Recidiva
Harastal
- Joined
- Sep 3, 2005
- Posts
- 89,726
I'm sure people are offended by my level of offendedness.
...can I use this as a sig quote?
I have a crush on you, I can't help it.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'm sure people are offended by my level of offendedness.
I guess I'm not done quoting others yet, even when I said I wasn't gonna.
And it makes me want to just . . . I don't know. But I try to just walk away. Not worth the effort involved.
Cheer up BeachGurl - and thank you for starting this most instructive thread - a lot of what has been said here makes a lot of sense and I appreciate the insight and candor of its many contributors. But it took courage for you to iniate this.
The few little arrows slung at you remind me of ancient Chinese saying:
"Man who sticks head above crowd must expect brick in face".
Keep your head held high !
Sorry, it's not up to the person making the statement, whatever it might be, as to whether or not they're offensive statements, offense is in the eye of the affected. I agree that you've done a pretty good job of trying not to be offensive, but a bunch of people have pointed out some fallcies. Fallacies that are rooted in their own personal experiences - I don't get it. Whatever cat, bb, or recidiva had to say about it it's like "yes, but, that's not what I meant, or I ackowledge that there may be other reasons that you might be big BUT that's not what I'm talking about..."
The way these things work is that people say something really offensive about a group of people who are already persecuted enough, those people explain their reality and then it's "gee you're all SO sensitive" turning the pity party back onto the person who made the comment in the first place.
It's not about you. You asked, you are hearing the reality and opinion of real live fat people and it's not jiving with the answers you must have been hoping for on some level. What exactly, are you hoping people tell you?
I'm sure people are offended by my level of offendedness. That's fine. I'm simply explaining how some of these statements strike me, as someone who's done fat/not/fat again, and liked herself OK though the changes and thinks there are other things in the world to worry about more.
Like why the poor don't have real food in their neighborhoods.
...can I use this as a sig quote?
I have a crush on you, I can't help it.
I actually didn't have preconceived notions about what people would say beyond expecting some level of offense from some people because it is a very touchy subject. And I'm not offended by your offendedness. Actually, I like how you say it like it is without couching it in a bunch of garbage. I have difficulty doing that and wish I were better at it.
I had hoped that since I've come at it from multiple angles personally myself that people might realize I have some valid questions and points. But I also realize that some of my comments have been taken to mean something I didn't intend. No worries. It's largely the medium. It's hard to understand what a person might mean when you can't hear their tone or see their expressions. And people don't really know me, so they don't know the personal struggles I've had beyond what I am able to express here. And I have a very strong feeling that there are those here who don't believe me anyway. That's okay, I expected that, too.
I knew when I posted this thread that it would bring to the forefront strong feelings. I have my own strong feelings about it when people make comments in the reverse, but since it's about thin people, it's okay. The same sort of stereotyping but in reverse. Just like the race arguments or the religion arguments. One group can be bashed, but if you say anything at all about the other group, whether positive or negative, it's not allowed. I get that. It's okay. And I'm not going to pretend that my thoughts are all altruistic because yes, there is some level of personal preference within it. But it's really not any different from the person who prefers to date redheads or atheletes. Everyone has their preferences and shouldn't be bashed for those preferences. But when the preference is expressed as being physically fit or a thinner body type, then people automatically jump on them as being shallow and unrealistic. So it does have validity within the discussion. Although that wasn't my point, it is still part of the whole. And people keep trying to bring it back to that as if that's the point, that it is what leads the thoughts in my head. And it's not. But no matter how many times I say that, people won't believe it. So it's okay. Just silly, in my opinion.
I respect your right to be offended by the topic and the discussion. I respect your right to post your opposing views and I have no problem hearing what you and everyone else is saying. I don't believe that I'm backtracking on my point in any way. I've said more than once that it is partly asthetic for me as well. I would be lying if I said otherwise. So would everyone else.
Cheer up BeachGurl - and thank you for starting this most instructive thread - a lot of what has been said here makes a lot of sense and I appreciate the insight and candor of its many contributors. But it took courage for you to iniate this.
The few little arrows slung at you remind me of ancient Chinese saying:
"Man who sticks head above crowd must expect brick in face".
Keep your head held high !
Of course, and it's mutual, if I've not said it before.
There's something you bring up that I can't agree more with. The body hate has got to quit period. I'm sick of hearing how much happier skinny people have to be, or "eat a sandwich for crying out loud" or whatever or ripping people apart for eating whatever's out of the norm, whether that means lettuce and lemon or giant sized ribs. There's backlash and bullshit aimed at smaller/thinner people. I wish everyone could see it's all part of the same damn racket.
I have my own aesthetic preferences too, there's nothing wrong with that. Angelina Jolie is not in 'em.
Well, when I first got here you promised next life we'd be gay men together.
I have hopes.
I absolutely agree. And I believe that is a huge factor that contributes to the problem on both sides - those who gain too much and those who lose too much. Having done both - gained too much and lost too much - I know that issue played a huge factor for me. And I'm guessing for most others as well. So can we safely talk about that topic? Because I believe it's a big factor in the entire issue.
As to Angelina Jolie, not my type, either. I prefer my partner to have a little bulk, even though the people here don't think that's true.
I like both of those quotes.
I expected the arrows, so no worries. My frustration comes out of the idea that it's not okay to initiate this discussion in any form because it's about a group of persecuted people to begin with. I think with that mentality, the issues will never be addressed. It's okay. I expected to have the comments that it's all about being shallow and bigotted. I'm just glad the thread went 4 whole pages of really good discussion before it happened.
So all of that said, if you’re still with me on this, I do have a few questions for the group.
Is it just my own perception, or does this lifestyle seem to have an unusually high percentage of overweight individuals who are active within it? Or do you think that those within the lifestyle mirror those in society as a whole?
If you are in a D/s or M/s dynamic, is your partner in the same physical state (meaning physically fit or overweight) that you are in or are you physically opposites?
The previous Dom never said a word to me about my weight or eating habits. Only that he thought I looked like a real woman in his opinion. He liked curves. Master and I have a bit of a different dynamic since we are 24/7 TPE and he gets to see everything I eat, my activity level etc. What he's on my ass the most about honestly is to eat more. It's his opinion that I'm heavy because I don't eat enough. I pick at my food and eat random things instead of eating meals.As a Dominant/Master, do you encourage your submissive/slave to be health conscious? If not, is it because it is not important to you or because you are attracted to someone who is BBW?
I have no problem being as physically active as I want to be. I'm blessed with a lot of stamina and can usually outlast Master, who is by no means overweight. I'm also weirdly flexible for a fat chick. I'm as uncomfortable with public play as I assume all women are. It's been my experience that other women are far more judgmental of other women's bodies than men are. So I'm more comfortable nakie around men than I am most women.If you are overweight, do you find that you have difficulty being as physically active as you would like to be? Are you comfortable being partially or fully unclothed if you play in public or at private parties with others?
This kind of annoys me because it seems to imply that if a PYL is not regulating someones diet and exercise they don't care about them, or are not in control. Like others have stated the majority of people who thought I should lose weight was because I would be more attractive if I was thin. I'm also a smoker..oddly enough none of them cared about that.Yes, as I said, this post has a point. I wonder how many in D/s or M/s relationships have Dominants who are in control enough and care enough to help motivate their submissive/slave to get and stay healthy. My post is not so much about weight (although I’m sure many here will think it is) but is about physical health. We do a lot of physically draining activities. If you aren’t in decent physical shape, how much enjoyment are you able to get out of them?
As the Dominant, shouldn’t the physical well-being of all parties be up to you? I’m curious as to how you may see your role in the physical well-being of not only yourself, but those under your care.
I also saw a morbidly obese young woman in head to toe designer clothing, with a ridiculous amount of makeup and hair products, a very expensive pair of shoes on and a designer purse, carrying one of those tiny handbag dogs, which was also decked out in matching designer gear. I mean... why? What's the point of spending a small fortune on your appearance if you're not going to cosmetically enhance yourself by eating a bit less and doing a bit more? I have to say, that lady made me chuckle in an 'only in LA' fashion.
My wife has this exact problem! What brands have you been successful with? What she really needs right now is a good pencil skirt for work...she bought one at Kiyonna but although the ass fit, it was way too big at the waist.I also have a hourglass shape where my waist dips in so it's harder than hell to buy jeans that don't gap at the waist and still fit my ass..LOL.
Okay, I'll admit, Angilina, except for the fact she's a chick, is what I go for.
Gerold Buttler, deffo in a heart beat, but more the "P.S. I love you" look than the "300" look. I like tone, athletic, but not rippling muscles.
But then, I tend to go for the nerdy looking guys anyway. You know, tall and thin, glasses optional. If I get the hockey goalie, sweetness! Otherwize I'm in the gamer pool....but again *shallow moment* only the slimmer ones.
I used to feel bad about it, but now I don't let it bother me. I'm attracted to what I'm attracted to, and sexual attraction has a huge impact on whether you get a shot with me or not. I know what I like, sorry if that's offensive, but that's me.
And Netzach made some good points. My children are thin. They are extremely active due in part to the ADHD. They adore fruits and veggies and will pick them over sweets. Thing is I'm on a very tight budget. Have you seen the price of fresh fruits lately? It costs a buck for a box of snack cakes, and upwards of three dollars for a small carton of strawberries. I still try to buy the healthiest things for them. But in the real world, thing that are less healthy are a hell of a lot easier on my budget. It's a sad fact.
Okay, I'll admit, Angilina, except for the fact she's a chick, is what I go for.
Gerold Buttler, deffo in a heart beat, but more the "P.S. I love you" look than the "300" look. I like tone, athletic, but not rippling muscles.
But then, I tend to go for the nerdy looking guys anyway. You know, tall and thin, glasses optional. If I get the hockey goalie, sweetness! Otherwize I'm in the gamer pool....but again *shallow moment* only the slimmer ones.
I used to feel bad about it, but now I don't let it bother me. I'm attracted to what I'm attracted to, and sexual attraction has a huge impact on whether you get a shot with me or not. I know what I like, sorry if that's offensive, but that's me.
I'm attracted to what I'm attracted to, and sexual attraction has a huge impact on whether you get a shot with me or not. I know what I like, sorry if that's offensive, but that's me.
I can understand why reading the way I wrote that would suggest that I meant the PYL should be able to control it. I didn't word it very well, I don't think. Really what I was getting at was that the PYL is in a position to influence. And unlikely enough, if the pyl is the one largely in charge of meals, then I'm guessing the influence comes from both directions. Some PYLs control the menu, some don't. Some influence, some don't. My question was largely asking is that the kind of influence you have or desire.This kind of annoys me because it seems to imply that if a PYL is not regulating someones diet and exercise they don't care about them, or are not in control. Like others have stated the majority of people who thought I should lose weight was because I would be more attractive if I was thin. I'm also a smoker..oddly enough none of them cared about that.
And Netzach made some good points. My children are thin. They are extremely active due in part to the ADHD. They adore fruits and veggies and will pick them over sweets. Thing is I'm on a very tight budget. Have you seen the price of fresh fruits lately? It costs a buck for a box of snack cakes, and upwards of three dollars for a small carton of strawberries. I still try to buy the healthiest things for them. But in the real world, thing that are less healthy are a hell of a lot easier on my budget. It's a sad fact.
My wife has this exact problem! What brands have you been successful with? What she really needs right now is a good pencil skirt for work...she bought one at Kiyonna but although the ass fit, it was way too big at the waist.
I hate to harp on this but I REALLY see a class component to this equation, a huge glaring one - the same people who can afford bypass surgeries, plastic surgeries and two hours per day at the gym because someone else watches the spawn are going to vilify the ones who can't even afford a half hour to cook and run the companies to *keep them that way*
someone else's lesiure time is because someone else is overworked.
Sorry, happy labor day everyone.