butters
High on a Hill
- Joined
- Jul 2, 2009
- Posts
- 84,358
It's lovely and impressionistic.
I don't like the "clipped/nipped" rhyme; it sounds contrived to me and pulls me out of the poem.
Also think you can lose "graceful" in S2 L1. "Coy behind pale fans" just sounds better to my ear and "graceful" is sort of telling.
I don't know how I feel about "battle." Otoh I want to smell salt and oceany scents but "battle" is such a disturbing word choice there it may be brilliant. Lol. You decide.
Why are they filtering thoughts? That's the first sense I get of humanizing them and not sure you want to go there. I like the fact that up to this line I don't know if they're mermaids or what they are. But if they're thinking, I guess that means they're mermaids....I dunno if I wanna know that.
"kiss the sky" sounds too rainbow/unicorn/sparkle to me and it also makes me think of Jimi Hendrix singing Purple Haze and do you want to end with that?
Of course these are just my stoopid opinions so feel free to ignore them.
And if you have time, give me some feedback on my reworked Chagall's Bride.
that was fast! ty
clipped/nipped - i'm hearin' ya
graceful - gone! perfect, just right
battle - it's the struggle - toyed with bodily fluids but blood, sweat n tears was way too old hat, toyed with scent of fear or scent of hope, that kinda thing. don't know if it stays or goes yet
filtering thoughts - maybe i need to drop 'thoughts', keep it to 'filter/ing'
(psst - it's a poet in the making and these are the inhabitants of the pond/sea they find themself in ... the 'clowns' and the 'bats' = various oddball egos, the small creatures = other new writers
and yeah, it was deliberately jimi H at the end, as that's the phrase that started this, though i dropped the 'excuse me' part. it's maybe not the best reason to keep it in, but i love that idea of propelling upwards through the heavy stuff to leap, bright as a flash, into the thin high blues and kiss the sky, water pearling away in droplets that catch fire in bright sunlight....
hmm, maybe i need to ...
um, maybe not
and Angelinadreama - YOU do not need to reiterate that (i know we both tend to by rote) - i get AND appreciate where you're coming from, and you never give offense but do me huge favours with your honest, open approach.
promise to give it my undivided attention sometime tomorrow during the day. i look forward to it! many thanks, hon. x