chronicle_tenko
LR's Lovable Idiot
- Joined
- Apr 7, 2006
- Posts
- 12,402
I like the critiques. But I am usually in the rare, as I take it well. I always wish to improve, and I know that sometimes, I need to.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I like the critiques. But I am usually in the rare, as I take it well. I always wish to improve, and I know that sometimes, I need to.
I also like critiques, from as many people as possible.
Maybe when posting, the person could say if a critique was desired?
As I am sharing a thread with Shy ..I will tell every one now ..she is possibly one of the best writers in LIT...I would be honored for her to offer a critique' of my writing.. like having Davinci looking over your crayon scribbles...
I shall remove my post if you like, it was never my intent to cause drama here, or to have people jump to your defense.
It was a simple question, not offered as a criticism, we have never met.
There are a lot of wonderful writers on the board and alas I am not amongst them as I am sure Ezra can attest to, as he has written with me in a couple of fluff threads.
I am simply too shy, to post and have mine publicly critiqued, I do however, want to learn. I like CT, love to be critiqued, but not in public and not on this board, in general it is rarely kind.
The comments you have made however, been constructive and insightful thus far I thank you. I would welcome your comments in private, if you really have the time, it is always nice to know a fellow teacher.
And you asked not to be the school teacher lol! So my only comment on your work would be in your second sentence because I would have put 'stony' where you put 'stone'.
It just gives more emotion to me as a reader I think. Not sure how to explain it really. And I'd probably put 'rose coloured blood' as well (I think I'm obsessed with saying everything is 'coloured' though - refer to my own sentences). Lol!
But I loved your sentences! There's something so sensual and reaching about them that I just don't see in what I write.
Thank you. And yes, I too struggled with finding the right "flow" of the 2nd sentence - I like how you fixed it.
Random word: Shimmer
Flower: Violet
Emotion: Anxiety
1. The sun shimmered in the sky despite the roiling clouds that devoured the warmth released. The first droplet fell and kissed the field of violets below, like an anxious lover awaiting her mates return.
2. Tears shimmered within her gazed; refusing to be separated from the dark brown pools. The rush of air was all the warning she received before taunt leather kissed crimson flesh. Her body shuddered with an anxious cry as his greedy stare devoured his mark. He released a soft, wicked chuckle as crimson was streaked with violet flecks.
3. Spots shimmered before his eyes as the next blow rocked his jaw and snapped his head back. The visceral scream of tendons, bone, and flesh was enough to jar anxiety free and replace it with the will to survive. He stood like a drunkard as the ugly violet bruise gave way to crimson ichor beneath.
So I tried to keep this as short as possible, but I tend to get wordy. I found it flowed better if I didn't try to restrict it to one sentence. Anyway, feel free to comment. I left my ego in my other pants.
Dinosaurs, poppy, love
Each poppy turned her thoughts to Flanders, and to her love, lost to the mechanical dinosaurs of the Great War.
Love soars as if lost in the dizzying sensuality of poppy-induced dreams and then falls, as earth-bound as the fossils of extinct dinosaurs.
The other dinosaurs shunned him for his love of poppy-flowers over fresh meat.
Random Word: Incessant
Flower: Magnolia
Emotion: Fear
The warm breeze on her naked breasts, the incessant beating of the tribal drums, the scent of Magnolia blossoms and her fear, were like a potent drug to her newly awakened senses.
Susan listened intently, nothing could be heard, just the incessant tap, tap taping of water dripping somewhere unseen within the frigid room, the magnolia undertones of the perfume she wore, were a sensual backdrop to her own icy fear, a lifeline she desperately held on to.
Her fear was that the dying Magnolia Tree would represent the end of an era; its incessant decline had paralleled the slow decay of her own worthless life, yet she was loath to cut it down, for that would represent her own failure, wouldn’t it?
Shy Mystica please critique me here, it occurred to me as I am learning by your critique of others, they to will learn from your critique of my work perhaps
Third attempt.
Random word: Lurk
Flower: Marigold
Emotion: Excited
1. She had to keep her excitement in check, it was free to lurk in the recesses of her mind; that was carefully hidden behind her thick marigold colored locks of hair.
2. He had been so careful to keep the thoughts that lurked in his mind from her, she couldn't know before hand his plans as they walked hand in hand beside the marigolds, his excitement growing with every step.
3. He couldn't forget the first time he saw her, she'd been so excited flower shopping, smelling the marigolds when his lurking eyes had first been blessed by seeing her, and now he was beyond excited to actually be speaking with her.
Random word: soap
Flower: lilac
Random emotion: fear
1: She relaxed beneath the sting of hot water, her fear washed away by the lilac scented soap bubbles covering her body.
2: Her cup slipped from her fingers as if wet and soapy and she stared in fear at the sprigs of lilacs strewn across her bed.
3: Lilacs are lovely, but I fear I deserve this for using soap as my random word.
Critiques are more than welcome. I want to learn to write well.
I am so glad you did post, Day. And your kids sound as delightful and cheeky as you! *giggles* Believe it or not, I think soap was actually a very hard word to have since it can be so limiting, as you seemed to have discovered from the looks of your third sentence .
I like how your sentences do not lack imagery yet remain punchy and short as to not confuse or overwhelm the reader. Your first sentence was perfect! I loved it! It was filled with simple imagery and free of wording 'baggage'. It is your second sentence that I feel you aren't giving justice to. You have beautifully described the paralysing effects of a fear directed at a lovely image you created (the lilacs upon the bed), but the sentence structure is taking away the impact.
She stared in fear at the sprigs of lilacs strewn across her bed, her cup slipped from her fingers as if slick with soap to smash heavily upon the floor.
Like Yeishia, fear is the most important part of the sentence, so I put that first. All other actions are secondary and a result of that fear. I changed the word 'wet' to 'slick' as I like the alliteration (both slick and soap have the same sound of 's', which makes it flow nicely) But since I did move your phrases around, it no longer sounded complete, so I did add how the cup finished to make the sentence feel complete but to also accentuate how damaging that fear is.
What do you think? Or have I destroyed what you wanted to achieve? I certainly hope not
Thank you so much for posting Tio_Narratore. Hard random word to use, but you seemed to have pulled it off! I will not critique, however, as you have not stated whether or not your post is open to do so. Please return and enjoy working with us
Yeishia, I am so proud of you. I am ecstatic that you took that leap and posted here. You should be so happy and proud as that is a big step to take when you are so shy about your work. Trust me, I am that shy about my work so I know how big of a step that is to take.
My first thoughts are that you have nothing to be shy about. Like all the others who have posted, you are naturally gifted at creating beautiful imagery and that you are very clever with the words you use. So, no more doubting yourself, Missy It was your second sentence that caught my attention as your first and last one were beautiful.
Personally, while you wrote some amazing descriptive phrases, the length of the sentence stole the impact it could have. And the amount of commas made it a little choppy.
Susan listened intently yet nothing could be heard as she desperately clung to the fear that had become her lifeline; the incessant tap, tap taping of water dripping somewhere unseen and the magnolia undertones of her perfume were merely a sensual backdrop to the icy fear.
For me, the most important part of the sentence was her fear, so I wanted to establish that first (moving your last set of words to the beginning). Placing it at the end seemed to diminish its importance. But perhaps that is just me.
I also liked the idea of making the fear an inanimate force that she couldn't control rather than a fear she owned as you had originally put it, in order to give the fear a sense of power that she couldn't control (give more impact to your beautiful first phrase). Which is why I put 'the icy fear' instead of 'her icy fear'. The simple wording changes the entire demeanor of the fear. I also took out some words that I thought were not needed as I thought they could be sacrificed in order to make the sentence flow more smoothly.
What do you think of the changes? Keep in mind that my opinion is not the gospel. I am learning too, these are just my humble thoughts.
Those were just editorial changes to enforce the beautiful phrases you already created to give them the impact and power they deserve. You writing is beautiful, Yeishia, so please don't ever doubt your natural skill?