Angeline
Poet Chick
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2002
- Posts
- 27,174
Angeline, sorry, I stand corrected. Thus it is:
Angeline in old making.
When people talk about poetry (and most of the time they don't even care, they repeat some oh-so famous saying by other oh-so famous so-great people) then it's like they are banging their heads against walls of a dark labyrinth. They bang their head agains the left wall, so they turn and then they bang against the right wall, etc. It's truly a random walk.
It's ironic to mention haiku in the given context. They talk about the 5-7-5 stupidity, completely missing poetry.
Condensation is not about poetry as a whole, it is only introducing a specific style--not better and not worse than other styles. When you avoid singular (to avoid "a"), and similar, then you give up on a big chunk of poetry, and you promote just a narrow style.
The basic principle is not condensation but
every element of a poem has to contribute to poetry
Warm regards,
I understand that what most Westerners think of as haiku is so far from what it should be as to be laughable. The American Sentence form does away with the line breaks (which most people totally miss the point on anyway as you note) and allows (indeed encourages) focus on people-related activity. So my point is it starts with the kernel of an idea from one culture and adapts it (ingeniously imo) to another.
And yes I agree with you that every element of a poem needs to contribute to poetry. You once suggested an exercise to me where one writes and then goes back and removes a certain number of words (without losing the essential meaning of the poem), and continues to do so until no more words can be removed without changing that meaning. It's a great exercise because once you take everything you can away, you see whether what you have left is a poem or not!
I'm not saying I succeed at that when I write, but it is what I aim toward. And when you do that taking away over and over, you get an ever greater sense of how many words are extraneous (i.e., add nothing).