🎃 Halloween Candy Battle 🍬🍬 —- closed until 2025

[DannieB]

Poor Jolly Rancher’s never stood a chance against Reese’s!

Absolutely. I eat around the edges to get my fill of the hard chocolate then eat the center with the peanut butter in one or two bites. People think I’m weird for doing this. Jokes on them, cause I am weird.

I do this as well, but instead of eating the center in bites I pop it in my mouth and suck on it until it melts in my mouth. And yes, I do get judged but suck it

My vote’s for Reese’s if that wasn’t clear

 

[UnquietDreams]

Poor Jolly Rancher’s never stood a chance against Reese’s!

I do this as well, but instead of eating the center in bites I pop it in my mouth and suck on it until it melts in my mouth. And yes, I do get judged but suck it

My vote’s for Reese’s if that wasn’t clear

I do that with the "fun" sized, just let it melt. With the regular ones I eat the chocolate off first.

Which is weird, because if a have a plan chocolate bar, chances are outstanding that I'm going to stick it in a jar of peanut butter.

 

[Iwillgo]

Sometimes you feel like a nut...

 

[UnquietDreams]

Sometimes you feel like a nut...

...and sometimes you nut.

 

[BrendaBear]

@crazychemgirl , you might want to update that very first posting with the latest chart to make it easy to see where we are.

 

[ToPleaseHim]

Sometimes you feel like a nut...

...and sometimes you nut.

I sang this

 

[barefootgirl69]

...and sometimes you nut.

They said it was coconut!

 

[subdudeme13]

@crazychemgirl , you might want to update that very first posting with the latest chart to make it easy to see where we are.

Where are we? You need to go back to Crazies latest post to find out where the thread is. I do like the idea.

 

[subdudeme13]

Poor Jolly Rancher’s never stood a chance against Reese’s!

I do this as well, but instead of eating the center in bites I pop it in my mouth and suck on it until it melts in my mouth. And yes, I do get judged but suck it

My vote’s for Reese’s if that wasn’t clear

Jolly Rancher's have there place but not in a delicious candy competition. They are good to suck in your mouth and to curl your tongue around when you are busy doing something and do not have the time to enjoy something deeply pleasurable.

 

[subdudeme13]

Sometimes you feel like a nut...

Sometimes you don't.

 

[aussiegeekygal]

Of course Reese's is going to win this because most of y'all are American. I'm not gonna yuck on your yum but am casting my ballot for Jolly Ranchers.

 

[DoRaMe]

I will take Jolly Rancher over Reeses

 

[crazychemgirl]

@crazychemgirl , you might want to update that very first posting with the latest chart to make it easy to see where we are.

Done… thanks!!!

 

[MandaPandaa]

To be honest, I don't love peanut butter and chocolate... But I'll be damned if I choose Jolly Ranchers - a hard candy - over rpc.

Unless they are sour gummy Jolly Ranchers. But I don't think that is what this is.

 

[13Fantasies]

I don't even like peanut butter that much but Jolly Ranchers can suck it... Reese Pumpkin for me!

Umm....aren't you supposed to suck Jolly Ranchers?

 

[Taegul]

"Reese’s is set to release a crazy new peanut butter and jelly peanut butter cup in 2025."

Looks like Reese's is already trying to strengthen its position for the 2025 Lit candy competition. I admire the aggressiveness.

 

[crazychemgirl]

Looks like Reese’s has won!!

 

[crazychemgirl]

Today’s battle is the last of the 1st round …



M&M Plain




VS



Starburst

 

[LaisDeMarieDeFrance]

Today’s battle is the last of the 1st round …



M&M Plain
View attachment 2416701



VS



Starburst
View attachment 2416702

Dang, this is a hard one! Idk that I can choose between them!

 

[SWR101]

Another hard bracket. I love starbursts as a something I can chew on for a bit.

But M&Ms are just so stinking versatile. You can eat them as is. Add them to baked goods, add them to ice cream and yogurt.

I’ll have to go with M&Ms

 

[TheMrBurns]

This is definitely the toughest choice of the first round. But that sexy green M&M has me leaning towards the milk chocolate that melts in your mouth, not in your hands.

 

[Cuckwannabe111]

M&M

 

[Lmizzler]

Today’s matchup is one of epic proportions.
In one corner we have the chocolate heavyweight that has stood the test of time.
In the other corner we have a delightfully fruity and chewy option that slowly dissolves away if you can keep from swallowing. (Not a euphemism)

I’m going with Starburst strictly on the basis of so many other solid chocolate choices if needed but not near as many other fruity options that are as comparable.

 

[Azuldrgon]

M&M's please.

 

[MidwestPrincess23]

Oof, this is an awfully tough one!
I’m going with Starburst on this one, simply because they last longer.