🎃 Halloween Candy Battle 🍬🍬 —- closed until 2025

[Whiskeyjack]

Starburst. M&M's aren't even good.

 

[Shymidwestgirl]

Starburst. M&M's aren't even good.

What blasphemy is a statement such as that above?

I don’t frequently pick chocolate candy for a treat but M&M’s are a classic.

Plus you don’t have to unwrap them all. Just be sure to eat the correct colors together.

 

[BrendaBear]

This one made me ponder more… but M&Ms for me.

 

[lavendersilk]

Since you didn't put "Mini" or "Peanut"(The only acceptable versions) I choose Starburst! Pink ones are best.

 

[Qky75]

What blasphemy is a statement such as that above?

I don’t frequently pick chocolate candy for a treat but M&M’s are a classic.

Plus you don’t have to unwrap them all. Just be sure to eat the correct colors together.

You seem familiar.....hmm. Did you dress up as the green m&m?

Which BTW M&M obviously.

 

[Bry1313]

Since you didn't put "Mini" or "Peanut"(The only acceptable versions) I choose Starburst! Pink ones are best.

It’s all chocolate otherwise. Starburst FTW

 

[Mada69]

Going with M&Ms on this one. I'm addicted to them.

 

[SirConradPeckereye]

Today’s battle is the last of the 1st round …



M&M Plain
View attachment 2416701



VS



Starburst
View attachment 2416702

If you would have done peanut m&m's no contest... but alas.... Starburst it is!

 

[SirConradPeckereye]

Looks like Reese’s has won!!

View attachment 2416692

Btw.... skittles ssssooooo should have beat twix!

 

[FreckledSprite]

 

[Taegul]

This is a tough choice but I think I have to go with M&Ms. I still have no idea why they print a W on each one but who cares as long as they taste good...

 

[Mr_bogey]

Of course Reese's is going to win this because most of y'all are American. I'm not gonna yuck on your yum but am casting my ballot for Jolly Ranchers.

Vegemite bias coming thru again.

 

[Taegul]

I'd just like to say that a matchup between Red Vines and Twizzlers would be awesome. That way, I could see all the Litsters who choose Twizzlers and put all of the no-taste blasphemous whores on ignore at the same time.

 

[BrendaBear]

Btw.... skittles ssssooooo should have beat twix!

 

[jeff_is_smiling]

 

[SirConradPeckereye]

Don't you sass me young lady!

Bunch of chocohollics here!

 

[LostHorizon]

Today’s battle is the last of the 1st round …



M&M Plain
View attachment 2416701



VS



Starburst
View attachment 2416702

This one is a no brainer…

M&Ms it’s not even close.

 

[Mr_bogey]

Today’s battle is the last of the 1st round …



M&M Plain
View attachment 2416701



VS



Starburst
View attachment 2416702

Why do you hate m&m's? Why chose the inferior "plain" m&m? If you put plain vs peanut, peanut wins every time. Peanut butter, almond, caramel, pretzel.

Peanut wins this easy. Plain is so pedestrian. If Starburst only came in the cherry and strawberry flavors, I'd vote that way over plain. As it stands, I'm truly torn and don't know which I'd reach for.
You display the "fun size" and iirc, the fun size Starburst only have 2 or 3 inside. Chances of being shutout on the best flavors and being truly disappointed are real. For that reason, I vote for boring old plain m&m's.

 

[LostHorizon]

Why do you hate m&m's? Why chose the inferior "plain" m&m? If you put plain vs peanut, peanut wins every time. Peanut butter, almond, caramel, pretzel.

Peanut wins this easy. Plain is so pedestrian. If Starburst only came in the cherry and strawberry flavors, I'd vote that way over plain. As it stands, I'm truly torn and don't know which I'd reach for.
You display the "fun size" and iirc, the fun size Starburst only have 2 or 3 inside. Chances of being shutout on the best flavors and being truly disappointed are real. For that reason, I vote for boring old plain m&m's.

You’re serious about your nuts.

 

[TheMrBurns]

Why do you hate m&m's? Why chose the inferior "plain" m&m? If you put plain vs peanut, peanut wins every time. Peanut butter, almond, caramel, pretzel.

Peanut wins this easy. Plain is so pedestrian. If Starburst only came in the cherry and strawberry flavors, I'd vote that way over plain. As it stands, I'm truly torn and don't know which I'd reach for.
You display the "fun size" and iirc, the fun size Starburst only have 2 or 3 inside. Chances of being shutout on the best flavors and being truly disappointed are real. For that reason, I vote for boring old plain m&m's.

So what about peanut M&Ms vs Starburst "Fave-Red"?

 

[Mr_bogey]

You’re serious about your nuts.

I love my nuts.

 

[LostHorizon]

Don't you sass me young lady!

Bunch of chocohollics here!

You’re right. It’s not a fair fight between anything chocolate and some mystery substance that tastes like fruit flavored plastic.

The chocolate candies should just be their own contest and the kiddie candies rated separately.

For example, Skittles vs Starbursts. That’s a fair contest.

 

[Mr_bogey]

So what about peanut M&Ms vs Starburst "Fave-Red"?
View attachment 2416751

Peanut wins!
Some people get addicted to drugs, my dad was addicted to Peanut M&Ms. I swear he joined Sam's club just so he could buy those big jars.
https://www.bjs.com/product/mms-cho...CLN78GKYD0Mh_U-TGjQaAhFQEALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds

 

[MandaPandaa]

Starburst. M&M's aren't even good.

Wait - you mean *plain* m&m's, right? Riiight?? Because I can agree with that one. I don't think I can allow m&m slander. Not even for you, Jack.

Starburst take this one for me tho.

 

[Whiskeyjack]

Wait - you mean *plain* m&m's, right? Riiight?? Because I can agree with that one. I don't think I can allow m&m slander. Not even for you, Jack.

Starburst take this one for me tho.

They used to have crispy M&M's and those were tolerable. I haven't seen those around in a while, though. Plain M&M's are barely candy. Peanut M&M's are just terrible. Like, they'd be good if there was an apocalypse and the world ended and that's all you had to eat. But for the most part any Peanut M&M's that come home on Halloween go straight in the trash. And nothing about my experiences with M&M's has made me want to try any of their other varieties.