Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
Peregrinator said:
You *Ishchuckled* at me.

1) You choose two examples that are closely related. If I wanted to know about paleobotany, I'd ask a paleobotanist first, and maybe get a friend who was some other kind to explain a few basics to me. If I want to know about cliamate, I'll look for papers by climatologists, not xenobotanists. If you're really going to say that one's research specialty doesn't lead to any special experience or knowledge in the given field, then we have nowehere to go. You might as well ask a quantum physicist what monkies eat during droughts. Makes no sense at all.

2) If you're interested in drinking the dog piss he leaves on the hydrant, I guess.

3) If I cited historic sketches of anything at all with no hard data to back it up, you'd dismiss it out of hand. The fact that when the telescope was invented people drew pictures of everything doesn't mean a whole lot in terms of precise measurement.

4) I don't know how you know what the greater group of climatologists are or aren't looking at. In any case, sure, Venus is also warmed by the sun. If it turns out to be warming in exactly the same proportion as indicated by sunspots, then so what? Is it warming at a different rate from the Earth? Do we have the data? No, and should we wait for a couple hundred years until we do? No. The trick is to prove that CO2 and other gh gas emissions are irrelevant. And even if you prove that, then you'll still have to convince me that it's worth breathing poison so you can drive your unnecessary suv for a few cents less than you could on biodiesel or electricity.


Don't quibble Perg.

1. I could have picked a paleobotanist and a biophysicist just as easily. And you're right that you should ask the paleobotantist first, but it seems to me that in doing so you prove my point. You assume you can understand the answer. Yet you persist in implying that a nuclear physicist wouldn't. Do you see a little paradox here? There's no fucking magic in science Perg. and in many cases those that specialize blind themselves to a bigger picture. It's like sticking your nose right up against the TV set. You can see the pixels, but you can't see the picture.

2. One can observe without partaking. :)

3. But there is hard data Perg. You can find it at the NASA and JPL websites for a start.

4. And now you're falling back on the same old argument. "We're ignorant as to the cause so we MUST make sacrifice, we MUST do something." Quite frankly Perg., why? Why must we do something? By all the estimates of the doom sayers it's a self healing problem. Billions will die. So the fuck what? They're all going to die anyway. It's not a matter of if, only when. Think of all the carbon that'll be sequestered. (I wonder if those that decree their remains be burned think of that. How about outlawing the roasting of the flesh?) Cut the earths population in half and according to the greens we'll all live in the garden once more. Half the pollution and twice the room for the rest of the critters. If you believe that man is a plague, well, here's the cure Perg. Rejoice Perg.

Ishmael
 
So I direct you all to the recent research report by LANCET, a somewhat reliable rag mag


They did research into WHO,

Run and supported by the UN, they are seen AS THE PREEMINENT SCIENTIFIC ORGINIZATION in the world

issuing research and proclamations that are treated as gospel

only problem as LANCET found out

is that WHO tended to MAKE STUFF UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

No science behind it


When contacted WHO admitted this to be true, of course BLAMING the "lack of money"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


the same can be said of the recent UN "report" of GlowBall BULLSHIT!
 
Ishmael said:
Don't quibble Perg.

1. I could have picked a paleobotanist and a biophysicist just as easily. And you're right that you should ask the paleobotantist first, but it seems to me that in doing so you prove my point. You assume you can understand the answer. Yet you persist in implying that a nuclear physicist wouldn't. Do you see a little paradox here? There's no fucking magic in science Perg. and in many cases those that specialize blind themselves to a bigger picture. It's like sticking your nose right up against the TV set. You can see the pixels, but you can't see the picture.

2. One can observe without partaking. :)

3. But there is hard data Perg. You can find it at the NASA and JPL websites for a start.

4. And now you're falling back on the same old argument. "We're ignorant as to the cause so we MUST make sacrifice, we MUST do something." Quite frankly Perg., why? Why must we do something? By all the estimates of the doom sayers it's a self healing problem. Billions will die. So the fuck what? They're all going to die anyway. It's not a matter of if, only when. Think of all the carbon that'll be sequestered. (I wonder if those that decree their remains be burned think of that. How about outlawing the roasting of the flesh?) Cut the earths population in half and according to the greens we'll all live in the garden once more. Half the pollution and twice the room for the rest of the critters. If you believe that man is a plague, well, here's the cure Perg. Rejoice Perg.

Ishmael
I don't know that I could understand it. The scientist in question would have to explain it in terms I would understand; that's part of the job, imo. That's part of what I expect to do as a doctor, explain incredibly complex things to patients so they understand what's going on. I wouldn't expect to understand all the specialized terms and math and techniques used by a paleobotanist, nor would I expect to have the historical perspective--years of research and reading professional journal articles and attending conferences--that a professional scientist has. I can't be an expert at everything, and neither can an increasingly specialized scientist.

2) Enough said.

3)Who measured the surface temp of Mars in 1920? 1930? 1940? Just tell me who published the data.

4) You can extend to absurdity if you want to, but it's not leading us anywhere interesting. And anyway, I said nothing like that. I asked you to prove a couple of assertions you made. Or if you like, you can list and refute every one of the hundreds of studies that point to anthropogenic gw. And to play along and answer your question, I don't have offspring; you do. If we were to take the attitude you're talking about, you should be the one who wants to fix the problem, just on the off chance that it might be true. For me, it's a philosophical ideal; we should stop polluting because it's the right thing to do, and because we can. For you it's a pragmatic, genetic imperative.
 
busybody said:
So I direct you all to the recent research report by LANCET, a somewhat reliable rag mag


They did research into WHO,

Run and supported by the UN, they are seen AS THE PREEMINENT SCIENTIFIC ORGINIZATION in the world

issuing research and proclamations that are treated as gospel

only problem as LANCET found out

is that WHO tended to MAKE STUFF UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

No science behind it


When contacted WHO admitted this to be true, of course BLAMING the "lack of money"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


the same can be said of the recent UN "report" of GlowBall BULLSHIT!
Is Rudy G a dummy or a terrorist?
 
Peregrinator said:
I don't know that I could understand it. The scientist in question would have to explain it in terms I would understand; that's part of the job, imo. That's part of what I expect to do as a doctor, explain incredibly complex things to patients so they understand what's going on. I wouldn't expect to understand all the specialized terms and math and techniques used by a paleobotanist, nor would I expect to have the historical perspective--years of research and reading professional journal articles and attending conferences--that a professional scientist has. I can't be an expert at everything, and neither can an increasingly specialized scientist.

2) Enough said.

3)Who measured the surface temp of Mars in 1920? 1930? 1940? Just tell me who published the data.

4) You can extend to absurdity if you want to, but it's not leading us anywhere interesting. And anyway, I said nothing like that. I asked you to prove a couple of assertions you made. Or if you like, you can list and refute every one of the hundreds of studies that point to anthropogenic gw. And to play along and answer your question, I don't have offspring; you do. If we were to take the attitude you're talking about, you should be the one who wants to fix the problem, just on the off chance that it might be true. For me, it's a philosophical ideal; we should stop polluting because it's the right thing to do, and because we can. For you it's a pragmatic, genetic imperative.

1. Now you're starting to get it. (Doctors BTW (MD type), are among the most ignorant, closed minded, autocratic assholes I've ever met in my life. And outside of their specialty they've professed the most outrageous shit I've ever heard. They look at life with a seriously flawed perspective.

3. Who cares? Do you deny what NASA and JPL are reporting? Do you deny that their measurements of the surface temperature increases on Mars tracks those on Earth? Fine, write them a letter and tell them they're full of shit.

4. Assertions? I have postulated questions based on reasonable doubt. And here you are engaged in a feeble attempt to force me to defend questions? That won't cut butter with a hot knife Perg.

You are falling into a trap I've found to be typical of most practicing physicians Perg. I call it the "God complex." A positivity of decisions that is endemic to your chosen profession. That is NOT and indictment Perg. Nor is it a crtiticism. Merely an observation. Quite understandable given the profession. But yours is a profession of practice and application, not one of questioning and consideration of alternatives. If you are like most MD's, you seek to apply your skill, not question it. And in that respect you are like most of your profession, skilled technicians. No more, no less. I find no fault in that Perg., it's a needed skill. But know yourself above all Perg. Know yourself.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
1. Now you're starting to get it. (Doctors BTW (MD type), are among the most ignorant, closed minded, autocratic assholes I've ever met in my life. And outside of their specialty they've professed the most outrageous shit I've ever heard. They look at life with a seriously flawed perspective.

3. Who cares? Do you deny what NASA and JPL are reporting? Do you deny that their measurements of the surface temperature increases on Mars tracks those on Earth? Fine, write them a letter and tell them they're full of shit.

4. Assertions? I have postulated questions based on reasonable doubt. And here you are engaged in a feeble attempt to force me to defend questions? That won't cut butter with a hot knife Perg.

You are falling into a trap I've found to be typical of most practicing physicians Perg. I call it the "God complex." A positivity of decisions that is endemic to your chosen profession. That is NOT and indictment Perg. Nor is it a crtiticism. Merely an observation. Quite understandable given the profession. But yours is a profession of practice and application, not one of questioning and consideration of alternatives. If you are like most MD's, you seek to apply your skill, not question it. And in that respect you are like most of your profession, skilled technicians. No more, no less. I find no fault in that Perg., it's a needed skill. But know yourself above all Perg. Know yourself.

Ishmael
I agree about docs, by and large. It's my goal not to be one of them. It's also why I won't take Crichton's opinion as anything more than some homeless wino's. But you didn't answer my objection.

3. In which case I could as easily say who cares who's reporting that CO2 is causing gw, couldn't I? NASA is reporting that as well, except that then we get all sorts of ad hominem and weasel arguments. Look, unless you can cite me the data and show me that it's credible, I don't believe that we know what the surface temp of Mars was fifty years ago. One of the loudest arguments we hear over and over re: gw is that we don't have data from a long enough period to draw conclusions, yet somehow we do have a long enough record to talk sensibly about Mars? That doesn't even sound like something busybody or lovelynice would say.

4. You make assertions all the time: "ALL of the models used in gw studies are flawed;" "Mars is warming, and we have enough data to talk about it;" "Reducing carbon emissions would destroy our economy." There's three examples that you've never defended with anything except rhetoric. I'm asking for the science.

No offense taken; I've been in prehospital medicine for a decade, and I am fully aware of the traps of being a physician. It's one of the things that makes me think I might do a MD/Ph.D program and do research and teach as well as practice.
 
Peregrinator said:
I agree about docs, by and large. It's my goal not to be one of them. It's also why I won't take Crichton's opinion as anything more than some homeless wino's. But you didn't answer my objection.

3. In which case I could as easily say who cares who's reporting that CO2 is causing gw, couldn't I? NASA is reporting that as well, except that then we get all sorts of ad hominem and weasel arguments. Look, unless you can cite me the data and show me that it's credible, I don't believe that we know what the surface temp of Mars was fifty years ago. One of the loudest arguments we hear over and over re: gw is that we don't have data from a long enough period to draw conclusions, yet somehow we do have a long enough record to talk sensibly about Mars? That doesn't even sound like something busybody or lovelynice would say.

4. You make assertions all the time: "ALL of the models used in gw studies are flawed;" "Mars is warming, and we have enough data to talk about it;" "Reducing carbon emissions would destroy our economy." There's three examples that you've never defended with anything except rhetoric. I'm asking for the science.

No offense taken; I've been in prehospital medicine for a decade, and I am fully aware of the traps of being a physician. It's one of the things that makes me think I might do a MD/Ph.D program and do research and teach as well as practice.

1. Crichtons opinion is as good as your belly button. Both of you have one. The converse is also true.

3. Well know, hasn't that been my point all along? (And you'd best check out the NASA/JPL sites before you engage in belittlement.)

4. Me? Nah, you overstate. You are stating in absolutes, I rarely do that. Call me a product of a life of surprises.

The retrovirus may just be the key to the cure to cancer. Think about it.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
1. Crichtons opinion is as good as your belly button. Both of you have one. The converse is also true.

3. Well know, hasn't that been my point all along? (And you'd best check out the NASA/JPL sites before you engage in belittlement.)

4. Me? Nah, you overstate. You are stating in absolutes, I rarely do that. Call me a product of a life of surprises.

The retrovirus may just be the key to the cure to cancer. Think about it.

Ishmael
1. Sure, but when he came out with his horseshit, he was treated like he knew something.
3. Link me to the Mars data. I'm trying to do homework at the same time and don't have time to go fuck around over there right now.
4. Those were direct quotes. But, okay. I won't take anything you say as if you mean it from now on....;)

I have thought about that, actually. A doc mentioned it, believe it or not. I was asking him to explain retrovirus to me...about fifteen years ago when Rolling Stone ran an article about some retrovirologist--probably the same one that AJ idolizes--who said that AIDS wasn't caused by HIV. I'm much more interested in parasitology than cancer. Parasites are cool.
 
Peregrinator said:
1. Sure, but when he came out with his horseshit, he was treated like he knew something.
3. Link me to the Mars data. I'm trying to do homework at the same time and don't have time to go fuck around over there right now.
4. Those were direct quotes. But, okay. I won't take anything you say as if you mean it from now on....;)

I have thought about that, actually. A doc mentioned it, believe it or not. I was asking him to explain retrovirus to me...about fifteen years ago when Rolling Stone ran an article about some retrovirologist--probably the same one that AJ idolizes--who said that AIDS wasn't caused by HIV. I'm much more interested in parasitology than cancer. Parasites are cool.

1. Really? In whose opinion? Challenge the science or be a sean. :)

3. No. Expend some effort Perg. You can call me a liar or you can PROVE it. Your choice.

4. And I can extract snippets of your ramblings and make a case as well. I think I've been pretty clear as to where I stand. For you to try to turn it into political sound bites is pretty shallow of you in my estimation, what do you think about that?

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
1. Really? In whose opinion? Challenge the science or be a sean. :)

3. No. Expend some effort Perg. You can call me a liar or you can PROVE it. Your choice.

4. And I can extract snippets of your ramblings and make a case as well. I think I've been pretty clear as to where I stand. For you to try to turn it into political sound bites is pretty shallow of you in my estimation, what do you think about that?

Ishmael
1. Mine. I already have.
3. You made the statement. Don't ask me to prove a negative. "That won't cut butter, etc." And anyway, I'm not calling you a liar; I'm questioning a pile of data that you say exists. If it exists, post it.
4. I wasn't turning anything into anything. You made some unsupported assertions, and I asked you to defend them. Don't get insulted; we do it to each other all the time.
 
From a reader:

I enjoyed the latest PB&J. I've been annoyed with the Chris Mooney "Republican War on Science" meme for a while now, which I suspect will rear its ugly head again in the next few week's with Al Gore's new opus, "The Assault on Reason."

In today's PB&J, you said that you were confident you could find examples of the left "squelching" science. I can think of two Clinton-era "attacks on science" (or efforts to distort science) that might be of interest, and one big one that pre-dates the Clinton administration, but was clearly driven by the left.

1. The first—classic—example is the senseless attack on Alar on apples, which was fueled by left-wing environmental groups and abetted by 60 Minutes, if memory serves.

http://www.acsh.org/publications/pubID.865/pub_detail.asp

2. Recall from Inconvenient Truth Gore's heartfelt admiration of his old professor and green mentor, Roger Revelle. The movie left out the fact that Gore's colleagues (likely with Gore's acquiescence, if not assistance) demonized Revelle and suggested that he had become senile after his views began to deviate from Gore's. (This led to a lawsuit, which eventually settled.) Fred Singer has written about this in a book edited by Michael Gough. The relevant chapter is here:

http://media.hoover.org/documents/0817939326_283.pdf

3. More vaguely (I couldn't find a link in the five minutes I searched), I seem to recall an effort of the Clinton administration to stem second hand smoke (SHS) in the early-to-mid 1990s. The effort was backed with a downright manipulative "meta-study" that carefully selected all of the studies that tended to prove that SHS was harmful, omitted those which did not, and toyed with the margin of error, exposure thresholds, and other statistical metrics in order to "prove" the harmful effects of SHS. Astonishingly, it turned out that if you look exclusively at the studies that tend to prove SHS's harmful effects, then multiply the harmful effects they found, you come up with the discovery that SHS is, um, really harmful.

If you had the time and inclination, I'll bet there are other examples too. The breast implant flap would be a good place to start. Food additives are another softball opportunity, because they pit the "pro science" forces of the left against the "pro health" or "pro environment" forces Of course, our friends at CEI (where I interned briefly during the beginning of the Clinton era) would be a good source for more juicy information.

Finally, I'll note that some of the "Republican War On Science" has nothing to do with science and everything to do with ethical and moral considerations. The administration, for example, has not distorted embryonic stem cell research, or silenced it. The administration does not deny the potential benefits. Bush has said simply that the benefits must be weighed against ethical considerations, which is totally legitimate and does not constitute a "war on science."

I hope this is helpful.
 
Al Qaeda, Iran, North Korea — and Global Warming
Democrats assess the threats to U.S. national security.

By Byron York

What a difference an election makes. Today the House of Representatives will debate whether global warming is so serious a threat to American national security that the director of National Intelligence, normally busy with issues like al Qaeda, Iranian nuclear research, and North Korean missiles, should be ordered to put aside other projects to create a special National Intelligence Estimate on climate change. So far, majority Democrats have pushed the proposal through the House Intelligence Committee — on a party-line vote — and there is a good chance it will become part of the final intelligence authorization bill passed by Congress.





“Climate change can have a serious impact on military operations and exacerbate global tensions,” says Democratic Rep. Sylvestre Reyes, the intelligence committee chairman, pointing to a report by a group of retired high-ranking military officers who recommend taking global warning into account in national-security strategy.

Republicans disagree. Their objection is not a denial of global warming, nor even an argument that some claims made about climate change, most notably by former Vice President Al Gore, are exaggerated. Rather, the GOP objection is that many other agencies inside the U.S. government are studying climate change, and there is no pressing need for the CIA to join in. “Why would it be in an intelligence bill?” asked committee ranking Republican Rep. Pete Hoekstra in an appearance on C-SPAN Wednesday morning. “What added value does the intelligence community add to this debate?”

The question is particularly acute, Republicans say, because the intelligence agencies are already stretched by the war on terror. Citing Iraq, Iran, and Afghanistan, Hoekstra added, “Do we really want to start diverting resources from those threats to global warming?”

Hoekstra and other Republicans worry that Democrats want to return intelligence policy to a time in the 1990s when the Clinton administration established what was known as the DCI Environmental Center within the CIA. The Center used satellite spying resources to track environmental matters. “They took pictures of volcanoes and sea turtle nests and took air samples of air pollution, as opposed to checking for traces of biological or chemical weapons, and it was all done at the behest of Al Gore,” says one Republican knowledgeable about intelligence affairs.

Former CIA director George Tenet mentions Gore’s environmental emphasis in his new book, At the Center of the Storm. “True to his interests, [Gore] had a fascination for wonkish issues,” Tenet writes. “He asked lots of questions about the impact on national security of water shortages, disease and environmental concerns.” Tenet reveals that some inside the CIA derided Gore’s priorities as “bugs and bunnies.”

“We started allocating precious intelligence resources to environmental issues just as al Qaeda was on the upswing,” says Rep. Hoekstra. “We were becoming politically correct. My fear is that we’re going back to the same place.”

The military officers’ report points to situations like drought in Darfur and Somalia and concludes that “Climate change can act as a threat multiplier for instability in some of the most volatile regions of the world, and it presents significant national security challenges for the United States.” While some lawmakers, mostly Democrats, have embraced the report’s conclusions, others suggest it is more than a little overdone. “Everything’s a national security issue these days,” Scott Barrett of the International Policy Program at Johns Hopkins told the Los Angeles Times. “It’s a bit of a marketing ploy.”

But soon it could be more than a ploy; it could be national policy. At the very least, it is now the position of the Democratic leadership in the House and Senate. (A similar National Intelligence Estimate measure is pending in the Senate.) And it comes just in time for coming campaigns: If global warming is a national security issue, then Democrats, contrary to their long-time image, can claim to be very, very tough on national security.
 
Peregrinator said:
1. Mine. I already have.
3. You made the statement. Don't ask me to prove a negative. "That won't cut butter, etc." And anyway, I'm not calling you a liar; I'm questioning a pile of data that you say exists. If it exists, post it.
4. I wasn't turning anything into anything. You made some unsupported assertions, and I asked you to defend them. Don't get insulted; we do it to each other all the time.

1, Cool. You accept your arguments as conclusive?

3. I've expressed opinions concerning the future, They're as valid as anyone elses. We're just betting on whose crystal ball is clearer here.

4. Is this a morph of #3?

Ishmael
 
"Scientists" that believe in all aspects of GW get the $$$ and recognotion

Those that dont

Get bashed and defunded

any SURPRISE that one side has so many boosters?


Sorta like the NEXT ICE AGE

DONT SPOIL MY VACATION, BINNY
 
its 5:30 here

I havent had a cup o joe

so my spelling is worse then usual

PLUS

BINNY GOT ME ANNOYED, AGAIN!


Stop it BINNY!
 
Ishmael said:
1, Cool. You accept your arguments as conclusive?

3. I've expressed opinions concerning the future, They're as valid as anyone elses. We're just betting on whose crystal ball is clearer here.

4. Is this a morph of #3?

Ishmael
1. Not my arguments. I accept the great preponderance of science as persuasive, but maybe just short of conclusive.

3. Ishmael: We have plenty of data on Mars.
Perg: Show me.
Ish: No.
Perg: Then how does anyone know anything about Mars?
Ish: Prove me wrong.

You shifted the burden of evidence again.

4. I don't think so; they're seperate topics.
 
busybody said:
"Scientists" that believe in all aspects of GW get the $$$ and recognotion

Those that dont

Get bashed and defunded

any SURPRISE that one side has so many boosters?


Sorta like the NEXT ICE AGE

DONT SPOIL MY VACATION, BINNY
This is untrue. It's been debunked twelve ways to Sunday.
 
busybody said:
its 5:30 here

I havent had a cup o joe

so my spelling is worse then usual

PLUS

BINNY GOT ME ANNOYED, AGAIN!


Stop it BINNY!
Did you raise fifty million for a terrorist or for a dummy?
 
Only because I didn't want to spend the time reading through 47 pages of BB and SeanH drivel...


I recommend reading this book by Michael Crichton...

He's a scientist, and an author...But those who can't keep an open enough mind to consider what he says, have no right to accuse others of blindly marching in lockstep with those who would dare to disagree with the "scientist" Al Gore himself.

http://www.crichton-official.com/fear/


Why Politicized Science is Dangerous
(Excerpted from State of Fear)

Imagine that there is a new scientific theory that warns of an impending crisis, and points to a way out.

This theory quickly draws support from leading scientists, politicians and celebrities around the world. Research is funded by distinguished philanthropies, and carried out at prestigious universities. The crisis is reported frequently in the media. The science is taught in college and high school classrooms.

I don't mean global warming. I'm talking about another theory, which rose to prominence a century ago.

Its supporters included Theodore Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson, and Winston Churchill. It was approved by Supreme Court justices Oliver Wendell Holmes and Louis Brandeis, who ruled in its favor. The famous names who supported it included Alexander Graham Bell, inventor of the telephone; activist Margaret Sanger; botanist Luther Burbank; Leland Stanford, founder of Stanford University; the novelist H. G. Wells; the playwright George Bernard Shaw; and hundreds of others. Nobel Prize winners gave support. Research was backed by the Carnegie and Rockefeller Foundations. The Cold Springs Harbor Institute was built to carry out this research, but important work was also done at Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford and Johns Hopkins. Legislation to address the crisis was passed in states from New York to California.

These efforts had the support of the National Academy of Sciences, the American Medical Association, and the National Research Council. It was said that if Jesus were alive, he would have supported this effort.

All in all, the research, legislation and molding of public opinion surrounding the theory went on for almost half a century. Those who opposed the theory were shouted down and called reactionary, blind to reality, or just plain ignorant. But in hindsight, what is surprising is that so few people objected.

Today, we know that this famous theory that gained so much support was actually pseudoscience. The crisis it claimed was nonexistent. And the actions taken in the name of theory were morally and criminally wrong. Ultimately, they led to the deaths of millions of people.



Click the link to read more
 
Don't bother clicking the link; it's eugenics.

And it's a bogus argument, because the artificial improvement of species has kept humanity going for millennia.
 
phrodeau said:
Don't bother clicking the link; it's eugenics.

And it's a bogus argument, because the artificial improvement of species has kept humanity going for millennia.

What is bogus?

Eugenics? Or the comparison that Crichton makes to the theory of mankind created global warming?

I tend to agree with him, in the fact that when Scientists can accurately predict the weather for 10 or more consecutive years, then we have a baseline to the science.

Unless blind funding is provided for scientists, then scientists will continue to interpret data the way they think their "client" wants in order to continue the funding.

Everyone touts the computer models as "proof" that mankind is causing global warming. Yet computer models said that '06 would be the worst Hurricane season on record. And we know what happened there huh? Surprisingly, those facts seemed to be under-reported.

Why is my kid indoctrinated in the public schools about the theory of mankind created global warming, in English class! Yet not presented with the opposing points of view? Is critical thinking no longer allowed in tax dollar funded schools?

My answer to her is:

Everyone agrees that the earth has gone through numerous ice ages...What did mankind do to cause the meltdown? Did the cavemen start too many fires?
 
Tungwagger said:
What is bogus?

Eugenics? Or the comparison that Crichton makes to the theory of mankind created global warming?

I tend to agree with him, in the fact that when Scientists can accurately predict the weather for 10 or more consecutive years, then we have a baseline to the science.

Unless blind funding is provided for scientists, then scientists will continue to interpret data the way they think their "client" wants in order to continue the funding.

Everyone touts the computer models as "proof" that mankind is causing global warming. Yet computer models said that '06 would be the worst Hurricane season on record. And we know what happened there huh? Surprisingly, those facts seemed to be under-reported.

Why is my kid indoctrinated in the public schools about the theory of mankind created global warming, in English class! Yet not presented with the opposing points of view? Is critical thinking no longer allowed in tax dollar funded schools?

My answer to her is:

Everyone agrees that the earth has gone through numerous ice ages...What did mankind do to cause the meltdown? Did the cavemen start too many fires?

That's dangerous talk.
 
Tungwagger said:
What is bogus?

Eugenics? Or the comparison that Crichton makes to the theory of mankind created global warming?

I tend to agree with him, in the fact that when Scientists can accurately predict the weather for 10 or more consecutive years, then we have a baseline to the science.

Unless blind funding is provided for scientists, then scientists will continue to interpret data the way they think their "client" wants in order to continue the funding.

Everyone touts the computer models as "proof" that mankind is causing global warming. Yet computer models said that '06 would be the worst Hurricane season on record. And we know what happened there huh? Surprisingly, those facts seemed to be under-reported.

Why is my kid indoctrinated in the public schools about the theory of mankind created global warming, in English class! Yet not presented with the opposing points of view? Is critical thinking no longer allowed in tax dollar funded schools?

My answer to her is:

Everyone agrees that the earth has gone through numerous ice ages...What did mankind do to cause the meltdown? Did the cavemen start too many fires?
I believe I stated why it's a bogus argument above.

You might do well to have a talk with your daughter's English teacher. And I suppose if "The Merchant of Venice" is in her curriculum, you ought to make sure she gets exposed to the idea that Jews can oppress Catholics, for balance.
 
there you have it in a NUTSHELL

anything

and

everyone

that speaks up against GloBall Yawning

is dereided and denounced

and now we are told

Dont even BOTHER reading the links,

THAT SAYS IT ALL!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top