teddybear4play
better when i'm drunk
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2002
- Posts
- 12,906
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?
I don't think the unions should have the right to ground the whole city to a halt simply because they want a little extra to go with the enough they already have. If they were getting shafted, then it would be a little bit different. But they already have plenty; the City really doesn't need a group of people haggling over an extra few bucks when it's got other shit to worry about.
And even to use your 9/11 example, some corporations did change the way they did things. Remember that big shitfit when the nearest Starbucks to the WTC was selling bottled water to the volunteers instead of giving it to them? "No freebies" was obviously company protocol, but they should have been more sensitive to the time and place.
Same as here. Sure, it's SOP for unions that when the contract is up, you haggle for more. But there should be a point when a union forgoes its own self-interests for the good of the people they work for; just as a corporation should forgo maximizing its profits for the good of the people they employ and serve.
TB4p
Well, 9/11 doesn't have anything specifically to do with it, other than it's the reason why the City is in the situation it's in. If they were in a budget crunch for all the other reasons they could be in a budget crunch, my argument would still be the same.Weevil said:2) Companies, in the wake of September 11th, did not change the way they do business out of Sympathy for New Yorkers. Viacom did not lower the cost of movie tickets to make it easier for Cops to take their kids to see Shrek, A&P didn't lower prices to help out those suddenly without the breadwinner in the family. Why should Unions change the way they operate because of 9/11 but nobody else?
(As to your question about the situation being reversed I don't know. On the one hand I'd be in favour of the Transit employees making good money, because everyone should make good money, but on the other hand I have other ideas on how to spend that money for the good of new york)
I don't think the unions should have the right to ground the whole city to a halt simply because they want a little extra to go with the enough they already have. If they were getting shafted, then it would be a little bit different. But they already have plenty; the City really doesn't need a group of people haggling over an extra few bucks when it's got other shit to worry about.
And even to use your 9/11 example, some corporations did change the way they did things. Remember that big shitfit when the nearest Starbucks to the WTC was selling bottled water to the volunteers instead of giving it to them? "No freebies" was obviously company protocol, but they should have been more sensitive to the time and place.
Same as here. Sure, it's SOP for unions that when the contract is up, you haggle for more. But there should be a point when a union forgoes its own self-interests for the good of the people they work for; just as a corporation should forgo maximizing its profits for the good of the people they employ and serve.
Absolutely. And unions, properly maintained, serve that mutually beneficial balance of power. But just as it's wrong for a company to fuck over their workers for their own sake, it's also wrong for a union to squeeze as hard as they can just because they have their employers by the balls.Weevil said:3) Your theory seems to be based on the idea that the ultimate power lies within the Company. Companies "treat their employees right" or act "generously" but I think there is a balance of power. You need someone signing the checks, you need someone to actually fry the chicken. Companies have accountants to make sure their interests are maintained, Unions have employees.
TB4p