Do you believe in evolution?

welshman said:
You all have a choice, believe in reality or fantasy. Evolution is a fact. Before mankind developed language and conscious thought god or gods did not exist, animals do not pray before they sleep do they! Religion is a false manifestation of Mankind trying to make sense of its Universe. As we (as a species) grow up we learn, at least some of us do.

Evolution is not a fact... it's a theory... the best explination we have for the things we observe.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Do you believe in evolution?

Dantetier said:
But there is a big reason for that... we are simply better... We learned better, we learned faster, and we learned harder.

Interesting post but I'll just pick up on this one point.

Let's go back in time to where we were on par with everything else on this planet. Whether we were once apes, giraffes, cockroaches or sharks I don't mind.

What exactly kick started us as a species into the learning better, faster and harder category, or do you think it just happened naturally and we picked up speed as we went along.

Which doesn't quite tie in with the human mind being largely unchanged during our written history until 200-300 years ago when we shifted into a higher gear.

Something must have been there to give us that initial advantage.

All I'm saying is that I can't see evolution having anything to do with it. The circle doesn't sqare somehow and the theory's to pat.

And as I'm also discounting God there must be something else.

ppman
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Do you believe in evolution?

p_p_man said:
Interesting post but I'll just pick up on this one point.

Let's go back in time to where we were on par with everything else on this planet. Whether we were once apes, giraffes, cockroaches or sharks I don't mind.

What exactly kick started us as a species into the learning better, faster and harder category, or do you think it just happened naturally and we picked up speed as we went along.

Which doesn't quite tie in with the human mind being largely unchanged during our written history until 200-300 years ago when we shifted into a higher gear.

Something must have been there to give us that initial advantage.

All I'm saying is that I can't see evolution having anything to do with it. The circle doesn't sqare somehow and the theory's to pat.

And as I'm also discounting God there must be something else.

ppman


When we discuss the human intellect like this... once you get past the point of sentience, you move beyond Evolution. Evolution on a species-wide scale takes MANY thousands of years... I mean... enough to notice a drastic change. Homo Erectus and Homo Sapien are incredibly close... but a small group of Homo Erectus discovered something that gave them the edge... be it that if a seed from an apple falls to the ground, and later a new apple tree grows there, which might spark Agriculture, or the ever famous lightning bolt hits the tree to give Mankind fire... there's something there.

in 2001: a Space Oddesy, Kubrick breaks it down simply... The Obelisk is a symbol... it could be anything... but he makes it an obelisk. That THING that the Obelisk represents sparks the thought of TOOLS into primitive mans head... and he picked up a club and brained his fellow primitive man.. thus giving him the edge. That's all it needs to give us a push...


Intellectual Evolution is different then Gene Evolution. It's more of a metaphor. Simple fact is, we are learning at an exponential rate... the more we know, the more we learn, and the faster we learn it... it's as simple as that.
 
Too many idiots in this thread. SLG and shaq were the only ones with sanity in the first ten posts or so. I don't even have the will to read the rest of idiocy.
 
p_p_man said:

Let's go back in time to where we were ON PAR with everything else on this planet....What exactly kick started us as a species into the learning BETTER, faster and harder category...

You still aren't listening. You're caught up with this idea that Evolution is about improving species, and nothing in the theory talks about that. Species don't get "better", they "adapt". It's the old adage that birds fly because they had to. We're smarter because we had to be smarter.

And there are plenty of timeline theories about how that happened.

1) We swung on trees, to avoid predators below.
2) Swinging from branch to branch improves hand-eye cooridination and digital manipulation.
3) The proto-humans with the best ability to swing survived the longest and got the best food.
4) As we got smarter, our brains actually got bigger.
5) As our brains got bigger our heads got bigger.
6) As our head got bigger childbirth became harder.
7) Those mutations that gave birth earlier, when the heads were smaller, survived best.
8) Earlier births led to more more helpless children.
9) Those mutations that showed a proclivity for cooperation (help with the kids) survived better, and we became social.
10) Social interraction and cooperation led to bigger brains..ETC.

Some smarter species evolved and did not survive (like the Neanderthals) because the environment changed too quicly for them to adapt. The only species of human to evolve to our level of intelligence and survive is homo spapien, though there were once seveal other human species, all living at the same time.

Apes (from whom we did not evolve, but with whom we share a common ancestor) that have survived to present day have done so because of other successful mutation experiments (in size and agilty).

Evolution is not a plan. It's not conscious. It does not have any idea what works and what doesn't. It's not "improving" anything. Natural selction is pure chance. Evolution doesn't actually "DO" anything, it isn't a chemical process. Evolution is just a way of explaining a process that happens in everything from a bacteria to a sunflower to a giraffe -- to whit, that with each reproduction tiny mutations occur, small changes in appearance, size, durability, smell, bone structure, and by pure chance those that have the best ability to survive the environment live to pass down those traits to the succeeding generations, who will produce their own random mutations.

And, again, it's extremely well proved.
 
Last edited:
Dietrich K. said:
Um ... bad question.

One doesn't "believe in" evolution any more than one "believes in" gravity or "believes in" heliocentrism. It's a scientific fact, not an article of faith.

And before you say it's just a "theory", look up the word as it applies to science and get back to me.

Look up the definition of science. Science is based on a set of observations and then hypothesizes on what makes those observations.

Also... people believe what they want to believe. Some people believe that you can get all the nutrients that you need out of the air.
 
I believe limited evolution takes place, such as what Darwin proved on the islands.

I don't believe man descended from apes. There's simply too much of a paradigm shift. It's a difference of kind, not a difference of degree.

We haven't found the missing link. I don't think we ever will.

TB4p
 
teddybear4play said:
I believe limited evolution takes place, such as what Darwin proved on the islands.

I don't believe man descended from apes. There's simply too much of a paradigm shift. It's a difference of kind, not a difference of degree.

We haven't found the missing link. I don't think we ever will.

TB4p

Darwin NEVER believed in evolution on a grand scale. He showed us Natural selection... but we have upgraded that to full blown evolution. Also... Chuck never claimed we were decended from apes... in fact... he was horribly offended when someone used his theory to use as a basis for the ape ancestor theory...


As for decended from apes... we may not have... but the similarities a far too close to not have a common ancestor.
 
There is no way to prove evolution at the end of the day its just another theory.

it takes a leap of faith to believe it.

some morons take it for a fact lol
 
yayati2937 said:
There is no way to prove evolution at the end of the day its just another theory.

it takes a leap of faith to believe it.

some morons take it for a fact lol

If you'll go back a page... you'll see that I said NOTHING in science is considered FACT.....
 
hanns u moron,

arabs are killers i agree
but not all muslims are arabs

India has 120million + muslims. Although there are bad things that happen there is no serious hatred between muslims and hindus
 
Dantetier said:
If you'll go back a page... you'll see that I said NOTHING in science is considered FACT.....

thats what i am saying its total bakwas and it is something tha scientific community doesnt want u to cotton onto.

There is no real evidence to support evolution it requires a leap of faith much like creationism.

We cant even tell where carbon came fromlet alone man!
 
The religion of Islam is an extremely peaceful religion...but it's when people use interpretations of ANY religion to think they are better then people of other religions, and use that thought as justification for murder and hatred... then they are perverting it. It's not just Islam... Every religion has done it.

Christians had the Crusades, Puritians had Salem, Christians kill doctors because they performed abortions. All religions have commited murder in the name of God, and that's one of the reasons I am Athiest.... besides the whole not believing in God thing
 
yayati92347 said:
thats what i am saying its total bakwas and it is something tha scientific community doesnt want u to cotton onto.

There is no real evidence to support evolution it requires a leap of faith much like creationism.

We cant even tell where carbon came fromlet alone man!

I don't know what you're talking about. There is a great deal of support for Evolution...

And Carbon is made up of 6 Protons, 6 Electrons and a number of Neutrons...
 
Dixon Carter Lee said:


Evolution is not a plan. It's not conscious. It does not have any idea what works and what doesn't. It's not "improving" anything. Natural selction is pure chance. Evolution doesn't actually "DO" anything, it isn't a chemical process. Evolution is just a way of explaining a process that happens in everything from a bacteria to a sunflower to a giraffe -- to whit, that with each reproduction tiny mutations occur, small changes in appearance, size, durability, smell, bone structure, and by pure chance those that have the best ability to survive the environment live to pass down those traits to the succeeding generations, who will produce their own random mutations.

And, again, it's extremely well proved.


Uh, perhaps you could elaborate.

If the process is purely chance, & not part of a program or devine intervention, why has it defied the laws of physics for a natural state of low energy/total randomness as in the case of a gas, & gone from simple single celled creatures to complex?
 
patient1 said:
Uh, perhaps you could elaborate.

If the process is purely chance, & not part of a program or devine intervention, why has it defied the laws of physics for a natural state of low energy/total randomness as in the case of a gas, & gone from simple single celled creatures to complex?

This is a classic arguement put forth by Creationsits. They have either misinterpreted the 2nd law of Thermodynamics, or purposfully perverted it. The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that "in all energy exchanges, if no energy enters or leaves the system, the potential energy of the state will always be less than that of the initial state." This is also commonly referred to as entropy. However... the Earth is not a closed system... If it were, your statement would be correct. However, the earth has an outside power source... the sun. Because of that.. more complex forms can arise from less complex forms... seemingly against the laws of physics
 
Evolution works, it has been used to evolve computer programs and electronic hardware that are more efficient than anything that could be designed. An example:

http://www.cogs.susx.ac.uk/users/adrianth/cacm99/node3.html

The task of the evolved circuit was simply to distinguish between 1kHz and 10kHz audio tones, producing a steady high output whenever one tone was present at the input, and a steady low for the other. It was evolved directly on a Xilinx XC6216 Field-Programmable Gate Array (FPGA). In simple terms, this VLSI device consists of an uncommitted array of components (or `cells'). Switches made from transistors (multiplexers) control how each component behaves, and how they are connected to each-other. The settings of the switches are controlled by the contents of RAM memory bits distributed throughout the chip; this memory can be rapidly and repeatedly written to by a host microprocessor, causing any of a vast number of possible electronic circuits to be physically instantiated in silicon.

...

Evolution was allowed to exploit the capabilities of the FPGA as freely as possible. Each candidate design was a setting of the configuration bits for a 10x10 corner of the array of cells. To test its fitness, each design was configured onto a real FPGA (no simulation), half-second bursts of 1kHz and 10kHz test stimuli were applied to its input, and a fitness score was automatically assigned according to the degree to which the output approximated the desired discrimination behaviour. The behaviour of the final circuit is near-optimal according to this fitness measure.

...

In our experiment, no constraints were placed on the circuit's structure or dynamical behaviour. No clock was provided, so evolution was searching the space of continuous-time dynamical systems made from the high gain analogue components normally used as logic gates. Evolution was free to explore the full repertoire of the FPGA's possible behaviours, of which digital systems constitute but a small subset. ... The experiment was successful, and the resulting circuit is considerably smaller than would be achieved by conventional methods given the same resources.

Until the present study, one could only speculate as to the circuit's means of operation, so unusual are its structure and dynamics. It was clear that continuous time played an important role. If the circuit was configured onto a different, but nominally identical, FPGA chip (not used during evolution), then its performance was degraded. If the temperature is raised or lowered, then the circuit still works, but the frequencies between which it discriminates are raised or lowered. (Digital circuits usually display unchanged behaviour followed by brittle failure on approaching their thermal limits.)

Evolution works, and works so well we have difficulty understanding the results.
 
Last edited:
Dietrich K. said:
Um ... bad question.

One doesn't "believe in" evolution any more than one "believes in" gravity or "believes in" heliocentrism. It's a scientific fact, not an article of faith.

And before you say it's just a "theory", look up the word as it applies to science and get back to me.


The validity of "facts" and truth are something philosophers and science both agree are necessary in order to carry out our daily lives...but given these facts are enclosed within a reality that is itself the independent variable calling anything a fact is the experimented playing a dual role as the experimenters.

Andit isn't a bad question because there are many people who don't believe in heliocentrism.

Have you seen the mathmatical formulas that support the heliocentric theory? Have you ever watched from a distant galaxy the revolution of the Earth around the Sun?

Good question...pompous answer...
 
Dantetier said:
This is a classic arguement put forth by Creationsits. They have either misinterpreted the 2nd law of Thermodynamics, or purposfully perverted it. The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that "in all energy exchanges, if no energy enters or leaves the system, the potential energy of the state will always be less than that of the initial state." This is also commonly referred to as entropy. However... the Earth is not a closed system... If it were, your statement would be correct. However, the earth has an outside power source... the sun. Because of that.. more complex forms can arise from less complex forms... seemingly against the laws of physics

Thank you for a plausible explanation.:)
 
Dantetier said:
This is a classic arguement put forth by Creationsits. They have either misinterpreted the 2nd law of Thermodynamics, or purposfully perverted it. The Second Law of Thermodynamics states that "in all energy exchanges, if no energy enters or leaves the system, the potential energy of the state will always be less than that of the initial state." This is also commonly referred to as entropy. However... the Earth is not a closed system... If it were, your statement would be correct. However, the earth has an outside power source... the sun. Because of that.. more complex forms can arise from less complex forms... seemingly against the laws of physics

This is well explained by MC Hawking in his track Entropy (to the tune of Naughty By Nature's OPP):

Entropy
Trash Talk
Harm me with harmony.
Doomsday, drop a load on 'em.

Verse 1
Entropy, how can I explain it? I'll take it frame by frame it,
to have you all jumping, shouting saying it.
Let's just say that it's a measure of disorder,
in a system that is closed, like with a border.
It's sorta, like a, well a measurement of randomness,
proposed in 1850 by a German, but wait I digress.
"What the fuck is entropy?", I here the people still exclaiming,
it seems I gotta start the explaining.

You ever drop an egg and on the floor you see it break?
You go and get a mop so you can clean up your mistake.
But did you ever stop to ponder why we know it's true,
if you drop a broken egg you will not get an egg that's new.

That's entropy or E-N-T-R-O to the P to the Y,
the reason why the sun will one day all burn out and die.
Order from disorder is a scientific rarity,
allow me to explain it with a little bit more clarity.
Did I say rarity? I meant impossibility,
at least in a closed system there will always be more entropy.
That's entropy and I hope that you're all down with it,
if you are here's your membership.

Chorus
You down with entropy?
Yeah, you know me! (x3)
Who's down with entropy?
Every last homey!

Verse 2
Defining entropy as disorder's not complete,
'cause disorder as a definition doesn't cover heat.
So my first definition I would now like to withdraw,
and offer one that fits thermodynamics second law.
First we need to understand that entropy is energy,
energy that can't be used to state it more specifically.
In a closed system entropy always goes up,
that's the second law, now you know what's up.

You can't win, you can't break even, you can't leave the game,
'cause entropy will take it all 'though it seems a shame.
The second law, as we now know, is quite clear to state,
that entropy must increase and not dissipate.

Creationists always try to use the second law,
to disprove evolution, but their theory has a flaw.
The second law is quite precise about where it applies,
only in a closed system must the entropy count rise.
The earth's not a closed system' it's powered by the sun,
so fuck the damn creationists, Doomsday get my gun!
That, in a nutshell, is what entropy's about,
you're now down with a discount.

Chorus

Trash Talk
Hit it!
Doomsday, kick it in!
 
claude_moveml said:
This is well explained by MC Hawking in his track Entropy (to the tune of Naughty By Nature's OPP):

*grins* I love MC Hawking... as well as Dr. Stephen Hawking.
 
I believe in both-

I believe in Evolution, but I also believe that God was the "Big Bang" that started it all.
 
Mz_Scarlett said:
I believe in both-

I believe in Evolution, but I also believe that God was the "Big Bang" that started it all.

Seeing how if I said there was no god, I would be stating a fact, which goes against everything I believe, I've always left the possibility open that I am wrong... the one bit I've allowed myself is that IF there is a God... It put forth the laws of the universe and said "Let there be light" or whatever, and the Big bang took off... but even that is extremely far fetched to my ever-logical mind
 
Back
Top