However you feel is absolutely okay, as long as it's how you truly feel and not how you think you're "supposed to" feel. You don't "have to" be angry; you don't "have to" forgive them; you don't "have to" do or be anything except true to yourself. And even that's optional.
I had to get angry with my family so that I could get strong enough to work through what they'd done; for me, anger gives me an initial burst of strength to start dealing with something, then once I've found a deeper source of strength I let go of the anger. Like Mylacerated said, the anger is a catalyst, not something I hold onto. For so many years I locked my anger away in a little box because I didn't think I had the right to be angry, so now I've given myself permission to feel that anger as long as I don't direct it toward anyone else, just toward events, and as long as I release it when it isn't useful anymore.
VFaulkon, if you're at peace and feel that there's no need to be angry at your family, that's wonderful. It's only a potential problem if you've chosen not to be angry because you "shouldn't" be angry at family or because "others have had it worse". Your experiences are your experiences, they made you feel the way you felt about them, and they shouldn't be compared with anyone else's experiences, because you aren't anyone else. The others who've posted on this thread have been through far more sheer hell than I have, but that doesn't mean I was any less abused or that my feelings and issues because of it are any less valid. My experiences were different, not lesser. It's not a hierarchy.
You're not "messed up", you're just finding your way through. Like the rest of us. Welcome, and please, take only the parts of what I say that make sense to you and ignore the rest. You're the only one who truly knows you.
I really don't feel angry at them. I've just come to understand, much like Mylacerated has, that my family members just are how they are. They certainly haven't changed any in the past ten years (which I find weird, because I know I am changing, so why aren't they?), and I know that they love me and care about me. They just suck at it, and being angry at them for that feels like being angry at a dog for biting you, y'know?
But what you and MLH have said sounds right - I have to go with what feels right to me and hope for the best. I still feel disappointed that I can't have a 'normal', functional family like I want, but I think at this point it can't be helped.
Hi VFaulkon, thankyou for sharing.
I can't imagine what you must have gone through but the one piece of advice I feel able to offer is this.
Anger as a catalyst is incredibly powerful. Anger carried around and nursed like a grudge is corrosive.
You have every right to be angry but to hold on to that in the long term is not a good thing. Anger is like fire, it must be handled with care and only used when strictly necessary and in a proportionate amount. I do believe that as women, anger is potentially more damaging sometimes, simply because we're less used to welcoming it and channelling it effectively.
I've done anger. I've also done slow burning rage and I clung to it for a number of years. I tried to articulate to my family what I had gone through and they didn't want to know. I railed against that, yelled, stomped and hated them for it. They have never changed one iota and they never will. I accept that now and I accept that being angry is pointless. It also maintains a negative emotional connection between me and my family, which just holds me back as I try to rebuild myself into something other than what they made me. Hatred still saps power from me just as futile, exasperated and unrequited love once did.
The opposite of love is not hate, it's indifference.
Now I have a 15ft high wall of reinforced concrete topped with razorwire, sentries, alarms and trigger happy snipers erected between me and my family. I do not care what they think of me, how they want me to live my life or whether they're disappointed with what I do. I have as little to do with them as possible because their attempts to make me feel like the lost little girl I was are damaging to me and indicative of their insecurity in the face of my own, brand new self assurance. I don't discuss my plans and give them the opportunity to be critical. I don't offer love or affection only to hand them an opportunity to snub me. I don't hand them power of any description over any aspect of who I am. I am not their business anymore and when you are able to move out of home and make your own way, your family will only have the influence over you that you give them.
Someone once said, 'nobody can make you feel like crap without your permission.'
You have to learn to stop giving that permission, to stop giving their opinions credence and allowing them to make you doubt. Everyone makes mistakes in life and falls flat on their ass every now and again but that does not make your choices wrong; it makes them yours. You have as much right to fuck your own life up spectacularly as you do to make it a wonderful success but their opinion and approval or lack of it must not be your benchmark.
It's hard and it goes against all our biological pre-programming and natural instincts but the only way to gain and retain power over your family and their abusiveness towards you is to genuinely cease caring. Anything less than that will just continue to demoralise you and hold you back.
One minor note that I probably wasn't clear on - I'm a guy. Not much difference given the topic, but just for the sake of clarification.
Like I said to Karenna, I don't really feel any natural anger towards them, just disappointment. I don't understand why they are how they are, why they couldn't see the effect they were having on me...there really isn't anything I can do about it but learn to accept it, which is where I'm at now, I think.
One thing that does feel weird - I know that, compared to the stories I've heard both here and from my friends IRL, my problems are more...subtle, I guess, but when I look back at my childhood - how painfully shy I was, how readily I resorted to self-deprecating humor and being the class clown just to get by, how much trouble I had connecting (and still have) with people my own age, and how hard it is for me to accept that my friends may not actually secretly have a million and one criticisms for me - was my family's treatment of me a major factor in that? If so, how much?
I'm still young (almost 22), so I guess I have some time to figure all this out. Hopefully, I can come to terms with everything rattling around in my head before I have a family that's depending on me to be a good father.
I just want to say thank you, all of you. Not being alone in this, I think, is key to finding our own ways out of the woods.