Was Hitler A Socialist? Of Course, He Was

[Bigtitsbitch1000x]

Wrong as usual. You attacked me first and you look like a man. Nobody would mistake you for a woman. NOBODY.

I never said I expect anybody to mistake me for a cis woman, you moron. I don't want that. I want the world to recognize the worth of transwomen based on the incredible miracle of our rebirth.

You are the classic consumer of the lowest category of porn. The one who grabs the dancers' asses, and gets thrown out; the one who stands in the doorway jerking off and giggling. You clearly desire me, as others on this site do. But even though you have wasted your life fapping, you can't articulate your sexual needs, so you leave sticky cum on pages I treat as holy scripture.

You are, in fact, a dungbeetle. Own it.

 

[Bigtitsbitch1000x]

I'm talking about afterwards. During the February Revolution, Tsar Nicholas II abdicated from the throne in favor of his son Mikhail. The Soviets, at that time controlled by Mensheviks and SRs, basically had power in their hands, but the Menshevik and SR leaders offered power to the Cadets (i.e. liberals). The liberals in turn offered power to the monarchy! Because of the militancy on the streets against these proceedings, it forced the abolition of the monarchy, instead of Mikhail becoming the Tsar. That's why the capitalist Provisional Government then came into being, initially headed by Prince Georgy Lvov, as the liberals were forced to buy time, to wait until they could go onto the offensive against the Soviets.


The most advanced sections of the Petrograd workers wanted the Bolsheviks to transfer all political power to the Soviets in July 1917. Only they had gone over to the Bolsheviks at that time in terms of wanting socialist revolution. The masses elsewhere still had illusions in the reformist leaders of the Mensheviks and SRs at that time.


I told you before. If you want to see what happened to the Nazi "left", look up Otto Strasser, Strasserism, Beefsteak Nazis and the Night of the Long Knives.

When the Nazis spoke of the "November criminals" who "stabbed Germany in the back" at the end of WW1, they were talking about the German revolutionaries of November 1918 that ended WW1, most obviously the Kiel uprising. The outbreak of this revolution caused the Kaiser to flee Germany for the Netherlands. Liberal and conservative historians like to claim that the "November criminals" were a myth. No, they weren't, Hitler was talking about the revolutionaries. Naturally, the far right saw the revolutionaries as criminals who had betrayed Germany.


The Nazis sought to draw in all despairing elements in German society, including ex-social democrats.

There were plenty of Beefsteak Nazis in the SA (i.e. Brown Shirt Storm Troopers). Beefsteak was a term used because it means brown on the outside and red on the inside, i.e. red being the color of socialism and communism. The Treaty of Versailles from 1919 limited the German Army to 100,000 troops, while the SA's numbers up to its June 1934 suppression was numbered in the millions. The Beefsteak Nazis were demanding a "second revolution" after January 1933 to establish "national socialism". Instead, Hitler and Himmler purged them during the Night of the Long Knives in June 1934. The Nazi "left" was utterly annihilated, smashed to bits, after they had done the dirty work of smashing the German labor movement and using force on the streets.

The Nazis saw Communism and the Soviet Union as their ultimate enemies. When the Nazis got into power, they went for the communists first, then trade unionists, then social democrats.


If we don't understand history, how can we understand how we have arrived at the present day situation?

I am increasingly unwilling to
accommodate the pretentious bloviations of this person or of Lit members in the political field in general. I can no longer put up with the favorite game of American amateur leftwats:
Pretend History. Presented with its companion: Patronizing Hoohah.

These people never walked a serious labor picket line, never took action to really help oppressed people anywhere, and revel in their privilege. Like Gavin Nuisance, they claim to stand with the masses while gorging on gourmet food.

RandyRebecca: you have the unspeakable nerve to write to me "I told you before. If you want to see what happened to the Nazi "left", look up Otto Strasser, Strasserism, Beefsteak Nazis and the Night of the Long Knives."

I tell you; I have forgotten more about this topic than you will know, i.e. really learn, if you live 1,000 years. I don't have to look anything up about this. I know it by heart.

Bitch, the so-called "Nazi left," a term you pulled out of your ass, is an exceptionally difficult topic unless one knows German and has an extremely deep knowledge of Germsn political history. Do you know German? Have you read STALIN AND GERMAN COMMUNISM by Ruth Fischer? Of course not. You have never read anything on any of these topics except thirdhand political propaganda. Have you read Victor Serge, Boris Souvarine, Arthur Rosenberg, Franz Borkenau, Edward Conze, Angelica Balabanova, or Richard Wilhelm? Do you know how it was that ginseng and the I Ching came to The West? Have you even read Deutscher? Of course not. Your knowledge of these matters is bluff. You are an intellectual tourist.

"When the Nazis spoke of the "November criminals" who "stabbed Germany in the back" at the end of WW1, they were talking about the German revolutionaries of November 1918 that ended WW1, most obviously the Kiel uprising. The outbreak of this revolution caused the Kaiser to flee Germany for the Netherlands. Liberal and conservative historians like to claim that the "November criminals" were a myth. No, they weren't, Hitler was talking about the revolutionaries. Naturally, the far right saw the revolutionaries as criminals who had betrayed Germany."

Wow, idiot, remind me not to invite you to any @ntifa events.

The term "November criminals" was not a Nazi invention. It was a term applied by the right specifically to the Social Democrats who had endorsed the armistice of 9 November 1918 in a parliamentary declaration on 8 November. The sailors' revolts were a factor, but not the sole determining factor.

The rest of your feeble jottings on that are unworthy of my attention.

You babble about the flight of Kaiser Wilhelm to The Netherlands. Right. To a place called Doorn. I went there to document its history. On my own money. Working with German Kurdish revolutionaries.

"The Nazis sought to draw in all despairing elements in German society, including ex-social democrats."

Really. And what were the queers in concentration camps but "despairing elements?" You think Röhm was Log Cabin? Of course you do, if one teases out your shabby pseudo'dialectic.

"The Nazis saw Communism and the Soviet Union as their ultimate enemies. When the Nazis got into power, they went for the communists first, then trade unionists, then social democrats."

Obscene bullshit, bitch. I refuse to let you do scat on the German Social Democratic. The Nazi regime attacked all leftist forces, beginning with the Social Dems and the unions. Repression of the Communists was uneven until the regime consolidated.

Name one German Social Democrat who joined the Nazis. Just one. You can't.

"If we don't understand history, how can we understand how we have arrived at the present day situation?"

You don't understand history and you and your reptile breed are doing your best to prevent Americans from understanding the extreme crisis we now face. Leftwats like Gabbard, with your assent if unspoken, actively serve Putin. Troglodytes like Sarandon and gangsters like RFK Jr. emulate the Third Period Stalinist line in Germany, which led directly to the Holocaust. My relatives died at the hands of the Nazis because Stalin backed Hitler in 1930-33 and 1939-41.

You, RandyRebecca, are not of the left. You are an enemy of the real left. You are an enemy of LGBTQ. Your insufferable arrogance and addiction to a pseudointellectual version of 3 Card Monte put us all in danger.

This is you:

Have a nice day!

( . )( . )

 

[Bigtitsbitch1000x]

Respectfully disagree.
The machinations of political minorities to subvert the law and institute "minority rule' in 1930 Germany and 2020 America are eerily similar.

Also the Republican party in 1930 America made strides towards their own fascist takeover America but were stopped by one right-wing USMC General, Smedley Butler.

Butler may have been the last of his kind: A Republican who put Country before Party.

1. Learn to write English.

2. You are not respectful of anybody. You are a phony typical of internet flame warriors.

3. So Adam Kinzinger and Liz Cheney aren't putting country before party?

4. Poor Smedley Butler. Destined to become a condom for leftwats.

5. The future of global bourgeois democracy hangs on the fate of its American progenitor.

This is too important for anybody to pay attention to your drooling.

( . )( . )