Do you believe in evolution?

Hook Jazzy and Cheyenne up, give them a wheelbarrow of fertility drugs and their own McD for good measure. With the pureness of their inferior genes and their choice to persistently lead unhealthy, sedentary lifestyles- their types will adapt and finally will be able to make it past 50 before their hearts explode.

Scientists: Stop trying to isolate "fat" genes, it's merely a delaying tactic, hardly worth the time and money. Deny people that live unhealthy lifestyles access to healthcare, let evolution take its course. They'll only shape up if they are forced to.
 
the thing that really made humans what we are instead of just smart monkey's is when we had to cross the plains in search of food ... then we stood up and that gave us the ability for our hands to evolve to be more complex (because they weren't just being used for walking on) and be able to use tools better this in turn increased our brain power


this happened by natural selection the monkeys that could cross the plains faster could get to the food quicker and breed more successfully and eventually through this mix of mutation and natural selection the monkeys were standing up ... and then the monkeys that had more devolped hands would be able to use tools better to get the dwindling food and thus breed more ... the monkeys that could learn how to use those tools better became even more sucessful and smarter and thus bred more


why do people have a hard time accepting this its not faith its fact
 
welshman said:
You all have a choice, believe in reality or fantasy. Evolution is a fact. Before mankind developed language and conscious thought god or gods did not exist, animals do not pray before they sleep do they! Religion is a false manifestation of Mankind trying to make sense of its Universe.
Religion may or may not be a false manifestation - but we don't know that for a fact because it is very hard to disprove some aspects of some religions, especially the fundamental claim that is relevant to this discussion; that some unknown entity creasted the cosmos.

Just a point of argument, but an important point.
 
People think by spending money they can change history and science and political data. The Negro as we know is being used by the West to rape rich Africa. So suddently man originates in Africa. When Africa has been raped first man will have suddenly appeared say in Papua New Guinea. The people of Aryavarta will protect The Negro from you exploiters.
 
All these foreign genetisists are busy manufacturing data to rape Africa and again exploit the Negro. Ask the gentists where carbon came from he does not know. Let alone a man. We Aryans are destined to protect the Negro from European exploitation.
 
I believe in micro evolution, a scientific and biblical truth.

I don't believe in macro evolution, an unproven scientific theory and biblical untruth.
 
yayati238 said:
All these foreign genetisists are busy manufacturing data to rape Africa and again exploit the Negro. Ask the gentists where carbon came from he does not know. Let alone a man. We Aryans are destined to protect the Negro from European exploitation.

You are a complete and utter moron...
 
The Heretic said:
Religion may or may not be a false manifestation - but we don't know that for a fact because it is very hard to disprove some aspects of some religions, especially the fundamental claim that is relevant to this discussion; that some unknown entity creasted the cosmos.

Just a point of argument, but an important point.

The problem with this is that much of science can and has been disproven.... but that is because science makes claims that can be experimented upon... you can say that one part oxygen and two parts hydrogen will make one part water... and you can prove that... but you cannot prove the existince of an omnipotent being of which we have NO scientific proof WHATSOEVER
 
Dantetier said:
You are a complete and utter moron...

don't waste your breath. You're new here - trust us, you'll get used to him, white noise in the background. After a while one even gets a bit fond of his antics, in an odd way.
 
It's easy to criticizing someone else's position when you haven't bothered to find out what their position is, but unless you're willing to read what scientists actually have to say, you have no business criticizing science - just like someone who has never even bothered to read the Bible has no business criticizing Christianity. Anyone who supports creationism should really read John Rennie's article "15 Answers to Creationist Nonsense" (Scientific American, July 2002) so they know what they are arguing against.

But since I know most people (myself included) can't usually be bothered reading long articles people link to, I'm posting a few quotes from the article that specifically relates to stuff brought up in this thread (I know, I know - most people don't read long quotes either - but there have to a be few posters around that are less lazy than me :D).
Dantetier said:
Evolution is not a fact... it's a theory... the best explination we have for the things we observe.
I know you weren't arguing that evolution should be dismissed on this basis Dantetier - but this is something that creationists often see as a weakness with evolution, so I thought it would be good to post the article's response.

Creationist Claim #1. Evolution is only a theory. It is not a fact or a scientific law.

Many people learned in elementary school that a theory falls in the middle of a hierarchy of certainty--above a mere hypothesis but below a law. Scientists do not use the terms that way, however. According to the National Academy of Sciences (NAS), a scientific theory is "a well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world that can incorporate facts, laws, inferences, and tested hypotheses." No amount of validation changes a theory into a law, which is a descriptive generalization about nature. So when scientists talk about the theory of evolution--or the atomic theory or the theory of relativity, for that matter--they are not expressing reservations about its truth.

http://www.sciam.com/media/inline/000D4FEC-7D5B-1D07-8E49809EC588EEDF_2.jpgGalápagos finches show adaptive beak shapes.

In addition to the theory of evolution, meaning the idea of descent with modification, one may also speak of the fact of evolution. The NAS defines a fact as "an observation that has been repeatedly confirmed and for all practical purposes is accepted as 'true.'" The fossil record and abundant other evidence testify that organisms have evolved through time. Although no one observed those transformations, the indirect evidence is clear, unambiguous and compelling.

All sciences frequently rely on indirect evidence. Physicists cannot see subatomic particles directly, for instance, so they verify their existence by watching for telltale tracks that the particles leave in cloud chambers. The absence of direct observation does not make physicists' conclusions less certain.
 
peachykeen said:
don't waste your breath. You're new here - trust us, you'll get used to him, white noise in the background. After a while one even gets a bit fond of his antics, in an odd way.

I understand about that... Back in my WBS days... there was a character named Ada.... cmpletely insulting... but he did it in such a way that those of lesser mental capability didn't get it... amazingly funn to those of us of higher functioning
 
patient1 said:
Uh, perhaps you could elaborate.

If the process is purely chance, & not part of a program or devine intervention, why has it defied the laws of physics for a natural state of low energy/total randomness as in the case of a gas, & gone from simple single celled creatures to complex?
Dantetier's already answered this - but your question ties in fairly nicely with two of the things discussed in the article (the second of which is basically just a rehash of what Dantetier said so I left it out of my post - it's #9 in the article if you want to read it).

Creationist Claim #8. Mathematically, it is inconceivable that anything as complex as a protein, let alone a living cell or a human, could spring up by chance.

Chance plays a part in evolution (for example, in the random mutations that can give rise to new traits), but evolution does not depend on chance to create organisms, proteins or other entities. Quite the opposite: natural selection, the principal known mechanism of evolution, harnesses nonrandom change by preserving "desirable" (adaptive) features and eliminating "undesirable" (nonadaptive) ones. As long as the forces of selection stay constant, natural selection can push evolution in one direction and produce sophisticated structures in surprisingly short times.

http://www.sciam.com/media/inline/000D4FEC-7D5B-1D07-8E49809EC588EEDF_7.gif

As an analogy, consider the 13-letter sequence "TOBEORNOTTOBE." Those hypothetical million monkeys, each pecking out one phrase a second, could take as long as 78,800 years to find it among the 2613 sequences of that length. But in the 1980s Richard Hardison of Glendale College wrote a computer program that generated phrases randomly while preserving the positions of individual letters that happened to be correctly placed (in effect, selecting for phrases more like Hamlet's). On average, the program re-created the phrase in just 336 iterations, less than 90 seconds. Even more amazing, it could reconstruct Shakespeare's entire play in just four and a half days.
 
Pixie Mischief said:
I believe in evolution when it comes to adapting minimaly but NOT that people like same ancerstor as apes. I dont really believe that but I do believe in things adapting a proff of this is the plants outside where I live all have little hairs to keep them warm because in the summer even it gets cold at night. The plants have evolve into making hairs to keep warm. there all fuzzy hehe
Todd-'o'-Vision said:
I believe in micro evolution, a scientific and biblical truth.

I don't believe in macro evolution, an unproven scientific theory and biblical untruth.
Creationist Claim #11. Natural selection might explain microevolution, but it cannot explain the origin of new species and higher orders of life.

Evolutionary biologists have written extensively about how natural selection could produce new species. For instance, in the model called allopatry, developed by Ernst Mayr of Harvard University, if a population of organisms were isolated from the rest of its species by geographical boundaries, it might be subjected to different selective pressures. Changes would accumulate in the isolated population. If those changes became so significant that the splinter group could not or routinely would not breed with the original stock, then the splinter group would be reproductively isolated and on its way toward becoming a new species.

Natural selection is the best studied of the evolutionary mechanisms, but biologists are open to other possibilities as well. Biologists are constantly assessing the potential of unusual genetic mechanisms for causing speciation or for producing complex features in organisms. Lynn Margulis of the University of Massachusetts at Amherst and others have persuasively argued that some cellular organelles, such as the energy-generating mitochondria, evolved through the symbiotic merger of ancient organisms. Thus, science welcomes the possibility of evolution resulting from forces beyond natural selection. Yet those forces must be natural; they cannot be attributed to the actions of mysterious creative intelligences whose existence, in scientific terms, is unproved.
 
Last edited:
teddybear4play said:
I believe limited evolution takes place, such as what Darwin proved on the islands.

I don't believe man descended from apes. There's simply too much of a paradigm shift. It's a difference of kind, not a difference of degree.

We haven't found the missing link. I don't think we ever will.

TB4p
Creationist Claim #13. Evolutionists cannot point to any transitional fossils--creatures that are half reptile and half bird, for instance.

Actually, paleontologists know of many detailed examples of fossils intermediate in form between various taxonomic groups. One of the most famous fossils of all time is Archaeopteryx, which combines feathers and skeletal structures peculiar to birds with features of dinosaurs. A flock's worth of other feathered fossil species, some more avian and some less, has also been found. A sequence of fossils spans the evolution of modern horses from the tiny Eohippus. Whales had four-legged ancestors that walked on land, and creatures known as Ambulocetus and Rodhocetus helped to make that transition [see "The Mammals That Conquered the Seas," by Kate Wong; Scientific American, May]. Fossil seashells trace the evolution of various mollusks through millions of years. Perhaps 20 or more hominids (not all of them our ancestors) fill the gap between Lucy the australopithecine and modern humans.
http://www.sciam.com/media/inline/000D4FEC-7D5B-1D07-8E49809EC588EEDF_3.jpgSkulls of some hominids predating modern humans (Homo sapiens).

Creationists, though, dismiss these fossil studies. They argue that Archaeopteryx is not a missing link between reptiles and birds--it is just an extinct bird with reptilian features. They want evolutionists to produce a weird, chimeric monster that cannot be classified as belonging to any known group. Even if a creationist does accept a fossil as transitional between two species, he or she may then insist on seeing other fossils intermediate between it and the first two. These frustrating requests can proceed ad infinitum and place an unreasonable burden on the always incomplete fossil record.

Nevertheless, evolutionists can cite further supportive evidence from molecular biology. All organisms share most of the same genes, but as evolution predicts, the structures of these genes and their products diverge among species, in keeping with their evolutionary relationships. Geneticists speak of the "molecular clock" that records the passage of time. These molecular data also show how various organisms are transitional within evolution.
 
Dantetier said:
crysede:


Excellent explaination
Thanks - but I can't take any credit for it, it's from John Rennie's article (a very good read :))
 
Dantetier said:
The problem with this is that much of science can and has been disproven.... but that is because science makes claims that can be experimented upon... you can say that one part oxygen and two parts hydrogen will make one part water... and you can prove that... but you cannot prove the existince of an omnipotent being of which we have NO scientific proof WHATSOEVER
Somewhat correct; at this point we have no proof and little evidence for an omipotent being (unless you argue that the existance of the universe itself is evidence - and then you are getting more into the metaphysical than the physical).

But my point was one of logic; as I am sure you are aware, you cannot categorically state that there is no omnipotent being because such a statement itself cannot be proven. If someone says prove to me that there is no creator of the universe, you can't do it - the best you can do is counter such a challenge with a challenge of your own for the person to prove the existance of a creator.

I am not using this as an argument for a creator - just stating that at the same time you cannot categorically deny the existance of a creator - which is what your assertion seemed to claim, and what I took issue with.

At this point in time, science cannot go back to before the point where the cosmos came into existance - indeed, from my understanding we cannot currently go back to past a point some infintesimally small amount of time after the universe came into existance. So we don't know and cannot even scientifically speculate on what brought the universe into existance, we cannot claim to know one way or the other who or what brought the universe into being. For all we know an omnipotent creator is as valid a claim as stating that it just popped into existance by accident.

Therefore, as a point of logic I took issue with your claim that religion is a "false manifestation" - since we neither know nor can prove any such thing. Science is all about learning what we can or cannot observe or know - not about speculating on what we cannot know, which is the realm of faith.
 
Last edited:
I think you guys are arguing the same point from two different sides.

The fact that we can't know that there is no God, means that the hypothesis "God exists" is scientifically meaningless since it is not testable or falsifiable - thus for science it is a fact that there is no such thing as a God, because postulating God's existence is impossible.
 
crysede said:
I think you guys are arguing the same point from two different sides.

The fact that we can't know that there is no God, means that the hypothesis "God exists" is scientifically meaningless since it is not testable or falsifiable - thus for science it is a fact that there is no such thing as a God, because postulating God's existence is impossible.
Almost. Since I am a seeker of truth I come at everything from the rules of logic - to me, if you can't prove or disprove something, it isn't a fact, ir is an unknown or in this case, from our present point of view, unknowable. Since, to me, the basis for science is logic, I would not accept that just because something is not testable or provable one way or the other, does not make it a fact that it is false - most scientists I know would chalk it up to an unknown. Hence my example of not knowing anything before some really small point in time after the creation of the universe.

As such, I could never be an atheist - at most I could be an agnostic; since logic dictates that from our POV it is impossible to disprove the existance of a creator - I would have to allow for that possibility.

I tend towards believing in a creator because I believe there was a cause (creation) to the effect (the universe). Going beyond that we get into the metaphysical and go around in circles with regards to logic and science. I tend towards Christianity in part because that is the way I was raised, but also because of all the religions it seems the closest to matching observable facts of the universe - ranging from our existance to our nature. That is neither a logical nor scientific argument for my religious beliefs, just an explanation.

What rules my life is the search for truth; if something conflicts with what I consider to be truth, then I disregard it - hence my adoption of evolution as a scientific fact over some people's insistence that creationism is fact. To me the former is scientific fact, the latter a belief. What I know is a different level of certainty of thought than what I believe.
 
yayati said:
All these foreign genetisists are busy manufacturing data to rape Africa and again exploit the Negro. Ask the gentists where carbon came from he does not know. Let alone a man. We Aryans are destined to protect the Negro from European exploitation.
Carbon comes from fusion - glad I could help :)
 
Why you would ask a geneticist where Carbon comes from, I don't know. that would be more along the lines of a Chemist... unless you get down to the sub-atomic level, then it would be a physacist... and further beyond that... once you get down to quarks, you're in the field of theoretical physics.... but I digress

I was in college for a short while in Kansas around the same time as the state board ruled that you can't test on evolution unless you also test on creationism...

Simplest terms.... Evolution is science. Creathion is Philosophy. When you start mixing the two and saying one does not exist because the other is true, that's where the problems come from. Evolution and creationism are not mutually exclusive
 
Back
Top