Do you believe in evolution?

Blindinthedark said:
No one could have said it any better.
That's the essence of evolution.

thank you :)


pixie don't worry about hanns hes just ... well i don't know what he is but hes not worth worrying about or responding too :)
 
I'm 4 foot. and why the hell should I care what people think?!? I do not. I unlike them have more maturity and do not stoop so low to callin people names to make myself feel better.
 
you know what would be cool? a big pellet gun or some shit mounted onto my wheelchair :eek: so I can plast ignorant little fucks.
 
and I dont mind shooting little fucktarts. as for why I am disabled, why should I tell you? so you will mock me? I dont think so. and yes I do have legs.
 
I really had to bite my tongue to read this thread all the way through before responding.

First let me say I don't believe in evolution - I know it to be a fact! Evolution is not a belief system like creationism, is is a scientific fact, and you don't have to believe in it.

It is proven every day in the scientific world at the mircoscopic level - medical science has to deal with it because microorganisms evolve much faster than we do, and play havoc with our bodies because we don't have the medicine to kill them when they infect us.

Eumenides said:
Until someone can give me hard proof that humans existed with the dinosaurs, I will always believe in evolution.
I almost read that the wrong way (the opposite of what you said). Of course there will never be any such proof because dinosaurs died out millions of years before humans ever existed. At the same time, such proof wouldn't mean anything other than that the earth is much younger than we thought - but still not as young as some creationists would have us believe (6000-7000 years).

[/b]I think that creationism and evolution do not have to be mutually exclusive. That could, perhaps, be because I don't take the bible literally... [/B]
Not all of the Bible is meant to be taken literally - some parts are symbolic, some figurative and some literal. But let's address the Genesis statement of God creating the earth (actually the cosmos the way I read it) in 7 "days": in the original Hebrew, the word "yôm" is used for "days" which denotes a period of time which can be anything from a 24 hour day to an indeterminate period of time (it could easily mean billions of years), depending on the context. In Genesis there is very little context to give us a scale that would contradict the observable facts we see now with regards to the age of the earth and the cosmos.
 
Pixie Mischief said:
and I dont mind shooting little fucktarts. as for why I am disabled, why should I tell you? so you will mock me? I dont think so. and yes I do have legs.
PM - a good idea is just to ignore trolls. They do not respond to reason or anything else except attention - which they thrive on. Ignore them and they will go away. argue with them and they just feed off of it - especially people as sick and small minded as this particular troll.

If it helps, just click on the profile button in his post, and in his profile you will see an option to add him to your ignore list.

I make it a rule to ignore not only trolls, but people who respond to trolls, but in this case I thought I should say something.
 
The Heretic said:
First let me say I don't believe in evolution - I know it to be a fact! Evolution is not a belief system like creationism, is is a scientific fact, and you don't have to believe in it.

It is proven every day in the scientific world at the mircoscopic level - medical science has to deal with it because microorganisms evolve much faster than we do, and play havoc with our bodies because we don't have the medicine to kill them when they infect us.
EXACTLY so. It's not a matter of belief(which is a theistic term), but ACCEPTANCE. If Evolution is wrong, the scientists who develop and test the concepts are wrong. If THEY are wrong, all the physical sciences are wrong.

And that's UNACCEPTABLE.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Do you believe in evolution?

p_p_man said:
I only mentioned those two as examples but look at any animal on the earth today and you won't find any of them have evolved much beyond their original state.
Since neither cockroaches nor sharks popped into the current state, but rather evolved from microorganisms (as did we all) then they did evolve significantly from "their original state". Once they got to the point where there was no longer any impetus to evolve and they filled an ecological niche, then they stopped evolving so much. But still, there are many different kinds of cockroaches and many different kinds of sharks - all significantly different from each other and all filling an evolutionary niche.

OK birds were once a certain type of dinosaur but that's about the only one I can think of right now.
Then you aren't thinking very hard; dogs were once a cat like tree climbing creature, hippos were once a pig like creature, horses were once very small dog like creatures, and on and on. If you go back through the evolutionary tree of all creatures you will see that they were once quite different from what they are now. The degree of difference depends on the ecological pressures and how well their evolutionary changes allowed them to succeed in their evolutionary niche. Some were very successful (such as the alligator, shark or many insects), some needed to continue to change (such as many mammals) and some could not evolve fast enough because their ecological niche either dissapeared or a better adapted species took over their niche.

And I cannot see evolution being nature's way of preserving a species, otherwise many of them wouldn't be extinct now. They would have evolved out of the danger zone.
See my statement above. Evolution is not a "way of nature" - it is a property of existence in any environment, natural or not; you adapt or you cease to survive. The upside of that fact is that if you can adapt, you can survive, the downside is that if you can't adapt you don't survive. The fact that species become extinct is as much a fact of that rule as is the survival of a species - two sides of the same coin.

And once we became the dominant species we should have stopped evolving...
For the most part, we pretty much have stopped evolving; many scientists are saying that now that we have stopped physically evolving. The reason is not because we are the dominant species - but because we have removed ecological pressures that would require us to evolve. We adapt so readily with our brain power by changing our environment that we don't need to evolve physically. This may have some huge downsides in the future.

No, Darwin's theory just doesn't fit the facts as I personally have observed them.
That is because you don't seem to really understand how evolution works, and your observations are flawed to boot.
 
For those of you who dont believe in evolution, know this...

I'm half a step away from throwing my poop on you right now. Hell, Aquila may very well be the missing link! Ridiculous!


An added note: Heretic's posts in this thread have caused me to take back all the bad things I've said about him, and half the bad things I've thought about him.
 
Here's the scary statistics you were probably thinking of, Shaq:

http://abcnews.go.com/sections/science/DailyNews/evolutionviews990816.html

45% of American adults in this poll believe in the biblical creation myth. This was a 1999 poll.

In 1997, 44 percent went for the "god created people in the last 10,000 years", and 39 percent went with "theistic evolution". That's 83%.

Among scientists, 55% didn't follow any theistic theory, 40% go for the "theistic evolution".

So, if you don't study the field, you're not likely to believe in evolution; if you do study the field, you are. That should explain the problem.

And apparently this only applies to our willfully obtuse populace - most any other country with a moderately educated population shows a more scientifically literate view.
 
sexyguy2 said:
EXACTLY so. It's not a matter of belief(which is a theistic term), but ACCEPTANCE. If Evolution is wrong, the scientists who develop and test the concepts are wrong. If THEY are wrong, all the physical sciences are wrong.

And that's UNACCEPTABLE.
Well, time and time again we have been proven wrong in some facet of our understanding of the physical sciences, and we change our viewpoint to adapt to and use what we have learned, but the evidence and arguments for evolution as fact are pretty much indisputable; microorganisms evolve at an observable rate, as have other smaller organisms. The larger, the more complex and the longer lived organisms take longer to evolve, but even so some of them have been observed to evolve, just more slowly.

Also, one can observe the physical evidence of past creatures that existed on this earth and only the fact of evolution can really explain that evidence.

This may seem like heresy for me to say as a fundamentalist Christian, but that is why I call myself a heretic - and I do not believe that for an intelligent and knowledgeable person, that evolution and creation beliefs really conflict. I do believe that God created the cosmos and set in place the system we now observe. Whether God meddled in his creation and caused us as humans to pop into existence to one degree or another is debatable, but in the beginning I do believe God started the whole universe in motion.
 
Re: For those of you who dont believe in evolution, know this...

SilvaTungDevil said:
An added note: Heretic's posts in this thread have caused me to take back all the bad things I've said about him, and half the bad things I've thought about him.
Aw shucks! *scuffles feet and turns red* :eek:

:D
 
Just let it be known before you read this that I am a devout Athiest, so I'm not going to try to compare Creationism vs. Evolutionism. I don't believe in God, only logic, and logically, there is no god, and Evolution is therefore the most plausible theory of how we are what we are.

In pure science, a theory is the best explaination for what we currently know. Any scientist worth his salt will never tell you that somehting as basic as the theory of gravity is absolutely, 100% right. in a perfect world, if the theorty of gravity is proven wrong just ONCE (though the experiment must be verified and proven to have been performed correctly, that's why nobody believes in Cold Fusion, even though a couple of rogue scientists have claimed to have produced it. But they couldn't do it again, and there was no definite proof of the experiment, so the Science world tossed it out), it will be discarded or amended to take the new information into account.

That being said, there is an almost unlimited amount of evidence to support the Theory of Evolution, you can find it in any scientific journal or book on the subject, but all we have to support Creationism (Evolutions prime competitor) is the Holy Bible, written by men over a mellenium ago. Not to mention that the very concept of God and His powers go against the primary laws of physics.

I'm not making a judgement against religion. I believe religion in it's purest form to be a wonderful thing. It teaches self-worth, and decent human values and ethics, but when people start to die (and kill) for their God, something has gone terribly wrong. as long as man has existed, He has been searching for meaning in things, why things happen. The best example I can give is the Great Flood of Noah. People saw rainbows, and they thought "what are rainbows, surely such a majestic sight cannot simply be part of the sky, if it was, why do we not see it every day?" They had no way of knowing that light passing through suspended water droplets refracts into the different colors of light, thus creating the rainbow. So they invented a story to explain it. The Greek and Roman Pantheons are another great example. They had a god for nearly everything, and if somehting went wrong, it wasn't their fault... If crops of wheat went bad, Ceres, (or Demeter) Goddess of the Harvest, was in a foul mood. It took personal destiny out of the equation. It made life much easier.

Hurm... turns out I did end up making a case for Evolution Vs. Creationism... Sorry. I didn't mean to be preachy, but I believe what I say, and above everything else, I believe in Tolerence for ideas, if not the way those ideas are carried out.

I leave myself open to constructive arguement.
 
Re: Re: Do you believe in evolution?

p_p_man said:
If Darwin was right and all things evolve naturally over millions of years why are we such an advanced species today but the cockroach and the shark have more or less stayed as they've always been?

Even given the argument that each species change within different timescales there should have been some noticeable evolvement by now...

That's not how evolution works. Evolution is not "improvement", and it does not work like a ladder where each species gets "higher" every year. Species do not get "better" or change just for the sake of changing. Evolution works by creating randon mutations in each generation, allowing those mutated offspriing best adapted to the changing environemnt to survive. Sharks haven't changed much because they don't have to -- their environment (water, plenty of smaller fish to eat) hasn't changed dramatically (and sharks have evolved in numerous ways to deal with temperature change and the size of their prey). Ditto with cockroaches, who haven't changed essentially, but are actually practicign evolution at ightning speed as they mutate astonishingly fast to produce new generations resistant to human poisons.
 
Last edited:
Dantetier said:
that's why nobody believes in Cold Fusion, even though a couple of rogue scientists have claimed to have produced it. But they couldn't do it again, and there was no definite proof of the experiment, so the Science world tossed it out), it will be discarded or amended to take the new information into account. ...

Just to clarify your excellent example, it was the recent Cold Fusion experiment that scientists have famously rejected, not Cold Fusion itself, which powers the sun, and is certainly "believed". I know you know that, but the way you worded your post you made it sound like Cold Fusion was a fantasy, like a perpetual motion machine.

Weclome to the board.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Do you believe in evolution?

The Heretic said:
For the most part, we pretty much have stopped evolving; many scientists are saying that now that we have stopped physically evolving. The reason is not because we are the dominant species - but because we have removed ecological pressures that would require us to evolve. We adapt so readily with our brain power by changing our environment that we don't need to evolve physically.[/B]

I can't see how they can say that as we're not anywhere near the end of the world yet (barring a major a catastrophe) but as I don't accept evolution I'll go along with what you say but physical evolution is not the only type to consider...

How about the mental process? Has that evolved? And is it still evolving?

If our brains are part of the evolutionary process, what happened to the brains of the other animals. Why haven't they improved at the same pace as ours. Nothing to threaten them? I doubt it.

As I said I find evolution hard to accept purely because there are too many loopholes in the theory...

ppman
 
Last edited:
Dixon Carter Lee said:
Just to clarify your excellent example, it was the recent Cold Fusion experiment that scientists have famously rejected, not Cold Fusion itself, which powers the sun, and is certainly "believed". I know you know that, but the way you worded your post you made it sound like Cold Fusion was a fantasy, like a perpetual motion machine.

Weclome to the board.

Thanks for supporting and welcoming me, I appreciate it...


however... Cold fusion is supposed to be room temperature fusion... quite literally... COLD fusion... the Sun has a huge fusion reactor in the center of it, fusing Hydrogen into Helium, yes, however... at nearly 15 million degrees Kelvin, it's hardly room temperature..
 
p_p_man said:

If our brains are part of the evolutionary process, what happened to the brains of the other animals. Why haven't they improved at the same pace as ours.

You aren't listening. Evolution is not about improving, it's about adapting. You don't understand the theory.

And there are no loopholes. Evolution has been observed on the molecular level with the AIDs virus. Scientists only disagree on aspects of evolution's process, not on evolution itself. Generational mutation and environmental adaptation do occur. There's more evidence for evolution that there is for Pluto.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Do you believe in evolution?

p_p_man said:
I can't see how they can say that as we're not anywhere near the end of the world yet (barring a major a catastrophe) but as I don't accept evolution I'll go along with what you say but physical evolution is not the only type to consider...

How about the mental process? Has that evolved? And is it still evolving?

If our brains are part of the evolutionary process, what happened to the brains of the other animals. Why haven't they improved at the same pace as ours. Nothing to threaten them? I doubt it.

As I said I find evolution hard to accept purely because there are to many loopholes in the theory...

ppman

As for us not evolving anymore... that's not technically true... With our advancement and superiority to the other creatures of the world, we don't have the survival need for evolution... the physical need for evolution is gone... we don't need to hunt... machines perform most of our basic tasks...

Human evolution has gone on to a higher state. Mental and intellectual evolution. Human intelligence is growing exponentially in this age of computers. in the past 100 years, we have amassed more knowledge then in all of the 130,000 years or so since the dawn of Man.

As for other creatures and their lack of menatlity... it's not quite true. Granted, if you look at a monkey, you might think that it is one stupid animal... but a monkey has the bas intelligence of a 5 year old child, and comparing that to say, an ant... that's quite a difference. Dolphins are another example... they have a mans of communication... and they play... somehting that no other creature other then humans have learned how to do... they play for the sheer enjoyment of it. But again... compared to humans... they aren't particularly intelligent.

But there is a big reason for that... we are simply better... We learned better, we learned faster, and we learned harder. That's the skinny on it. We are simply better then the other life on earth, and once we've taken up the role as the primary and only sentient life on Earth, other sentient life cannot come into being. Hemans are too scared of that. We'd destroy it before it got near the stage we were at a mere 50,000 years ago
 
Dantetier said:
Cold fusion is supposed to be room temperature fusion... quite literally... COLD fusion... the Sun has a huge fusion reactor in the center of it, fusing Hydrogen into Helium, yes, however... at nearly 15 million degrees Kelvin, it's hardly room temperature..

You're right. The Sun's engine is "fusion".
 
You all have a choice, believe in reality or fantasy. Evolution is a fact. Before mankind developed language and conscious thought god or gods did not exist, animals do not pray before they sleep do they! Religion is a false manifestation of Mankind trying to make sense of its Universe. As we (as a species) grow up we learn, at least some of us do.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top