Finding your inner conservative.

Candi owes far more to the past than he realizes. Far more than he owes to the present, certainly, and far more than he will owe to the future, almost certainly.

Of course I do. That doesn't need to be stated. If not for the efforts of the people in the past, I would still be legally considered an animal. L. Frank Baulm thought that we should be hunted for sport. We have to honor the sacrifices of the past in order to move forward. The past also owes me. We are accountable to our children. Species preservation over self preservation. We study the past because it was fucked up. Full of ignorance and wars that seemed very important at the time. Full of people who fought and died to make the world that we should appreciate. We shouldn't ignore their sacrifice and pretend that they didn't actually make any progress. I didn't grow up in an Americanization camp the way my grandma did, my gf didn't grow up in slavery, my bf didn't grow up an indentured servant. Because our ancestors fought their way out of those situations. So now we have more opportunities. Is it perfect? Of course not. But do we take what we have for granted? Of course not. We appreciate their sacrifices by acknowledging the horrors that they went through.
 
There's a difference between not idolizing something and hating it. You can view something realistically and not hate or love it. It's possible to just take things as they are. The fact of the matter is, I prefer living in a time with internet, vaccinations, a scientific understand of the human genome, water purifiers, air conditioning, sterilization techniques, etc. I honor the sacrifices of the people who came before me, who made it possible for me to have these things, rather than pretending that they somehow hurt me. My grandparents killed themselves in the mines so I wouldn't have to. Holding onto the past, getting black lung myself is an insult to them. We move forward so that the world is a better place for our children. I want Bitesize to have a world that's even /better/ than mine. Why the hell would I ever want her to go backwards? To a world where she could be paid less because of her skin color or her genitals? To a world where she could easily die of preventable disease? What kind of fucked up person would want that for their kids? We go forward for a reason.

The point is not to return to the past wholesale. The point is that if we are remotely intellectually honest, we can recognize that some aspects of the past were better. Healthcare, treatment of women and minorities, and a host of other things, are certainly better now, and I would not like to return to a previous age with regard to them. But workers' rights? Shared prosperity? Those are two things which have worsened in the past thirty years, and I would like to go back to pre-Thatcher/Reagan on those particular issues. You appear to be saying, in a manner which is far less subtle than your usual arguments, that everything about the present is better than everything about the past. Is that - can that - really be true?
 
Of course I do. That doesn't need to be stated. If not for the efforts of the people in the past, I would still be legally considered an animal. L. Frank Baulm thought that we should be hunted for sport. We have to honor the sacrifices of the past in order to move forward. The past also owes me. We are accountable to our children. Species preservation over self preservation. We study the past because it was fucked up. Full of ignorance and wars that seemed very important at the time. Full of people who fought and died to make the world that we should appreciate. We shouldn't ignore their sacrifice and pretend that they didn't actually make any progress. I didn't grow up in an Americanization camp the way my grandma did, my gf didn't grow up in slavery, my bf didn't grow up an indentured servant. Because our ancestors fought their way out of those situations. So now we have more opportunities. Is it perfect? Of course not. But do we take what we have for granted? Of course not. We appreciate their sacrifices by acknowledging the horrors that they went through.

You owe almost everything you have or ever will have to those who came before you. I'm glad to see you have at least some appreciation for that fact.
 
If anything, I argued the exact opposite of that. Political conservatives are almost always radical, not truly conservative. It is they who want profound change, and the left who are fighting a desperate rearguard action to preserve the more generous societal settlement of the past.

I think you misunderstand me wilfully. In the past, tea was served from teapots and tasted better, and Starbucks did not exist. Those are good things. The existence of Starbucks, and the diminishment of properly-served tea, are not progress, but dilute the richness of societal intercourse. Likewise repetitive music. Plastic is not as good in most consumer goods as wood, leather and metal. Etc, etc. There are things which were prevalent in the past, and rare now, which were positive things. I am a conservative in that I would like to return to those aspects of the past, without dragging the old racism and sexism back with them.

What are you talking about? Those things still exist. Starbucks serves tea out of metal teapots. And Starbucks isn't a recent company. They opened in the 70s and actually have fewer locations now than they did in the 90s. I'm sorry that you don't like plastic, the material that is healthiest for things like medical tubing, but right now my father is getting a stint in his heart that wouldn't be possible without the material. That's a bad example because he's a fucking asshole, but how many little kids would your anti-plastic mentality kill? Wood, leather, and metal aren't fucking rare. You can still get them. But now you have a choice. There's nothing stopping you from wearing an entire outfit of leather, especially right now that it's winter. There's nothing stopping you from brewing a pot of tea in a teapot. We have a fucking teapot and we're rednecks. If you want that, it's not limited to some time period. Just do it.
 
The point is not to return to the past wholesale. The point is that if we are remotely intellectually honest, we can recognize that some aspects of the past were better. Healthcare, treatment of women and minorities, and a host of other things, are certainly better now, and I would not like to return to a previous age with regard to them. But workers' rights? Shared prosperity? Those are two things which have worsened in the past thirty years, and I would like to go back to pre-Thatcher/Reagan on those particular issues. You appear to be saying, in a manner which is far less subtle than your usual arguments, that everything about the present is better than everything about the past. Is that - can that - really be true?

You genuinely believe that my great grandma living in an Americanization camp that was so fucked up that Hitler based his concentration camps on it had a better shared prosperity than I do? You believe my great grandpa who died from black lung because he was forced into the coal mines, underground, when he was a preteen, had better workers rights than I do? You're going to sit there, with a strait face, and tell me that?
 
Also, I'm extremely insulted that you would ever call me subtle. I pride myself on the fact that I call life as I see it. I am NEVER subtle. I don't fuck around.
 
You genuinely believe that my great grandma living in an Americanization camp that was so fucked up that Hitler based his concentration camps on it had a better shared prosperity than I do? You believe my great grandpa who died from black lung because he was forced into the coal mines, underground, when he was a preteen, had better workers rights than I do? You're going to sit there, with a strait face, and tell me that?

Why did you quote me, Candi, if you completely ignore what I actually say?

I know nothing of your family. I'm sorry they had a wretched time and were treated abysmally back whenever. My point was that in the late 70s, in the US and the UK, workers were paid better and had more rights, and wages were a higher proportion of national wealth compared with unearned income, and that those are things a progressive ought to desire, even though they are in the past. My point is that some, not all things in the past were better than some, not all things in the present. Is that such a difficult point to grasp?

And it's 'straight'. My face, though I may wish it otherwise, is hardly strait. :)
 
How dare you hate plastic!

I actually have a pretty big stake in this. Plastic really does make it possible. As a child I would have died had I not had plastic. The invention of plastic is one of the best things that has ever happened to the medical industry. It's affordable, it's mailable, it's easy to sterilize- it tops rubber in every way. Rubber dries out. Rubber cracks. Rubber fucking kills people. If not for plastics, we would have so many medical deaths, remember how high those used to be?

Maybe talk to somebody about your plastic hate who isn't caring for two relatives who are in and out of the hospital.
 
Last edited:
I actually have a pretty big stake in this. Plastic really does make it possible. As a child I would have died had I not had plastic. The invention of plastic is one of the best things that has ever happened to the medical industry. It's affordable, it's mailable, it's easy to sterilize- it tops rubber in every way. Rubber dries out. Rubber cracks. Rubber fucking kills people. If not for plastics, we would have so many medical deaths, remember how high those used to be?

Maybe talk to somebody about your rubber hate who isn't caring for two relatives who are in and out of the hospital.

For goodness' sake, no-one mentioned rubber. :rolleyes:
 
Why did you quote me, Candi, if you completely ignore what I actually say?

I know nothing of your family. I'm sorry they had a wretched time and were treated abysmally back whenever. My point was that in the late 70s, in the US and the UK, workers were paid better and had more rights, and wages were a higher proportion of national wealth compared with unearned income, and that those are things a progressive ought to desire, even though they are in the past. My point is that some, not all things in the past were better than some, not all things in the present. Is that such a difficult point to grasp?

And it's 'straight'. My face, though I may wish it otherwise, is hardly strait. :)

And I call bullshit. That might have been true if you were a white, middle-class or above male, since the difference between CEOs and their employees wasn't what it was today. But if you were under the middle class, any gender but cismale or any race except white- and I mean /white/ white, not Celtic or Italian or anything outside that narrowly defined racial checkbox that they had back in the day, you were fucked.
 
Share, if you would be so good, those things you still prefer the old-fashioned way.

I like homebirthing, and nursing my babies, and keeping them close to me during the night.

I like simmering orange peels on the stove to make the house smell nice.

I like making sun tea in a jar on the porch, and letting my children mix things by hand.

I like clotheslines, and cloth diapers, and skirts and dresses and aprons.

I like using what we have, and buying secondhand.

I like church, and church music, and church activities, and church people.

I like homeschooling, and networking, and apprenticing.

I like holding a new-to-me book in my hand, and running my fingers over the binding and the endpapers, and smelling the pages.

I like meeting new people, and taking the time to listen to them, and learn something from them.

I like letting our hair dry naturally, and not curling it or straightening it.

I like fucking someone because I care about them, and not just because they turn me on. And I like loving one man for a long, long time.

I like writing letters, and lining dresser drawers with old wrapping paper, and collecting things in canning jars.

I like learning by listening, and watching, and doing, and I appreciate people who take the time to teach me something new.

I like scrapbooks, and pinking shears, and taking my daughters to the fabric store to shop for ribbons for their hair.

I like making music for it's own sake, and for the joy it brings others.

I like fabric hankies, and the modesty of a dressing gown, and flowers from my garden, picked by a child's hands.





but i'm sorry, I don't like pencils or chalk. they give me the heebie-jeebies.
 
I like homebirthing, and nursing my babies, and keeping them close to me during the night.

I like simmering orange peels on the stove to make the house smell nice.

I like making sun tea in a jar on the porch, and letting my children mix things by hand.

I like clotheslines, and cloth diapers, and skirts and dresses and aprons.

I like using what we have, and buying secondhand.

I like church, and church music, and church activities, and church people.

I like homeschooling, and networking, and apprenticing.

I like holding a new-to-me book in my hand, and running my fingers over the binding and the endpapers, and smelling the pages.

I like meeting new people, and taking the time to listen to them, and learn something from them.

I like letting our hair dry naturally, and not curling it or straightening it.

I like fucking someone because I care about them, and not just because they turn me on. And I like loving one man for a long, long time.

I like writing letters, and lining dresser drawers with old wrapping paper, and collecting things in canning jars.

I like learning by listening, and watching, and doing, and I appreciate people who take the time to teach me something new.

I like scrapbooks, and pinking shears, and taking my daughters to the fabric store to shop for ribbons for their hair.

I like making music for it's own sake, and for the joy it brings others.

I like fabric hankies, and the modesty of a dressing gown, and flowers from my garden, picked by a child's hands.





but i'm sorry, I don't like pencils or chalk. they give me the heebie-jeebies.

See? This is what I mean. There's nothing on that list that isn't completely doable right now.
 
Candi is like eyer, except younger with more slang. Just hateful and bitter and always freaking right about every thing. Even when you try to be nice and include him in a conversation, he shoves that shit right back in your face, arguing against literally no one because nobody made the points or supports the claims he's fighting so antagonistically about.


This topic makes me sad now. Des, why does this always fucking happen? :(
 
I actually have a pretty big stake in this. Plastic really does make it possible. As a child I would have died had I not had plastic. The invention of plastic is one of the best things that has ever happened to the medical industry. It's affordable, it's mailable, it's easy to sterilize- it tops rubber in every way. Rubber dries out. Rubber cracks. Rubber fucking kills people. If not for plastics, we would have so many medical deaths, remember how high those used to be?

Maybe talk to somebody about your rubber hate who isn't caring for two relatives who are in and out of the hospital.

I'm a bi-synthetic-material-phile. I like rubber AND plastic. Like a whore.

But really, you are being obtuse about the point of this thread. Which is fine. I appreciate the fire and passion about polymers. It's more interesting than people saying "I like good quality leather shoes. " Because who gives a fuck?
 
I used to do cash always up until around three years ago. I was at the grocery store getting checked out and the amount came out to be more than what I was pocketing, so I just swiped my card and that was that. Afterwards, I thought to myself, "why am I not just using the card I'm filling up anyway?" Became unconscious habit. Now doing it for everything swipeable. I haven't been in a movie ticket line to pay at the window when going to the theatre in ages, either. Just press that lil' computer in the lobby...*boop boop boop boop swipe beeeep~* ;)

If and when I upgrade my 5 to a 6 or higher, I'll prolly do Apple Pay and just hover my phone over shit or however it is you execute it. :D

I still like having cash to hold though, always will. My hangout bars are mostly cash only, so I'm always saving my paper money for them. I think nabe dive bars should remain traditional cash only, it makes the social of drinking feel real and kinda sorta susses out the platinum AmEx douchebags coming in and trying to use a card to pay for a $5 tab. Which happens a lot more than you think.

The convenience of credit strikes me as very circumstantial and is one it pays to be realistic about.

I used to pay cash for gasoline fer chrissakes. Finally one day I asked myself, "why am I standing in line behind four clowns getting a cup of coffee, a honey bun and a carton of Marlboros"? Paid credit at the pump ever since.
 
I like homebirthing, and nursing my babies, and keeping them close to me during the night.

I like simmering orange peels on the stove to make the house smell nice.

I like making sun tea in a jar on the porch, and letting my children mix things by hand.

I like clotheslines, and cloth diapers, and skirts and dresses and aprons.

I like using what we have, and buying secondhand.

I like church, and church music, and church activities, and church people.

I like homeschooling, and networking, and apprenticing.

I like holding a new-to-me book in my hand, and running my fingers over the binding and the endpapers, and smelling the pages.

I like meeting new people, and taking the time to listen to them, and learn something from them.

I like letting our hair dry naturally, and not curling it or straightening it.

I like fucking someone because I care about them, and not just because they turn me on. And I like loving one man for a long, long time.

I like writing letters, and lining dresser drawers with old wrapping paper, and collecting things in canning jars.

I like learning by listening, and watching, and doing, and I appreciate people who take the time to teach me something new.

I like scrapbooks, and pinking shears, and taking my daughters to the fabric store to shop for ribbons for their hair.

I like making music for it's own sake, and for the joy it brings others.

I like fabric hankies, and the modesty of a dressing gown, and flowers from my garden, picked by a child's hands.

Wow. That's all I can think of at the moment.
 
I'm a bi-synthetic-material-phile. I like rubber AND plastic. Like a whore.

But really, you are being obtuse about the point of this thread. Which is fine. I appreciate the fire and passion about polymers. It's more interesting than people saying "I like good quality leather shoes. " Because who gives a fuck?

YOU CAN GET LEATHER SHOES RIGHT NOW!

I own leather shoes. Nothing happened to them! Leatherwork did not die out. We factory farm now. We have more leather than any of our ancestors!
 
YOU CAN GET LEATHER SHOES RIGHT NOW!

I own leather shoes. Nothing happened to them! Leatherwork did not die out. We factory farm now. We have more leather than any of our ancestors!

You've convinced me. Im glad everything in the past is dead. Everything sucked.
 
What am I being obtuse about, exactly? Because everyone is acting as if I'm not responding correctly, so I will accept that I am genuinely confused. But not on purpose. I honestly have no idea what I'm doing wrong.
 
You've convinced me. Im glad everything in the past is dead. Everything sucked.

Thank you.

But it's not enough just to be glad that we don't live in that world. We have to be thankful that people went through hell to change it so we don't have to. We have to be appreciative. We have to spend every single day striving to do the same so our children can look at the world around them and realize how much better they have it than us. We can't just be thankful and get complacent, we have to keep striving forward.
 
And I call bullshit. That might have been true if you were a white, middle-class or above male, since the difference between CEOs and their employees wasn't what it was today. But if you were under the middle class, any gender but cismale or any race except white- and I mean /white/ white, not Celtic or Italian or anything outside that narrowly defined racial checkbox that they had back in the day, you were fucked.

No. That simply isn't true. The working class in both our countries was far better off in every post-war decade than it was after Reagan. Forget the middle classes. They are the ones who have done better in the last thirty years. But since you think the past has nothing to teach us, you cannot complain about that. You cannot learn from history, and so you are doomed to repeat it.

It is sad, and shallow. Human history is not linear. Do you think the Dark Ages were progress compared with the Roman Empire?

On the plastic thing, though it is wearying to repeat it, I said that most consumer goods are not improved by plastic. Most.

Ah, what's the point?
 
Back
Top