The 2002 World Cup Thread

p_p_man said:


Not this one...

Read the thread title...

:(

Every thread has a title. Every thread starts out with a point in mind. Every thread, well most, occasionally veers off topic. and if people want it to, whatever.
 
Weevil said:


No doubt. Beaten on the goal and committed the foul that led to the penalty.

But, it's just that the make up of the game(Tie but South Korea scores the big equalizer) would lead to a "tie but moral victory for S. Korea" but when you examine it the result favoured the US way more(If Portugal beats poland the US would only need a point against poland to move on)

korea on the other hand needs(again, assuming a Portugal win later today and a US loss to Poland ) would need To then beat Portugal to go through(unless of course the Portugal victory over poland is only 1-0) in which case it would go to goal differential which is getting too convoluted for me.

korea definitely needed the win more. I just don't give a damn how they spin it. That's all. I'm concerned about our team. Their press can hang us in effigy on the front page and call that draw a tremendous triumph in the face of all that is unholy, for all i care. We still get a point in the standings.
 
p_p_man said:
Leave this self pitying, nobody likes us because we're Americans rubbish for a political thread...

I don't think the officiating made any real difference in the outcome of the USA-Korea match but it certainly did seem biased to my untrained eye.

What's you're opinon of the officiating of this world cup? -- Not just this game, but overall. I've not been impressed, and to some extent, neither have the commentators on ESPN2. The refs seem to be "swallowing their whistle" and letting games get a lot rougher than they need be and/or showing some favoritism.
 
Weird Harold said:
I've not been impressed, and to some extent, neither have the commentators on ESPN2. The refs seem to be "swallowing their whistle" and letting games get a lot rougher than they need be and/or showing some favoritism.

Really? How is it usually called? Is a foul called if two players look at each other funny?

I saw a foul called on two guys both going for the ball running into each other, I can't imagine a worse over officiating.
 
fanzee1 said:


korea definitely needed the win more. I just don't give a damn how they spin it. That's all. I'm concerned about our team. Their press can hang us in effigy on the front page and call that draw a tremendous triumph in the face of all that is unholy, for all i care. We still get a point in the standings.

Oh well, I was just pontificating.
 
Weevil said:


Wouldn't surprise me.

I mean, the two host countries here got pretty soft groups and the 98 american group will continue to be a pretty shady looking deal.

I mean, after everything that has gone down in FIFA(From Blatters alleged criminality to the shenanigans surrounding the awarding of the 06 Cup) would fixing groups be that surprising?

England and Argentina together again? Maybe it's all coincedence. Maybe, hell probably, it's just that in a field of 32 there are going to be patterns everyway it slots.

But I doubt it.

I'm not saying it's not rigged. I really have no idea. It's difficult to see how usa's '98 draw is evidence of it though. We played Iran, Germany and Denmark, was it? Germany we certainly weren't going to beat but the others we had a shot against. It's not like they put us in with Brazil, Italy, Argentina. My apologies if Denmark wasn't the third team. I'm a little fuzzy on that.
 
Weevil said:


Oh well, I was just pontificating.


and that's what we're here for!


Anybody else watching tunisia/belgium. Maybe it's just me coming down from the u.s. match but this one ain't exactly thrilling me.
 
QUESTION ABOUT REFEREES

Turkey - strategically, but nevertheless - protested before the game about the referee from Benin, a small African country that doesn't even have its own league.

Do you think that in the light of the World Cup there should only be highly experienced Referee's allowed? Or do you think that other Referee's should be given a chance too?

The Referee in the game Turkey vs Costa Rica was competent, other inexperienced ones were simply horrific.

What would you say?
 
Weevil said:


Really? How is it usually called? Is a foul called if two players look at each other funny?

I saw a foul called on two guys both going for the ball running into each other, I can't imagine a worse over officiating.

That's one of the complaints ESPN2's commentators have made -- the calls are inconsistent. Many calls that should be made aren't, and calls that shouldn't be made are made, often in favor of one team over the other.

The possible fouls that catch my eye are the holding and american football style tackles that aren't noticed by the ref.
 
Weevil said:


No, and Japan is a pretty decent side itself but there's no real Powerhouse in either division. I think it's suspicious to say the least.

FIFA World Rankings (May 2002)

Argentina 2
England 12
Sweden 19
Nigeria 27

Belgium 23
Russia 28
Tunisia 30
Japan 32

Fix or not?
 
Weevil said:


Really? How is it usually called? Is a foul called if two players look at each other funny?

I saw a foul called on two guys both going for the ball running into each other, I can't imagine a worse over officiating.

I dont think I have ever watched a game where everyone has been happy with the ref - there is always going to be " dubious " desicions and when the ref has to make spit second decisions then - there will be marginal calls

The Italians are going crazy saying they were robbed - but as long as refs are human then you will get judgement calls that when they are examined in slow motion from every angle you can usualy find something

On the whole I think the standard has been good
 
Re: QUESTION ABOUT REFEREES

LittleDevilWithAHalo said:
Turkey - strategically, but nevertheless - protested before the game about the referee from Benin, a small African country that doesn't even have its own league.

Do you think that in the light of the World Cup there should only be highly experienced Referee's allowed? Or do you think that other Referee's should be given a chance too?

The Referee in the game Turkey vs Costa Rica was competent, other inexperienced ones were simply horrific.

What would you say?


i think that, in general, when you have big games involving "elite" athletes, it is wise to have a referee from a high-profile league, so that the players will respect him/her. As for the particular issues of this world cup, i'm much more concerned about the linesmen/referee's assistants. The offsides calls in that turkey/costa rica game and many others have been horrible.

I haven't seen one side getting favored over the other, just terrible calls. In some games, like costa rica/turkery, it was so bad you wondered whether the linesmen understood the rule, as silly as that sounds.
 
Re: Re: QUESTION ABOUT REFEREES

fanzee1 said:



i think that, in general, when you have big games involving "elite" athletes, it is wise to have a referee from a high-profile league, so that the players will respect him/her. As for the particular issues of this world cup, i'm much more concerned about the linesmen/referee's assistants. The offsides calls in that turkey/costa rica game and many others have been horrible.

I haven't seen one side getting favored over the other, just terrible calls. In some games, like costa rica/turkery, it was so bad you wondered whether the linesmen understood the rule, as silly as that sounds.


The worst offside-call was when Inimoto shot his second goal and it wasn't given because it was - apparently NOT - an offside goal.
 
jass1960 said:


FIFA World Rankings (May 2002)

Argentina 2
England 12
Sweden 19
Nigeria 27

Belgium 23
Russia 28
Tunisia 30
Japan 32

Fix or not?

Surprised that Russia are that low - whats the link Jas I thought they qualified unbeaten - and they have an excelent World Cup record which is one way that the groups are chosen
 
fanzee1 said:



and that's what we're here for!


Anybody else watching tunisia/belgium. Maybe it's just me coming down from the u.s. match but this one ain't exactly thrilling me.

Got it on in the office and just had two goals - hotting up a bit
 
I thought the refs were supposed to come only from the countries that were in the tournament. It's strange that Fifa didn't learn from the mistakes of the last world cup, when refs from small time leagues made some dubious calls in the first round. It shows that only the experienced refs called the subsequent matches.
 
Re: Re: Re: QUESTION ABOUT REFEREES

LittleDevilWithAHalo said:



The worst offside-call was when Inimoto shot his second goal and it wasn't given because it was - apparently NOT - an offside goal.


only one of many absurd calls.
 
I still don't understand that call....someone tried to explain it to me but I ended up being more confused! I just can't see anything wrong with that goal...
 
Gord said:


Got it on in the office and just had two goals - hotting up a bit

i'm watching too. you're right. getting better. Still hasn't pulled me away from the board yet, though.:)
 
However, I do think that the refereeing this tournament has been better than I expected. All the bad calls seem to have piled up in one games, like the Italy vs Crotia, Japan vs Belgium, and Brazil vs Turkey. Otherwise the refs have been pretty good.
 
fanzee1 said:


I'm not saying it's not rigged. I really have no idea. It's difficult to see how usa's '98 draw is evidence of it though. We played Iran, Germany and Denmark, was it? Germany we certainly weren't going to beat but the others we had a shot against. It's not like they put us in with Brazil, Italy, Argentina. My apologies if Denmark wasn't the third team. I'm a little fuzzy on that.

The third team was Yugoslavia.


I didn't mean in terms of quality of opponents but that each team is from a country that, well, has had issues with the United States in the past.
 
Ask For More said:
However, I do think that the refereeing this tournament has been better than I expected. All the bad calls seem to have piled up in one games, like the Italy vs Crotia, Japan vs Belgium, and Brazil vs Turkey. Otherwise the refs have been pretty good.

i couldn't disagree more. I think the officiating has been miserable throughout. More for offsides than for fouls, though. Fouls haven't been awful anyway, I don't think.
 
Back
Top