...
 
Jim. You're speaking in shoulds and coulds. I was speaking about fact. History has shown religion as the cause, excuse for or catalyst of most of the worlds major battles:

The Crusades
The Catholic/Protestant wars in France
The Catholic/Church of England wars in Britian
Everything going on in the middle east for the last 5,000 years
The European part of WWII

I can go on.

Should it be that way? Hell no. Could it be different? Maybe.

Is it? No.
 
I'm all for a "don't ask-don't tell" policy. This includes the President and Ashcroft (among others). Being PC has been so ingrained upon us that there is no reason that public events (such as memorials to 9/11) should have had such religious overtones. Unfortunately, Bush knows that his trump card with the conservative Republicans is his strong Christian religious ties. So, exercised his own religious values in such public events ignoring the rest of the populace...albeit a minority in this country. Similarly, there is no reason that workers at the DOJ feel forced into daily prayer sessions because of Ashcroft's beliefs. Prayer in the workforce, in the schools, and outside home or church, I feel is inappropriate. No one should force their religious values on others. I have a religion, but I have no intention of exercising that religion outside of my home and my church. I ask that the same courtesy be extended to me, especially by those who yield political power.
 
Rhys said:
JMJ. The Editors of the King James Version of the Bible did indeed change passages in the bible and the language used (hence the thees and thous) to suit the King. We still use this version of the bible today. The Catholic edition of the Bible contains the Apocrypha...a kind of "extra" section that contains other Gospels and various writings. These things have been noted historically. I attended a Methodist University and I took Biblical History because it was a required course to get my degree. She is correct.

Rhys, I'm not doubting your education. I also have a formidable education, both formal and informal, concerning the Bible and religion in general.

It is true that the editors of the Bible - all 16 of them - changes language used. Well, that's because most folks didn't read Greek, Aramaic, and Hebrew. That kind of makes sense to me.

But yes, I know what you're saying. And from my own studying into the events of this translation, and the many steps that were placed in it to ensure maximum scrutiny by each member, that the words I have are the words I was meant to have. The Apocrypha was a series of books that wasn't included in the original 1611 King James version of the Bible but which were added later. The scholars that edited the translation considered them very close to canon, but not up to the level of scrutiny to which they had subjected every text. This was the first tier of rejected books in the Bible.

Besides, in a metaphysical sense, I rather think that God is capable of getting a book published, if that's what he wanted to do, don't you? :)
 
JazzManJim said:
This, also, is untrue.

Religion, even as a set of absolute beliefs need not cause havoc and, indeed, in many circumstances has not caused havoc.

I can think right off the top of my head of the Quakers, for instance. The Amish also serve as another example.

It's my firm belief that the greatest problem with most organized religions, and the varieties of Christianity in particular, that they forget a basic tenet of their own belief systems: free will.

People will believe what they will. You can introduce them to your belief, cajole them, even, but it doesn't mean that they will believe. And you can't force them. All you can do by going further is to spark enmity toward you and those who believe like you.

A lot of religions have forgotten that, in the end, belief is individual. It is (if you follow this belief anyhow) your soul for which you have to answer. You can only be responsible for sharing your beliefs with others, not for what they do with it once you've shared.

I have a belief system replete with absolutes. I believe in absolute rights and wrongs - in black and white and very few shades of grey. I understand, though, that everyone may believe what they wish. It is, after all, their own lives and souls for which they'll have to answer. Oddly enough, the only problems I've ever had with anyone over my beliefs are with those who tell me that I have no right to absolute beliefs. I find those people get very hostile toward me, which puzzles me, because hostility seems to fly in the face of their own beliefs. It's as if the very notion that someone should hold absolute beliefs is offensive to them, no matter what that person chooses to do with those beliefs.

You have every right to your beliefs just as the next person is to theirs. I for one would never argue your beliefs. Facts, yes. Beliefs...NEVER.

Just a point though...not intentionally, the Quakers did indeed cause havoc by standing for their principles and subsequently being persecuted for that reason. It all depends on the POV used.
 
brokenbrainwave said:
futhermore, learn some Hebrew and read both side by side. Not even close, not by a landslide.
Or get some interlinear Bibles. I don't think there are huge variances given that I have Greek and Hebrew interlinears of the Bible sitting on my shelf, but then I am not a Biblical scholar either. But we are getting way off topic, whether there are variances in the translations of the Bible have little to do with whether the original issue of the thread. The possible motives behind translations may have relevance, but not that much.
 
sunstruck said:
Jim. You're speaking in shoulds and coulds. I was speaking about fact. History has shown religion as the cause, excuse for or catalyst of most of the worlds major battles:

We've gone over this one, you and I. I can name rampant nationalism and ethnic enmity as the cause of most of the world's major battles and have as sound a basis in historical fact as you do with religion.

I speak in shoulds and could because that's what's relly important to the discussion. Yes, religion has been ill-used as a tool to further selfishness and greed and hate. So has a lot of stuff. Religion is a handy weapon to weild because so many people care so little for what exists in their own hearts. They take for granted that they even have a religion to believe at all in many cases.

Is that the fault of a religion. No, no more than it's the fault of a tire-irn that's used to bash in someone's head.

Who is at fault are the leaders of nations and those who follow blindly, regardless of the reason.

The problem, IMO, with the invocation of God and religion in this country is that all too often it's done by rote and has been stripped of any possible significance whatsoever. It's been sewn into the tapestry of the country so very well that it has no practical use to anyone in it. People say the Pledge of Alliegance heedless of the words they're actually saying. They barely realize the very reason they have basic Constitutional rights at all was partly for a strong religious reason.

They take this all for granted and barely consider what role, if any, religion has in their lives. I respect you all here far mroe than the average Christian because, whether your beliefs mirror mine or not, you've obviously put real thought into what you believe and you make it a part of your lives each day. That matters far more to me than the casual use of the name of God in some memorial address.
 
JazzManJim said:
Besides, in a metaphysical sense, I rather think that God is capable of getting a book published, if that's what he wanted to do, don't you? :)

My grandfather, a theologian and minister, went nuts whenever I employed this type argument with him. I loved it. :D
 
I disagree that it was off topic heretic. Could it not be said the Bible changes from translation to translation to suite the needs of the translators?
That happens even within the same translation, so its valid. Lets take Second Corinthians, forgive me I forgot the chapter, but it deals with speaking in tongues. I was raised a "holy roller" (ugh)and it was used to back their belief in this activity. Funny how the more reserved sects use this same passage to bolster their arguement against it. Whats the common demomenator? They both basically cut and paste the parts they like.
 
JazzManJim said:
The problem, IMO, with the invocation of God and religion in this country is that all too often it's done by rote and has been stripped of any possible significance whatsoever. It's been sewn into the tapestry of the country so very well that it has no practical use to anyone in it. People say the Pledge of Alliegance heedless of the words they're actually saying. They barely realize the very reason they have basic Constitutional rights at all was partly for a strong religious reason.

They take this all for granted and barely consider what role, if any, religion has in their lives. I respect you all here far mroe than the average Christian because, whether your beliefs mirror mine or not, you've obviously put real thought into what you believe and you make it a part of your lives each day. That matters far more to me than the casual use of the name of God in some memorial address.

This comment is very true about almost everything people do. Very few see the little things anymore. They don't take pleasure in what they have...only in their desires for what they won't have. I do agree here...straying from more than just the flock...original intent I mean.
 
Diablogrl said:
I have a religion, but I have no intention of exercising that religion outside of my home and my church. I ask that the same courtesy be extended to me, especially by those who yield political power.
I exercise my religion everywhere and at all times, but in such a way so as not to shove it down people's throats or to make people feel I am being sanctimonious. Most people don't even know I am a fundamentalist Christian unless they start discussing it with me. Since to me being a Christian means believing in Christ as my savior, and practicing his teachings, especially with regards to loving God and my neighbors, I don't see any problem with practicing my religion everywhere and anytime. I don't have to get down on my knees with a Bible in my hand to pray - I don't even have to close my eyes.

I think part of the problem is that too few Christians truly practice their religions outside their home and church when Christianity (or most any religion) is meant to be a methodology for living. Practicing a religion does not necessarily mean making people aware of your religion or prostelytizing constantly - it means living according to your beliefs, and if more people practiced that, both religious and non-religious, the world would probably be a better place.
 
calypso_21 said:
My grandfather, a theologian and minister, went nuts whenever I employed this type argument with him. I loved it. :D

Yeah...I've done this a time or two myself. It's one of my favorite things to use. ;)
 
brokenbrainwave said:
I disagree that it was off topic heretic. Could it not be said the Bible changes from translation to translation to suite the needs of the translators?
That happens even within the same translation, so its valid. Lets take Second Corinthians, forgive me I forgot the chapter, but it deals with speaking in tongues. I was raised a "holy roller" (ugh)and it was used to back their belief in this activity. Funny how the more reserved sects use this same passage to bolster their arguement against it. Whats the common demomenator? They both basically cut and paste the parts they like.

I agree that it could indeed be said.



Um btw...First Corinthians Chapters 12 & 14.
 
Purple Haze said:
You people are making it very hard for me to get any work done today...

You know this is not the first time I've been told this. Even today.
 
The Heretic said:
I think part of the problem is that too few Christians truly practice their religions outside their home and church when Christianity (or most any religion) is meant to be a methodology for living. Practicing a religion does not necessarily mean making people aware of your religion or prostelytizing constantly - it means living according to your beliefs, and if more people practiced that, both religious and non-religious, the world would probably be a better place.

I agree with what you are saying here. I believe the original purpose was to spread God's word and Jesus' teachings...not necessarily to force people into a belief system they truly can not stand behind. As JMJ stated, there is free will, this is my belief...with that one has to come to into their own as far as a belief in God is concerned. My testimonial is just that...mine.
 
Diablogrl said:
I'm all for a "don't ask-don't tell" policy. This includes the President and Ashcroft (among others). Being PC has been so ingrained upon us that there is no reason that public events (such as memorials to 9/11) should have had such religious overtones. Unfortunately, Bush knows that his trump card with the conservative Republicans is his strong Christian religious ties. So, exercised his own religious values in such public events ignoring the rest of the populace...albeit a minority in this country. Similarly, there is no reason that workers at the DOJ feel forced into daily prayer sessions because of Ashcroft's beliefs. Prayer in the workforce, in the schools, and outside home or church, I feel is inappropriate. No one should force their religious values on others. I have a religion, but I have no intention of exercising that religion outside of my home and my church. I ask that the same courtesy be extended to me, especially by those who yield political power.

I think that people should be free to speak their beliefs in public... sure, they might "offend" some people... but when you have freedom of speech, there will usually be someone that can claim to be "offended", no matter what is being said (religious or not) That's one of the things that makes the United States a great country.

As for those with "political power", I think a "don't ask-don't tell" policy on religion could hide very important information as to how the leader would perform his or her job, because someone who follows a particular religion will practice its principles in every aspect of their life, not just their private life. The leader's decision's would be affected by his/her religious beliefs. Therefore, the public would be affected by these religious beliefs.

There are some countries that do not permit anything "religious" outside the home, but I don't think there are many Americans that would want to live in those countries...
 
brokenbrainwave said:
I disagree that it was off topic heretic. Could it not be said the Bible changes from translation to translation to suite the needs of the translators?
To a certain degree in certain circumstances. Since I have researched this a bit, I do believe that there has also been a good deal of effort in various scolarly translations to maintain the original intent and meaning of the words. Of course if you go with some of the less than scholarly translations then you get all kinds of variations.


That happens even within the same translation, so its valid. Lets take Second Corinthians, forgive me I forgot the chapter, but it deals with speaking in tongues. I was raised a "holy roller" (ugh)and it was used to back their belief in this activity. Funny how the more reserved sects use this same passage to bolster their arguement against it. Whats the common demomenator? They both basically cut and paste the parts they like.
I think here you are talking more about interpretation rather than translation - two different but related things. Everybody has their own interpretation, some use scholarly exegesis, others just wing it according to their own whims and agenda, but I believe most of the serious attempts at translation at least attempt to be true to the original intent most of the time.
 
I don't have much to contribute, I'm just enjoying the read.

I will share a couple of comments I've heard from "Christians" lately:

___________________________

"Those Muslims, they think their way is the only right way."

"Those cults, thay start teaching their beliefs to children from the time they can talk."

___________________________

Pot, meet Kettle.

Does "agnostic" mean you're not quite sure, but you're open to possibillities?
 
Back
Top