512 Architects & Engineering Professionals

Was 9/11 an Inside Job?

  • Yes, the buildings were controlled demolitions with the Terrorists used as decoys.

    Votes: 56 71.8%
  • Yes, Osama Bin Laden is actually a CIA operative. That's why everyone lets him escape all the time.

    Votes: 17 21.8%
  • Yes, the Republicans are evil and the whole thing was used to hide and delay a huge stock market cra

    Votes: 11 14.1%
  • No, it was Ishmael and you can clearly see him throwing people out the windows. Nobody jumped.

    Votes: 16 20.5%
  • No, the buildings were just ready to fall down anyway....chipboard!

    Votes: 8 10.3%
  • SusyQ controlled the terrorists with her blowjobathic powers.

    Votes: 11 14.1%

  • Total voters
    78
On the melted steel theory...

FACT: Jet fuel burns at 800º to 1500ºF, not hot enough to melt steel (2750ºF). However, experts agree that for the towers to collapse, their steel frames didn't need to melt, they just had to lose some of their structural strength--and that required exposure to much less heat. "I have never seen melted steel in a building fire," says retired New York deputy fire chief Vincent Dunn, author of The Collapse Of Burning Buildings: A Guide To Fireground Safety. "But I've seen a lot of twisted, warped, bent and sagging steel. What happens is that the steel tries to expand at both ends, but when it can no longer expand, it sags and the surrounding concrete cracks."

http://popularmechanics.com/

http://911review.com/pm/markup/index.html

True, which proves jet fuel fires could not have turned steel to vapor that was found in significant concentrations in the dust analysis. Nor could collapse pulverization, or a blast furnce effect from the beams falling for <10 seconds.
 
True, which proves jet fuel fires could not have turned steel to vapor that was found in significant concentrations in the dust analysis. Nor could collapse pulverization, or a blast furnce effect from the beams falling for <10 seconds.


You ever seen what a hammer mill does to a car, engine and all?

When several thousand tons of steel fall almost a quarter of a mile to the ground things are gonna get a bit bashed up and broken don't you think?

Not to mention the abrasive affect of the same weight as all the steel in broken and crushed concrete..

Just might create a little steel dust don't you think?
 
Last edited:
You ever seen what a hammer mill does to a car, engine and all?

When several thousand tons of steel fall almost a quarter of a mile to the ground things are gonna get a bit bashed up and broken don't you think?

No to mention the abrasive affect of the same weight as all the steel in broken and crushed concrete..

Just might create a little steel dust don't you think?

The problem is that H beams were found after they had cooled that looked like swiss cheese from the extreme heat basically melting holes through them. There were numerous reports of cranes pulling out columns or beams where the end of the beam was literally dripping metel and white hot weeks after the collapses. No controlled demolition of skyscapers in Vegas or anywhere else has ever caused such anomalies. All the steel in all those demolitions fell a long way down, and even though literal tons of HE linear shaped charges were used, this effect of mass-vaporized steel (other than where the charges cut through) has never been observed.
 
You ever seen what a hammer mill does to a car, engine and all?

When several thousand tons of steel fall almost a quarter of a mile to the ground things are gonna get a bit bashed up and broken don't you think?

Not to mention the abrasive affect of the same weight as all the steel in broken and crushed concrete..

Just might create a little steel dust don't you think?

The arithmatic of steel consumption in the WTC has been debated for years now. None of the numbers are reliable, because none of them are measuring the same thing. Many tons of steel are bonded to concrete and will never be recovered as scrap, and so never weighed.

This sylogism started silly and gets sillier everytime it is repeated.

Steel is missing
Steel cannot be destroyed or lost
therefore something extraordinary happened.

This incarnation of Turd is too tedious to continue the discussion. I'll wait for the next one.
 
The problem is that H beams were found after they had cooled that looked like swiss cheese from the extreme heat basically melting holes through them. There were numerous reports of cranes pulling out columns or beams where the end of the beam was literally dripping metel and white hot weeks after the collapses. No controlled demolition of skyscapers in Vegas or anywhere else has ever caused such anomalies. All the steel in all those demolitions fell a long way down, and even though literal tons of HE linear shaped charges were used, this effect of mass-vaporized steel (other than where the charges cut through) has never been observed.
It's not a problem.

Controlled demolitions don't start with prolonged fires at great heights. The steel was heated hundreds of feet in the air, then got stoked to the extreme in the collapses. Melted, perforated, vaporized - all perfectly possible. Unlike red-mercury-primed, non-lethal, non-radioactive, invisible, nuclear, shaped, double-secret, Communist munitions.
 
The arithmatic of steel consumption in the WTC has been debated for years now. None of the numbers are reliable, because none of them are measuring the same thing. Many tons of steel are bonded to concrete and will never be recovered as scrap, and so never weighed.

This sylogism started silly and gets sillier everytime it is repeated.

Steel is missing
Steel cannot be destroyed or lost
therefore something extraordinary happened.

This incarnation of Turd is too tedious to continue the discussion. I'll wait for the next one.

That might be true if something like 90% of the concrete in the floors wasn't turned to dust. Remember, the EPA estimated 1 million tons of dust. Each tower only weighed ~250,000- 500,000 tons upon completion. (Varying estimates). 1 million tons of dust means a huge portion of the total weight of the towers was turned to dust. Period.
 
It's not a problem.

Controlled demolitions don't start with prolonged fires at great heights. The steel was heated hundreds of feet in the air, then got stoked to the extreme in the collapses. Melted, perforated, vaporized - all perfectly possible. Unlike red-mercury-primed, non-lethal, non-radioactive, invisible, nuclear, shaped, double-secret, Communist munitions.

Except there was zero evidnce of these mythical "extreme stoked fires. There was black smoke before the collapses. Evodenc of oxygen deprived "smoldering" fires.

The NYFD reported they had the fires "knocked down" all the way up on the 98th floor of the first tower struck.

The 1975 WTC fire that was hot enough to melt windows never did any structural damage, and this was before the sprinkler system was installed. The 1975 fire burned for over 4 hours at temperaturs above 1000 degrees F. Never caused ANY steel "weakening", or any structural damage.
 
Except there was zero evidnce of these mythical "extreme stoked fires. There was black smoke before the collapses. Evodenc of oxygen deprived "smoldering" fires.

The NYFD reported they had the fires "knocked down" all the way up on the 98th floor of the first tower struck.

The 1975 WTC fire that was hot enough to melt windows never did any structural damage, and this was before the sprinkler system was installed. The 1975 fire burned for over 4 hours at temperaturs above 1000 degrees F. Never caused ANY steel "weakening", or any structural damage.
If you're hoping not to find evidence of extreme fires, I suggest avoiding all video of the disaster, about twenty thousand eye-witnesses, and about a billion people who watched on TV. If your entire theory rests on there not being extreme fire, you have just conceded that you have no theory.
 
The problem is that H beams were found after they had cooled that looked like swiss cheese from the extreme heat basically melting holes through them. There were numerous reports of cranes pulling out columns or beams where the end of the beam was literally dripping metel and white hot weeks after the collapses. No controlled demolition of skyscapers in Vegas or anywhere else has ever caused such anomalies. All the steel in all those demolitions fell a long way down, and even though literal tons of HE linear shaped charges were used, this effect of mass-vaporized steel (other than where the charges cut through) has never been observed.

That might be true if something like 90% of the concrete in the floors wasn't turned to dust. Remember, the EPA estimated 1 million tons of dust. Each tower only weighed ~250,000- 500,000 tons upon completion. (Varying estimates). 1 million tons of dust means a huge portion of the total weight of the towers was turned to dust. Period.

Yeah what the fuck ever Einstein... Sometimes shit happens.. there isn't a 100% explanation for the anomalies...

FACT.. the towers were hit by 200 ton jets.. fires burned in the towers for over an hour... the structure then failed and collapsed.. anything else is speculation or conjecture... deal with it and move on already...

You want to believe in conspiracy, cover up, aliens from mars, death rays, suitcase nukes or some other outlandish shit brought them down? go ahead.. I'm sure you are going to have company with a lot of other brain dead lunatics..


This sylogism started silly and gets sillier everytime it is repeated.

Steel is missing
Steel cannot be destroyed or lost
therefore something extraordinary happened.

This incarnation of Turd is too tedious to continue the discussion. I'll wait for the next one.

I Agree... I'm done with it...:rolleyes:
 
If you're hoping not to find evidence of extreme fires, I suggest avoiding all video of the disaster, about twenty thousand eye-witnesses, and about a billion people who watched on TV. If your entire theory rests on there not being extreme fire, you have just conceded that you have no theory.


I see lots of black smoke, and very little actual flames.

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/wtc_fires_dsnc1775A.jpg

Black smoke always means a smoldering "cool" fire.
 
Yeah what the fuck ever Einstein... Sometimes shit happens.. there isn't a 100% explanation for the anomalies...

FACT.. the towers were hit by 200 ton jets.. fires burned in the towers for over an hour... the structure then failed and collapsed.. anything else is speculation or conjecture... deal with it and move on already...

You want to believe in conspiracy, cover up, aliens from mars, death rays, suitcase nukes or some other outlandish shit brought them down? go ahead.. I'm sure you are going to have company with a lot of other brain dead lunatics..




I Agree... I'm done with it...:rolleyes:

You're insane. "Stuff happens", eh? Something happened to you at birth, your unbilical cord deprived you of oxygen.
 
I don't believe I said they always go down like that.

Yes you did. That's why I'm calling you an idiot.

I believe I said something along the lines of they always go down into their own footprint

LOL - except that they don't. Fucking LOOONY!

You fuckwits have never given any examples of that happening with any other steel framed hirise buildings. You can't. It's NEVER EVER HAPPENED.

Only possible with controlled demos. Bad luck fuckface, your mommoy dropped you as a baby, and you don't know a damn thing about physics, history, or building contruction.

I hate because nobody really talks like that except people who are clueless and want to sound smart. .

Yep, YOU, you stupid idiot.

Of course the reasons for me saying that don't matter because you're an idiot .

LOL - back your shit recently loonytunes? No, you haven't. LOL

You and your stupid lying friends are the numero uno of idiots on the board.
 
Yes you did. That's why I'm calling you an idiot.



LOL - except that they don't. Fucking LOOONY!

You fuckwits have never given any examples of that happening with any other steel framed hirise buildings. You can't. It's NEVER EVER HAPPENED.

Only possible with controlled demos. Bad luck fuckface, your mommoy dropped you as a baby, and you don't know a damn thing about physics, history, or building contruction.



Yep, YOU, you stupid idiot.



LOL - back your shit recently loonytunes? No, you haven't. LOL

You and your stupid lying friends are the numero uno of idiots on the board.

Nope, couldn't have been CD's, not enough evidence of conventional exposives which leave "fingerprints". Not to mention lighting off literal tons of thermite or shaped cutting charges would have set off every explosives detector (sniffer) in NYC. Something else had to be used: exotic demolition weapons planted by AL Q. They made sure they got the job right the second time around. Evil bastards. All over future oil reserves. Morons.
 
No, you missed it. I'm saying you're right. It's one of those things, not American Flight 77.

My question is this: there was a Flight 77, right? So where is it? Where are the people from it? What do your sources tell you about this?

You must've been the thickest kid in thicksville. I swear that your shithead bullshit has been shot down a hundred times before, and that I already answered it on this very topic.

According to the FAA, Flight 77 wasn't scheduled to fly that day. So it's nowhere. It never flew that day. As for the people; DEAD or non existent. Mass murderers who are planning to kill 3000 Americans don't give a fuck about a 100 or so more.

The blackbox data that shows that flight 77 never hit the Pentagon. It flew north of CITGO. It never flew low enough to hit the light poles or any buildings in the area. It flew too high to do any of that. The blackbox data is clearly, obvious, not from any plane that hit the Pentagon.

You have no video of large passenger hitting the Pentagon either.

Your witnesses contradict each other, and many contradict the govt bullshit.

The govt is lying.
 
According to the FAA, Flight 77 wasn't scheduled to fly that day. So it's nowhere. It never flew that day.

Got it. Flight 77 did not exist.

The blackbox data that shows that flight 77 never hit the Pentagon. It flew north of CITGO. It never flew low enough to hit the light poles or any buildings in the area. It flew too high to do any of that. The blackbox data is clearly, obvious, not from any plane that hit the Pentagon.

Got it. Flight 77 did exist.

Very zen, my friend. I'm impressed.
 
Nope, couldn't have been CD's, not enough evidence of conventional exposives which leave "fingerprints". Not to mention lighting off literal tons of thermite or shaped cutting charges would have set off every explosives detector (sniffer) in NYC. Something else had to be used: exotic demolition weapons planted by AL Q. They made sure they got the job right the second time around. Evil bastards. All over future oil reserves. Morons.

Wrongo, boyo. Thermite traces were found, and thermite is not necessary for controled demos. Conventional explosives there's plenty of evidence of.

Only need a little more than half a ton of conventional demo charges to take down both the Twin Towers, and less than 300lbs to take down WTC 7.

The sniffer dogs had been removed for day, which would've been penty of time to drive a couple of trucks full of the required demo charges into the buildings.

The maintenance levels were every 10 floors as someone long ago pointed out, they probably packed more explosives into the twin towers than they strictly needed to take the buildings down.

As for nukes, you seem hellbent on ever increasing numbers. Turdface and his hologram planes and 10 nukes in each building? You're either a plant, or a total loon. I suspect the former.

Not that it's impossible for 1 small nuke to be smuggled into the basements, all someone has to do is drive in a van. That would explain the molten steel and iron 2 months later.

Al Queda is a term originally used to refer to the database on useful terrorists. Most of the Al Queda operations have been fronts for the black ops of govt intel agencies like MOSSAD and CIA. These facts came out ages ago.

Why were 1000s of Isreali "art students" rounded up and quietly deported after 911? Why were those Israelis dancing as they video recorded the collapse of the twin towers? Why were there Israelis arrested with a van full of bombs trying to cross over to Manhattan while pretending to be Palestinian terrorists?

Lot of evidence of foreign government involvement, but not from some pissant nearly nonexistent "Al Queda" fairtyale terrorists made up by western govts, but from some rogue gang of the Israeli govt's MOSSAD, with ties to some of the leaders of PNAC. Most of them convinced that they were setting to blame Arabs for a patriotic cause, all doing their bit parts, unaware of the true size and scale of the operation and what others were doing. Mixed up with the several military exercises going on that day, which allowed some people to use parts of those military exercies to cover their own actions and delay the USA military's response times.
 
Nothing would explain pools of molten metal months later. Not in this universe anyway.

I can almost buy a massive government conspiracy, secret missiles, kidnapped passengers, etc.

But molten metal that doesn't cool and harden?

To quote my favorite engineer: "You can't change the laws of physics!"
 
According to the FAA, Flight 77 wasn't scheduled to fly that day. So it's nowhere. It never flew that day. As for the people; DEAD or non existent. Mass murderers who are planning to kill 3000 Americans don't give a fuck about a 100 or so more.

Got it. Flight 77 did not exist.

Right, it didn't exist.

The blackbox data that shows that flight 77 never hit the Pentagon. It flew north of CITGO. It never flew low enough to hit the light poles or any buildings in the area. It flew too high to do any of that. The blackbox data is clearly, obvious, not from any plane that hit the Pentagon.
Got it. Flight 77 did exist..

No, you're a dipshit loser who ignored the rest of what I said, and what I meant. The points are clear for a person with commonsense and a modicum of logic; you have neither.

It's obvious that the alleged flight 77 blackbox data is not from any plane that hit the Pentagon. It must be from a different plane.

You have no video of large passenger hitting the Pentagon either.

Your witnesses contradict each other, and many contradict the govt bullshit.

The govt is lying.

Cherry picking? What a loser you certainly are. You have to lie about what someone else has said to make your own points How fucking sick is that. You're a mental case and a half, my sick shill buddy.
 
Nothing would explain pools of molten metal months later. Not in this universe anyway

Nukes in the basement would.

But molten metal that doesn't cool and harden?

Given an initial temperature of 100,000s of degrees kelvin, and the insulation of thousands of tons of concrete, certainly possible that 2 months later it would still be molten. Fact is that there were molten pools of iron and steel 2 months later.
 
Last edited:
Wrongo, boyo. Thermite traces were found, and thermite is not necessary for controled demos. Conventional explosives there's plenty of evidence of.

Only need a little more than half a ton of conventional demo charges to take down both the Twin Towers, and less than 300lbs to take down WTC 7.

The sniffer dogs had been removed for day, which would've been penty of time to drive a couple of trucks full of the required demo charges into the buildings.

The maintenance levels were every 10 floors as someone long ago pointed out, they probably packed more explosives into the twin towers than they strictly needed to take the buildings down.

As for nukes, you seem hellbent on ever increasing numbers. Turdface and his hologram planes and 10 nukes in each building? You're either a plant, or a total loon. I suspect the former.

Not that it's impossible for 1 small nuke to be smuggled into the basements, all someone has to do is drive in a van. That would explain the molten steel and iron 2 months later.

Al Queda is a term originally used to refer to the database on useful terrorists. Most of the Al Queda operations have been fronts for the black ops of govt intel agencies like MOSSAD and CIA. These facts came out ages ago.

Why were 1000s of Isreali "art students" rounded up and quietly deported after 911? Why were those Israelis dancing as they video recorded the collapse of the twin towers? Why were there Israelis arrested with a van full of bombs trying to cross over to Manhattan while pretending to be Palestinian terrorists?

Lot of evidence of foreign government involvement, but not from some pissant nearly nonexistent "Al Queda" fairtyale terrorists made up by western govts, but from some rogue gang of the Israeli govt's MOSSAD, with ties to some of the leaders of PNAC. Most of them convinced that they were setting to blame Arabs for a patriotic cause, all doing their bit parts, unaware of the true size and scale of the operation and what others were doing. Mixed up with the several military exercises going on that day, which allowed some people to use parts of those military exercies to cover their own actions and delay the USA military's response times.

Show me evidence of high explosives like cutting charges. Tell me why every bomb sniffer (electronic) didn't go off when these magical tons of explosives went off? In EVERY CD there is a distinct smell in the air of nitrogen after the event. You are talking about lighting off hundreds of pounds of chemical explosives, per building. (even though traditional CD's use much more than what you claim) What about logistics? No one in manhattan ever noticed truckloads of explosives being brought in and literally thousands of devices being planted? Impossible. The exotic "nuke" theory solves all these little problems you like to ignore.

Further plausability is obtained when looking at reports that Al Q has indeed obtained Russian "loose nukes".

http://www.jamestown.org/terrorism/news/article.php?articleid=23647


I have no fucking clue where you come up with "hologram planes", now you are just being deceitful. I have never mentioned such things. I have mentioned the "home run" remote control anti-hijacking system which was hacked.

As for "who did it", are you seriously going to claim the "government" or Mossad also staged the 1993 bombing? I guess they also blew up the USS Cole, various embassies, and everything else bin Laden took credit for? Are you suggesting bin Laden himself is really a CIA operative?

At any rate, you are illogical in assuming there were conventional explosives used when you either refuse or simply cannot produce any real evidence. No residues. No dust analysis. Nothing excpet some photos of cut beams with no reference as to if they were cut before or after. Tell me how the other severely damaged buildings in the complex were taken down.

Your theory also rests on the fact that 9/11 was done to give Bush a reason to invade Iraq. That is also illogical, as Bush had all the reasons he needed. WMD excuse, and more importantly failure of Saddam to conform to UN resolutions.

9/11 was indeed a PREEMPTIVE strike on the US to stop or delay the invasion and occupation of Iraq for it's strategic oil importance.

I suggest you stop the childish name calling and stick to facts with me, missy.
 
Last edited:
It's obvious that the alleged flight 77 blackbox data is not from any plane that hit the Pentagon. It must be from a different plane.

Got it. It existed, but didn't hit the Pentagon.

No problem, that answers it.

Now that only leaves one very small problem: where is it? Where did it go? What does the black box say about that?

One other question, if you don't mind: Where did they get the black box?
 
Nothing would explain pools of molten metal months later. Not in this universe anyway.

I can almost buy a massive government conspiracy, secret missiles, kidnapped passengers, etc.

But molten metal that doesn't cool and harden?

To quote my favorite engineer: "You can't change the laws of physics!"

They also found a "pothole" in the "bathtub" foundation that went at least 40 feet down into solid bedrock. The hole looks alarmingly like a big glob of molten goo basically melted right through the basement levels, foundation, and bedrock. Basic "China Syndrome".
 
Nothing would explain pools of molten metal months later. Not in this universe anyway.

I can almost buy a massive government conspiracy, secret missiles, kidnapped passengers, etc.

But molten metal that doesn't cool and harden?

To quote my favorite engineer: "You can't change the laws of physics!"
Let me hand you a sparkler. It's got a steel wire about eight inches long, with some aluminum and potassium nitrate along most of its length. Here, hold the end that's just the wire.

OK, I'll light it now. See how brightly it burns? It's very hot at the burning tip, but cool at the end you're holding. That's because steel is a very poor conductor of heat.

Now the sparkler is getting shorter. What's happening to the wire inside? Is it melting or vaporizing? Both maybe?

The sparkler part is burning up, and reaches the end. All that's left is a shortened piece of wire. What's on the end - is it all the molten steel? No, it doesn't seem to be there. It must have vaporized.

About an inch and a half is still glowing red. What happens if you blow on it? Will it go out like a candle? Hm, not at all, it instantly glows orange and gets hotter. Keep blowing, and some more of the steel wire disappears - vaporizing. Fascinating.

So if your oxygen-poor exhaled breath can make that steel wire vaporize, imagine how much more the clear air over New York can stoke the falling steel beams of the WTC towers. How many thousands of degrees hotter could that steel be heated? How much steel could vaporize? And how well insulated would it be under millions of tons of debris and ashes?

Is it really impossible for molten steel to be found weeks after the collapse? Think about it.

If you're stil not convinced, see if you can find a reputable materials specialist who doubts the events of 9/11 based on the recovery of molten steel.
 
Back
Top