Let's Hear It for the First Amendment!!

Thanks Ish. I never thought when I got here that I'd even stand on even footing with you. Now I wonder why you used to look so wise when you're really just what Vette used to be. I guess we all grow up and the people we looked up to eventually turn out to be just tiny, insignificant, ignorant people.

In the dialectic you're still fare behind. You can proclaim yourself even, or ahead, as is your right under the first amendment.

You aren't a match, you're an amusement.

Ishmael
 
In the dialectic you're still fare behind. You can proclaim yourself even, or ahead, as is your right under the first amendment.

You aren't a match, you're an amusement.

Ishmael

Ah. I love it when the impotent one speaks as if he's someone.

Do you have a patent on impotence?
 
Kid was stupid enough to wear a t-shirt with a gun on it, whether it said NRA or not to school. Given the amount of gun violence at schools, it should be a no-brainer that wearing a t-shirt with a gun on it isn't going to go over well. Then he makes a scene and says he wont't take it off. To top all of that off, he now says they are trying to take away his second amendment.

Boo-fucking-hoo.

You cannot commit an act of violence with a t-shirt. Any rule prohibiting such attire is a violation of the First Amendment.

You should say "Boo-hoo-hoo" over this clear infringement of the First Amendment.
 
His shirt wasn't offensive. He was.

I agree his shirt was not offensive. However, the authorities claimed it was offensive, which was why they ordered him to remove it. Such an order, being a violation of his First Amendment rights, was not lawful; therefore he was right to refuse to follow it.

Courts have always ruled that laws and rules and regulations that are contrary to the US Constitution are invalid at their inception and need not be obeyed.
 
Ah. I love it when the impotent one speaks as if he's someone.

Do you have a patent on impotence?

Ahh, it's like being double-teamed by the whores up around Connecticut and S, the 'International whore District.' For the most part a higher class of whore than your average congressmen or senator, they were honest about what they did, or wanted.

The whores, unlike you, pretty much stayed on subject. Giving a decided advantage to the whores.

Ishmael
 
You cannot commit an act of violence with a t-shirt. Any rule prohibiting such attire is a violation of the First Amendment.

You should say "Boo-hoo-hoo" over this clear infringement of the First Amendment.

If a school determines that an image of a gun is a violation of their rule against clothing that depicts violence, then they are allowed to have him remove the shirt, or send him home for the day.

Schools have a much broader power over "speech" than does the government. They are minors, there to be educated.
 
In the dialectic you're still fare behind. You can proclaim yourself even, or ahead, as is your right under the first amendment.

You aren't a match, you're an amusement.

Ishmael


Their rules don't mention violence in any way. When i was reading about Tinker it was mentioned how schools have a broader scope to restrict speech. I guess assuming it is a reasonable rule.
 
I visited a local school that displays most of the state's flags in its commons. I counted the flags, and 2-3 were missing: Mississippi and Georgia. I asked the principal about it, and he said the flags offend him. He's black.

Another school I went to prohibited Christian symbols amongst their Winter Holiday displays. But they featured symbols from all the other religions. They patiently explained to me that the Christian symbols offend some people. The others are included because its discrimination to omit them.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Their rules don't mention violence in any way. When i was reading about Tinker it was mentioned how schools have a broader scope to restrict speech. I guess assuming it is a reasonable rule.

The content is neither lewd nor vulgar, so it fits under Tinker, not Fraser.

And you are right, a high school student's First Amendment rights are circumscribed in light of the school's academic mission. They, students, still have rights, though.

The question, then, is the T-shirt likely to lead to a substantial and material disruption? My guess is that the NRA is pretty noncontroversial in that school district.
 
The content is neither lewd nor vulgar, so it fits under Tinker, not Fraser.

And you are right, a high school student's First Amendment rights are circumscribed in light of the school's academic mission. They, students, still have rights, though.

The question, then, is the T-shirt likely to lead to a substantial and material disruption? My guess is that the NRA is pretty noncontroversial in that school district.

But then does a large gun on a shirt fit under the violence section of the rules?
 
Can schools have dress codes? Yes or no.

That's the whole question.

Whether you think a particular dress code is stupid or not is irrelevant. Get with the program or get on the school board.
 
Last edited:
Can schools have dress codes? Yes or no.

That's the whole question.

Whether you think a particular dress code is stupid or not is irrelevant. Get with the program or get on the school board.

There is another question. Does the dress code cover the shirt in question.
 
But then does a large gun on a shirt fit under the violence section of the rules?

If it were a T-shirt that glorified the Columbine incident, or that contained the slogan "...let God sort them out," then probably yes.

But guns have nonviolent as well as violent uses. The NRA historically educated people in nonviolent uses of firearms. It's more than that, now, of course; it's a political animal; that does not help the school, though, since that transforms the message into a type of political speech.
 
There is another question. Does the dress code cover the shirt in question.
Most places I've seen that has one, some of that is left at the manager's (or in this case the teachers') discretion.
 
You cannot commit an act of violence with a t-shirt. Any rule prohibiting such attire is a violation of the First Amendment.

You should say "Boo-hoo-hoo" over this clear infringement of the First Amendment.

Except the Constitution applies to the federal government, not to states, counties or schools. More to the point though students don't have freedom of speech (really nobody does but that's another issue) . Again I don't see anybody up in arms about the thousands of schools that don't allow earrings, colored laces, sports jerseys or tube tops.

I agree his shirt was not offensive. However, the authorities claimed it was offensive, which was why they ordered him to remove it. Such an order, being a violation of his First Amendment rights, was not lawful; therefore he was right to refuse to follow it.

Courts have always ruled that laws and rules and regulations that are contrary to the US Constitution are invalid at their inception and need not be obeyed.

It's not a matter of offensive or not. It's a matter of the school said no. Nothing more, nothing less.
 
He was allowed to wear the shirt, but only inside out. That's a reasonable compromise for the situation. If the shirt somehow manifests "free speech", there's no infringement - he's still got the shirt on.

He refused. That's not acceptable behavior for a student.
 
I visited a local school that displays most of the state's flags in its commons. I counted the flags, and 2-3 were missing: Mississippi and Georgia. I asked the principal about it, and he said the flags offend him. He's black.

Another school I went to prohibited Christian symbols amongst their Winter Holiday displays. But they featured symbols from all the other religions. They patiently explained to me that the Christian symbols offend some people. The others are included because its discrimination to omit them.


You "visited" a school (nothing at all weird about that) and decided, what the hell, I think I'll count their flags?

I call bullshit on that and even more so on your second paragraph.
 
You "visited" a school (nothing at all weird about that) and decided, what the hell, I think I'll count their flags?

I call bullshit on that and even more so on your second paragraph.

Then a Democrat parked his car on his granddaughter's femurs and calmly filled up with gas while she was screaming in agony. Or maybe that was before he started visiting schools, not sure.
 
You "visited" a school (nothing at all weird about that) and decided, what the hell, I think I'll count their flags?

I call bullshit on that and even more so on your second paragraph.

He actually thinks people are going to believe his bullshit, that's the funniest part.
 
If it were a T-shirt that glorified the Columbine incident, or that contained the slogan "...let God sort them out," then probably yes.

But guns have nonviolent as well as violent uses. The NRA historically educated people in nonviolent uses of firearms. It's more than that, now, of course; it's a political animal; that does not help the school, though, since that transforms the message into a type of political speech.

Hold up... what non-violent use does a gun have? Every time I've used a gun it's been for violence. Not against humans, but still violent.
 
Back
Top