Government Strike Breaking

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

Weevil said:
What confuses me is why you seem to think that making as much money for yourself as possible is acceptable in boardrooms but not in lunchrooms.
Because profit has its limits. I'm not a strictly laissez-faire advocate, because I do think workers should have rights. Very few conservatives/Republicans would argue for abolishing the minimum wage. But that sets a limit on how much profit companies can reap.

Profit works because businesses flourish, develop new innovations, and serve their customers better. It also gives their workers jobs, and, if businesses turn more profits, even more jobs.

Where profit becomes greed is a gray area. I wouldn't know where to define that line.

But it seems to me that for a group of workers threatening to paralyze a city already in a budget crisis and hemorrhaging money due to a terrorist attack so they can take their already pretty-damn-good system and make it just a liiiittle bit better, crosses my line of decency, wherever it might lie.

TB4p
 
Re: Organize the unorganize

REDWAVE said:
The key is organizing the unorganized, especially those who are lower paid-- service sector workers (fast food, etc.), office workers. It is urgent and vital to unionize the South, bringing black and white workers together to confront the bosses and smash the racist right-wingers who control the South (and now the whole nation) once and for all. Finish the Civil War!
Hey, I got a question: if you were a New Yorker, would you boycott public transportation to show solidarity with the transit workers?

TB4p
 
Re: Organize the unorganize

REDWAVE said:
The key is organizing the unorganized, especially those who are lower paid-- service sector workers (fast food, etc.), office workers. It is urgent and vital to unionize the South, bringing black and white workers together to confront the bosses and smash the racist right-wingers who control the South (and now the whole nation) once and for all. Finish the Civil War!

Redwave, you're a fruitcake. :D

Unionize McDonalds? Sure, they can pay that burger flipper $15/hr and then charge you $10 for a Big Mac. Would that suit you?

It is not urgent and vital to unionize anything anymore. Most companies have become progressive enough that they know how to treat their workers properly, thus eliminating the need for unions at all.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
Well personally that's another thing I disagree with. One of the main reasons I'm against unions is the lack of individual recognition for jobs well done, or the opposite. I worked for the VON for a number of years - in the office. Granted we did get to experience some of the benefits of the nurse's union, without having to pay dues for it, but one of the things that grated on most of us who worked there, was that employee A could do a job for 3 years and do it half assed, and she'd get the same raise as employee B who had done an exceptional job for the same amount of time.

I prefer to be acknowledged for work I've done, rather than relying on a union negotiating my contract for me, and knowing I don't deserve the increase.

I suppose, however in a union as large as mine that would create an enormous amount of added Bureaucracy(When's the last time you heard someone demand that of the province?) to oversee and rank everyones performance.

A job like mine shouldn't be 66% or 77% it should be pass/fail with those who pass really high getting promoted in accordance with their ability.

Again, you're objections seem to be based on what others are getting. Stay within yourself.
 
Fruitcake?

I've been called a fruitcake a time or two . . .

TB-- yes, if I lived in the NYC area, I would boycott public transportation run by scab labor, and ride a bike instead (eco friendly), in support of the strike.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

teddybear4play said:
Because profit has its limits. I'm not a strictly laissez-faire advocate, because I do think workers should have rights. Very few conservatives/Republicans would argue for abolishing the minimum wage. But that sets a limit on how much profit companies can reap.

Profit works because businesses flourish, develop new innovations, and serve their customers better. It also gives their workers jobs, and, if businesses turn more profits, even more jobs.

Where profit becomes greed is a gray area. I wouldn't know where to define that line.

But it seems to me that for a group of workers threatening to paralyze a city already in a budget crisis and hemorrhaging money due to a terrorist attack so they can take their already pretty-damn-good system and make it just a liiiittle bit better, crosses my line of decency, wherever it might lie.

TB4p

A few things, good sir.

1) The minimum wage is around because of union members changing the way the world sees the workplace. At issue isn't so much whether or not Warren Buffet agrees with the minimum wage as it is whether or not JP Morgan did.

2) Increased pay for workers works because that increases the quality of life for their families, increases their children's chances of becoming one of the educated elite, goes back into the system so it can pay for shiney, shiney tanks.

3) I don't know enough about the New York situation to comment on it but if that is true than where do you think Unions are compared to Companies in terms of doing crappy, sleazy things? George Steinbrenner just eliminated Yankee employees dental coverage so he can pay Sterling Hitchcock for a couple of weeks. That is why Unions exist. So excuse me if I hold my nose during the rare opportunity when a Union has a chance to shove it to a Billionaire.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Weevil said:
I suppose, however in a union as large as mine that would create an enormous amount of added Bureaucracy(When's the last time you heard someone demand that of the province?) to oversee and rank everyones performance.

A job like mine shouldn't be 66% or 77% it should be pass/fail with those who pass really high getting promoted in accordance with their ability.

Again, you're objections seem to be based on what others are getting. Stay within yourself.

And those that fail being dismissed or demoted. Not being given the same as everyone else.

It has to do with what others are getting when I know that I do my job better and yet am not being recognized for it, and someone who does it halfassed will earn the same pay increase as me.

Unions have a stranglehold on certain areas in our society, and it's ridiculous to assume that will ever be let go of. But I see no need for new union shops to pop up - not when there are now laws in place to protect workers against unsafe or intolerable working conditions. Their time has passed - at this point they are a convenience, no more.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
And those that fail being dismissed or demoted. Not being given the same as everyone else.

It has to do with what others are getting when I know that I do my job better and yet am not being recognized for it, and someone who does it halfassed will earn the same pay increase as me.

Unions have a stranglehold on certain areas in our society, and it's ridiculous to assume that will ever be let go of. But I see no need for new union shops to pop up - not when there are now laws in place to protect workers against unsafe or intolerable working conditions. Their time has passed - at this point they are a convenience, no more.

Exactly, if my colleague does his job poorly to the extent that he "fails" well, let's just say that corner office will be mine before it's his.

It still sounds like you're too outwardly focused. Others might make more than me for less work, but I'm well paid, I don't get horsewhipped at work so I'm happy. You need to look inward.

As to the existence of Unions, well, you seem to ignore the past. The reason Unions exist is that Companies left to run things without Unions gave it large to their employees at every turn. The existence of Unions is neccesary because the interests of the Rich have to be held in check.
 
Unions are good for all workers

All workers, both union and non-union, were better off relatively in the 1950's, when 40% of the workforce was unionized, than they are now, with only 9% unionized. The gap between rich and poor was much less, also. Then, CEO's on the average made only about 40 times as much as the average worker, instead of 400.
 
Re: Unions are good for all workers

REDWAVE said:
All workers, both union and non-union, were better off relatively in the 1950's,.

Well, White Male workers I suppose.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Weevil said:
Exactly, if my colleague does his job poorly to the extent that he "fails" well, let's just say that corner office will be mine before it's his.

It still sounds like you're too outwardly focused. Others might make more than me for less work, but I'm well paid, I don't get horsewhipped at work so I'm happy. You need to look inward.

As to the existence of Unions, well, you seem to ignore the past. The reason Unions exist is that Companies left to run things without Unions gave it large to their employees at every turn. The existence of Unions is neccesary because the interests of the Rich have to be held in check.

Well I disagree with that last point, for reasons I've outlined already.

And of course I'm looking inward. I'm offering my opinion on why I dislike unions and would have an extremely difficult time agreeing to support with monthly dues. I'd prefer a job where I'm well paid, and don't get horsewhipped and it's solely based on my skill and talents - not because some overpaid fuck negotiated an increase in my contract.

Even if you get that corner office, he'll still be there - so your promotion will be based on your worth, but his job security is due to a unions influence. That job would be better filled with someone that would actually pass that test.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, honey

Freya2 said:
Well I disagree with that last point, for reasons I've outlined already.

And of course I'm looking inward. I'm offering my opinion on why I dislike unions and would have an extremely difficult time agreeing to support with monthly dues. I'd prefer a job where I'm well paid, and don't get horsewhipped and it's solely based on my skill and talents - not because some overpaid fuck negotiated an increase in my contract.

Even if you get that corner office, he'll still be there - so your promotion will be based on your worth, but his job security is due to a unions influence. That job would be better filled with someone that would actually pass that test.

Sure, but most of your reasons seem to be anecdotal evidence that can't be taken real seriously.

And you're looking inward in terms of your thoughts here but a lot of your views on Unions seem to come from jealousy/resentment of others. Which is a bad thing to base beliefs on.

Finally, I don't think you know too much about hiring for the kind of job I have. At my present position I was determined to be the best possible applicant. When I was entry level I was the best possible applicant. Everyone who gets a job where I work has "passed a test" and if their performance slips to the point of failing that person will usually leave the job(With or without it being forced upon them)

It's not real hard to become a member of my Union.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Freya, h

Weevil said:
Sure, but most of your reasons seem to be anecdotal evidence that can't be taken real seriously.

And you're looking inward in terms of your thoughts here but a lot of your views on Unions seem to come from jealousy/resentment of others. Which is a bad thing to base beliefs on.

Finally, I don't think you know too much about hiring for the kind of job I have. At my present position I was determined to be the best possible applicant. When I was entry level I was the best possible applicant. Everyone who gets a job where I work has "passed a test" and if their performance slips to the point of failing that person will usually leave the job(With or without it being forced upon them)

It's not real hard to become a member of my Union.

Youre contradicting yourself. First you say you have to pass a test, then you say it's not hard to get into your union. Which could lead one to believe that it's not real hard to perform your job. Or that the test isn't that hard to pass.

It's not jealousy. Resentment? Maybe. But it's due to personal experience, which I happen to think is a perfect thing to base beliefs on. Do I resent a situation in which someone benefits the same as others for not performing at the level of others? Damn right I do.

So what am I doing about it? Going back to school for an education in a field in which I'll be judged on my own skills - and will succeed or fail accordingly.
 
Good for you, Freya. I'm all for education. I just hope you take some classes which encourage and teach independent thinking, and not just courses which prepare you for a particular vocation.
 
REDWAVE said:
Good for you, Freya. I'm all for education. I just hope you take some classes which encourage and teach independent thinking, and not just courses which prepare you for a particular vocation.

I don't need to learn independent thinking. I've got that down pat.


And you never told me what I could do to get you on my side. ;)
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Frey

Freya2 said:
Youre contradicting yourself. First you say you have to pass a test, then you say it's not hard to get into your union. Which could lead one to believe that it's not real hard to perform your job. Or that the test isn't that hard to pass.

It's not jealousy. Resentment? Maybe. But it's due to personal experience, which I happen to think is a perfect thing to base beliefs on. Do I resent a situation in which someone benefits the same as others for not performing at the level of others? Damn right I do.

So what am I doing about it? Going back to school for an education in a field in which I'll be judged on my own skills - and will succeed or fail accordingly.

No, I'm not contradicting myself, you just aren't understanding me. The test passed is the getting the job(A tricky test, you're up against good folk usually) When I said it's not hard to join my union what I meant is that if the government wants to give you a job we'll usually take people into our union. There aren't quizzes or paddling ceremonies.

Freya, if you don't mind me saying, you're biggest problem with serious threads is that you don't realize that personal experience might be great to base beliefs on but it's lousy to base arguments on. There's no verification, It could be isolated and extreme and it might be based on circumstances not known to all.

Please, if you want to have discussions here about important political or socio-economic issues here you might need to rely on more than stories overheard in a pool hall.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:

Weevil said:
No, I'm not contradicting myself, you just aren't understanding me. The test passed is the getting the job(A tricky test, you're up against good folk usually) When I said it's not hard to join my union what I meant is that if the government wants to give you a job we'll usually take people into our union. There aren't quizzes or paddling ceremonies.

Freya, if you don't mind me saying, you're biggest problem with serious threads is that you don't realize that personal experience might be great to base beliefs on but it's lousy to base arguments on. There's no verification, It could be isolated and extreme and it might be based on circumstances not known to all.

Please, if you want to have discussions here about important political or socio-economic issues here you might need to rely on more than stories overheard in a pool hall.

Gee Weevil, that was hardly condescending at all. I don't involve myself in political threads partly because of your reasoning and partly because of this type of "Pat the little dummy on the head" attitude that so many of you display so well.

I started posting in this thread to bother Redwave a little bit. My words were questioned and I argued my points based on my knowledge and experience. I never once claimed to be the wise woman of unions. At all times I stated my own personal views - which whether you like them or not, I am entitled to have, just as you are yours. You argue your points based on your personal knowledge of your union - I argue mine based on my knowledge of my father's and various friends I have that are involved in them, as well as experience working closely with union members at my previous job. So they are opposing? Big fucking deal. That doesn't make my views any less valid than your own.
 
Just being you

Just being your sweet self is enough to win me over, Freya.
;)
 
Re: Just being you

REDWAVE said:
Just being your sweet self is enough to win me over, Freya.
;)

:kiss:

Good night Redwave. It was great fun debating with you.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:

Freya2 said:
Gee Weevil, that was hardly condescending at all. I don't involve myself in political threads partly because of your reasoning and partly because of this type of "Pat the little dummy on the head" attitude that so many of you display so well.

I started posting in this thread to bother Redwave a little bit. My words were questioned and I argued my points based on my knowledge and experience. I never once claimed to be the wise woman of unions. At all times I stated my own personal views - which whether you like them or not, I am entitled to have, just as you are yours. You argue your points based on your personal knowledge of your union - I argue mine based on my knowledge of my father's and various friends I have that are involved in them, as well as experience working closely with union members at my previous job. So they are opposing? Big fucking deal. That doesn't make my views any less valid than your own.


Indeed, your views are less valid not because they differ from mine but because they are based on a such a limited scope.

You can have your views until the cows come home for all I care, the "pat on your head" may have been condescending but that was mainly because I realized I was debating an issue with someone who wouldn't believe what I was saying because it never happened to her cousin's husband Gord, up near Bobcaygeon.

and while I base my arguments on Union membership on my own personal experience within OPSEU(One of the largest Unions in the Country, that went on strike while I was a member) none of my views on Unions in general come from my personal life experience. I'm am not trying to curtail your posting your views but just giving a word of advice.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

Weevil said:
1) The minimum wage is around because of union members changing the way the world sees the workplace. At issue isn't so much whether or not Warren Buffet agrees with the minimum wage as it is whether or not JP Morgan did.
True enough. But if the right-wing mantra were "profit at all costs," they'd be rolling back all of the workers' gains. I don't see Mitch McConnell saying we need to abolish the Child Labor laws.

Weevil said:
2) Increased pay for workers works because that increases the quality of life for their families, increases their children's chances of becoming one of the educated elite, goes back into the system so it can pay for shiney, shiney tanks.
Again, that's fine and I have nothing wrong with that. A company should have the responsibility to pay their employees a fair wage for the work that they do. My objection to the transit strike is that it seems to me, on balance, that they're already paid more than generously.

If, for whatever reason, the City had money just laying around, and the workers didn't think they were getting their due share of it, then I'd be more supportive — as I would if an extremely profitable private company refused to share their windfalls with the people who make their business work. But the City is in some pretty deep shit, and the transit workers are exploiting their position as a vital part of the City's operations to try to squeeze more money out of them at the expense of everything else the City needs to be doing. That offends me.

If the roles were reversed, and the City had plenty of money and the workers were strapped, you and REDWAVE would bemoan the situation and demand the City stop being so selfish. Why should it be different now?

Weevil said:
3) I don't know enough about the New York situation to comment on it but if that is true than where do you think Unions are compared to Companies in terms of doing crappy, sleazy things? George Steinbrenner just eliminated Yankee employees dental coverage so he can pay Sterling Hitchcock for a couple of weeks. That is why Unions exist. So excuse me if I hold my nose during the rare opportunity when a Union has a chance to shove it to a Billionaire.
I think it's a case-by-case basis. There are, I'm sure, some unions that do the right thing, just as there are some corporations that do right by their employees. There are some owners who are greedy fucks (Steinbrenner being a model example), and some unions who are more concerned about their coffee breaks than the overall productivity and responsibility to the people that pay them to do their jobs.

I can't very well say that REDWAVE is wrong for supporting unions no matter what, painting corporations with such a broad brush, then turn around and say that all corporations are better negotiators than unions.

I can understand why someone might get a little thrill when a group of relatively modest people have an opportunity to screw rich guys. Doesn't make it right, though.

TB4p
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:

Weevil said:
Indeed, your views are less valid not because they differ from mine but because they are based on a such a limited scope.

You can have your views until the cows come home for all I care, the "pat on your head" may have been condescending but that was mainly because I realized I was debating an issue with someone who wouldn't believe what I was saying because it never happened to her cousin's husband Gord, up near Bobcaygeon.

and while I base my arguments on Union membership on my own personal experience within OPSEU(One of the largest Unions in the Country, that went on strike while I was a member) none of my views on Unions in general come from my personal life experience. I'm am not trying to curtail your posting your views but just giving a word of advice.

Actually I wouldn't believe what you were saying because you never offered me one argument to make me want to change my mind. At least Saint Peter was able to come with legitimate reasons that unions were necessary in some cases - you on the other hand shared with me details of your own job and union, and did nothing to show me a different way of thinking on this.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: What about the bosses?

teddybear4play said:
True enough. But if the right-wing mantra were "profit at all costs," they'd be rolling back all of the workers' gains. I don't see Mitch McConnell saying we need to abolish the Child Labor laws.

Again, that's fine and I have nothing wrong with that. A company should have the responsibility to pay their employees a fair wage for the work that they do. My objection to the transit strike is that it seems to me, on balance, that they're already paid more than generously.

If, for whatever reason, the City had money just laying around, and the workers didn't think they were getting their due share of it, then I'd be more supportive — as I would if an extremely profitable private company refused to share their windfalls with the people who make their business work. But the City is in some pretty deep shit, and the transit workers are exploiting their position as a vital part of the City's operations to try to squeeze more money out of them at the expense of everything else the City needs to be doing. That offends me.

If the roles were reversed, and the City had plenty of money and the workers were strapped, you and REDWAVE would bemoan the situation and demand the City stop being so selfish. Why should it be different now?

I

I think we're pretty much on the same page here so I'd throw in three points.

1) Mitch McConnel, whoever that may be, isn't calling for an end to child labour laws true, but I happen to think that's in part because of the positive changes Unions have made to society. The Corporations can't "roll back" all union gains because the Unions have a major political party in their pocket, just like the corporations do. Change that balance and you might see Weevil Jr. sewing CK labels before you know it.

2) Companies, in the wake of September 11th, did not change the way they do business out of Sympathy for New Yorkers. Viacom did not lower the cost of movie tickets to make it easier for Cops to take their kids to see Shrek, A&P didn't lower prices to help out those suddenly without the breadwinner in the family. Why should Unions change the way they operate because of 9/11 but nobody else?

(As to your question about the situation being reversed I don't know. On the one hand I'd be in favour of the Transit employees making good money, because everyone should make good money, but on the other hand I have other ideas on how to spend that money for the good of new york)

3) Your theory seems to be based on the idea that the ultimate power lies within the Company. Companies "treat their employees right" or act "generously" but I think there is a balance of power. You need someone signing the checks, you need someone to actually fry the chicken. Companies have accountants to make sure their interests are maintained, Unions have employees.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re:

Freya2 said:
Actually I wouldn't believe what you were saying because you never offered me one argument to make me want to change my mind. At least Saint Peter was able to come with legitimate reasons that unions were necessary in some cases - you on the other hand shared with me details of your own job and union, and did nothing to show me a different way of thinking on this.

Well, and vague historical precedents. But aside from this little issue I was mainly thinking of the Smoking Ban one. I offered my experiences here to show you an example of some of the positive aspects of being in a Union(Because you said how unneccesary you believe all Unions to be) can be a positive and neccesary thing.

The fact that you couldn't take something mentioned in personal experience(The added level of Bureaucracy involved in reviewing thousands of employees) and see how it applies on a larger scale(There are lots of big Unions) can't really be held against me, can it?
 
Back
Top