Let's Hear It for the First Amendment!!

What's the purpose of a sledge hammer?

Are they sometimes used to destroy rocks or to tear apart structures?

Is a paper target "harmed" when it is shot?

Yes. The target is destroyed.

And they have the gaul to charge like $10 for them. That always pissed me off.

The last pack I bought had zombies on them though. So I felt a little less bad about it.
 
SCOTUS ruled long ago that when the Constitution say "Congress shall pass no law..." that same prohibition applied to lower governments also.



It's a matter of the school having unfair and capricious rules and of this courageous boy refusing to be bullied by them. Rosa Parks, anybody?

To the first half of your comment. Chicago, New York, California, soon to be New Jersey seem to all have passed enough laws restricting Firearms that the if the SCOTUS did infact rule as you claim (I assume you're right) it's clearly either unenforcible or simply not enforced.

As for unfair rules, I keep giving a list of other unfair rules and nobody is arguing against them. Cell phones and video games aren't allowed either on most schools, certainly not in the On position.

If you want to compare a kid choosing to wear something agains tthe rules with someone being born against the rules. Fine. The buses primarily changed their rules after being boycotted though not because the government came down but whatever. It's not like it needs to make logical sense here.
 
They were talking about nuking Deep Water Horizon. That doesn't change the primary purpose of a nuke. People have been murdered by being held under water in pools, that doesn't change the primary purpose of a pool. Guns have been used in a pinch as splints and screwdrivers have been used as prybars. None of which changes it's primary purpose.

So?

It's still overbroad because they have other uses.

And your analysis is still irrelevant. The legal question is whether that T-shirt will foreseeably cause a "material and substantial disruption of school activities or invasion of the rights of other students"?

I cannot imagine an NRA T-shirt with a large firearm causing any sort of disruption in a school in West Virginia. It sure as hell would not here.
 
Last edited:
To the first half of your comment. Chicago, New York, California, soon to be New Jersey seem to all have passed enough laws restricting Firearms that the if the SCOTUS did infact rule as you claim (I assume you're right) it's clearly either unenforcible or simply not enforced.

As for unfair rules, I keep giving a list of other unfair rules and nobody is arguing against them. Cell phones and video games aren't allowed either on most schools, certainly not in the On position.

If you want to compare a kid choosing to wear something agains tthe rules with someone being born against the rules. Fine. The buses primarily changed their rules after being boycotted though not because the government came down but whatever. It's not like it needs to make logical sense here.

We brought our phones to school too.

...my school was REALLY shitty though. They just didn't give a fuck about anything.
 
SCOTUS ruled long ago that when the Constitution say "Congress shall pass no law..." that same prohibition applied to lower governments also.

This is stupid and superficial. Reread the Heller opinion. And the kid's Second Amendment rights are not being violated under any stretch of the imagination.
 
So?

It's still overbroad because they have other uses.

And your analysis is still irrelevant. The legal question is whether that T-shirt will foreseeably cause a "material and substantial disruption of school activities or invasion of the rights of other students"?

I cannot imagine an NRA T-shirt with a large firearm causing any sort of disruption in a school in West Virginia. It sure as hell would not here.

They don't really have other proper uses.

As for a disruption of school activities, that's 100% in the eye of the beholder. It's no different from yamalka, hijab, Angels hat, earring, tube top or open toed shoe. All of which are banned at most schools. The reality is that dress code violations are a catch all at schools that can be applied pretty much equally to anything.

This is stupid and superficial. Reread the Heller opinion. And the kid's Second Amendment rights are not being violated under any stretch of the imagination.

Of course they are. . .not sure how. . .wait. You can strangle someone with a shirt. Since you argue that any use of an object is legit I'm labeling my shirt as a weapon.
 
Yep. Get that kid. And treat him the same way you do Boy Scouts who forgot to take the pocket knife out of their backpack when they came back from a hike, and the kid who had a GI. Joe doll complete with plastic gun, and the girl who's shirt is a few sizes to short and maybe bares her midriff if she moves the wrong way.
 
They don't really have other proper uses.

As for a disruption of school activities, that's 100% in the eye of the beholder. It's no different from yamalka, hijab, Angels hat, earring, tube top or open toed shoe. All of which are banned at most schools. The reality is that dress code violations are a catch all at schools that can be applied pretty much equally to anything.



Of course they are. . .not sure how. . .wait. You can strangle someone with a shirt. Since you argue that any use of an object is legit I'm labeling my shirt as a weapon.

Your First Amendment analysis is approaching the sophistication of Vette's argument that the First Amendment is not implicated by Florida's banning physicians from asking patients about guns.

In this First Amendment case, Alan Newsom (Newsom), a student at Jack Jouett Middle School (Jouett) in Albemarle County, Virginia, by and through his parent and next friend, Fred Newsom, appeals from a district court order denying his motion for a preliminary injunction seeking to enjoin the enforcement of the portion of Jouett's 2002-2003 dress code which prohibits “messages on clothing, jewelry, and personal belongings that relate to ․ weapons.”  

* * *

Newsom posits that the 2002-2003 Jouett Dress Code is overbroad because (1) it applies to nonviolent and nonthreatening images/messages related to weapons and (2) there is a dearth of evidence demonstrating that the display of images/messages related to weapons, nonviolent, nonthreatening, or otherwise, would substantially disrupt school operations or interfere with the rights of others.[/B]

We begin our overbreadth analysis by noting that there simply is no evidence in the record (as the record has developed through the preliminary injunction stage of the case) demonstrating that clothing worn by students at Jouett containing messages related to weapons, nonviolent, nonthreatening, or otherwise, ever substantially disrupted school operations or interfered with the rights of others.   Indeed, there is no evidence that Newsom's t-shirt, let alone any other article of clothing worn by a student that contained a message relating to weapons, ever caused a commotion or was going to cause one at Jouett.   This lack of evidence strongly suggests that the ban on messages related to weapons was not necessary to maintain order and discipline at Jouett.7

Turning to the language of the 2002-2003 Jouett Dress Code, when we examine the code in view of the fact that there was no evidence presented at the preliminary injunction stage of the case demonstrating that clothing worn by students at Jouett containing messages related to weapons, nonviolent, nonthreatening, or otherwise, ever substantially disrupted school operations or interfered with the rights of others, the 2002-2003 Jouett Dress Code can be understood as reaching lawful, nonviolent, and nonthreatening symbols of not only popular, but important organizations and ideals.   For example, the State Seal of the Commonwealth of Virginia depicts a woman standing with one foot on the chest of a vanquished tyrant, holding a spear.   The symbol obviously depicts a woman holding a weapon.   Thus, under the 2002-2003 Jouett Dress Code, a student may not wear or carry any items bearing the State Seal of the Commonwealth of Virginia.   Likewise, the symbol of the University of Virginia's athletic mascot-the Cavalier-is two crossed sabers.   This symbol also relates to weapons.   According to the Virginia Attorney General, the symbol is used throughout Charlottesville to direct visitors to the university's football stadium and other facilities and simply to promote the university's athletics.   Ironically, Albemarle County High School, which is located across the street from Jack Jouett Middle School, uses the image of a patriot armed with a musket as its own mascot.   Various clothing depicting support for the University of Virginia and Albemarle County High School by way of the schools' mascots would be banned under the 2002-2003 Jouett Dress Code.

* * *

On April 29, 2002, during the student lunch period at Jouett, Elizabeth Pitt (Pitt), an assistant principal at Jouett, observed Newsom, who at the time was a twelve-year-old student in the sixth grade at Jouett, sitting at a table on the opposite side of the cafeteria with his back towards her.1  Pitt's attention was drawn to Newsom by his purple t-shirt, which depicted three black silhouettes of men holding firearms superimposed on the letters “NRA” positioned above the phrase “SHOOTING SPORTS CAMP.” Although the men appear to be aiming their firearms, the t-shirt did not indicate what or whom their targets may be.   The front of the t-shirt bore a smaller but identical version of the men superimposed on the initials “NRA,” but no other writing or symbols.

* * *

Aside from these non-controversial symbols, the 2002-2003 Jouett Dress Code would apparently distinguish between a t-shirt bearing a peace sign and the message “No War” and one with a picture of an army tank in desert camouflage that urges support for our troops.   Similarly, it would prevent a student from wearing a t-shirt bearing the insignia of many of the fighting units engaged in overseas operations in which parents or siblings may serve.   Banning support for or affiliation with the myriad of organizations and institutions that include weapons (displayed in a nonviolent and nonthreatening manner) in their insignia can hardly be deemed reasonably related to the maintenance of a safe or distraction-free school.   Finally, the quintessential political message the school here is trying to promote-“Guns and School Don't Mix”-would, under a reasonable interpretation, be prohibited on clothing under the 2002-2003 Jouett Dress Code.
 
This is stupid and superficial. Reread the Heller opinion. And the kid's Second Amendment rights are not being violated under any stretch of the imagination.

LMAO. I think SCOTUS decisions are a bit above his reading level. Start him off with The Cat Sat on the Mat and we'll see where it goes from there.
 
Elliot, you do know that you for serious can't wear any of those shirts to school? Interestingly that Axel Rose one you just posted is a real shirt and I knew a guy who had to change out of it.
 
You're actually not supposed to wear anything with a logo, so that one would be out even without the gun.
 
It's become very popular to speak of eroding liberties and adopt faux-libertarianism roughly since the office of president was filled with an uppity neggra. Because most of those doing the faux-libertarianing have never libertarianed before, they're a bit slapdash about it. They know it has SOMETHING to do with the Constitution and unalienable rights and the like, but they're never quite sure how, say, a school dress code fits in to all this. So they wait to see what the blogosphere lights up with, and then noisily tag along for the ride, wrapped in an American flag and fitted with a handy pull-tab that makes prepackaged streams of verbal outrage spill from their slack jaws with stunning consistency and regularity.

However, listen closely to those Handy Patriotic Fun PhrasesTM, and you'll hear something else. Lean way in. Listen close. Yup, there it is:

"Ain't no goddamned dirty nigger gonna tell me what to do."
 
Last edited:
Maybe I'm crazy, isn't the MI3 poster have a gun?

And I'm unclear how Hollywood is encouraging kids to break school rules. Is the NRA encouraging kids to break school rules? I'm constantly hearing about how "Back in my day we all had gun racks on our trucks and nobody batted an eye." Is the video game industry encouraging kids to bring game to school?
 
I can't believe they have such absurd school dress codes......it's a public babysitting service not a fucking prep academy. :rolleyes:
 
Elliot, you do know that you for serious can't wear any of those shirts to school? Interestingly that Axel Rose one you just posted is a real shirt and I knew a guy who had to change out of it.

Yes, that was kind of the point. I know it's a real shirt. Some guys I knew wore it - to school. With no problems whatsoever. Of course, this was back in the 80s/90s.

I could've worn it too, but I didn't own one/want one. What I couldn't wear was short shorts or a skirt that rose above mid-thigh, even though the cheerleaders' uniform skirts were well above that. We actually had a big protest about that rule, which included a bunch of the boys wearing short skirts (there was no rule against the boys wearing them!), and about 80% of the school skipping out on the second half of classes for a week. They actually changed the policy as a result, and there was much rejoicing.

I remember once having a cassette tape of the GnR Lies album that I took to school, and the art for it included a picture of a naked woman with the naughty bits thinly blacked out. An obnoxious kid ripped it out of my hand and waved in front of the teacher, "Hey, Mr. W! She's got porn!" Mr. W. took the tape from him, rolled his eyes, and handed it back to me.

Reminiscing on Redoubt,
Ellie
 
Yes, that was kind of the point. I know it's a real shirt. Some guys I knew wore it - to school. With no problems whatsoever. Of course, this was back in the 80s/90s.

I could've worn it too, but I didn't own one/want one. What I couldn't wear was short shorts or a skirt that rose above mid-thigh, even though the cheerleaders' uniform skirts were well above that. We actually had a big protest about that rule, which included a bunch of the boys wearing short skirts (there was no rule against the boys wearing them!), and about 80% of the school skipping out on the second half of classes for a week. They actually changed the policy as a result, and there was much rejoicing.

I remember once having a cassette tape of the GnR Lies album that I took to school, and the art for it included a picture of a naked woman with the naughty bits thinly blacked out. An obnoxious kid ripped it out of my hand and waved in front of the teacher, "Hey, Mr. W! She's got porn!" Mr. W. took the tape from him, rolled his eyes, and handed it back to me.

Reminiscing on Redoubt,
Ellie

I guess what I don't understand is why you keep posting Google images of shirts you can't wear to school. I'm not saying that you shouldn't. I literally don't get it.
 
wow. an old man who enjoys talking and writing about underage sex starts a thread on school dress codes for minors, and the GB fulfills his fantasies.
 
I guess what I don't understand is why you keep posting Google images of shirts you can't wear to school. I'm not saying that you shouldn't. I literally don't get it.

Question is why can't you wear them to school??:confused:

http://www.rockworldeast.com/dimage/zoom/6387.jpg

^^ only T shirt in MS/HS I was ever asked to change.....other than that we could pretty much wear w/e we wanted.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top