Let's Hear It for the First Amendment!!

Hold up... what non-violent use does a gun have? Every time I've used a gun it's been for violence. Not against humans, but still violent.
It dispels evil, like holding up a cross. Evil is cowed because a cross is a symbol of execution, like a gun.
 
First of all, it's a weapon. Of course it's violent. Second and more importantly the schools have the right to set whatever rules they wish. Get back to me when you're up in arms about guys not being able to go to school with earrings (which is the only reason I don't have any piercings, it was forbidden for 12 years of my life and I simply don't care enough now) or when you care about kids being restricted from having colored shoe strings or certain sports logos on their shirts (most notably the Raiders).

The rules are the rules and you follow them.



ROFL. PArt of their heritage? If I didn't know you were serious I'd laugh my ass off.

You weren't allowed to wear earrings to school? I had half my fucking face pierced and nobody said shit to me. Or anyone else. We didn't have any kind of anti-piercing thing. I never set off the detectors either... which led me to believe they didn't actually detect shit.
 
Nope, no piercings for males, no colored shoe laces, no hats, no Jerseys. For girls no strapless tops/dresses, no short skirts (definition of short was whatever annoyed the teacher). Nothing that represented or could represent drugs (had to wear my Gym shirt once because Mario+Mushrooms=drugs). Those are just the rules.
 
when i hear of shit like this i am always reminded of the movie, demolition man.

wonder what would happen if i wore a t-shirt with a pic of a vagina on it?
 
Hold up... what non-violent use does a gun have? Every time I've used a gun it's been for violence. Not against humans, but still violent.

Skeet shooting.

Target shooting.

Self defense, which may result in violence but does not necessarily result in violence.

Hunting, though meeting a strict definition of violence, probably would not trigger the school code definition of violence--that definition is probably tied to humans and their possessions.
 
Today that kid is wearing an orange jumpsuit.

And nobody will sit next to him during lunch.
 
Nope, no piercings for males, no colored shoe laces, no hats, no Jerseys. For girls no strapless tops/dresses, no short skirts (definition of short was whatever annoyed the teacher). Nothing that represented or could represent drugs (had to wear my Gym shirt once because Mario+Mushrooms=drugs). Those are just the rules.

We had everything on that list except the piercings. My mom would have raised hell if they said "no piercings for boys" but it was ok for girls. We had people raise hell until they let boys wear skirts. For some reason there was a kilt fad at the time... Appearantly there was a metal band with guys who wore kilts? I remember them and their bagpipes, but I can't remember the name- anyway, my point is, how did parents not complain over that? Most people have at least their ears pierced.

I only ever got in trouble one time over clothes. I was wearing a T-shirt that had a pentagram or a satanic cross or something on it and I threw a bitch fit, not because I cared but because I was like 14 and knew that if I threw a bitch fit I could get out of class. The principal called my mom, and my mom is a bitch, so she was like, "I SWEAR TO GOD IF COME UP THERE AND BRING HIM ANOTHER SHIRT BECAUSE THIS ONE HAS RELIGIOUS SYMBOLS THAT YOU DON'T LIKE AND I SEE ONE BITCH WEARING A CROSS NECKLACE I WILL SLIT YOUR FUCKING THROAT! I WILL CALL THE ACLU! I WILL SHUT YOU MOTHERFUCKERS DOWN! JOHN PAUL (the superintendent, who she was fucking) AND I WILL HAVE SOME MOTHERFUCKING WORDS!"

Long story short, he asked me if I wanted to go back to class or go home. I went home. They learned really fast that you had to hate me or my brother /really/ bad to punish us, because my mom was a giant bitch and my dad was a cop who was also a giant bitch, who was horribly neglectful and liked to forget that he had kids at all, so if he had to take time out of his fat-ass day to talk to a teacher or something, there would be hell to pay. I wore shirts with guns on them all the time, if you count stuff like game shirts. No one noticed.
 
when i hear of shit like this i am always reminded of the movie, demolition man.

wonder what would happen if i wore a t-shirt with a pic of a vagina on it?

Demolition Man? Isn't that the "liberal" utopia where violence has become so unheard of that when there is a murder every policeman (except the ancient fossil) look at each other wondering what the hell a 187 means because one hasn't occured in over twenty years? Sure it wasn't perfect, there were sewer people eating rat burgers because beef was outlawed or something but cars also drove their damnselves.

Skeet shooting.

Target shooting.

Self defense, which may result in violence but does not necessarily result in violence.

Hunting, though meeting a strict definition of violence, probably would not trigger the school code definition of violence--that definition is probably tied to humans and their possessions.

Can I count closing deep water oil spills, testing and asteroid destruction as non-violent uses of nuclear weapons?
 
Can I count closing deep water oil spills, testing and asteroid destruction as non-violent uses of nuclear weapons?

You can count it as you see fit.

The school has to count it from the standard of whether it is foreseeable that its depiction will cause a substantial material disruption in the school.

That shirt may cause a substantial disruption in a school in Newtown right now.

Seems to me it's non-threatening and non-disruptive in a W.V. school.
 
Skeet shooting.

Target shooting.

Self defense, which may result in violence but does not necessarily result in violence.

Hunting, though meeting a strict definition of violence, probably would not trigger the school code definition of violence--that definition is probably tied to humans and their possessions.

All of those things are violent. Violence is something that results in destruction. You destroy targets and those little plates. You kill the deer. You hurt the person attacking you.

You think of violence negatively. It's not. Just because something isn't negative doesn't mean it isn't violent.
 
Demolition Man? Isn't that the "liberal" utopia where violence has become so unheard of that when there is a murder every policeman (except the ancient fossil) look at each other wondering what the hell a 187 means because one hasn't occured in over twenty years? Sure it wasn't perfect, there were sewer people eating rat burgers because beef was outlawed or something but cars also drove their damnselves.



Can I count closing deep water oil spills, testing and asteroid destruction as non-violent uses of nuclear weapons?

Holy fucking shit you guys have no idea how much I love Demolition Man.
 
Skeet shooting.

Target shooting.

Self defense, which may result in violence but does not necessarily result in violence.

Hunting, though meeting a strict definition of violence, probably would not trigger the school code definition of violence--that definition is probably tied to humans and their possessions.
For the cost of a couple of shotguns, you could buy your own Big Buck arcade console, shoot rain or shine, in season or out, and never run out of bullets.

http://www.bmigaming.com/bigbuckhunter-big-buck-hd-models.htm
 
All of those things are violent. Violence is something that results in destruction. You destroy targets and those little plates. You kill the deer. You hurt the person attacking you.

You think of violence negatively. It's not. Just because something isn't negative doesn't mean it isn't violent.

Self defense can but does not necessarily result in violence. Brandishing a weapon may be enough.

Using your definition, though, do you think the dress code permits the school to suspend a student for wearing a Habitat or Humanity T-shirt depicting a carpenter nailing a shingle to a roof because he has used a hammer violently on the nail, shingle, and roof?
 
You can count it as you see fit.

The school has to count it from the standard of whether it is foreseeable that its depiction will cause a substantial material disruption in the school.

That shirt may cause a substantial disruption in a school in Newtown right now.

Seems to me it's non-threatening and non-disruptive in a W.V. school.

It's completely non-threatening, it may or may not be non-disruptive. Disruption is pretty much dominated by a combination of the student's actions and the teachers reactions. I highly doubt that most (perhaps you cjh, I admit I don't pay much attention to you) of the people up in arms here would be saying anything if this was about a woman in a Hijab, or a kid with earrings. Every few months we hear about a boy wearing a dress or a girl wearing a tux to prom and the Right never seems to give a shit about freedom of speech THEN.

Self defense can but does not necessarily result in violence. Brandishing a weapon may be enough.

Using your definition, though, do you think the dress code permits the school to suspend a student for wearing a Habitat or Humanity T-shirt depicting a carpenter nailing a shingle to a roof because he has used a hammer violently on the nail, shingle, and roof?

Stupid comparison. A gun is designed to harm, a hammer is designed to build. Maybe if you had a guy with a sword on his shirt you'd have an argument worthy of discussion.
 
Kid was stupid enough to wear a t-shirt with a gun on it, whether it said NRA or not to school. Given the amount of gun violence at schools, it should be a no-brainer that wearing a t-shirt with a gun on it isn't going to go over well. Then he makes a scene and says he wont't take it off. To top all of that off, he now says they are trying to take away his second amendment.

Boo-fucking-hoo.

Given the amount of gun violence in Chicago!

God Forbid you wear Chicago Bears, Bulls, Black Hawks, Cubs or White Sox T-Shirts.

Since Jan. 1, 2012 Chicago police have recorded 2,364 shooting incidents and 487 homicides and counting.............................
 
He was allowed to wear the shirt, but only inside out. That's a reasonable compromise for the situation. If the shirt somehow manifests "free speech", there's no infringement - he's still got the shirt on.

He refused. That's not acceptable behavior for a student.

Are you saying that objecting to be bullied is not accectable behavior or that knuckling under and relinquishing one's Constitutional rights is acceptable behavior? :eek:
 
Last edited:
Self defense can but does not necessarily result in violence. Brandishing a weapon may be enough.

Using your definition, though, do you think the dress code permits the school to suspend a student for wearing a Habitat or Humanity T-shirt depicting a carpenter nailing a shingle to a roof because he has used a hammer violently on the nail, shingle, and roof?

Hammers don't destroy/hurt nails. They nail them into things to build things. If it's just a hammer, devoid of nails though, then yes, you could. In the teacher's handbook, it says that you can call a kid out for pretty much anything. I've been the teacher, and i won't call a kid out for anything. You could wear a shirt with a porn scene or a beer ad in my classroom and I don't give a fuck. I wouldn't have noticed he had it on, actually, because I don't notice what students wear, I notice their behavior.

Having said that, I've also, as stated above, been that kid. And I can tell you right now he doesn't give a fuck about free speech, he wants to get out of class, and he wants to throw a bitch fit for attention. He's in 8th grade, so he's 13. He's not been hurt, he's a whiny bitch. I, too, am a whiny bitch, so I don't think that what he's done is wrong. It is, however, bitchy.
 
Given the amount of gun violence in Chicago!

God Forbid you wear Chicago Bears, Bulls, Black Hawks, Cubs or White Sox T-Shirts.

Since Jan. 1, 2012 Chicago police have recorded 2,364 shooting incidents and 487 homicides and counting.............................

Those shirts are banned in every school I went to along with Raiders, Lions and a few others. Pretty much Silver and Black, Blue or Red are all forbidden. Along with colored laces and earrings. I assume you have another argument?

Are you saying that objecting to be bullied is not accectable behavior or that knuckling under and relinquishing one's Constitutional rights is acceptable behavior.

Yes. Especially since the Constitution only prevents the federal government, states can still do as they please and so can schools which are usually run by the county.
 
It's completely non-threatening, it may or may not be non-disruptive. Disruption is pretty much dominated by a combination of the student's actions and the teachers reactions. I highly doubt that most (perhaps you cjh, I admit I don't pay much attention to you) of the people up in arms here would be saying anything if this was about a woman in a Hijab, or a kid with earrings. Every few months we hear about a boy wearing a dress or a girl wearing a tux to prom and the Right never seems to give a shit about freedom of speech THEN.



Stupid comparison. A gun is designed to harm, a hammer is designed to build. Maybe if you had a guy with a sword on his shirt you'd have an argument worthy of discussion.

What's the purpose of a sledge hammer?

Are they sometimes used to destroy rocks or to tear apart structures?

Is a paper target "harmed" when it is shot?
 
Except the Constitution applies to the federal government, not to states, counties or schools. More to the point though students don't have freedom of speech (really nobody does but that's another issue) . Again I don't see anybody up in arms about the thousands of schools that don't allow earrings, colored laces, sports jerseys or tube tops.
SCOTUS ruled long ago that when the Constitution say "Congress shall pass no law..." that same prohibition applied to lower governments also.

It's not a matter of offensive or not. It's a matter of the school said no. Nothing more, nothing less.

It's a matter of the school having unfair and capricious rules and of this courageous boy refusing to be bullied by them. Rosa Parks, anybody?
 
Are you saying that objecting to be bullied is not accectable behavior or that knuckling under and relinquishing one's Constitutional rights is acceptable behavior.
Yes, when you're faced with a teacher, police officer, drill sergeant or other authority figure.

You might not understand, since you haven't gone to school yet.
 
What's the purpose of a sledge hammer?

Are they sometimes used to destroy rocks or to tear apart structures?

Is a paper target "harmed" when it is shot?

They were talking about nuking Deep Water Horizon. That doesn't change the primary purpose of a nuke. People have been murdered by being held under water in pools, that doesn't change the primary purpose of a pool. Guns have been used in a pinch as splints and screwdrivers have been used as prybars. None of which changes it's primary purpose.
 
The student wore the shirt to five classes, without comment or incident, before the teacher of the sixth had a problem with it.

On the first day of his suspension, in protest of what happened, other students wore t-shirts depicting guns. One was told (by guess who?) he was in violation, the others weren't, and none of them was suspended or disciplined, let alone arrested.

The principal and other school officials have declined to comment at all.

In other words, the school is keenly aware that their policy was politically interpreted and abused by one of their teachers, and so was Marcum. He wasn't belligerent, vulgar or disrespectful when he pointed out that his clothing wasn't in violation of policy; he didn't even raise his voice.

I hope he and his family win the case in court.

Plain on Pluto,
Ellie
 
Back
Top