Government Strike Breaking

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

Weevil said:
2) Companies, in the wake of September 11th, did not change the way they do business out of Sympathy for New Yorkers. Viacom did not lower the cost of movie tickets to make it easier for Cops to take their kids to see Shrek, A&P didn't lower prices to help out those suddenly without the breadwinner in the family. Why should Unions change the way they operate because of 9/11 but nobody else?

(As to your question about the situation being reversed I don't know. On the one hand I'd be in favour of the Transit employees making good money, because everyone should make good money, but on the other hand I have other ideas on how to spend that money for the good of new york)
Well, 9/11 doesn't have anything specifically to do with it, other than it's the reason why the City is in the situation it's in. If they were in a budget crunch for all the other reasons they could be in a budget crunch, my argument would still be the same.

I don't think the unions should have the right to ground the whole city to a halt simply because they want a little extra to go with the enough they already have. If they were getting shafted, then it would be a little bit different. But they already have plenty; the City really doesn't need a group of people haggling over an extra few bucks when it's got other shit to worry about.

And even to use your 9/11 example, some corporations did change the way they did things. Remember that big shitfit when the nearest Starbucks to the WTC was selling bottled water to the volunteers instead of giving it to them? "No freebies" was obviously company protocol, but they should have been more sensitive to the time and place.

Same as here. Sure, it's SOP for unions that when the contract is up, you haggle for more. But there should be a point when a union forgoes its own self-interests for the good of the people they work for; just as a corporation should forgo maximizing its profits for the good of the people they employ and serve.

Weevil said:
3) Your theory seems to be based on the idea that the ultimate power lies within the Company. Companies "treat their employees right" or act "generously" but I think there is a balance of power. You need someone signing the checks, you need someone to actually fry the chicken. Companies have accountants to make sure their interests are maintained, Unions have employees.
Absolutely. And unions, properly maintained, serve that mutually beneficial balance of power. But just as it's wrong for a company to fuck over their workers for their own sake, it's also wrong for a union to squeeze as hard as they can just because they have their employers by the balls.

TB4p
 
I wish the workers had the bosses by the balls

Talking about the transit workers having their "employers by the balls" at a time when the workers are under an injunction not to strike, and are being threatened with fines, firings, and even jailings, is such an utter inversion of reality as to totally boggle the mind . . .
 
Re: I wish the workers had the bosses by the balls

REDWAVE said:
Talking about the transit workers having their "employers by the balls" at a time when the workers are under an injunction not to strike, and are being threatened with fines, firings, and even jailings, is such an utter inversion of reality as to totally boggle the mind . . .
Which is exactly the reaction they deserve for what they're trying to do.

Like I said, time and a place for everything. They shouldn't have tried to force something at a time when the City really can't afford it and would react strongly against it.

(And when I said that, I meant in general . . . in this case, the transit workers thought they had the City by the balls [threatening to shut everything down], but they found they're in for a fight this time.)

TB4p
 
Last edited:
TB

(1) It is the MTA which is trying to force an extremely unfavorable contract down the workers' throats.

(2) Billionaire Mayor Michael Bloomberg has plenty of money in the budget for more windfalls for the rich. It is ONLY the workers who are being told to make sacrifices.

(3) In the U.S., government always (or almost always) intervenes in labor disputes in favor of management, never in favor of the workers.

Therefore, the transit workers need revolutionary leadership which will defy the unconstitutional injunction, and seek to unite ALL workers in a NYC general strike, and demand that the rich and the corporations pay for the crisis they have created, instead of making the workers pay for it. If the TWU bureaucrats are too craven to do this, the rank and file should go over their heads, and walk out on their own in a wildcat strike.
 
Re: TB

REDWAVE said:
(1) It is the MTA which is trying to force an extremely unfavorable contract down the workers' throats.

(2) Billionaire Mayor Michael Bloomberg has plenty of money in the budget for more windfalls for the rich. It is ONLY the workers who are being told to make sacrifices.

(3) In the U.S., government always (or almost always) intervenes in labor disputes in favor of management, never in favor of the workers.

Therefore, the transit workers need revolutionary leadership which will defy the unconstitutional injunction, and seek to unite ALL workers in a NYC general strike, and demand that the rich and the corporations pay for the crisis they have created, instead of making the workers pay for it. If the TWU bureaucrats are too craven to do this, the rank and file should go over their heads, and walk out on their own in a wildcat strike.
And what happens when all the other workers in New York who DON'T have it as good as the transit workers (because their union isn't as strong because of the threat of transit strike) see that they have more than them and are still bitching?

Say a quick goodbye to revolution.

TB4p
 
Divide & conquer

It's a tactic at least as old as the Roman Empire: divide and conquer. The bosses (and their lackeys and mouthpieces) constantly stir up prejudices and rivalries among the workers, to keep them fighting among themselves, so they won't UNITE against their common class enemy-- the bosses.
 
The NY unions have cut some pretty good deals for themselves at the expense of the ordinary working class fuck. Things like retirement after 20 years with full pay and benefits etc........ Bloombergs being a billionaire is no more relevent than John Kerry being the richest man in the senate. Fuck the unions.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

teddybear4play said:
Well, 9/11 doesn't have anything specifically to do with it, other than it's the reason why the City is in the situation it's in. If they were in a budget crunch for all the other reasons they could be in a budget crunch, my argument would still be the same.

I don't think the unions should have the right to ground the whole city to a halt simply because they want a little extra to go with the enough they already have. If they were getting shafted, then it would be a little bit different. But they already have plenty; the City really doesn't need a group of people haggling over an extra few bucks when it's got other shit to worry about.

<snip>TB4p

Damn good post TB4p! Actually though, 9/11 has a lot to do with it. NYC has lost billions of dollars due to the terrorist attacks. There is no rich CEO that is holding workers hostage. The city is already facing massive deficits. To strike now would make the situation even worse. In addition, in order to pay for the ridiculous increase that the transit worker's want, the MTA would have to raise the fares even more than they are planning. Currently, the numbers being discussed are a $.50sent raise no matter what, and an potentially, an additional $1.00 on top of it.

As for unions in general, they do as much good as they do bad. While they certainly served a purpose originally, they now raise the cost of doing businesses that consumers wind up paying for. In the end, it is always the average guy (the person REDWAVE thinks he is arguing for) who always pays for it.

The main problem with unions is that they reward mediocrity and pay people based on seniority and not performance. This drives up the "cost" of their services which is passed down the chain, ultimately to the end consumer (the average guy).

REDWAVE is blinded by the concept of unions, and can't see the damage that they do to everyone excluding their members.
 
Support for strikers

While the rich and their lackeys rail at the transit workers, calling them selfish (pots and kettles), the union ig getting a lot of working class support in NYC. There is a mass rally in support of them scheduled for Sunday at 2 p.m. Cab drivers and CUNY students are also lining up with them, and there is talk of a "Critical Mass" bike ride on Monday. For more details on these exciting developments, see

http://nyc.indymedia.org

The rich have always been waging class warfare against us. We need to start fighting back.

Class struggle!
 
Re: Support for strikers

REDWAVE said:
ass struggle!

Well, I'm assuming that you mean it's too big, and you have to struggle to get them into your pants.

One method would be dieting, which could reduce the size of your ass.

Another thing you could do is use talcum powder.


Oh yeah, you could get your brains out of there and remove the wiring that connect your ass directly to your keyboard.

Just a few thoughts.
 
What bosses hate

The bosses (and their lackeys) are infuriated at the thought that some workers make a decent living-- that cuts into their profits. They are infuriated even more by the thought that workers might band together and stand up to them. That's why they fight so hard to keep workers isolated and unorganized, so they can easily pick them off one by one, group by group.

But what really infuriates them the most, and utterly terifies them, is the idea that all the workers of the world might band together and rise up against them, and defeat them.
:cool:
 
This is not truly relevant. But I just can't get worked up over transit workers making as much as they do and demanding an 18 to 24 percent raise. In my home state all state employees (white and blue collar) are facing a 6 to 10 percent pay cut because of budget problems. (The state constitution requires a balanced budget.) When I see employees that are paid well threaten to strike for that great a percentage raise I'm afraid they will not find a sympathetic friend here.
 
Re: What bosses hate

REDWAVE said:
The bosses (and their lackeys) are infuriated at the thought that some workers make a decent living-- that cuts into their profits. They are infuriated even more by the thought that workers might band together and stand up to them. That's why they fight so hard to keep workers isolated and unorganized, so they can easily pick them off one by one, group by group.

But what really infuriates them the most, and utterly terifies them, is the idea that all the workers of the world might band together and rise up against them, and defeat them.
:cool:
Yep, I'll bet they live in constant fear of that.

Get fuckin' real.

There is no group of suit-wearing "bosses" who have a Grand Master Strategy of how to take care of all the unions in New York, or America, or the world.

They, for the most part, worry about the same shit the workers worry about: the success of their company, the health of their family.

TB4p
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

zipman7 said:
Damn good post TB4p! Actually though, 9/11 has a lot to do with it. NYC has lost billions of dollars due to the terrorist attacks. There is no rich CEO that is holding workers hostage. The city is already facing massive deficits. To strike now would make the situation even worse. In addition, in order to pay for the ridiculous increase that the transit worker's want, the MTA would have to raise the fares even more than they are planning. Currently, the numbers being discussed are a $.50sent raise no matter what, and an potentially, an additional $1.00 on top of it.

As for unions in general, they do as much good as they do bad. While they certainly served a purpose originally, they now raise the cost of doing businesses that consumers wind up paying for. In the end, it is always the average guy (the person REDWAVE thinks he is arguing for) who always pays for it.

The main problem with unions is that they reward mediocrity and pay people based on seniority and not performance. This drives up the "cost" of their services which is passed down the chain, ultimately to the end consumer (the average guy).

REDWAVE is blinded by the concept of unions, and can't see the damage that they do to everyone excluding their members.

Hi Zip, another interesting post, mind if I comment?

Unions in Oz are the only insurance that the workers have against discrimination by bosses and managers. After a century of head-banging, sensible employers have learned that conciliation is the go . . . give as bit, take a bit. The system is not perfect and there are silly abuses on both sides . . . but it works, and is even written into the Oz Constitution.

Blaming the workers for the increasing costs of manufactured goods or rail trainsit services is a little short -sighted . . . let's deal with manufactured goods first.

The recent collapse of Enron, Arthur Anderson, Haliburton and many other corporations was caused by a financial system which allowed the excesses of managerial salaries and perks to exceed the capacity of the system to provide them . . . remember, it was the Executives who walked away with huge payouts . . . legally because they had invoiced the corporation and so created part of the financial death blow to the corporation.

In Oz we had HIH Insurance executives getting huge loans from the company "forgiven" by management, additional invoiced payments being rushed through the books as the corporation collapsed and largesse by the CEO to his many favourite charities at a level not seen since the days of Rome. But nowhere was there any thought of these executives having any responsibility to the ultimate owners, the shareholders. Indeed, Oz Corporations Law is written to protect executives AGAINST the wishes of the shareholders. I think the same may apply in America.

And what about the workers, unionised or not, who lost their jobs after years of loyal service . . . too bad!! . . . the executives spent your long service and holiday pay entitlements.

The pattern was repeated in the collapse of Ansett Airlines, where Kiwi corporate crooks assetstripped the corporation to prop up their own failing airline, Air New Zealand, leaving aussie workers in the lurch, many after a lifetime of loyal service.

Or the best example is National Textiles, managed (& owned?) by the Prim Monster's brother . . . the Oz government bailed out the executives and left the workers to fend for themselves without their long service, holiday and retrenchment entitlements . . . nice to be well connected to the government purse . . .

To say that the "unions is that they reward mediocrity and pay people based on seniority and not performance" is an unsustainable position . . . the excesses of management cause much more price inflation, but it is disguised in the corporation balance sheet under the heading "Executive salaries and perks".

"This (enormous Executive salary package entitlements) drives up the "cost" of their services which is passed down the chain, ultimately to the end consumer (the average guy)" much, much more than any workers demands. For example, the CEO of OZ Telstra "earned" a $A1.25 milllion "bonus" for watching the share price fall to a mere $A4.50 ($US 2.20 about) for the world's most efficient and cash-up telco). LOcally at the university, the Union facilites CEO demanded and got a "performance bonus" of an alleged $A3,000 for LOSING about $A1,000 per day trading. Who are we kidding?? Managerment is the biggest cost of production, NOT the workers.

Only management is unrestrained in its claims in the work place and so makes unrealistic demands which corporations meekly accept because all executives benefit at the expense of the shareholders. It is really legal robbery. :)
 
Sellout!

Roger Toussaint, TWU Local 100 leader, has betrayed the rank and file by reaching a tentative agreement with the MTA bosses. This deal provides a lump sum payment of $1,000 the first year, and 3% wage increases the next two. That will barely cover increases in the cost of living, if that. Toussaint and the union bureaucrats have caved in to management without a fight. Originally, the union had sought an 8% annual increase.

The bus and subway workers should overwhelmingly vote down this outrageous sellout!
 
Maybe they realized that they looked stupid for striking.

If they had any leverage at all, they wouldn't have accepted the deal.

TB4p
 
Thanks to REDWAVE for bumping this thread. I missed it the other day when it was fresh. I think the late night hours of the biggest part of the debate was why I missed it.

I don't want to add a thing, I just wanted to compliment Freya (and others) for well thought out posts.
 
Texan said:
Thanks to REDWAVE for bumping this thread. I missed it the other day when it was fresh. I think the late night hours of the biggest part of the debate was why I missed it.

I don't want to add a thing, I just wanted to compliment Freya (and others) for well thought out posts.

Thanks a lot Texan. :)
 
ENOUGH!!!

tb4p...it was already pointed out to you and yet you ignore it...the city's buget problems have nothing to do with this. the mta is a private company.

freya...you seem very young and naive. i think what saint peter (and others) was trying to point out was that you see your microcosm and relate the world to it. if you think the overwhelming majority, half of, or even significant minority of bosses are decent, you are really living in la la land. this is why i'm "mean". people just don't get it otherwise.

finally, why on earth does the mismanagement of money always fall on the shoulders of those who don't manage it?

GREED IS GOOD.
UNION IS CAPITALSIM!!!!!
 
Last edited:
Re: You can't run the subways with bayonets!

REDWAVE said:
As of now, the contract has expired, but the craven TWU leadership is still negotiating, instead of calling a strike. Here's two excellent articles commenting on the situation, from the Sparts and their splinter group the IG:

http://www.icl-fi.org/ENGLISH/twu793.htm

http://www.internationalist.org/nycsubways1202.html

What about the loss of life that would have accompanied a strike? I guess the fact that ambulances and other emergency vehicles would be greatly delayed in reaching their destinations doesn't fit into your black and white picture of class struggle.

The truth is that the people striking are dead wrong.

1) They make more money than a lot of other people
2) Their "boss" is the cash starved NYC government, which is still decimated by the economic impacts of 9/11
3) There was very little support for their strike by other workers
4) Striking right before Christmas was being viewed as extortion by many other average workers
5) The increases asked for by the union would have put an extraordinary burden on the average guy, not the wealthy who take taxi's anyway


Of course, these factors don't quite fit into your paranoid theories of revolution, do they?
 
Re: ENOUGH!!!

paganangel said:
tb4p...it was already pointed out to you and yet you ignore it...the city's buget problems have nothing to do with this. the mta is a private company.

freya...you seem very young and naive. i think what saint peter (and others) was trying to point out was that you see your microcosm and relate the world to it. if you think the overwhelming majority, half of, or even significant minority of bosses are decent, you are really living in la la land. this is why i'm "mean". people just don't get it otherwise.

finally, why on earth does the mismanagement of money always fall on the shoulders of those who don't manage it?

GREED IS GOOD.
UNION IS CAPITALSIM!!!!!

I'm neither. I never once claimed to speak outside of my own experience or knowledge, in regards to companies and how they treat employees, and on unions and the damage they do. And even if a bunch of brainwashed union people want me to believe that they are perfect and not to be questioned, it won't make me change my opinions on them.

Unions promote laziness and inferiority in workers, they are partially responsible for the increased costs of goods and services, and they are outdated and no longer necessary in the workplace. That's my opinion, and not one of you have said one thing to make me feel otherwise.
 
Re: Re: You can't run the subways with bayonets!

zipman7 said:
What about the loss of life that would have accompanied a strike? I guess the fact that ambulances and other emergency vehicles would be greatly delayed in reaching their destinations doesn't fit into your black and white picture of class struggle.

The truth is that the people striking are dead wrong.

1) They make more money than a lot of other people
2) Their "boss" is the cash starved NYC government, which is still decimated by the economic impacts of 9/11
3) There was very little support for their strike by other workers
4) Striking right before Christmas was being viewed as extortion by many other average workers
5) The increases asked for by the union would have put an extraordinary burden on the average guy, not the wealthy who take taxi's anyway


Of course, these factors don't quite fit into your paranoid theories of revolution, do they?
ok, let's go punch for punch.

1) what other people? and THAT is a communist idea. you are worth what you can get someone to pay you. who died and left you karl marx?! how can you decide what is acceptable for others to make?
2)no it isn't. for the x time...their "boss" is the mta.
3)not where i'm from. no one wanted it, but most were behind them and thought the mta and bloomberg were serious assholes.
4)now you really do seem to be wired in to EVERYONE'S head don't you? try speaking for yourself. besides even if EVERYONE in this city were against them, it wouldn't be a good argument.
5) as i said b4 that is not the workers' fault...even the state comptroler has asked the mta to open their books because the budget deficits seem fishy.
 
Last edited:
Re: Re: ENOUGH!!!

Freya2 said:
I'm neither. I never once claimed to speak outside of my own experience or knowledge, in regards to companies and how they treat employees, and on unions and the damage they do. And even if a bunch of brainwashed union people want me to believe that they are perfect and not to be questioned, it won't make me change my opinions on them.

Unions promote laziness and inferiority in workers, they are partially responsible for the increased costs of goods and services, and they are outdated and no longer necessary in the workplace. That's my opinion, and not one of you have said one thing to make me feel otherwise.
you realize you just proved my point. i was saying you were naive BECAUSE you don't speak outside your experince. naivete and closed mindedness are so often linked.
 
Re: Re: Re: You can't run the subways with bayonets!

paganangel said:
ok, let's go punch forpunch.

1) what other people and THAT is a communist iea. you are worh what you can get someone to pay you. who died and left you karl marx?! how can you decide what is acceptable for others to make?
2)no it isn't. for the x time...their "boss" is the mta.
3)not where i'm from. no one wanted it, but most were behind them and thought the mta and bloomberg were serious assholes.
4)now you really do seem to be wired in to EVERYONE'S head don't you. try speaking for yourself. besides if EVERYONE in this city were against them, it wouldn't be a good argument.
5) as i said b4 that is not the workers fult...even the state comptroler has asked the mta to pen their books because the budget deficits seem fishy.

oh yeah...and loss of life... isn't that a little...wel, extreme. i mean really there is absolutely nothing to indicate that would happen. in fact they were planning on keeping lanes open just for emergency services. they don't do that normally. emergency vehicles may actually be able to get to the scenes FASTER! that's a sad fear tactic.
 
Back
Top