The 2002 World Cup Thread

jass1960 said:



Of course they don't but at least they give you an indication - now everyone is amazed by the USA's results because we think they are shit at football, but the rankings say that they are not a bad side and that has been proved - the rankings also say that England are not as good as we think we are so we had better not get complacent and pull our finger out against Nigeria.

So then the rankings being used to counter my "soft group" argument is faulty at best.

So I'm vindicated.
 
The rankings are totally wrong - just looked at them

How can Scotland be so low !! 54th

But seriously looking at them the Honduras are 26th !!Now correct me if I am wrong but who the hell are they and who have they ever beaten and where is it !!
 
Weevil said:


So then the rankings being used to counter my "soft group" argument is faulty at best.

So I'm vindicated.

I know it was a while ago but I if you think back you will see that I agreed with your soft group theory and backed it up with the rankings!!!
 
Gord said:
The rankings are totally wrong - just looked at them

How can Scotland be so low !! 54th

But seriously looking at them the Honduras are 26th !!Now correct me if I am wrong but who the hell are they and who have they ever beaten and where is it !!


in Honduras they are saying exactly the same thing about Scotland!
 
Weevil said:


Oh yeah? When's the last time a team ranked fourth in the country was left out of the NCAA's?


4th at the end of the season? Hardly no one. Because at that point, the rankings closely approximate the rpi because so many games have been played. There are plenty of teams that have been ranked in the top 10 preseason who haven't made the tournament. And every year there are several teams ranked in the top 25 who are seeded well below their ranking because they don't have the schedule strength to rack up the rpi points. Look, this has been hashed and rehashed on espn boards forever. Go there and post and i guarantee you 100 people will come out of the woodwork to try to straighten you out.
 
jass1960 said:


I know it was a while ago but I if you think back you will see that I agreed with your soft group theory and backed it up with the rankings!!!

Well, yes and no. You backed up the Japanese groups softness but according to the Fifa rankings the Korea group is hard as a mofo.

But it's besides the point. I'm basing this on observation and reputation and the two groups are soft. The rankings don't play up how good a team is and are, therefore, useless.
 
jass1960 said:



in Honduras they are saying exactly the same thing about Scotland!

Yes I think you missed the slight sarcasm in my voice. I think my pub team could give Scotlland a run at the moment

But I am surprised at Honduras - what have they ever done ?? How are they 26th
 
fanzee1 said:



4th at the end of the season? Hardly no one. Because at that point, the rankings closely approximate the rpi because so many games have been played. There are plenty of teams that have been ranked in the top 10 preseason who haven't made the tournament. And every year there are several teams ranked in the top 25 who are seeded well below their ranking because they don't have the schedule strength to rack up the rpi points. Look, this has been hashed and rehashed on espn boards forever. Go there and post and i guarantee you 100 people will come out of the woodwork to try to straighten you out.

Sure but at this point(Shouldn't the world cup be soccers NCAAs?) shouldn't the rankings closely resemble the end of season College basketball rankings? Now, if Oregon is 4th at the end of the year it's usually because Oregon is the fourth best team in the country.

If columbia is 4th right before the World Cup they should be in the World Cup.
 
Gord said:


Yes I think you missed the slight sarcasm in my voice. I think my pub team could give Scotlland a run at the moment

But I am surprised at Honduras - what have they ever done ?? How are they 26th

No I didn't, you should know me better than that - maybe I should have put :D at the end of my comment :D
 
Weevil said:


Politically?

uhh, no one but the point about hockey is that I knwo what it feels like, from a fans point of view.


OK. it seemed like you were making two separate points before and now you've mixed them together. I guess i'm the one confused. Sorry.
 
Weevil said:


Sure but at this point(Shouldn't the world cup be soccers NCAAs?) shouldn't the rankings closely resemble the end of season College basketball rankings? Now, if Oregon is 4th at the end of the year it's usually because Oregon is the fourth best team in the country.

If columbia is 4th right before the World Cup they should be in the World Cup.


If Oregon is ranked 4th at the end of the season in basketball, it usually means they have had the 4th best year, not that they are necessarily the 4th-best team, if you understand the distinction there.

The FIFA rankings aren't really a good barometer in a similar situation because, as i have learned here this morning, they are based on so much more than just one year. If they were based on just one year, then they would be much more reflective of the kind of season any one team has had. Obviously, that's not what FIFA is looking to do, or they wouldn't have games 8 years old affecting the standings. The good news is that rankings don't get you into the world cup. You gotta earn it.
 
Gord said:




But I am surprised at Honduras - what have they ever done ?? How are they 26th


Last seen doing well in the group matches of the 2000 CONCAF Gold Cup where they beat the losing finalists Colombia.

Weevil that is the one that Canada won - makes you proud doesn't it!
 
And Weevil...

It does beg the question, what the hell are the FIFA rankings for, if not to show who is likely to have a stronger side at any given point in a season?
 
fanzee1 said:



If Oregon is ranked 4th at the end of the season in basketball, it usually means they have had the 4th best year, not that they are necessarily the 4th-best team, if you understand the distinction there.

The FIFA rankings aren't really a good barometer in a similar situation because, as i have learned here this morning, they are based on so much more than just one year. If they were based on just one year, then they would be much more reflective of the kind of season any one team has had

but if they're properly weighted(Strength of schedule etcetera) then wouldn't it be a much more accurate representation of the key question which is; How good is this team?
 
Re: And Weevil...

fanzee1 said:
It does beg the question, what the hell are the FIFA rankings for, if not to show who is likely to have a stronger side at any given point in a season?

Wait, that's my question.
 
Weevil said:


but if they're properly weighted(Strength of schedule etcetera) then wouldn't it be a much more accurate representation of the key question which is; How good is this team?

the FIFA rankings you mean? Yes. Like i said, FIFA's formula makes you wonder exactly what they are trying to show with their rankings.
 
Re: Re: Re: And Weevil...

fanzee1 said:



it seems we have reached the area of agreement.

Jeez, all I ever said is that the ranking aren't an accurate reflection of how good a team is. You agreed all along?
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: And Weevil...

Weevil said:


Jeez, all I ever said is that the ranking aren't an accurate reflection of how good a team is. You agreed all along?


that's true, we disagreed about other stuff, not that. It's not like i'm pissed off, you know.
 
back to soccer

anybody still watching tunisia/belgium? Hasn't been too terrible. Lots of chances. Also lots of bad finishing, unfortunately.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: And Weevil...

Weevil said:


Jeez, all I ever said is that the ranking aren't an accurate reflection of how good a team is. You agreed all along?

I think most people who know anything about football would agree with the above statement
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: And Weevil...

Gord said:


I think most people who know anything about football would agree with the above statement

so gord, what are the rankings for then? I must admit, i never paid any attention to them until this world cup, because they have been in my face all the time for this one. Not so in 94 or 98.
 
Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: And Weevil...

fanzee1 said:


so gord, what are the rankings for then? I must admit, i never paid any attention to them until this world cup, because they have been in my face all the time for this one. Not so in 94 or 98.


Well every sport has rankings because it gives the ruling body something to do

For FiFa and Uefa it does form the basis of which group you end in when draw for qualifiing for Euro Or WC

Ie you have one good team one nearly good team one pretty shit team and one absolute pants team - IN THEORY

ie in Group A Senegal were I suppose to be the Pants also rans which obviously is not the case as French result showed ie better team than ranking revealed
 
OK, Portugal just scored a second goal over Poland inthe 6th minute. It certainly looks like they're getting the three points for this game.

That means Poland is out of the second round before they play the US. Is that gging to make it easier or harder for the US to win against Poland?
 
Weird Harold said:
OK, Portugal just scored a second goal over Poland inthe 6th minute. It certainly looks like they're getting the three points for this game.

That means Poland is out of the second round before they play the US. Is that gging to make it easier or harder for the US to win against Poland?

4-0 at the final whistle which will give Portugal great heart against South Korea and really deflate Poland, so I would say Portugal and USA to win and both qualify.
 
Back
Top