Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
Peregrinator said:
Which has nothing to do with whether gw is caused by people or not.

Read any science yet?
He says it does

He lies

The science is disputed

the "science" for is based on MODELS created in a LAB

Bo GASS!
 
busybody said:
He says it does

He lies

The science is disputed

the "science" for is based on MODELS created in a LAB

Bo GASS!
Prove it. Post links to every study that supports the idea and then post links to solid science that disagrees. You can't, because you don't read the science. You don't know what you're talking about.
 
I posted DOZENS of C n P's that debunk the 'science"

Good Ole FREAK DOPE is always one step behind screaming

LIES LIES LIES!
 
busybody said:
I posted DOZENS of C n P's that debunk the 'science"

Good Ole FREAK DOPE is always one step behind screaming

LIES LIES LIES!
You have never posted actual science. You post people's pajamas. Post links to articles published in peer-reviewed journals.
 
Peregrinator said:
Not assumptions.

I've posted so many times about what I think should be done. Let's do something new; assume for a minute that definitive proof surfaces that we are in fact contributing to gw, that carbon is the problem. How would you address it? Bring to bear the engineering skills you speak of. What would you suggest?

I've already made one suggetion. (Outlaw cremation.)

And Seems that Rodger Daltry read some of my really old threads and has taken up that cry. (Burn all the oil as fast as we can.)

And we've known what a good portion of the answer was for years. But it was members of your religion that effectively killed the construction of any new nuclear plants.

We know that there is NO short term solution for surface transportation so why waste a ton of money even pissing around with concepts there. We know what the solution is, but materials technology manufacturing is a long way from a viable economic roll out.

And there is no, and probably won't be a, solution for air travel.

Wind and solar are getting there but the land surface required is outrageous. Geothermal has it's own set of problems be it 'flash to atmosphere' or closed loop.

This country should have been deriving 75%+ of its electricity from nuclear plants back in the 70's. Thank you environmentalists.

Ishmael
 
If we can come up with an efficient source for land transportation and electricity(alternative fuels), we can save some for air travel.
 
FORBES' RICH KARLGAARD ASKS how many people died because of Rachel Carson?


Buried in paragraph 27, and paraphrasing the Congressman, The Washington Post concedes that "numerous" deaths might have been prevented by DDT.

Let's stop here. Any curious reader would ask, Just how "numerous" is numerous? Wouldn't you ask that question? The Post never asks that question. Why?

Because the answer devastates Rachel Carson and her followers. According to these CDC figures, malaria kills more than 800,000 children under age five every year.

Every year, 800,000 small children die from malaria, a disease once nearly eradicated. Ponder that.

And all The Washington Post can say is "numerous?"

But they have no problem saying BILLIONS will die cause of GW

But they have no problem quoting the genius scientists, Algore, John Revolting and Leonardo the Craprio saying the world will end

Yes, BINNY, idiots like you will chime in AGAIN, IF IT WAS USED RIGHT.............BULLSHIT

YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MILLIONS OF DEATHS

That's scandalous.


More info

http://gladwell.com/2001/2001_07_02_a_ddt.htm

The politics of DDT

http://www.reason.com/news/show/32735.html

of course ANYTHING that disputes YOUR hysteria is DIPSHIT

YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MILLIONS OF DEAD PEOPLE

NO WONDER YOU LOVE MOOSESHIT TERRORISTS

YOU ARE AS MUCH A KILLER AS THEY ARE
 
Ishmael said:
I've already made one suggetion. (Outlaw cremation.)

And Seems that Rodger Daltry read some of my really old threads and has taken up that cry. (Burn all the oil as fast as we can.)

And we've known what a good portion of the answer was for years. But it was members of your religion that effectively killed the construction of any new nuclear plants.

We know that there is NO short term solution for surface transportation so why waste a ton of money even pissing around with concepts there. We know what the solution is, but materials technology manufacturing is a long way from a viable economic roll out.

And there is no, and probably won't be a, solution for air travel.

Wind and solar are getting there but the land surface required is outrageous. Geothermal has it's own set of problems be it 'flash to atmosphere' or closed loop.

This country should have been deriving 75%+ of its electricity from nuclear plants back in the 70's. Thank you environmentalists.

Ishmael
Could you stop with the religion horseshit? I won't take equally stupid insulting shots at you either. It makes your posts read like a diatribe directed at someone else, rather than a conversation.

What is your solution to nuclear waste storage/transportation?
 
busybody said:
FORBES' RICH KARLGAARD ASKS how many people died because of Rachel Carson?


Buried in paragraph 27, and paraphrasing the Congressman, The Washington Post concedes that "numerous" deaths might have been prevented by DDT.

Let's stop here. Any curious reader would ask, Just how "numerous" is numerous? Wouldn't you ask that question? The Post never asks that question. Why?

Because the answer devastates Rachel Carson and her followers. According to these CDC figures, malaria kills more than 800,000 children under age five every year.

Every year, 800,000 small children die from malaria, a disease once nearly eradicated. Ponder that.

And all The Washington Post can say is "numerous?"

But they have no problem saying BILLIONS will die cause of GW

But they have no problem quoting the genius scientists, Algore, John Revolting and Leonardo the Craprio saying the world will end

Yes, BINNY, idiots like you will chime in AGAIN, IF IT WAS USED RIGHT.............BULLSHIT

YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MILLIONS OF DEATHS

That's scandalous.


More info

http://gladwell.com/2001/2001_07_02_a_ddt.htm

The politics of DDT

http://www.reason.com/news/show/32735.html

of course ANYTHING that disputes YOUR hysteria is DIPSHIT

YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR MILLIONS OF DEAD PEOPLE

NO WONDER YOU LOVE MOOSESHIT TERRORISTS

YOU ARE AS MUCH A KILLER AS THEY ARE
You obviously know nothing about the issue. Here's some stuff you should read so you can try to sound like more than an eight year old who parrots what daddy said at dinner last night:

http://theforcethat.blogspot.com/2006/10/dissing-rachel-carson.html

The problem--here--was that the US wanted to blanket spray everywhere with it, which A) doesn't work, and B) causes the problems that Carson, and others, warned about. Its proper use is on the inside of houses, on the walls. After a mosquito bites, it lands on the nearest surface, typically a wall, to excrete the excess water in the blood meal, so it can fly far enough to lay eggs. When it lands on that wall sprayed with DDT, it dies. Great, as far as it goes. The person who was just bit still has been exposed to the disease. So you need mosquito nets to protect people while they're sleeping, and DDt on the walls to kill the mosquitos who do get through. Spraying DDT all over the place, as we were doing in the fifties, wasn't attacking malaria. It was attacking a bug that people didn't like, and it was killing off raptors, most notably the bald eagle. The lashback snowballed, and there were some mistakes made in resisting DDT use in other countries, many of them as political and government-corruption based as anything. If you really believe that but for Rachel Carson, Sierra Leone would have no malaria, you're insane. Ask the DeBeers diamond company about that.

And for what it's worth, before you go insane and put more words in my mouth, I support the proper use of DDT, if combined with all the other necessary approaches; bed nets, treatment for the sick, education, etc. But if all you want to do is coat the earth with toxins, go fuck yourself.
 
Peregrinator said:
Could you stop with the religion horseshit? I won't take equally stupid insulting shots at you either. It makes your posts read like a diatribe directed at someone else, rather than a conversation.

What is your solution to nuclear waste storage/transportation?
err

it aint ISH that made it into religion

its the GW crowd

BINNY/DDT!
 
BINNY/DDT!

Read thru all these links

National Post's Deniers series:
Scientists who challenge the climate change debate

The series

http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/news/story.html?id=f7806f79-bf1f-4bd1-8d33-c904feb71047

at the bottom


Statistics needed -- The Deniers Part I
Warming is real -- and has benefits -- The Deniers Part II
The hurricane expert who stood up to UN junk science -- The Deniers Part III
Polar scientists on thin ice -- The Deniers Part IV
The original denier: into the cold -- The Deniers Part V
The sun moves climate change -- The Deniers Part VI
Will the sun cool us? -- The Deniers Part VII
The limits of predictability -- The Deniers Part VIII
Look to Mars for the truth on global warming -- The Deniers Part IX
Limited role for C02 -- the Deniers Part X
End the chill -- The Deniers Part XI
Clouded research -- The Deniers Part XII
Allegre's second thoughts -- The Deniers XIII
The heat's in the sun -- The Deniers XIV
Unsettled Science -- The Deniers XV
Bitten by the IPCC -- The Deniers XVI
Little ice age is still within us -- The Deniers XVII
Fighting climate 'fluff' -- The Deniers XVIII
Science, not politics -- The Deniers XIX
 
I'll take a look. Still haven't read any actual science, have you? I could post a thousand newspaper articles on the scientists who support gw. Proves nothing, just like this canadian crap you just posted.
 
Peregrinator said:
Could you stop with the religion horseshit? I won't take equally stupid insulting shots at you either. It makes your posts read like a diatribe directed at someone else, rather than a conversation.

What is your solution to nuclear waste storage/transportation?

Why? When the advocates treat it as such. :)

The solution has already been worked out. Yucca mountain. As have the transportation containment systems. I know that there are some people all pissed off about Yucca mountain but that's a red herring. The place is already a long term waste land. A pock marked paradise of plutonium residue.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
Why? When the advocates treat it as such. :)

The solution has already been worked out. Yucca mountain. As have the transportation containment systems. I know that there are some people all pissed off about Yucca mountain but that's a red herring. The place is already a long term waste land. A pock marked paradise of plutonium residue.

Ishmael
Because I don't, and not all of the "advocates" do either.

Do you see it as a viable long-term solution for the ages? Can we use Yucca forever?
 
Peregrinator said:
Because I don't, and not all of the "advocates" do either.

Do you see it as a viable long-term solution for the ages? Can we use Yucca forever?

Sure it's a viable long term for the ages. Barring a killer meteor strike, but then I don't think too many people will be worrying about Yucca mountain.

How much can we store there? Lots. Between Yucca Mtn., Yucca flats, and Frenchmans Flats there is land for storage to spare. And the land is already unusable for any other practicle purpose anyway. There is also a shitpot full of radioactive stuff buried at white sands if an overflow is needed.

The bottom line is that it would buy us a few thousand years to argue about alternatives. I suspect science would have moved forward an inch or two by then. We'll have either moved on to fission or we'll be back in the hunter-gatherer stage of civilization. Either way, it won't represent a problem. Hell, I can see some future tribal unit using it as a 'magical' burial ground. "Gee mom, great-great-great-grandpa hasn't rotted a bit."

Ishmael
 
It will cost BILLIONS

Yes BILLIONS

it will kill the economy

Let the BASHING begin


Are Real Costs of Dealing With Climate Change Being Hidden From the Public?

As Al Gore and his band of not so merry global warming alarmists in buses and in the press try to convince Americans that they need to alter behaviors in order to save the planet, an inconvenient truth is being cynically withheld: this is going to cost a lot of money.

Of course, one of the delicious hypocrisies is that these are the same people who decry the current economic boom as only helping the rich, and state regularly and fervently that the poor and middle-class are being left behind.

At the same time, such mid- to lower-level wage earners should be saddled with exorbitant additional expenses to shelter them from a wolf that might never come knocking at their doors.

Makes sense, right?

With that in mind, the Chicago Tribune’s Laurie Goering wrote a fabulous piece recently exposing some of the potential costs of this exercise that most media don’t want you to know (emphasis added throughout, h/t Benny Peiser):

For the United States, the most aggressive scenario in the new U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change mitigation report — holding greenhouse gases in the atmosphere to less than 500 parts per million, up from the current 380 parts per million — could cost $240 billion a year, or 2 percent of the nation's income, said Robert Mendelsohn, a climate-change economist at Yale University.

Yikes. That would be almost ten percent of the current budget. How do you think that will impact deficits and debt expansion?

But let’s make this discussion more personal:

Reducing greenhouse gases vigorously and quickly probably would push Americans' heating and electric bills up by 50 percent to 100 percent, said Jae Edmonds, a scientist and economist with the Joint Global Change Research Institute, based in Maryland. Gasoline prices would rise between 50 cents and $1 a gallon, he said.

Nice. How would that impact the personal finances of Americans at the middle and bottom rungs of the income ladder?

Furthermore, as it seems a metaphysical certitude that Congress isn’t going to cut $240 billion per year in other spending to pay for climate change remedies, such costs clearly would come from higher taxes.

So, if you add up the 50 to 100 percent increase in home heating and electric bills, along with a 50 cent to $1 per gallon gas hike, AND higher taxes, this could mean financial doom for many Americans.

And, the resulting reduction in consumer spending on other items likely would cause a recession with higher unemployment.

Is it any wonder that the actual dollars involved in climate change solutions are being kept from this hysterical discussion?
 
Ishmael said:
Sure it's a viable long term for the ages. Barring a killer meteor strike, but then I don't think too many people will be worrying about Yucca mountain.

How much can we store there? Lots. Between Yucca Mtn., Yucca flats, and Frenchmans Flats there is land for storage to spare. And the land is already unusable for any other practicle purpose anyway. There is also a shitpot full of radioactive stuff buried at white sands if an overflow is needed.

The bottom line is that it would buy us a few thousand years to argue about alternatives. I suspect science would have moved forward an inch or two by then. We'll have either moved on to fission or we'll be back in the hunter-gatherer stage of civilization. Either way, it won't represent a problem. Hell, I can see some future tribal unit using it as a 'magical' burial ground. "Gee mom, great-great-great-grandpa hasn't rotted a bit."

Ishmael
Okay...another objection that I hear is that nuke tech is old; research hasn't been as aggressive or continuous. Your thoughts?

Oh, and another: It's really inefficient.
 
busybody said:
It will cost BILLIONS

Yes BILLIONS

it will kill the economy

Let the BASHING begin


Are Real Costs of Dealing With Climate Change Being Hidden From the Public?

As Al Gore and his band of not so merry global warming alarmists in buses and in the press try to convince Americans that they need to alter behaviors in order to save the planet, an inconvenient truth is being cynically withheld: this is going to cost a lot of money.

Of course, one of the delicious hypocrisies is that these are the same people who decry the current economic boom as only helping the rich, and state regularly and fervently that the poor and middle-class are being left behind.

At the same time, such mid- to lower-level wage earners should be saddled with exorbitant additional expenses to shelter them from a wolf that might never come knocking at their doors.

Makes sense, right?

With that in mind, the Chicago Tribune’s Laurie Goering wrote a fabulous piece recently exposing some of the potential costs of this exercise that most media don’t want you to know (emphasis added throughout, h/t Benny Peiser):

For the United States, the most aggressive scenario in the new U.N. Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change mitigation report — holding greenhouse gases in the atmosphere to less than 500 parts per million, up from the current 380 parts per million — could cost $240 billion a year, or 2 percent of the nation's income, said Robert Mendelsohn, a climate-change economist at Yale University.

Yikes. That would be almost ten percent of the current budget. How do you think that will impact deficits and debt expansion?

But let’s make this discussion more personal:

Reducing greenhouse gases vigorously and quickly probably would push Americans' heating and electric bills up by 50 percent to 100 percent, said Jae Edmonds, a scientist and economist with the Joint Global Change Research Institute, based in Maryland. Gasoline prices would rise between 50 cents and $1 a gallon, he said.

Nice. How would that impact the personal finances of Americans at the middle and bottom rungs of the income ladder?

Furthermore, as it seems a metaphysical certitude that Congress isn’t going to cut $240 billion per year in other spending to pay for climate change remedies, such costs clearly would come from higher taxes.

So, if you add up the 50 to 100 percent increase in home heating and electric bills, along with a 50 cent to $1 per gallon gas hike, AND higher taxes, this could mean financial doom for many Americans.

And, the resulting reduction in consumer spending on other items likely would cause a recession with higher unemployment.

Is it any wonder that the actual dollars involved in climate change solutions are being kept from this hysterical discussion?
*shrug*

Google it, and you can find all sorts of dissenting opinions from equally qualified people. Choose the Chicken Little economists if you want.

You bore me.
 
Peregrinator said:
Okay...another objection that I hear is that nuke tech is old; research hasn't been as aggressive or continuous. Your thoughts?

Oh, and another: It's really inefficient.

Old? In what way Perg? The research in power technology may not have been as aggressive as it might have been in the US, but research has moved forward. We aren't the only nation using nuclear energy you know? Control technology has moved forward rapidly. The same control processes used in nuclear power generation are used in any other continuous/batch process, ie. refineries or coal fired electircal generation plants.

Inefficient compared to what? It's still the cheapest way to generate power going.

You are demanding a reduction in CO2 loading and now are arguing against the ONLY viable short term alternative to achieving that goal. There is nothing out there that will achieve that goal in the amount of power required in the forseeable future. As much as we both might like it otherwise, the laws of physics and thermodynamics can not be altered to suit our whims.

The only alternatives you can point to is solar and wind. Neither are economically viable on the scale required in the next two decades or so and without a substantial increase in the price of oil it's unlikely they ever will. Of the two, only solar MAY have the potential to surpass nuclear with regards to cost/KWH. Wind power has reached it's limit as to cost/KWH. Generator and propeller technology is even older and better understood than nuclear. There is nothing new to be learned there. Solar at least offers the benefit of direct conversion and as such offers the highest probability of efficiency increases required to match nuclear.

Ishmael
 
Probe Carbon Offsets, Congressmen Say
By Fred Lucas
CNSNews.com Staff Writer
May 21, 2007

(CNSNews.com) - For those who support it, it offers the reward of "carbon neutrality" without having to lower one's standard of living. To critics, it allows guilt-free pollution. Either way, the burgeoning carbon offset industry needs more oversight, say two members of Congress.

In a letter to the Government Accountability Office, Republican Reps. Tom Davis of Virginia and Darrell Issa of California asked for an investigation into emission offset programs.

About 60 different companies sell carbon offsets to U.S. consumers but operate under virtually no standards, the congressmen said. They cited reports alleging that some organizations get money for emissions that don't exist and that others make large profits on cleanups that would have taken place anyway.

"We want to understand the products sold in these markets and make sure they are doing what they say they are," said Davis, the ranking Republican on the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee.

"Offsets are becoming a convenient shortcut for individuals and industry to become 'carbon neutral.' Now that we see legislation introduced to direct the federal government to do the same thing, we need a complete picture," Davis said.

Congress is considering multiple bills this year to curb global warming, including a proposal to require federal agencies to use a portion of their budgets to buy offsets.

Climate campaigners have created a procedure that allows an individual, business or institution responsible for high levels of carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions -- blamed for climate change -- to buy "offsets." They do this by paying a levy that is supposed to go towards renewable energy sources such as solar and wind power.

The money can also be used to plant trees -- so-called "carbon sinks" that remove carbon from the atmosphere.

Thus, according to advocates, high energy users can pay to become "carbon neutral" -- they are making up for the amount of CO2 they produce by funding eco-friendly projects elsewhere.

Already Delta Air has announced that it will be the first "carbon neutral" airline by allowing passengers to voluntarily pay a surcharge directed toward forestry projects. Also, many electric companies allow customers to pay extra for conservation measures.

However, one environmental group's study into the issue concluded, "There are no widely-accepted standards, for example, as to what qualifies as an offset for purposes of making consumers carbon neutral."

The study by Clean Air Cool Planet, a New Hampshire-based group that partners with companies and educational institutions in the northeast to help reduce CO2 emissions, continues, "In the absence of an accepted standard, almost anyone can offer to sell you almost anything and claim that this purchase will make you carbon neutral."

Another study, by the Tufts University Climate Initiative, also voices skepticism.

"Voluntary offsets are of limited value to solve the increasing threat of climate change," the Tufts study said. "They should not be seen as a way to buy environmental pardons."

But the Tufts study goes on to say, "Voluntary offsets do have their place in spurring innovation and financing carbon reducing projects that would otherwise not have happened.

"They are especially appropriate for individuals who have done their best to reduce their personal emissions but would like to neutralize some of the unavoidable emissions that they are responsible for," it says.

Responsible people in the carbon offset industry agree that there should be greater oversight, said Ted Dodge, executive director of the National Carbon Offsets Coalition, an industry group.

"At some point, we need federal standards," Dodge told Cybercast News Service.

He understands some of the skepticism about carbon offsets but believes the industry does offer a positive step forward.

"If you want to tackle climate change, you don't take anything off the table," Dodge said. "Is it the final answer? Probably not. Technology will at some point pass us by."

Carbon offsets gained notoriety earlier this year after former Vice President Al Gore's company, Global Investment Management, confirmed that it pays for the carbon offsets of Gore and other employees of the firm.

Gore, a leading campaigner on global warming, announced that he bought carbon offsets to compensate for his high energy use. Reports indicated that he ran up average monthly power bills of $1,200.
 
Ishmael said:
Old? In what way Perg? The research in power technology may not have been as aggressive as it might have been in the US, but research has moved forward. We aren't the only nation using nuclear energy you know? Control technology has moved forward rapidly. The same control processes used in nuclear power generation are used in any other continuous/batch process, ie. refineries or coal fired electircal generation plants.

Inefficient compared to what? It's still the cheapest way to generate power going.

You are demanding a reduction in CO2 loading and now are arguing against the ONLY viable short term alternative to achieving that goal. There is nothing out there that will achieve that goal in the amount of power required in the forseeable future. As much as we both might like it otherwise, the laws of physics and thermodynamics can not be altered to suit our whims.

The only alternatives you can point to is solar and wind. Neither are economically viable on the scale required in the next two decades or so and without a substantial increase in the price of oil it's unlikely they ever will. Of the two, only solar MAY have the potential to surpass nuclear with regards to cost/KWH. Wind power has reached it's limit as to cost/KWH. Generator and propeller technology is even older and better understood than nuclear. There is nothing new to be learned there. Solar at least offers the benefit of direct conversion and as such offers the highest probability of efficiency increases required to match nuclear.

Ishmael
Fusion........... It will be achieved
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top