Do you believe in evolution?

The Heretic said:
Almost. Since I am a seeker of truth I come at everything from the rules of logic - to me, if you can't prove or disprove something, it isn't a fact, ir is an unknown or in this case, from our present point of view, unknowable. Since, to me, the basis for science is logic, I would not accept that just because something is not testable or provable one way or the other, does not make it a fact that it is false - most scientists I know would chalk it up to an unknown. Hence my example of not knowing anything before some really small point in time after the creation of the universe.
That's just one of the rules of science - if a theory is not testable and falsifiable, then the theory is meaningless. You can't make meaningful scientific claims about God, because there cannot be a God within science.

I think logic is great for science, but I think it's highly overrated in general, and quite useless when it comes to higher truths. Such things cannot even be spoken of in language: they can only be pointed towards, in an effort to get the hearer to turn their own head and see. Applying logic to religion is to reduce religion's message to language - since the language does not contain the message, the message is lost.
 
yayati said:
Bad luck for you from outside Bharat. We indians are pure Aryans. Do not waste your time it will never work.
You deny reincarnation then? That is a rather odd position for one who seems to hold the Veda's in some esteem. :D
 
70/30 said:
Hook Jazzy and Cheyenne up, give them a wheelbarrow of fertility drugs and their own McD for good measure. With the pureness of their inferior genes and their choice to persistently lead unhealthy, sedentary lifestyles- their types will adapt and finally will be able to make it past 50 before their hearts explode.

Yup, still mentioning me any chance you get- begging for some affection from me. The little boy in school who runs around the playground tying to get the little blonde haired girl's attention- that's you.

Sorry though, I'm already taken. :)

:rose:
 
crysede said:
I think you guys are arguing the same point from two different sides.

The fact that we can't know that there is no God, means that the hypothesis "God exists" is scientifically meaningless since it is not testable or falsifiable - thus for science it is a fact that there is no such thing as a God, because postulating God's existence is impossible.

Not quite. It's true that "God exists" is a scientifically meanningless hypothesis (since it can't be falsified), but it does not follow that "for science it is a fact that there is no such thing as God." On the otherhand, the statement "God does not exist" IS a valid scientific hypothesis, because it could be disproven at anytime if God wished to demonstrate to everyone that he does exist. So while it's probably true that most scientists operate under the assumption that God does not exist, that's not the same thing as saying that is is a scientific fact that God does not exist.

By the way, nice link to the "15 answers to Creationist nonsense." I do still think that the answers to 14 and 15 are a little unsatisfactory. Darwinian evolution might be the best explanation we have, but that doesn't mean that it adequately explains everything. I'm almost certain that 300 years from now, many of the things widely believed by scientists today to be true will be shown to be false (or only partly true). So I think it is good for people to keep an open and skeptical mind.
 
One of the most wonderful thing about TRUE scientists is that we are always completely open to valid questions. If someone comes up and says "I'm going to perform this experiment to prove that the theory of gravity as it currently stands is wrong in a macroscopic environment" Scientists wouldn't dismiss that out of hand. They will wait for him to be proven wrong or correct, and then that experiment would be duplicated by several independent labs and if it is shown that there is enough evidence to change the theory, then the theory would be changed. That is what science should be..
 
nawtyleanni said:
Not quite. It's true that "God exists" is a scientifically meanningless hypothesis (since it can't be falsified), but it does not follow that "for science it is a fact that there is no such thing as God." On the otherhand, the statement "God does not exist" IS a valid scientific hypothesis, because it could be disproven at anytime if God wished to demonstrate to everyone that he does exist. So while it's probably true that most scientists operate under the assumption that God does not exist, that's not the same thing as saying that is is a scientific fact that God does not exist.
I think science is actually pretty strict about the 'testability and falsifiability' requirement referring to humans ;)

God could prove God's existence, of course, but it only makes sense (scientifically) to deny the existence of something that could, at least in principle, be experimentally shown to exist (or not). However, just as there is no experiment that scientists could perform that would prove God did not exist, there is no scientific experiment that would show that God did exist either. God's existence, or lack there of, is simply outside the realm of possible scientific inquiry.

So, within science, there cannot be any God (the moment you say anything about God, you have stepped outside the bounds of science).
By the way, nice link to the "15 answers to Creationist nonsense." I do still think that the answers to 14 and 15 are a little unsatisfactory. Darwinian evolution might be the best explanation we have, but that doesn't mean that it adequately explains everything. I'm almost certain that 300 years from now, many of the things widely believed by scientists today to be true will be shown to be false (or only partly true). So I think it is good for people to keep an open and skeptical mind.
You're quite welcome :)

I'm very avid about shooting down creationist nonsense - not because I want to defend science (I don't see creationism as posing any real threat), but because I want to defend religion. Creationism, and other forms of religious scientism, strip away all deeper meaning from religion - reducing it to nothing more than another scientific theory, and a crappy one at that.

I totally agree with you about the benefit of remaining skeptical though - I'm a thoroughgoing skeptic myself: I don't think we can ever have certain knowledge of anything (I don't even think we can know for certain, that we can't know anything for certain :D)
 
Dantetier said:
One of the most wonderful thing about TRUE scientists is that we are always completely open to valid questions.

Not only scientists but ordinary folk as well like to ask and question things that have been 'undisputed' facts for many a long year...

That's part of what makes life so interesting...

:)

ppman
 
Part of the prob seems to be that people don't fully understand Evolution by Natural selection. Here's how it works.

1) Living things produce offspring that are different from themselves. Even with animals that "clone" themselves there is the occasional genetic mutation wich causes a difference.
2) Living things produce more offspring than can survive in the environment.
3) Only the best suited or stongest offspring survive
4) These go on to live and produce bringing us back to 1.

Things don't decide to evolve, the environment dictactes how the the living thing will be.

For instance here's an example that's true, current and about the Galapagos.

Most of us know about the finches that live on the islands and how they have different beak shapes. On one of the islands (forget which) the two prodaminant species were birds with smaller longer beaks (bug eaters) and birds with big robust beaks (sead eaters). The bug eaters outnumbered the sead eaters 3 to 1.

The last el nino caused a drought on the island making it difficult for the smaller beaked ones to find enough bugs to eat. As a result their numbers dropped severly since they couldn't adapt to the environmental changes. The drought was good for the seed eaters as it killed off the covering vegitation to allow them to more easily find seeds.

Result: big beaked birds now outnumber the small beaked ones 3 to 1.

The same can be said for all other creatures and plants on the planet.

There is scientific conjecture that says humans are not really evolving any more but that due to our population. Natural selection need isolated populations to work. As humans can travel to any point around the world we are no longer isolated. Our genetic make up will continue to become more homogenous as time passes.

Funny thing is, Humanity almost died out. If you look at the mitochondrial evidence you will find that the human genome has much less variation than chimps even though there are fewer chimps than humans. This suggests that millions of years ago our species went thru a genetic "pipeline" that constricted our gene pool.
 
Blindinthedark said:
Things don't decide to evolve, the environment dictactes how the the living thing will be.

This is a result of the standard Darwinian theory of evolution by natural selection. Recent experiments have shown that adaptive mutations occur more often than would be expected than if mutations were random. A book on the subject (which I have not read, but a close friend has) is Quantum Evolution by Johnjoe McFadden:

http://www.surrey.ac.uk/qe/C12.htm (more excerpts at http://www.surrey.ac.uk/qe/qecontents.html)

Environmental enhancement of mutation rates is precisely the phenomenon discovered by John Cairns when he discovered those enigmatic adaptive mutations ... Adaptive mutations occur more frequently when they are beneficial to the cell, in direct contradiction of standard Neo-Darwinian evolutionary theory which states that mutations always occur randomly with respect to the direction of evolutionary change. The initial experiments performed by John Cairns, incubated E. coli cells that were unable to grow on lactose, on media containing lactose and on parallel media without lactose. If, as claimed by standard Neo-Darwinian evolutionary theory, mutations always occur randomly in relation to the direction of evolutionary change, then the same rate of mutation would be expected to be observed in both sets of cells. However, Cairns discovered that after a prolonged period of starvation, mutations that allowed the E. coli to utilise lactose increased in frequency. It appeared that the presence of lactose specifically enhanced mutations that allowed the cells to eat the lactose. The E. coli cell appeared to be able to direct its own mutations.

... These experiments are still very controversial. Strict Neo-Darwinism is deeply ingrained in current biological thinking and most biologists are very reluctant to accept any revision of its dogmas. There is no question that the observations reported by Cairns are real; but many scientists maintain that there are likely to be more conventional explanations of Cairn’s experiments, than the existence of adaptive mutations. Nevertheless, others such as Professor Barry Hall at the University of Rochester have detected adaptive mutations in a variety of bacterial systems. In one of Hall’s most recent experiments he measured the mutation rates in non-growing E. coli cells for two different DNA bases in the same gene. When neither gene was beneficial then the mutations occurred at the same rate but when one of the genes conferred a selective advantage then its mutation rate was enhanced.

The problem with adaptive mutations is to provide a mechanism that could account for them. The interaction between the cell and its environment is conducted at the level of proteins, like beta galactosidase. The conventional information flow inside living cells is from DNA to RNA to protein. There is no conventional path by which information in the cell’s environment (the presence of lactose) can feedback to the DNA that encodes enzymes like beta galactosidase. The path: gene -> messenger RNA -> protein -> lactose is not reversible. Professor Hall commented in a recent paper that, … the selective generation of mutations by unknown means is a class of models that cannot, and should not, be rejected.

Quantum evolution may generate adaptive mutations by providing the required feedback loop: lactose -> protein -> messenger RNA -> gene, via conditional quantum measurement. The ability of the living cell to measure the positions of fundamental particles within the DNA double helix will be determined by the composition of its environment, in this case, the presence of lactose. Lactose arms the quantum measuring devices of the cell, enabling it to measure the position of the DNA protons that (potentially) encode the beta galactosidase enzyme. The cell may then perform a dense series of measurements on the position of DNA bases that will perturb the dynamics of those protons and hence enhance mutation rates. Quantum measurement may thereby enhance the rate of beneficial mutations to cause adaptive mutations and drive evolution.

The difference between this and conventional Darwinian evolutionary theory is that the environment can effect the direction mutations take in evolution, not only selecting for beneficial mutations after they occured randomly. I don't think it shows that organisms decide how to evolve, I'm more inclined to think that it's lucky chance that the environment feeds back to mutation in the case described (lactose).
 
claude_moveml said:
I don't think it shows that organisms decide how to evolve, I'm more inclined to think that it's lucky chance that the environment feeds back to mutation in the case described (lactose).
They may not "decide", but it may be built into the system more than you think; have you ever read "General Systems Theory" by Bertalanffy? Choas Theory is just a subset of GST.
 
The Heretic said:
They may not "decide", but it may be built into the system more than you think; have you ever read "General Systems Theory" by Bertalanffy? Choas Theory is just a subset of GST.

Interesting book from what I can find out on the internet (it seems a vast field). I'll add it to the list of books I intend to read.

The ability to adapt more rapidly is an adaptation that could be selected for by the environment, as the environment selects the organisms that have adapted to the environment, and the ones that have adapted to the environment are more likely to be amongst those with the adapted ability to adapt to the environment. It is all so clear now. :)
 
claude_moveml said:
(it seems a vast field).
Yes it is - I call it "The Big Picture". Bertalanffy was (is?) a biologist by the way - if I remember correctly. The way he developed the theory was basically that he observed that in biological systems the whole was greater than the sum of the parts. He then extended that to other systems, and eventually found that almost anything, from weather, to the way people vote, to the way biological organisms work, are all systems - hence General Systems Theory.
 
Back
Top