"Top Kill" fails

I can't believe you want to compare Soviet dedication to safety in anything, but in this the comparison strikes true if you're comparing omnipotent central planning states to each other and the increased likelihood of accidents when industry becomes melded to state...

Have you read "Failure Factory" by Gertz?

Aside from the mindless "We blame Bush for lax regulation" there is also the bubbling and more truer story of regulators and industry being in bed and passing back and forth with regularity for we also see that in the Financial arena and with the Press and the Democrat Party...
__________________
"As the 20th century drew to a close, the connection between hard scientific fact and public policy became increasingly elastic. In part this was possible because of the complacency of the scientific profession; in part because of the lack of good science education among the public; in part because of the rise of specialized advocacy groups which have been enormously effective in getting publicity and shaping policy; and in great part because of the decline of the media as an independent assessor of fact."
Michael Crichton, 2003 lecture at Caltech "Aliens Cause Global Warming."
 
What a crock of crap is that?

Ishmael

I agree with the reply to the bolded part.



We shoved them out to sea for political gain and expected that political regulation would "protect" us and the planet that the State Religion of Gaia wants to protect by ending all drilling.
__________________
"The more communal enterprise extends, the more attention is drawn to the bad business results of nationalized and municipalized undertakings. It is impossible to miss the cause of the difficulty: a child could see where something was lacking. So that it cannot be said that this problem has not been tackled. But the way in which it has been tackled has been deplorably inadequate. Its organic connection with the essential nature of socialist enterprise has been regarded as merely a question of better selection of persons. It has not been realized that even exceptionally gifted men of high character cannot solve the problems created by socialist control of industry."
Ludwig Heinrich Edler von Mises
 
At this point it does not matter which party was at the helm when the rules were made. Those guidelines failed us in this instance. Other countries have other rules which may have helped out here. A diversion pipe is not a shabby idea. A valve that actually worked might have been nice.

So the Gulf is all oily. Big fucking deal. We should just leave it all oily and drill the rest of it out at full speed. Clean it up after we suck that bitch dry.
 
It's not.

Those companies have been skirting the line for a while, in the interest of profit.

It just blew back on British Petroleum.

Then it was up to the Administration to take note of that and stop it, not give them a safety award...

So the blow-back is not just on the industry, but on the government that's "too big to fail."

He was, remember, the transformative change guy!
__________________
As for many great “thinkers,” for Barack Obama and his coterie words seem to exist mostly in the realm of metaphor rather than as descriptors of actual action actually occurring in anything so humdrum as reality. And so it is that, even as his bungling administration flounders in the turbulent waters of the Gulf, on the speaker’s podium the president still confidently sails forth deftly steering the ship through the narrow ribbon of sludge between the Scylla of sonorous banality and the Charybdis of gaseous uplift.

Mark Steyn
 
At this point it does not matter which party was at the helm when the rules were made. Those guidelines failed us in this instance. Other countries have other rules which may have helped out here. A diversion pipe is not a shabby idea. A valve that actually worked might have been nice.

So the Gulf is all oily. Big fucking deal. We should just leave it all oily and drill the rest of it out at full speed. Clean it up after we suck that bitch dry.

No, you miss the main point. No amount of regulation or oversight is ever going to make any endeavor a perfectly safe one, because all of these things are POLITICAL instruments, but two, and more importantly, no one can foresee every circumstance nor anticipate every failure no matter how restrictive the law becomes, even long after the law has become a force of tyranny.
__________________
The essence of a dictator’s method is not to write harsh laws and enforce them rigidly. The world’s most destructive thugs have wanted something different. They have wanted to impose their wills on a compliant populace using arbitrary power — power not limited by laws or constitution, but power that was open-ended, ill-defined, and could be expanded based on the whims of the moment.

Well-written laws are the enemy of the dictator. As philosopher Ayn Rand put it, “When men are united by ideas, i.e., by explicit principles, there is no room for favors, whims, or arbitrary power: the principles serve as an objective criterion for determining actions and for judging men, whether leaders or members.” Laws, properly formulated, are based on principles, and serve to translate those principles into firm criteria for judging particular cases. What a dictator wants is to be free of such principles and to use his power as he wishes.

John David Lewis
 
No, you miss the main point. No amount of regulation or oversight is ever going to make any endeavor a perfectly safe one, because all of these things are POLITICAL instruments, but two, and more importantly, no one can foresee every circumstance nor anticipate every failure no matter how restrictive the law becomes, even long after the law has become a force of tyranny.
__________________
The essence of a dictator’s method is not to write harsh laws and enforce them rigidly. The world’s most destructive thugs have wanted something different. They have wanted to impose their wills on a compliant populace using arbitrary power — power not limited by laws or constitution, but power that was open-ended, ill-defined, and could be expanded based on the whims of the moment.

Well-written laws are the enemy of the dictator. As philosopher Ayn Rand put it, “When men are united by ideas, i.e., by explicit principles, there is no room for favors, whims, or arbitrary power: the principles serve as an objective criterion for determining actions and for judging men, whether leaders or members.” Laws, properly formulated, are based on principles, and serve to translate those principles into firm criteria for judging particular cases. What a dictator wants is to be free of such principles and to use his power as he wishes.

John David Lewis

No. You miss the point.

Politics make the rules, but the rules have been in place and have a longer shelf life than politicians. Safer drilling makes for expensive oil. America don't like that shit!

We have to make a choice, as a society, to accept higher gas prices as a cost of being safe, or to keep filling up our SUVs and fuck the world.

I am good with either choice. My years on this earth are limited. Oily beaches do not affect me.

You can tell me about the dems and pubes and all your nifty cut and pastes quotes all you want. None of those groups alone have enough power to make a change here.
 
No. You miss the point.

Politics make the rules, but the rules have been in place and have a longer shelf life than politicians. Safer drilling makes for expensive oil. America don't like that shit!

We have to make a choice, as a society, to accept higher gas prices as a cost of being safe, or to keep filling up our SUVs and fuck the world.

I am good with either choice. My years on this earth are limited. Oily beaches do not affect me.

You can tell me about the dems and pubes and all your nifty cut and pastes quotes all you want. None of those groups alone have enough power to make a change here.

You want safer drilling then let the oil companies drill where it safe.

That's politics putting them out in deep water, not the desire for cheap oil, besides Obama doesn't WANT cheap oil, never has unless he needs to be for the moment to prevent political harm.

Remember, when gas spiked to $4.00 a gallon, Barack was only displeased at the rate of increase, not the increase. This spill is a big political boon to him for now he can do that which he is politically inclined to do under Gaia's loving umbrella...
__________________
When I was asked earlier about, uh, the issue of coal. Uhhh, y'know, under my plan of a cap-and-trade system, electricity rates would necessarily skyrocket....
We would put a cap-and-trade system in place, eh, that is as aggressive, if not more aggressive, than anybody else's out there. So if somebody wants to build a coal-powered plant, they can. It's just that it will bankrupt them because they're gonna be charged a huge sum for all that, uh, greenhouse gas that's being emitted.


Barack Hussein Obama
Editorial board meeting, San Francisco Chronicle
January 2008
 
Then it was up to the Administration to take note of that and stop it, not give them a safety award...

So the blow-back is not just on the industry, but on the government that's "too big to fail."

He was, remember, the transformative change guy!
Okay, he's been as paralyzed by indecision as Bush was by Katrina. It does seem as though when modern Presidents are confronted with disasters, they tend to look the other way and hope somebody else will fix it.

But, under the US Constitution, this disaster isn't Obama's responsibility.

His responsibility is to enforce the laws that Congress passes, and Congress has passed laws that allowed this to happen.

Now, with control of FEMA, he could have acted earlier to begin to construct berms and so forth to limit the damage to marshes and wetlands, but stopping the flow from that well isn't something he has any authority to do.
 
Okay, he's been as paralyzed by indecision as Bush was by Katrina. It does seem as though when modern Presidents are confronted with disasters, they tend to look the other way and hope somebody else will fix it.

But, under the US Constitution, this disaster isn't Obama's responsibility.

His responsibility is to enforce the laws that Congress passes, and Congress has passed laws that allowed this to happen.

Now, with control of FEMA, he could have acted earlier to begin to construct berms and so forth to limit the damage to marshes and wetlands, but stopping the flow from that well isn't something he has any authority to do.

Congress has been ceding authority at warp speed to the executive and all it's EPA-style agencies. This is a clear indication that Federal government has grown too large under the framework of the Constitution and that the people running the show are no longer accountable to ANYBODY, so they devolve into tight little communities who protect their turf at all costs as we saw with Global Warming and the Government of Gaia.

Having said that, and having heard Obama set his own ass up for a fall during his campaign, he now owns this fall, this is now the issue with which his legacy will be tarred and feathered and I seriously doubt if he is re-electable now, he's lame goose down...
__________________
I wonder if the president knows what a disaster this is not only for him but for his political assumptions. His philosophy is that it is appropriate for the federal government to occupy a more burly, significant and powerful place in America—confronting its problems of need, injustice, inequality. But in a way, and inevitably, this is always boiled down to a promise: "Trust us here in Washington, we will prove worthy of your trust." Then the oil spill came and government could not do the job, could not meet need, in fact seemed faraway and incapable: "We pay so much for the government and it can't cap an undersea oil well!"
Peggy "Better Late Than Never" Noonan
 
Okay, he's been as paralyzed by indecision as Bush was by Katrina. It does seem as though when modern Presidents are confronted with disasters, they tend to look the other way and hope somebody else will fix it.

But, under the US Constitution, this disaster isn't Obama's responsibility.

His responsibility is to enforce the laws that Congress passes, and Congress has passed laws that allowed this to happen.

Now, with control of FEMA, he could have acted earlier to begin to construct berms and so forth to limit the damage to marshes and wetlands, but stopping the flow from that well isn't something he has any authority to do.

We all understand that Byron, but we didn't write those opening remarks or set up the teleprompter last Thurs. Reality and politics are quite often two different species and in the political realm Barry now owns the disaster lock, stock, and barrel. He stepped up and put the noose around his own neck.

Ishmael
 
We all understand that Byron, but we didn't write those opening remarks or set up the teleprompter last Thurs. Reality and politics are quite often two different species and in the political realm Barry now owns the disaster lock, stock, and barrel. He stepped up and put the noose around his own neck.
Yes, that's pretty much the case.

It's unfortunate that in his legal studies Obama never took any time out to acquaint himself with the US Constitution.

He might have saved his ass...
 
Yes, that's pretty much the case.

It's unfortunate that in his legal studies Obama never took any time out to acquaint himself with the US Constitution.

He might have saved his ass...

Oh, he's aquainted with it, hs just doesn't like it.

Ishmael
 
Oh, he's aquainted with it, hs just doesn't like it.

Ishmael

True dat!
__________________
But, the Supreme Court never ventured into the issues of redistribution of wealth, and of more basic issues such as political and economic justice in society.

To that extent, as radical as I think people try to characterize the Warren Court, it wasn’t that radical. It didn’t break free from the essential constraints that were placed by the founding fathers in the Constitution, at least as its been interpreted and Warren Court interpreted in the same way, that generally the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties. Says what the states can’t do to you. Says what the Federal government can’t do to you, but doesn’t say what the Federal government or State government must do on your behalf...,

Barack Hussein Obama
2001 Radio Interview
 
... I’m a child of the British Empire and, back in my kindergarten days, almost all the stories we were taught about kings went more or less the same way. Generations of English children learned of Alfred the Great, King of Wessex back in the 9th century. Another A-list bigshot: Winston Churchill called him “the greatest Englishman that ever lived.” One day, during a tumultuous time in the affairs of his kingdom, he passed a remote cottage and called in on the local peasant woman to rest a while. Unaware of who he was, she went off to milk the cow and told him to mind the cakes she’d left on the hearth. He was a big-picture guy preoccupied with geopolitical macro-trends and he absentmindedly let the cakes burn. She took him to task (“You’re happy to eat the cakes but too lazy to keep an eye on them”) but, upon realizing he was the king, begged a thousand pardons. “No, no,” he said. “Entirely my fault.” And there in the rude hovel he humbly turned the woman’s loaves for her.

In the age of kings, we were taught that kings were human, with human failings. Now, in the age of citizen-presidents, we are taught that government has unlimited powers over “heaven, earth, and sea.” Unlike Canute and Alfred, the vanity of Big Government knows no bounds. Tim Flannery, the Aussie global warm-monger who chaired the Copenhagen climate circus a few months back, announces with a straight face that “we’re trying to act as a species to regulate the atmosphere.” Never mind anything so footling as the incoming tides, but the very atmosphere! How do you do that? Well, first, take one extremely large check. Next, add several extra zeroes to it. Then, toss it out the window. “He whom heaven, earth, and sea obey by eternal laws”? Hah! That’s chickenfeed compared to the way things are gonna be once heaven, earth, and sea are forced to submit to a transnational micro-regulatory regime.

Almost every problem we face today arises from the vanity of Big Government. Why has BP got oil wells 5,000 feet underwater in the middle of the Gulf of Mexico? Because government regulated them off-land, off-coast, and ever deeper into the briny. True, BP went along. Its initials stand for “British Petroleum.” You may not be aware of that if you’ve seen any of their commercials in recent years: “BP — Beyond Petroleum.” They were an oil company ashamed of their product, and advertising only how anxious they were to get with the environmental program. And a fat lot of good that did them. BP, not to mention its customers, would have been better to push back against government policies that drive energy suppliers into ever more unpredictable terrain in order to protect the Alaskan breeding grounds of the world’s largest mosquito herd. Instead, we’ll do the opposite. There’ll be even more government protection of “the environment,” and even more government regulation of the oil industry, and BP will be drilling for oil in that Icelandic volcano.

It’s the same in Europe. Greece’s problem isn’t so very difficult to diagnose. Like many Western nations, its government has spent tomorrow today. As in New York and California, public-sector unions have looted the future. This is the entirely foreseeable consequence of government policy.
Mark Steyn
NRO
__________________
"The more communal enterprise extends, the more attention is drawn to the bad business results of nationalized and municipalized undertakings. It is impossible to miss the cause of the difficulty: a child could see where something was lacking. So that it cannot be said that this problem has not been tackled. But the way in which it has been tackled has been deplorably inadequate. Its organic connection with the essential nature of socialist enterprise has been regarded as merely a question of better selection of persons. It has not been realized that even exceptionally gifted men of high character cannot solve the problems created by socialist control of industry."
Ludwig Heinrich Edler von Mises
 
We all understand that Byron, but we didn't write those opening remarks or set up the teleprompter last Thurs. Reality and politics are quite often two different species and in the political realm Barry now owns the disaster lock, stock, and barrel. He stepped up and put the noose around his own neck.

Ishmael



Exactly.

Total incompetence and disregard for the safety systems that were already in place.

If you're drilling for oil in the deep sea, of course something terrible can happen, so you have a plan on what to do when it does.

Why were they drilling so far offshore in miles deep water anyhow? Hmm?

How could there not have been a plan for a spill?

How could it all be so ad hoc, so inadequate, so embarrassing?

We're plugging it now with tires, mud and golf balls?

Charles Krauthammer:
Obama didn't help much with his finger-pointing speech in which he denounced finger-pointing, then proceeded to blame everyone but himself, everything then turned sour when he reflexively added that these problems have been going on "for a decade or more" – translation: Bush did it – while, in contrast, his own interior secretary had worked diligently to solve the problem "from the day he took office."

Really? Why hadn't we heard a thing about this?

What about the September 2009 letter from Obama's National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration accusing Interior's Minerals Management Service of understating the "risk and impacts" of a major oil spill?

( http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/national/14agency/1_Comments-on-MMS-5YearPlan.pdf )

When you get a blowout 15 months into your administration, and your own Interior Department had given BP a "categorical" environmental exemption in April 2009, the buck stops there.

OWN IT!


...
 
Last edited:
Maybe now he'll think twice about accepting offers from experts in the Middle East who have experience with deep water drilling leaks.

His excuse was that the concern was the "time element" ... they made the offer 5 weeks ago ... it could have been fixed weeks ago.
They have no experience with deep water spills. No one does. The Persian gulf is 150ft deep. That's not deep water.

August before they can start pumping to relieve the pressure. I don't think anyone know's how long that's going to take.

Ishmael
You clearly don't know what a relief well does, or what it's purpose is. It's not drilled to relieve pressure, it's drilled to plug the original Macondo bore hole.

Further, they're drilling out that far because that's where the big reserves are. They've been doing it for years, this is nothing new.

Obama and the Feds take over spill containment from day 1. Fucking please....those jokers wouldn't have a fucking clue, and would end up sourcing it out to the guys that are currently doing it.

Safety systems ignored?

Do some fucking research, and stop re-spewing every nugget the media throws out.
 
Last edited:
All this begs the question:

Why in the hell are they drilling for oil in mile deep water?

There is any easy answer.
 
They have no experience with deep water spills. No one does. The Persian gulf is 150ft deep. That's not deep water.

You clearly don't know what a relief well does, or what it's purpose is. It's not drilled to relieve pressure, it's drilled to plug the original Macondo bore hole.

Further, they're drilling out that far because that's where the big reserves are. They've been doing it for years, this is nothing new.

Obama and the Feds take over spill containment from day 1. Fucking please....those jokers wouldn't have a fucking clue, and would end up sourcing it out to the guys that are currently doing it.

Safety systems ignored?

Do some fucking research, and stop re-spewing every nugget the media throws out.

Why don't you walk us through that procedure.

Ishmael
 
All this begs the question:

Why in the hell are they drilling for oil in mile deep water?

There is any easy answer.
Because there is demand for oil, and the shallow water GoM is about played out. The supermajors have sold the majority of their shallow water rights to medium sized firms.

Very nice. NOAA clearly should be revered when it comes to safety. However, even in the pretty highlighted parts, I didn't read ONE safety related recommendation in regards to systems or procedures. Nice multi page red herring though.

Why don't you walk us through that procedure.

Ishmael
A subsea relief well is drilled in order to re-establish control over another well. Theoretically, since the location of the uncontrolled well has been mapped, relief wells can be drilled much more quickly than the original. Once the original well is intercepted, high volumes of drilling mud are pumped in, interrupting the flow of oil and gas...essentially cutting off flow. At that point, the well may be sealed at the surface with concrete or perhaps a well packer (I doubt BP wants anything to do with this well going forward, so I believe there is lots of concrete in its future.)

It's not be necessary to completely stop flow, as any reduction in wellhead pressure is helpful and may give the BOP stack enough slack to operate. That assumes that the BOP stack has not been damaged during the uncontrolled flow.

I doubt your political pundits or news sources are reporting this, but in regards to the Macondo well in the GoM, BP is in compliance with Canada's relief well policy. 200% in compliance, actually.

Thanks for misinforming the GB!
 
Because there is demand for oil, and the shallow water GoM is about played out. The supermajors have sold the majority of their shallow water rights to medium sized firms.

Very nice. NOAA clearly should be revered when it comes to safety. However, even in the pretty highlighted parts, I didn't read ONE safety related recommendation in regards to systems or procedures. Nice multi page red herring though.

A subsea relief well is drilled in order to re-establish control over another well. Theoretically, since the location of the uncontrolled well has been mapped, relief wells can be drilled much more quickly than the original. Once the original well is intercepted, high volumes of drilling mud are pumped in, interrupting the flow of oil and gas...essentially cutting off flow. At that point, the well may be sealed at the surface with concrete or perhaps a well packer (I doubt BP wants anything to do with this well going forward, so I believe there is lots of concrete in its future.)

It's not be necessary to completely stop flow, as any reduction in wellhead pressure is helpful and may give the BOP stack enough slack to operate. That assumes that the BOP stack has not been damaged during the uncontrolled flow.

I doubt your political pundits or news sources are reporting this, but in regards to the Macondo well in the GoM, BP is in compliance with Canada's relief well policy. 200% in compliance, actually.

Thanks for misinforming the GB!

Well now, there ya go. Lots of pumping is involved. They might even use some specialty kill fluids instead of mud. In extreme cases even expolsives are used. Regardless of the specific method used they are going to fill the leaking bore hole with cement once the pressure is relieved and all of that is going to take some time after the bore intercept is made.

Regarding the stack, I'm a little surprised that no alternative means was incorporated into the design to hook up to the rams to shut the flow down. Neither the shear ram, the lateral ram, nor the annular seem to have any provision for a secondary hook-up to force operation. The implication is that single point failure vulnerabiltiy was built in.

Your statement implies that the stack has operational pressure limitations, limitations I find hard to accept. Even a partial operation of the shear rams should sufficiently reduce flow pressure to allow full operation of the lateral ram. I do concede that the annular would be of limited value.

Ishmael

PS I've made no mention as to whether BP was in compliance or not.
 
This is where they went wrong, they didn't ask Ish for advice. Dumb bastards.
 
Back
Top