Government Strike Breaking

Re: Re: Re: ENOUGH!!!

paganangel said:
you realize you just proved my point. i was saying you were naive BECAUSE you don't speak outside your experince. naivete and closed mindedness are so often linked.

Union workers and brainwashing are so often linked too.

If I'm closed minded, provide me with some facts to refute my opinions. Open my mind a bit. Don't spout the party line, because it won't do a damn thing. And don't bother with all the advances that have been made because of unions - I know all that, and have already conceded the point that in their time, they were useful. Not one person on this thread has said one thing to show that unions are anything but exactly what I have said they are. And I'd be rather surprised if you could come up with anything besides the old tried and true bullshit that union workers have been spouting for years. Trust me, I've heard it all. I lived with a union head for 9 months once - I know all the propoganda.
 
no propaganda, no party line. unions, with all their flaws, are the best protection a worker has. and again, you think you've "seen it all" b/c you lived with aunion head for nine months?! c'mon! i've seen them try to not pay guys. i've seen thm force them to do INCREDIBLY unsafe things. I'VE seen them write layoff checks for not staying late enough. i've seen lying and screaming and physical violence. you haven't seen close to it all. and just b/c others don't make enough does not mean union employees make too much.
 
paganangel said:
no propaganda, no party line. unions, with all their flaws, are the best protection a worker has. and again, you think you've "seen it all" b/c you lived with aunion head for nine months?! c'mon! i've seen them try to not pay guys. i've seen thm force them to do INCREDIBLY unsafe things. I'VE seen them write layoff checks for not staying late enough. i've seen lying and screaming and physical violence. you haven't seen close to it all. and just b/c others don't make enough does not mean union employees make too much.

That still doesn't cut it. I'm not allowed to use my personal experience and knowledge to form an opinion,yet somehow it's ok for you and others to do that exact thing. How does that work again?

I've seen companies that treat their employees like gold, so as to prevent union invasion. I've seen incompetent workers protected by their union status. I've seen people that drive a fucking bus make as much or more money than someone who goes to university for 5 years. I've seen unions harrass, threaten and badger people who don't follow their brainwashing, people like teachers who actually do the job for the children, and not for the money involved, people who care about their jobs more than they care about pleasing some righteous asshole who makes 500k a year and tells them to live on $30/wk strike pay.
 
Re: Re: Re: You can't run the subways with bayonets!

paganangel said:
ok, let's go punch for punch.

1) what other people? and THAT is a communist idea. you are worth what you can get someone to pay you. who died and left you karl marx?! how can you decide what is acceptable for others to make?
2)no it isn't. for the x time...their "boss" is the mta.
3)not where i'm from. no one wanted it, but most were behind them and thought the mta and bloomberg were serious assholes.
4)now you really do seem to be wired in to EVERYONE'S head don't you? try speaking for yourself. besides even if EVERYONE in this city were against them, it wouldn't be a good argument.
5) as i said b4 that is not the workers' fault...even the state comptroler has asked the mta to open their books because the budget deficits seem fishy.

1) The other people are teachers, nurses etc. Comparative studies done showed that transit workers are well paid in comparison. I can voice my opinion on what a group of people make when they can hold a city hostage. If you're for them, that's great. When subway prices go up to $3.00 to pay for it, a lot of average people will get hurt. For a lot of people, there are no alternatives to taking public transportation. And getting to work is a necessity, not a nice to do.
2) The MTA may be somewhat privatized, but is inextricably tied to the city government. That is why the city foots the bill for a lot of projects that the MTA does. Therefore, the funds do have to come out of the city's budget.
3) Where are you from? Everyone that I speak to is against the strike and I am talking about a cross section of New Yorkers, from all walks of life.
4) Perhaps the reasons that they are severely reducing their demands is because of the sentiments that I have been expressing, which are representative of local news interviews, opinion pieces and the people I speak with. What do you call it when transportation grinds to a halt, right when people are Christmas shopping? I call it extortion.
5) No, it is not the worker's fault. Choosing to go on strike when there is no money to pay them is their fault. It represents a selfishness that is not in the city's best interests. While mismanagement occurs everywhere, going on strike now is like a gif "fuck you" from the transit workers.
 
you've braiwashed yourself.

why do you think those companies want to prevent union invasion?
i'm not saying don't base things on your own opinion...that's all ANYONE can do. butbase them on more than JU?ST your experience...bew more worldy...enlightened. see things from other points of view. we all obviously see yours.

besoides...now you are starting to repeat the same lines in response to different arguments no new counters.



"bored now" - dirty willow
 
paganangel said:
you've braiwashed yourself.

why do you think those companies want to prevent union invasion?
i'm not saying don't base things on your own opinion...that's all ANYONE can do. butbase them on more than JU?ST your experience...bew more worldy...enlightened. see things from other points of view. we all obviously see yours.

besoides...now you are starting to repeat the same lines in response to different arguments no new counters.

Why do they want to prevent union invasion? Oh gee, I dunno - maybe so they won't have to double the worker's already equitable wages and drive up the cost of their products even more? So that they can continue to compete in the marketplace? So they don't have to move to Mexico to put out a product at a reasonable price?

I do see things from other's POV - my father was a union guy for 35 years. My ex-boyfriend was a head up the union's ass.....errr, union head for many years. My step mother was in a union for 30+ years. I watch the news, I read the papers and form my opinion on what I see. I've heard all the lines, all the reasons why they are so wonderful - and I've also heard two out of the three (plus many others I know that are in unions or work with them) admit that they are essentially useless in this day and age, unless of course, you have some weird interest in shutting down entire companies or essential services.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: You can't run the subways with bayonets!

zipman7 said:
1) The other people are teachers, nurses etc. Comparative studies done showed that transit workers are well paid in comparison. I can voice my opinion on what a group of people make when they can hold a city hostage. If you're for them, that's great. When subway prices go up to $3.00 to pay for it, a lot of average people will get hurt. For a lot of people, there are no alternatives to taking public transportation. And getting to work is a necessity, not a nice to do.
2) The MTA may be somewhat privatized, but is inextricably tied to the city government. That is why the city foots the bill for a lot of projects that the MTA does. Therefore, the funds do have to come out of the city's budget.
3) Where are you from? Everyone that I speak to is against the strike and I am talking about a cross section of New Yorkers, from all walks of life.
4) Perhaps the reasons that they are severely reducing their demands is because of the sentiments that I have been expressing, which are representative of local news interviews, opinion pieces and the people I speak with. What do you call it when transportation grinds to a halt, right when people are Christmas shopping? I call it extortion.
5) No, it is not the worker's fault. Choosing to go on strike when there is no money to pay them is their fault. It represents a selfishness that is not in the city's best interests. While mismanagement occurs everywhere, going on strike now is like a gif "fuck you" from the transit workers.
i've already responded to most of this.

1)jst because some people don't make enough doesn't mean others make too much. if the mta maaged their money bettr...this wouldn't be an issue. nor should it.
2) it is NOT tied to city governement. they fot the bil for projects as an invesment for the city. a subsidy so to speak. that's like saying the yankees and mets are tied to the city b/c of the new stadium plans.
3)i'm from nyc. who are the peole that you speak to that represent the "cross section" of new yorkers?
4) severely reducing their demands?! when did that happen? one percnt is a severe reduction i thought itwas offering a compromise? then the mta ofered...um lemme see...oh yeah..NOTHING! it was an insult. the didn't WANT to strike! no one did. theywere forced to. but everyoneloves to blame the unions. and it's not extortion at all. they aren't threatening anyone in te least. and it is hardly heir fault that they are the most convenient way to get around. if nothing else that only sterengthens their position.
5) wrong. they have totake care of themselves. c'mon. y is her no money? they can't be resposible foor tha. if they thought that way, they'd never get anything.
 
Back
Top