"Top Kill" fails

At the end of the day Nature will tale care of nature.Look at all past disasters. Sure it will take time but it will be done, whether it be Fire Earthquake, tornado or hurricane.
 
At the end of the day Nature will tale care of nature.Look at all past disasters. Sure it will take time but it will be done, whether it be Fire Earthquake, tornado or hurricane.

Nature may decide not to take humans into account when taking care of herself though. It's not nice to fool or piss off Mother Nature.
 
No, you miss the main point. No amount of regulation or oversight is ever going to make any endeavor a perfectly safe one, because all of these things are POLITICAL instruments, but two, and more importantly, no one can foresee every circumstance nor anticipate every failure no matter how restrictive the law becomes, even long after the law has become a force of tyranny.

Oil slicks in the name of profits are a form of tyranny also.

If an industry can cause a disaster of regional proportion - with a simple part failure, perhaps that industry should be inline for greater oversight and regulation? Perhaps the government does have the responsibility to step in and write restrictive rules and laws when the lack of such can pollute an ocean?

No?

And as for being handed safety awards -- where did the safety data used come from? BP execs and oil industry data or government and independent divers and experts inspecting the rig? I'll wager the former.
 
Oil slicks in the name of profits are a form of tyranny also.

If an industry can cause a disaster of regional proportion - with a simple part failure, perhaps that industry should be inline for greater oversight and regulation? Perhaps the government does have the responsibility to step in and write restrictive rules and laws when the lack of such can pollute an ocean?

No?

And as for being handed safety awards -- where did the safety data used come from? BP execs and oil industry data or government and independent divers and experts inspecting the rig? I'll wager the former.

But oil slicks for charity are OK? How about oil slicks to lose money? Or the 'break even' oil slicks?

Will oil slicks be OK when gas is $20/gal.?

BP fucked up and they're going to pay dearly. And their fuck up is probably going to become a case study in how not to do things in the future.

Ishmael
 
At the end of the day Nature will tale care of nature.Look at all past disasters. Sure it will take time but it will be done, whether it be Fire Earthquake, tornado or hurricane.

In the end it we won't be here ...... 2012 is coming, Mother Nature will shrug us all off......then The Mess will all get cleared up, a clean slate until man (if any survive) fucks it all up again.
 
Regarding the stack, I'm a little surprised that no alternative means was incorporated into the design to hook up to the rams to shut the flow down. Neither the shear ram, the lateral ram, nor the annular seem to have any provision for a secondary hook-up to force operation. The implication is that single point failure vulnerabiltiy was built in.

Your statement implies that the stack has operational pressure limitations, limitations I find hard to accept. Even a partial operation of the shear rams should sufficiently reduce flow pressure to allow full operation of the lateral ram. I do concede that the annular would be of limited value.

Not sure what you're getting at with the first paragraph by 'alternate means.' Regulations throughout the world pretty much require accumulators to have enough back up pressure to operate shear and annulars, separate the LMRP and have a 50% reserve left over. ROV's technically might be able to do it via their port, but very slowly as their onboard pumps just don't have the capacity to close the rams in the 45 seconds required by the standards. BP tried that and it didn't work out.

Likewise, I'm not saying the stack has operational limitations as in depth, or wellbore pressure. I'm saying that the mechanisms which control the actuation of the rams etc can become damaged quickly during uncontrolled flow. If they do, you can have all the actuation pressure you want, it's not going to make any difference.

I am not here in an attempt to absolve BP/Anadarko/TransOcean/Cameron/Halliburton of responsiblity, as clearly there were problems. However, folks just blithering on about shit they don't understand (safety systems, Canadian requirements) because some asshole said something on the radio or wrote it on the interwebs just pisses me off. Don't be a sheeple people.
 
Last edited:
But oil slicks for charity are OK? How about oil slicks to lose money? Or the 'break even' oil slicks?

Will oil slicks be OK when gas is $20/gal.?

BP fucked up and they're going to pay dearly. And their fuck up is probably going to become a case study in how not to do things in the future.

Ishmael


And the only way to be certain that BP becomes a case study in how not to operate - is through strict government regulation. Sorry, I don't like that any more than anyone else, but it's the truth.
 
And the only way to be certain that BP becomes a case study in how not to operate - is through strict government regulation. Sorry, I don't like that any more than anyone else, but it's the truth.
Very true.

The AEC doesn't let people experiment with atomic bombs in the name of private enterprise.

This is an endeavor with similar destructive potential.
 
Oil slicks in the name of profits are a form of tyranny also.

If an industry can cause a disaster of regional proportion - with a simple part failure, perhaps that industry should be inline for greater oversight and regulation? Perhaps the government does have the responsibility to step in and write restrictive rules and laws when the lack of such can pollute an ocean?

No?

And as for being handed safety awards -- where did the safety data used come from? BP execs and oil industry data or government and independent divers and experts inspecting the rig? I'll wager the former.

You think the oil slick is tyranny?

What do you think the price will be when government aTAXes it and oil companies begin trying to squeeze oil out of existing wells as their options are limited by the outrage of the day...?

Benevolence at the pump?

I'm still in the camp redt's in: one major tropical storm disperses the man-leaked oil the same way the ocean cleans up Gaia's leaking oil...

And your last point highlights the Libertarian position when government becomes more than cop and prosecutor of wrongs done, but instead tries to become an industry expert, regulator and preventor, or provider of "safety," the only thing you're ever going to get is either the fox guarding the hen-house or a toothless, half-blind 20 year-old coon hound who can no longer track guarding the coop.
 
And the only way to be certain that BP becomes a case study in how not to operate - is through strict government regulation. Sorry, I don't like that any more than anyone else, but it's the truth.

OK, this time we'll let kbate the omnipotent pick...




Aforementioned Fox or Hound to guard the chickens?
 
Very true.

The AEC doesn't let people experiment with atomic bombs in the name of private enterprise.

This is an endeavor with similar destructive potential.
Well, from my simple mind, this whole enterprise looks like an experiment gone wrong and continuing to worsen with every failed 'effort' on the part of BP.
 
And the only way to be certain that BP becomes a case study in how not to operate - is through strict government regulation. Sorry, I don't like that any more than anyone else, but it's the truth.

Circular argument my dear. The government can make all the regulations it wants, but to what end if they're not enforced?

Further, we have absolutley no evidence that BP violated any regulation beyond anecdotal utterances. I don't discount that they might have fucked up royally re. regulation violations, but I've seen far too many 'rush to judgements' in my years to be jumping on that bandwagon just yet.

No matter how bad it is, the environment will clean itself up. All sorts of little monocellular critters are going to be thriving on that crude. They'll bloom, then die off once the cornucopia has spilled it's last dreg. Then the regular critters will flow back in to fill their niches in the never ending battle for a place to live and a bite to eat.

All of the outrage will disapate, to be replaced with an even more dangerous outrage when the price of gas hits $5+/gal.

Anyone noticed that the price of a loaf of bread has increased 20% in the past 8 months? Seems to me that there are a lot of people not keeping their eye on the real ball in the real ball game.

Ishmael
 
What would you say was a worse disaster, Three Mile Island, or this?

Well, I would think that waiting until the end of this one and finding out what actually happened would be what a prudent man does rather than condemning and hanging after only hearing from the prosecution witnesses...




;) ;)
 
You think the oil slick is tyranny?

What do you think the price will be when government aTAXes it and oil companies begin trying to squeeze oil out of existing wells as their options are limited by the outrage of the day...?

Benevolence at the pump?

I'm still in the camp redt's in: one major tropical storm disperses the man-leaked oil the same way the ocean cleans up Gaia's leaking oil...

And your last point highlights the Libertarian position when government becomes more than cop and prosecutor of wrongs done, but instead tries to become an industry expert, regulator and preventor, or provider of "safety," the only thing you're ever going to get is either the fox guarding the hen-house or a toothless, half-blind 20 year-old coon hound who can no longer track guarding the coop.


Ah, so your solution is to turn a blind eye and let it go - hoping nature will just wash it away and in the meantime thank the good lord for $2.85 a gallon gas.

When the outrage is of regional nature - That is time for government intervention. A leaking tanker truck - meh. A flawed drilling system - in use in multiple places which can pollute entire oceans and destroy the lives of millions - is perhaps important enough to get our Elected politicians action?

No?
 
Well, I would think that waiting until the end of this one and finding out what actually happened would be what a prudent man does rather than condemning and hanging after only hearing from the prosecution witnesses...




;) ;)

Yes well... YOU CAN'T HANDLE THE TRUTH
 
Circular argument my dear. The government can make all the regulations it wants, but to what end if they're not enforced?

Further, we have absolutley no evidence that BP violated any regulation beyond anecdotal utterances. I don't discount that they might have fucked up royally re. regulation violations, but I've seen far too many 'rush to judgements' in my years to be jumping on that bandwagon just yet.

No matter how bad it is, the environment will clean itself up. All sorts of little monocellular critters are going to be thriving on that crude. They'll bloom, then die off once the cornucopia has spilled it's last dreg. Then the regular critters will flow back in to fill their niches in the never ending battle for a place to live and a bite to eat.

All of the outrage will disapate, to be replaced with an even more dangerous outrage when the price of gas hits $5+/gal.

Anyone noticed that the price of a loaf of bread has increased 20% in the past 8 months? Seems to me that there are a lot of people not keeping their eye on the real ball in the real ball game.

Ishmael

No one, ESPECIALLY a political body (camel - committee ;) ;) ) can foresee every eventuality or outcome, that's why they're called "accidents" and regulation, as we know only ever serves to retard progress...

Again, who is it going to be, Fox or Hound?
__________________
"The more communal enterprise extends, the more attention is drawn to the bad business results of nationalized and municipalized undertakings. It is impossible to miss the cause of the difficulty: a child could see where something was lacking. So that it cannot be said that this problem has not been tackled. But the way in which it has been tackled has been deplorably inadequate. Its organic connection with the essential nature of socialist enterprise has been regarded as merely a question of better selection of persons. It has not been realized that even exceptionally gifted men of high character cannot solve the problems created by socialist control of industry."
Ludwig Heinrich Edler von Mises
 
Back
Top