Finding your inner conservative.

'I am a conservative in everything except politics', my father used to say, and the same is true of me. I think my dangerous proclivities are well known hereabouts - tea, furniture, architecture, books, music, good manners, etc. But what of yours? Whether liberal or conservative, anarchist or fascist, in your political views, what about in life generally?

Share, if you would be so good, those things you still prefer the old-fashioned way. You too, Candi! There must be something...
real sex, where your partner's mind and body's the best playground with no need of ropes, pulleys, or electronic noisy bastard gadgets.

books. ones you can hold, feel, smell....

fountain pen as a preference

burning stuff! bonfires, log fires, coal fires - but wood best of all, for its smell and how the live-light runs and ripples along a dead branch, flowering and sparking. *sigh*

walking, looking at the view not a phone screen.

cooking on a flame rather than electric or microwave - but they're what i use :(

making toast using a toasting fork over an open fire


don't get to do most of this stuff very often, but i know what i like.
 
vinyls over cds or even downloads (don't have the money though and haven't purchased music in ages)

and books over ebooks
 
I am delighted to see that this thread has engendered a great deal of lively debate. Among this, there appears to some discussion about the thread title, and I thought I might bumble in at this point and give my own point of view.

In England, certainly, and I thought elsewhere, conservatism means a whole attitude to life, philosophy, etc, of which politics is but one, fairly minor and relatively recent strand. The cultural war in England, insofar as we have one, is not a division between liberals and conservatives (both dubious definitions of their respective movements in the US anyway) but the more traditional division of right and left.

Many conservative organisations in the UK - the Ramblers' Association, the National Trust, the Arts and Crafts movement - were set up by avowed socialists. They wanted the beautiful countryside to be open to all, not grubbed up and sold off to developers; they wanted country mansions to be available for the public to see, not reserved for the aristocratic wealthy; they wanted fine furniture and skilled artisans to be appreciated by all, and for the small craftsman to be given a chance over and above the factory owning industrialist. Their aims, therefore, were both clearly conservative - to preserve the best of the past rather than plunge headlong into a money-counting, capitalist future - and equally clearly left-wing in origin and impetus.

One could even create a logically consistent opposition between conservatism - that is, a desire to keep the best of the past, and only change things when the change is overwhelmingly and clearly for the common good - and the current British Conservative party ever since Thatcher, which might now more properly be described as radical. We have had an NHS for over 60 years: it is conservative to wish to keep it, but Conservative/radical to destroy it. Conservatives like rambling old buildings in central London, inefficient and charming reminders of a noble past - political Conservatives (radicals) want to rip them up and replace them with gigantic skyscrapers funded by Quatar, or Saudi Arabia, or China. Harold Macmillan, an old-fashioned Conservative of the old school, once criticised Thatcher for, as he put it in his typically patrician fashion, 'selling off the family silver' (ie privatisation) - something no true conservative would ever do.

So from an English perspective, conservatism, meaning the preservation of the best of the past, has a history not only longer, nobler and separate from political conservatism but, in many ways, directly opposed to it. I would argue that the same is true of America - the Tea Party, for example, want such radical change that they can hardly be conservative in the proper sense. But I accept that the term, as used in the US is now almost exclusively associated with the political right. That, however, is absolutely not how I meant it.

And I do mean conservative. 'Old-fashioned', which has been suggested as a synonym, is not only faintly pejorative, but also to me implies a moderately eccentric, wholly personal lifestyle choice. A man who collects snuff-boxes might be seen as old-fashioned. What I mean by conservatism is closer to a philosophical credo, and certainly far more than a mere personal preference. It amounts to a belief that, in some important areas of life, we have gone backwards - that the old ways were better - and that society as a whole would be better off if we returned to the previous style or method. I genuinely and whole-heartedly believe that the world would be a better place if we listened to more Tallis and less 50 Cent - if we drank more whole leaf tea in silver tea pots, and less coffee in polystyrene cups from tax-avoiding global corporations - and if we sent fewer texts and wrote more letters.

That's what I meant, anyway. I'm fully aware of the authorial fallacy, and I know that any thread, once started, has a life of its own. So this is just one post among the rest, and no more privileged than any other. In case you were interested, though, there's my argument for why I will continue to use the word conservatism to describe many of my views outside the political sphere.

I apologise for the interruption. Do carry on...:)
 
real sex, where your partner's mind and body's the best playground with no need of ropes, pulleys, or electronic noisy bastard gadgets.

books. ones you can hold, feel, smell....

fountain pen as a preference

burning stuff! bonfires, log fires, coal fires - but wood best of all, for its smell and how the live-light runs and ripples along a dead branch, flowering and sparking. *sigh*

walking, looking at the view not a phone screen.

cooking on a flame rather than electric or microwave - but they're what i use :(

making toast using a toasting fork over an open fire


don't get to do most of this stuff very often, but i know what i like.

I agree on five of the seven.
 
'I am a conservative in everything except politics', my father used to say, and the same is true of me. I think my dangerous proclivities are well known hereabouts - tea, furniture, architecture, books, music, good manners, etc. But what of yours? Whether liberal or conservative, anarchist or fascist, in your political views, what about in life generally?

Share, if you would be so good, those things you still prefer the old-fashioned way. You too, Candi! There must be something...

How is any of that conservative?

Of course I have beliefs that run the political spectrum. I've mentioned before that I dislike the bichromatic rainbow that is American politics. I don't understand why you mentioned me, the hunting, fishing, gun-toting, hillbilly who spends posts calling people out over overregulation in the farming and firearm communities as if I'm some sort of massive liberal.

/Tea/ isn't conservative. Tea's a drink imported from (mostly) Asian countries like India where farming practices are outsourced to children being paid slave wages. It's as American as sushi. None of the shit that you mentioned is conservative. You seem to be mistaking the words "conservative" and "traditional". Conservatives believe that tea should be produced in America by the American free market. Those should be American children out there picking herbs with no breaks in the hot sun, for hours on end. And, apparently, it's American market regulation, not common decency that prevents such a thing. There' a difference between being political and being stupid.

If I was going to drink tea- not that I like hot leaf water- I would drink fair trade. Or the mint that we can grow here that my gf drinks. That weird ass Dandilion tea that is gross as fuck. She says it's good if you put honey in it but she's full of shit. It's gross.

Nobody is either liberal or conservative, because the world isn't set up like that. Both categories are too constricting. Like every label ever.
 
If what you mean is Old-fashioned, how far am I allowed to go back? I prefer a matrilinial, more egalitarian society to patriarchal bullshit that we've had post-colonialism. Socially. But that's not that we need to go backwards, that's just that we need to merge cultures better than everyone trying to assimilate into a Eurocentric worldview as if Europe is so fucking great. They literally lost half their population because they were covered in diseased fleas. Some fucking master race. Take a goddamn shower. You can make flea-killing soap out of fireplace ashes and animal fat.
 
I'm trying to think of anything old I like, like before my lifetime, and I'm having a hard time. Maybe reefer maddness era non-regulations of drugs? Like before there was a drug czar? That seems like it was less annoying. Handing out cocaine in the soda with your cheeseburgers. But I want that without the rampant racism, sexism, and homophobia. Without the intense class system that made Appalachia a coal-infused wasteland so that people in the rich parts of the states could have their coked-up cheeseburgers. They got suburban box-row houses and we got little kids with black lungs. My great-grandpa (gramp's dad) worked in the mines when he was /twelve years old/. That would have been in the 50s, which I think is when Reefeer Madness was set. This looks mid-century. Yeah, my generation could break into song too if we were coked-up all the damn time. Put it in toothpaste and shit.
 
Oh, Candi. I'm disappointed but sort of not surprised. Maybe I shouldn't have bothered writing my long, boring explanation earlier. This thread is explicitly not about politics.

And the best tea is not picked by child labour. Some of the best is picked by monkeys.
 
"I'm trying to think of anything old I like, like before my lifetime, and I'm having a hard time."

Candi, you really need to think harder.
 
"I'm trying to think of anything old I like, like before my lifetime, and I'm having a hard time."

Candi, you really need to think harder.

Candi hates the past. I think it defines us.

'Society is a contract between the living, the dead, and the yet to be born.'
 
Well, having quoted that old conservative Burke in my last post, I'll turn to the radical of all radicals Karl Marx* in this one:

'History repeats itself: first as tragedy, second as farce.' I think we know which we are living through now.

*Though I expect Candi would consider him a hidebound reactionary, and probably racist and sexist to boot...:)
 
Stop trying to use your fancy british verbiage to trick us simple Americans into believing that conservative doesn't always mean asshole republican. We won't stand for it!!
 
Oh, Candi. I'm disappointed but sort of not surprised. Maybe I shouldn't have bothered writing my long, boring explanation earlier. This thread is explicitly not about politics.

And the best tea is not picked by child labour. Some of the best is picked by monkeys.

I read it. I disagreed. I think that the idea that conservatives are more "old fashioned" than liberals is ridiculous.

And no one else has mentioned anything good about the past either. The shit that people have mentioned liking isn't specific to any time period. Like I said, tea is not limited to any time period. Books aren't limited to any time period, unless you specifically want books rather than scrolls. Somebody here actually thought that bondage was a recent invention? Like they've never heard of the Marque DeSade?
 
Well, having quoted that old conservative Burke in my last post, I'll turn to the radical of all radicals Karl Marx* in this one:

'History repeats itself: first as tragedy, second as farce.' I think we know which we are living through now.

*Though I expect Candi would consider him a hidebound reactionary, and probably racist and sexist to boot...:)

Candi owes far more to the past than he realizes. Far more than he owes to the present, certainly, and far more than he will owe to the future, almost certainly.
 
Candi hates the past. I think it defines us.

'Society is a contract between the living, the dead, and the yet to be born.'

There's a difference between not idolizing something and hating it. You can view something realistically and not hate or love it. It's possible to just take things as they are. The fact of the matter is, I prefer living in a time with internet, vaccinations, a scientific understand of the human genome, water purifiers, air conditioning, sterilization techniques, etc. I honor the sacrifices of the people who came before me, who made it possible for me to have these things, rather than pretending that they somehow hurt me. My grandparents killed themselves in the mines so I wouldn't have to. Holding onto the past, getting black lung myself is an insult to them. We move forward so that the world is a better place for our children. I want Bitesize to have a world that's even /better/ than mine. Why the hell would I ever want her to go backwards? To a world where she could be paid less because of her skin color or her genitals? To a world where she could easily die of preventable disease? What kind of fucked up person would want that for their kids? We go forward for a reason.
 
I read it. I disagreed. I think that the idea that conservatives are more "old fashioned" than liberals is ridiculous.

And no one else has mentioned anything good about the past either. The shit that people have mentioned liking isn't specific to any time period. Like I said, tea is not limited to any time period. Books aren't limited to any time period, unless you specifically want books rather than scrolls. Somebody here actually thought that bondage was a recent invention? Like they've never heard of the Marque DeSade?

If anything, I argued the exact opposite of that. Political conservatives are almost always radical, not truly conservative. It is they who want profound change, and the left who are fighting a desperate rearguard action to preserve the more generous societal settlement of the past.

I think you misunderstand me wilfully. In the past, tea was served from teapots and tasted better, and Starbucks did not exist. Those are good things. The existence of Starbucks, and the diminishment of properly-served tea, are not progress, but dilute the richness of societal intercourse. Likewise repetitive music. Plastic is not as good in most consumer goods as wood, leather and metal. Etc, etc. There are things which were prevalent in the past, and rare now, which were positive things. I am a conservative in that I would like to return to those aspects of the past, without dragging the old racism and sexism back with them.
 
Back
Top