The 2002 World Cup Thread

jass1960 said:


Yes - 'cos it gioes both ways - the video ref could have disallowed the penalty that we got on Friday - it was a definite dive by Owen that could well have been overruled but would have taken ages to adjudicate on.

Didn't answer the question. Besides, the NFl has decided that they won't review subjective decisions and a Dive is clearly a subjective decision.

Whether the ball touched his hand or not is not subjective and would have been decided in two minutes.
 
Ask For More said:


In a way that's the problem in itself. Also because the Fifa rankings are historical that means that the are often twisted. For example USA qualifed for the last three World cups, but England didn'tmake it in 94, so that counts against them. Germany are pants now, but haven't missed a World Cup in yonks, so they get a higher rating than they deserve.


They are historical but only 8 years and they are weighted so the results for 8 years ago count for only 1/36 of the points total
 
Weevil said:


Which was kind of my earlier point. But still, Iran???? Iran????? I'm not saying it is rigged but it's like Britney's boobs. It wouldn't really surprise me if they were.


LOL!!! I was actually happy we drew Iran because they SUCK!!! Of course, we fielded a bunch of wannabe prima donnas that year instead of a team, with predictable results.


You have said you are canadian, i can see how it would seem like a struggle to play enemies/former enemies all the time, from your perspective. If there anybody who is REALLY on bad terms w/Canada? Seriously.
 
jass1960 said:



And look what happens American Football - a 1 hour game now lasts 3 weeks!!!!!!!!

No thanks - keep it the way it is - exciting!

Yes but that is more to do with the game ie special teams - changing from offense to defense etc.

I watch rugby a lot to and the video ref does not slow it down. It iis quick and fair - and more importantly the crowd gets to see the correct call. It adds to the excitment. I cant understand why you are agaisnt it

As someone else mentioned Maradonnas hand would have been sussed
 
jass1960 said:


Yes - 'cos it gioes both ways - the video ref could have disallowed the penalty that we got on Friday - it was a definite dive by Owen that could well have been overruled but would have taken ages to adjudicate on.

now that i don't think you would want. Once you start getting replay officials ruling on dives you just add another level of subjectivity to things. That's a recipe for disaster.
 
Weevil said:


Yeah, I felt that way too. Mainly because there has to be some sort of Subjectivity in those rankings, doesn't there?

Well, is there? Does anyone have the formula for the FIFA rankings handy?
 
jass1960 said:



They are historical but only 8 years and they are weighted so the results for 8 years ago count for only 1/36 of the points total

That still counts for the last two world cups. Some information:

The factors used are:

Friendly match x 1.00
Continental championship preliminary x 1.50
FIFA/Confederations' Cup match x 1.50
World Cup preliminary match x 1.50
Continental championship finals match x 1.75
World Cup finals match x 2.00


This means that qualifying matches are weighted 50% higher than friendlies, continental final round matches 75 % higher and matches during World Cup finals twice as much.


Should be pretty self explanatory
 
Gord said:


The general conscencus of the TV pundits in the UK is that the overall standard has been good.

You are always going to get some inconsistent calls as human judgement is being used . I tend to agree - I watch major premier game twice a week and believe me there are houlers every game.


of course there are always bad calls in any sport. I think we can desire better than what we have gotten so far this world cup, however.
 
fanzee1 said:


You have said you are canadian, i can see how it would seem like a struggle to play enemies/former enemies all the time, from your perspective. If there anybody who is REALLY on bad terms w/Canada? Seriously.

When it comes to Hockey?????? More than you'd think. As I mentioned in the Olympics Canada got a taste of it and, quite frankly, it sucked and sucked hard. The fact that Hamrlik wasn't suspended for his hit on Fleury dogs me to this day.

Bad terms with Canada? Uhhhh, I think the Spanish are still mad at us for arresting a few of their fishermen a while back.
 
Gord said:


Yes but that is more to do with the game ie special teams - changing from offense to defense etc.

I watch rugby a lot to and the video ref does not slow it down. It iis quick and fair - and more importantly the crowd gets to see the correct call. It adds to the excitment. I cant understand why you are agaisnt it

As someone else mentioned Maradonnas hand would have been sussed

Thats fine in a match that might have 50 points - do you really want that in a game which has otherwise could be 0-0? - gotta take the rough with smooth!

And also it would change the face of football - the offside trap would be all the rage because defences would be sure they would get every decision, whereas at the moment ther can be mistakes and that weakens the offside trap.
 
Ask For More said:


That still counts for the last two world cups. Some information:

The factors used are:

Friendly match x 1.00
Continental championship preliminary x 1.50
FIFA/Confederations' Cup match x 1.50
World Cup preliminary match x 1.50
Continental championship finals match x 1.75
World Cup finals match x 2.00


This means that qualifying matches are weighted 50% higher than friendlies, continental final round matches 75 % higher and matches during World Cup finals twice as much.


Should be pretty self explanatory

However


Last 12 months (e.g. 1998) : 8/8 value
+ previous year (1997) : 7/8 value
+ previous year (1996) : 6/8 value
+ previous year (1995) : 5/8 value
+ previous year (1994) : 4/8 value
+ previous year (1993) : 3/8 value
+ previous year (1992) : 2/8 value
+ previous year (1991) : 1/8 value
 
jass1960 said:


However


Last 12 months (e.g. 1998) : 8/8 value
+ previous year (1997) : 7/8 value
+ previous year (1996) : 6/8 value
+ previous year (1995) : 5/8 value
+ previous year (1994) : 4/8 value
+ previous year (1993) : 3/8 value
+ previous year (1992) : 2/8 value
+ previous year (1991) : 1/8 value

Can we all agree however that these rankings are so convoluted as to be essentially meaningless? I mean, let's be fair that means that what the United States did against Jamaica in 1994 has an impact on whether or not they should be ranked above the Koreans today. That's insane. It's like the RPI in College Football.
 
jass1960 said:


Thats fine in a match that might have 50 points - do you really want that in a game which has otherwise could be 0-0? - gotta take the rough with smooth!

And also it would change the face of football - the offside trap would be all the rage because defences would be sure they would get every decision, whereas at the moment ther can be mistakes and that weakens the offside trap.

But if it is a crucial try that can turn a game then it doesnt matter how many points it is. What matters is what is a fair try.

Also how can you say the descion will go with defenders - how many offsides do you see on sky that were actualy level. I think that it could be used only if there is a goal scored. Make the players play the whistle. At least it would end Tony Adams putting his arm up every 5 mins.
 
You can't convince me that the Fifa rankings are accurate enough. I just can't see the USA being ranked only oneplace below England to start with. And Colombia ranked fourth when they didn't even qualify and have played appalingly in the last World Cups? Give me a break!


1 France
2 Brazil
2 Argentina
4 Colombia
5 Portugal
6 Italy
7 Mexico
8 Spain
9 Netherlands
10 Yugoslavia
11 Germany
12 England
13 United States
14 Romania
15 Ireland Republic
15 Czech Republic
17 Cameroon
18 Paraguay
19 Sweden
20 Denmark
 
Ask For More said:
You can't convince me that the Fifa rankings are accurate enough. I just can't see the USA being ranked only oneplace below England to start with. And Colombia ranked fourth when they didn't even qualify and have played appalingly in the last World Cups? Give me a break!


1 France
2 Brazil
2 Argentina
4 Colombia
5 Portugal
6 Italy
7 Mexico
8 Spain
9 Netherlands
10 Yugoslavia
11 Germany
12 England
13 United States
14 Romania
15 Ireland Republic
15 Czech Republic
17 Cameroon
18 Paraguay
19 Sweden
20 Denmark

Now, I may be an idiot but doesn't that mean that there are, what, 4 teams ranked in the top twenty that aren't here this year? That doesn't make a lot of sense to me.
 
Weevil said:


Can we all agree however that these rankings are so convoluted as to be essentially meaningless? I mean, let's be fair that means that what the United States did against Jamaica in 1994 has an impact on whether or not they should be ranked above the Koreans today. That's insane. It's like the RPI in College Football.


It's fucked, to be sure. RPI is college basketball though, which is also fucked. But college football has the damnable Bowl Championship Series ratings, or BCS, easily the most fucked of all.
 
Ask For More said:
You can't convince me that the Fifa rankings are accurate enough. I just can't see the USA being ranked only oneplace below England to start with. And Colombia ranked fourth when they didn't even qualify and have played appalingly in the last World Cups? Give me a break!


1 France
2 Brazil
2 Argentina
4 Colombia
5 Portugal
6 Italy
7 Mexico
8 Spain
9 Netherlands
10 Yugoslavia
11 Germany
12 England
13 United States
14 Romania
15 Ireland Republic
15 Czech Republic
17 Cameroon
18 Paraguay
19 Sweden
20 Denmark


I'm not defending the rankings, believe me, but you have to earn your way in anyway, so it's kind of pointless to fret over them too much. Like i tell folks who worry about the college basketball polls all year, rankings aren't what get you into the tournament.
 
Gord said:


Also how can you say the descion will go with defenders - how many offsides do you see on sky that were actualy level. I think that it could be used only if there is a goal scored. Make the players play the whistle. At least it would end Tony Adams putting his arm up every 5 mins.


LOL. And that's an excellent argument against. Have to give you that.
 
Weevil said:


Now, I may be an idiot but doesn't that mean that there are, what, 4 teams ranked in the top twenty that aren't here this year? That doesn't make a lot of sense to me.


So what!

So there are 4 teams that didn't qualify and when the next rankings come out on July 4th that will be rectified Columbia will slip down and USA will still be up there because of the results in this World Cup.
 
fanzee1 said:



I'm not defending the rankings, believe me, but you have to earn your way in anyway, so it's kind of pointless to fret over them too much. Like i tell folks who worry about the college basketball polls all year, rankings aren't what get you into the tournament.

Oh yeah? When's the last time a team ranked fourth in the country was left out of the NCAA's?
 
jass1960 said:



So what!

So there are 4 teams that didn't qualify and when the next rankings come out on July 4th that will be rectified Columbia will slip down and USA will still be up there because of the results in this World Cup.

Except it shows that the rankings don't exactly tell you how good a soccer team is.
 
Weevil said:


When it comes to Hockey?????? More than you'd think. As I mentioned in the Olympics Canada got a taste of it and, quite frankly, it sucked and sucked hard. The fact that Hamrlik wasn't suspended for his hit on Fleury dogs me to this day.

Bad terms with Canada? Uhhhh, I think the Spanish are still mad at us for arresting a few of their fishermen a while back.


nah, i'm not talking about in hockey. i meant politically.


And Canada did NOT get jobbed at the Olympics. And if you think they did, go have a conversation with Fetisov and the rest of the russians, who were convinced the fix was in for North America. Sometimes, when we are passionate about things, we don't see events very clearly.

If you want to debate it further, PM me, or better yet, start a new thread.

Let's get back to soccer on this one. I've now veered away from it too long.
 
Weevil said:


Except it shows that the rankings don't exactly tell you how good a soccer team is.


Of course they don't but at least they give you an indication - now everyone is amazed by the USA's results because we think they are shit at football, but the rankings say that they are not a bad side and that has been proved - the rankings also say that England are not as good as we think we are so we had better not get complacent and pull our finger out against Nigeria.
 
fanzee1 said:



nah, i'm not talking about in hockey. i meant politically.

Politically?

uhh, no one but the point about hockey is that I knwo what it feels like, from a fans point of view.
 
Back
Top