Government Strike Breaking

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

SaintPeter said:
Now you lost me Freya. You complain that your 12 bucks does not go far and yet do not want to make the move to better your position. Seems like the person who never votes bitching about the politicians.

You can join a union. Go down to the hall and ask. It may require years of apprenticeship to make the top dollar. It may require journeyman upgrades to get the best jobs. The investment is well worth it.

You know - in some of those cases, they actually earn their money. I was referring more to the transit workers, auto workers etc who don't.

But you're suggesting that every $12/hr worker quit their jobs, redirect their entire career and train for upwards of 5 years at something new so that they don't have to bitch about their wages anymore? So we can have an over saturation of skilled trades workers, when the job market wouldn't support that many anyways, and so they'd be laid off half the tme and collect unemployment. That makes sense.

It's maybe not a matter of them being underpaid so much as it is a matter of some others being overpaid.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
You know - in some of those cases, they actually earn their money. I was referring more to the transit workers, auto workers etc who don't.

But you're suggesting that every $12/hr worker quit their jobs, redirect their entire career and train for upwards of 5 years at something new so that they don't have to bitch about their wages anymore? So we can have an over saturation of skilled trades workers, when the job market wouldn't support that many anyways, and so they'd be laid off half the tme and collect unemployment. That makes sense.

It's maybe not a matter of them being underpaid so much as it is a matter of some others being overpaid.

So why bitch? Because someone is better off than you? My neighbour makes about ten times as much as I do and works much less(In terms of hours) and I don't care. That's his life and his business and who cares?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Weevil said:
So why bitch? Because someone is better off than you? My neighbour makes about ten times as much as I do and works much less(In terms of hours) and I don't care. That's his life and his business and who cares?

I'm not bitching. Redwave suggested that everyone should get up in arms over a bunch of overpaid transit workers and I explained why lots won't. I don't figure that a person needs to join a union, and count on them to do for them what intelligence and work ethic does for other people.
 
Re: Re: Government Strike Breaking

Freya2 said:
I'm sure the working people will be able to support them just fine when they can't get to work either. And if they are anything like the transit workers here, they won't get much sympathy for their plight. When you get $25/hr for driving a fucking bus, it's hard for those making $12, and actually working hard for it, to work up any tears for you.

Yeah I can see where I was off with the "bitching" comment.

Have you ever driven a bus?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
I'm not bitching. Redwave suggested that everyone should get up in arms over a bunch of overpaid transit workers and I explained why lots won't. I don't figure that a person needs to join a union, and count on them to do for them what intelligence and work ethic does for other people.

But your intelligence and work ethic only gets you 12 bucks. Think how far that same intelligence and work ethic would get you in a union job with good benefits and a retirement.
 
Re: What about the bosses?

REDWAVE said:
I don't see you complaining about the bosses, like billionaire Michael Bloomberg, who basicly bought the Mayor's office, and the far greater amount of money they make.
It's not about the money. Supply and demand. Only a few people have the business acumen and education to be CEO's. Just about anybody can drive a bus.

It's the mindset that pisses me off. The transit workers, for the most part, make plenty. They could be happy with that, but instead they've threatened to shut a whole city down until they get even more. Sounds pretty selfish to me.

Hey, what about the cabbies? Those hacks face at least as much danger as the other guys. But they don't bitch because their pay, for the most part, is dependent on their own individual merits rather than the fact that they have a big union with automatic clout because they can control the mobility of 8 million people.

You want to bitch about corporate monopolies? The union has its own monopoly. You want a public transportation system? Then you play by our rules. If we want more, fuck you, you'd better pay up. Why, in your world, are they always right and management always wrong? Don't you have a point when you can say, "You know what? You guys really don't need this" and concentrate on a workers' group that really is getting shafted?

TB4p
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

SaintPeter said:
But your intelligence and work ethic only gets you 12 bucks. Think how far that same intelligence and work ethic would get you in a union job with good benefits and a retirement.

I think I'll answer you - I've been trolled once by Weevil and am not interested in it again tonight.

Pay rates, for the most part, depend on qualifications. One of the few places that isn't correct is unions. The uneducated, the incompetent, the lazy can benefit from a union. Put a worker of that calibre in the regular job market and they won't get anywhere. Right now, I'm trained to work in an office, and would most likely make about $12-15/hr. I hope to go back to school, and if so, and I succeed, I'll make a hell of a lot more than that. And it'll be on my own merits - not through a union.
 
Re: Re: What about the bosses?

teddybear4play said:
It's not about the money. Supply and demand. Only a few people have the business acumen and education to be CEO's. Just about anybody can drive a bus.

It's the mindset that pisses me off. The transit workers, for the most part, make plenty. They could be happy with that, but instead they've threatened to shut a whole city down until they get even more. Sounds pretty selfish to me.

I mean, CEO's make plenty. But to make more they shut down plants leaving thousands unemployed. They move their companies offshore to pay lower taxes. They lobby the government to change laws for their benefit.

Seems a little selfish to me.

I thought Right-Wingers were all about "Greed is good" or does that only apply to those born into a Country Club.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
I think I'll answer you - I've been trolled once by Weevil and am not interested in it again tonight.

Pay rates, for the most part, depend on qualifications. One of the few places that isn't correct is unions. The uneducated, the incompetent, the lazy can benefit from a union. Put a worker of that calibre in the regular job market and they won't get anywhere. Right now, I'm trained to work in an office, and would most likely make about $12-15/hr. I hope to go back to school, and if so, and I succeed, I'll make a hell of a lot more than that. And it'll be on my own merits - not through a union.

Alright, Freya I'm sorry about the ruse I subjected you to. An unconditional and complete apology.

Now, have you ever driven a bus?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Weevil said:
Alright, Freya I'm sorry about the ruse I subjected you to. An unconditional and complete apology.

Now, have you ever driven a bus?

No.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:

So you don't really know how much work it is, do you?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Weevil said:
So you don't really know how much work it is, do you?

One of my friend's husband drives a bus, and he even laughs at how much they get paid for it. So I assume that if he considers himself to be living the high life for an easy job, it can't be too difficult.

I grant that it can be stressful, and I'd assume that would worsen depending on where they work, but like I said, I'm relating this to my direct experience and knowledge - and $25/hr for a relatively small city like mine is overpaid no matter how you look at it.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
I think I'll answer you - I've been trolled once by Weevil and am not interested in it again tonight.

Pay rates, for the most part, depend on qualifications. One of the few places that isn't correct is unions. The uneducated, the incompetent, the lazy can benefit from a union. Put a worker of that calibre in the regular job market and they won't get anywhere. Right now, I'm trained to work in an office, and would most likely make about $12-15/hr. I hope to go back to school, and if so, and I succeed, I'll make a hell of a lot more than that. And it'll be on my own merits - not through a union.

That is a popular misconception but completely untrue. The apprenticeship you are not willing to go through trains skilled craft. Would the rats like us to go to work for them? Hell yes. We are approached often for foreman and prodject manager spots. Do we accept? Fuck no. Why would I trade good money and secure work outlook for that?

Your 12-15 bucks would go way up if you worked union. They would provide school instead of you paying for it if the job you wish to train for falls under the union's jurisdiction.

http://www.opeiu.org/
 
Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

Weevil said:
I mean, CEO's make plenty. But to make more they shut down plants leaving thousands unemployed. They move their companies offshore to pay lower taxes. They lobby the government to change laws for their benefit.

Seems a little selfish to me.

I thought Right-Wingers were all about "Greed is good" or does that only apply to those born into a Country Club.
Right-wingers are not about "Greed Is Good." That was from a Charlie Sheen/Michael Douglas movie.

I'm not going to say that everything corporations do is sweet and wonderful. Business is sometimes cutthroat. But I think CEO's should have the same kind of merit-based contracts as any other worker. None of this guaranteed crap where they make out like bandits and leave their employees holding the bag.

And should you be bitching about the companies moving overseas, or the tax situation that forced them to that point?

TB4p
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

SaintPeter said:
That is a popular misconception but completely untrue. The apprenticeship you are not willing to go through trains skilled craft. Would the rats like us to go to work for them? Hell yes. We are approached often for foreman and prodject manager spots. Do we accept? Fuck no. Why would I trade good money and secure work outlook for that?

Your 12-15 bucks would go way up if you worked union. They would provide school instead of you paying for it if the job you wish to train for falls under the union's jurisdiction.

http://www.opeiu.org/

Again, I wasn't referring to skilled trades. To me, 5 years of apprenticeship is no different than 5 years of university or college, and as such they deserve their wages.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
One of my friend's husband drives a bus, and he even laughs at how much they get paid for it. So I assume that if he considers himself to be living the high life for an easy job, it can't be too difficult.

I grant that it can be stressful, and I'd assume that would worsen depending on where they work, but like I said, I'm relating this to my direct experience and knowledge - and $25/hr for a relatively small city like mine is overpaid no matter how you look at it.

I think your friend's husbands remarks were probably in jest, if you listen to civil servants for any amount of time you'd think our perks include penthouse suites and free steak dinners every night.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Weevil said:
I think your friend's husbands remarks were probably in jest, if you listen to civil servants for any amount of time you'd think our perks include penthouse suites and free steak dinners every night.

Actually they weren't. She's a hairdresser and they both admit she works harder than him.


Also, that reference to companies moving to avoid taxes - is it not entirely possible that they move because they simply can't afford to pay union wages in a competitive market anymore? There are many companies that treat their employees right, and so those companies are able to get their products out at a much cheaper price. Unions were good in their time - that time is over now.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
Again, I wasn't referring to skilled trades. To me, 5 years of apprenticeship is no different than 5 years of university or college, and as such they deserve their wages.


Do that math. What does 5 years of college cost? Do college students have insurance and benefits? Most dont.

For "unskilled" union work (I hate that phrase) there generally is no apprenticeship. As a skilled trades worker many can enter the union with no appreticeship if a number of years in the craft can be shown. We are not a country club. We want you to join us and make us stronger.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

teddybear4play said:
Right-wingers are not about "Greed Is Good." That was from a Charlie Sheen/Michael Douglas movie.

I'm not going to say that everything corporations do is sweet and wonderful. Business is sometimes cutthroat. But I think CEO's should have the same kind of merit-based contracts as any other worker. None of this guaranteed crap where they make out like bandits and leave their employees holding the bag.

And should you be bitching about the companies moving overseas, or the tax situation that forced them to that point?

TB4p

Pardon me, sir. I know "greed is good" is from Wall Street, but I always laboured under the assumption that Fiscal Conservatives believe in the concept of Companies looking to make as much money as they possibly can while staying within the realm of legality.

Excuse me but CEO's do have merit based contracts and that is a huge part of the problem.

As to the tax problem, well, I think you'd be hard pressed to say that every company that has done a slimey thing like that was in real financial need of doing so.

But in a strictly "Rules of the Game" interpretation of things, I don't have problems with companies making record profits moving operations to the Bahamas and factories to Mexico. In the US system a company is encouraged to make as much green as possible.

What confuses me is why you seem to think that making as much money for yourself as possible is acceptable in boardrooms but not in lunchrooms.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

SaintPeter said:
Do that math. What does 5 years of college cost? Do college students have insurance and benefits? Most dont.

For "unskilled" union work (I hate that phrase) there generally is no apprenticeship. As a skilled trades worker many can enter the union with no appreticeship if a number of years in the craft can be shown. We are not a country club. We want you to join us and make us stronger.

Well I don't think what I have done would be considered a craft. :D

My girlfriend tried to talk me into going through to be an electrician when I lost my job. She loves it and has been doing it for years.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
Well I don't think what I have done would be considered a craft. :D

My girlfriend tried to talk me into going through to be an electrician when I lost my job. She loves it and has been doing it for years.

Tits like those and the sparkies will love you forever. :)

Thanks for the debate Freya and have a nice night.

SaintPeter
SMWIA Journeyman

http://www.smwia.org/
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
Actually they weren't. She's a hairdresser and they both admit she works harder than him.


Also, that reference to companies moving to avoid taxes - is it not entirely possible that they move because they simply can't afford to pay union wages in a competitive market anymore? There are many companies that treat their employees right, and so those companies are able to get their products out at a much cheaper price. Unions were good in their time - that time is over now.

No, many of the companies that move have done so in years when they post record profits.

But who cares? Unions try to make the money they can, the people who run companies try to make the money they can.

Are Union's a thing of the past? Well, obviously not. When you have a huge group of employees you need to organize just so you can have someone negotiate your contract(Which I'm sure is easier for companies than negotiating individually)
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

SaintPeter said:
Tits like those and the sparkies will love you forever. :)

Thanks for the debate Freya and have a nice night.

SaintPeter
SMWIA Journeyman

http://www.smwia.org/

Sleep well Saint Peter.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Weevil said:
No, many of the companies that move have done so in years when they post record profits.

But who cares? Unions try to make the money they can, the people who run companies try to make the money they can.

Are Union's a thing of the past? Well, obviously not. When you have a huge group of employees you need to organize just so you can have someone negotiate your contract(Which I'm sure is easier for companies than negotiating individually)

Well personally that's another thing I disagree with. One of the main reasons I'm against unions is the lack of individual recognition for jobs well done, or the opposite. I worked for the VON for a number of years - in the office. Granted we did get to experience some of the benefits of the nurse's union, without having to pay dues for it, but one of the things that grated on most of us who worked there, was that employee A could do a job for 3 years and do it half assed, and she'd get the same raise as employee B who had done an exceptional job for the same amount of time.

I prefer to be acknowledged for work I've done, rather than relying on a union negotiating my contract for me, and knowing I don't deserve the increase.
 
Organize the unorganize

The key is organizing the unorganized, especially those who are lower paid-- service sector workers (fast food, etc.), office workers. It is urgent and vital to unionize the South, bringing black and white workers together to confront the bosses and smash the racist right-wingers who control the South (and now the whole nation) once and for all. Finish the Civil War!
 
Back
Top