512 Architects & Engineering Professionals

Was 9/11 an Inside Job?

  • Yes, the buildings were controlled demolitions with the Terrorists used as decoys.

    Votes: 56 71.8%
  • Yes, Osama Bin Laden is actually a CIA operative. That's why everyone lets him escape all the time.

    Votes: 17 21.8%
  • Yes, the Republicans are evil and the whole thing was used to hide and delay a huge stock market cra

    Votes: 11 14.1%
  • No, it was Ishmael and you can clearly see him throwing people out the windows. Nobody jumped.

    Votes: 16 20.5%
  • No, the buildings were just ready to fall down anyway....chipboard!

    Votes: 8 10.3%
  • SusyQ controlled the terrorists with her blowjobathic powers.

    Votes: 11 14.1%

  • Total voters
    78
Let me hand you a sparkler. It's got a steel wire about eight inches long, with some aluminum and potassium nitrate along most of its length. Here, hold the end that's just the wire.

OK, I'll light it now. See how brightly it burns? It's very hot at the burning tip, but cool at the end you're holding. That's because steel is a very poor conductor of heat.

Now the sparkler is getting shorter. What's happening to the wire inside? Is it melting or vaporizing? Both maybe?

The sparkler part is burning up, and reaches the end. All that's left is a shortened piece of wire. What's on the end - is it all the molten steel? No, it doesn't seem to be there. It must have vaporized.

About an inch and a half is still glowing red. What happens if you blow on it? Will it go out like a candle? Hm, not at all, it instantly glows orange and gets hotter. Keep blowing, and some more of the steel wire disappears - vaporizing. Fascinating.

So if your oxygen-poor exhaled breath can make that steel wire vaporize, imagine how much more the clear air over New York can stoke the falling steel beams of the WTC towers. How many thousands of degrees hotter could that steel be heated? How much steel could vaporize? And how well insulated would it be under millions of tons of debris and ashes?

Is it really impossible for molten steel to be found weeks after the collapse? Think about it.

If you're stil not convinced, see if you can find a reputable materials specialist who doubts the events of 9/11 based on the recovery of molten steel.

Nope, sparklers do not vaporize, the wire curls up. it's still there after the sparkler burns out, it does not get shorter.
 
Nukes in the basement would.



Given an initial temperature of 100,000s of degrees kelvin, and the insulation of thousands of tons of concrete, certainly possible that 2 months later it would still be molten. Fact is that there were molten pools of iron and steel 2 months later.

Nonsense. Show me a picture.
 
Let me hand you a sparkler. It's got a steel wire about eight inches long, with some aluminum and potassium nitrate along most of its length. Here, hold the end that's just the wire.

OK, I'll light it now. See how brightly it burns? It's very hot at the burning tip, but cool at the end you're holding. That's because steel is a very poor conductor of heat.

Now the sparkler is getting shorter. What's happening to the wire inside? Is it melting or vaporizing? Both maybe?

The sparkler part is burning up, and reaches the end. All that's left is a shortened piece of wire. What's on the end - is it all the molten steel? No, it doesn't seem to be there. It must have vaporized.

About an inch and a half is still glowing red. What happens if you blow on it? Will it go out like a candle? Hm, not at all, it instantly glows orange and gets hotter. Keep blowing, and some more of the steel wire disappears - vaporizing. Fascinating.

So if your oxygen-poor exhaled breath can make that steel wire vaporize, imagine how much more the clear air over New York can stoke the falling steel beams of the WTC towers. How many thousands of degrees hotter could that steel be heated? How much steel could vaporize? And how well insulated would it be under millions of tons of debris and ashes?

Is it really impossible for molten steel to be found weeks after the collapse? Think about it.

If you're stil not convinced, see if you can find a reputable materials specialist who doubts the events of 9/11 based on the recovery of molten steel.

That made my head hurt. Which side are you arguing?

Concrete absorbs heat.
 
Bullshit, sir.

I have lit many, and I can attest they do not vaporize.

Proof: A finished sparker pushed against a plastic tube to show the heat still left in the metal wire for saftey reasons!


Taken from here:

http://www.firework-review.org.uk/fireworksafety4b.htm

Notice the BURNED OUT sparkler is still quite intact.





Another image:

http://static.howstuffworks.com/gif/fireworks-sparkler.jpg

As you can clearly see, the burned out portion is still there, although blackened and slightly curved.

Seriously, have you ever held a sparkler? I have NEVER had one burn down to a "nub".
 
Last edited:
Batshit, I'm convinced you don't even believe this by now. I think you just staked out a position and are arguing it to argue it.

Normally, that's cool by me. Most of time, I'm more interested in the argument than the subject at hand anyway. But I do want to remind you that, nuke or airplane, terrorist or inside job, smoke or fire or steel, this particular argument ends the same way: lots and lots of people died. Actual people.

When you discuss whether fire burns steel, you're forgetting: either way, it burns people to death. When you discuss whether airplanes can bring a building down, you're forgetting: either way, there were airplanes that crashed, and killed real people.

I don't know if you have kids. Scary thought, but nevermind. You're someone's son, brother, friend. The parents, children, brothers, sisters, friends and coworkers for those who died that day are not theoretical. They are real, and some of them are even on Lit.

So remember, when you talk about what brings towers down, regardless of what does, they came down and brought a few thousand people with them.

I am aware that I have stoked this discussion as well. I have the false and often dumb belief that I can Socrates people into being reasonable. I am wrong, of course.

At this point, I'd only ask--perhaps in vain, of course--that you have some respect and view this with the perspective it deserves. It's all fun to discuss, but at the end of the day, whatever happened, these were actual people who died in the building you're discussing so glibly from afar.
 
Batshit, I'm convinced you don't even believe this by now. I think you just staked out a position and are arguing it to argue it.

Normally, that's cool by me. Most of time, I'm more interested in the argument than the subject at hand anyway. But I do want to remind you that, nuke or airplane, terrorist or inside job, smoke or fire or steel, this particular argument ends the same way: lots and lots of people died. Actual people.

When you discuss whether fire burns steel, you're forgetting: either way, it burns people to death. When you discuss whether airplanes can bring a building down, you're forgetting: either way, there were airplanes that crashed, and killed real people.

I don't know if you have kids. Scary thought, but nevermind. You're someone's son, brother, friend. The parents, children, brothers, sisters, friends and coworkers for those who died that day are not theoretical. They are real, and some of them are even on Lit.

So remember, when you talk about what brings towers down, regardless of what does, they came down and brought a few thousand people with them.

I am aware that I have stoked this discussion as well. I have the false and often dumb belief that I can Socrates people into being reasonable. I am wrong, of course.

At this point, I'd only ask--perhaps in vain, of course--that you have some respect and view this with the perspective it deserves. It's all fun to discuss, but at the end of the day, whatever happened, these were actual people who died in the building you're discussing so glibly from afar.

The only ones disrepecting the dead are people like you who refuse to even ask questions about how they died, to hopefully prevent this from happening in the future.
 
The only ones disrepecting the dead are people like you who refuse to even ask questions about how they died, to hopefully prevent this from happening in the future.
No, you're wrong. If that's why you're asking, you're looking in entirely the wrong place.

Let's say you're correct, and terrorists both planted bombs and flew airplanes into the buildings. Remove the explosives from the equation, and many people still die. So it doesn't stop anything from happening again. In fact, obsessing about the explosives distracts from the real place that might prevent it from happening again: U.S. foreign policy and diplomacy.

Go to school on the history of Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and now Iraq and Iran. See why radical Islamists find the need to act against the U.S. Hint: It's not because they hate freedom or even because the Koran is so inciteful.

If you really want to be sure it never happens again, get your head out of the conspiracy sites and study geopolitics. You will find answers there that you'll never get to debating how sparklers work. THAT respects lives. Tossing around pseudoscience and wrapping it in the lofty pursuit of justice is disingenuous as best and profane at worst.
 
No, you're wrong. If that's why you're asking, you're looking in entirely the wrong place.

Let's say you're correct, and terrorists both planted bombs and flew airplanes into the buildings. Remove the explosives from the equation, and many people still die. So it doesn't stop anything from happening again. In fact, obsessing about the explosives distracts from the real place that might prevent it from happening again: U.S. foreign policy and diplomacy.

Go to school on the history of Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and now Iraq and Iran. See why radical Islamists find the need to act against the U.S. Hint: It's not because they hate freedom or even because the Koran is so inciteful.

If you really want to be sure it never happens again, get your head out of the conspiracy sites and study geopolitics. You will find answers there that you'll never get to debating how sparklers work. THAT respects lives. Tossing around pseudoscience and wrapping it in the lofty pursuit of justice is disingenuous as best and profane at worst.

I disagree with your accusation that arguing about seemingly insignificant details about a tragic event is "profane".

Did I bring up sparklers? No.

I know exactly why they attacked us. US military bases in Saudi Arabia and US allegiance with Israel.

I have also gone over the reasons in great detail, where everything points directly to coming energy wars.

I'll say it one more time: 9/11 was a preemptive strike to delay or stop Bush from invading Iraq and occupying it FOREVER because of it's oil reserves.
 
Last edited:
I disagree with your accusation that arguing about seemingly insignificant details about a tragic event is "profane".

Did I bring up sparklers? No.

I know exactly why they attacked us. US military bases in Saudi Arabia and US allegiance with Israel.

I have also gone over the reasons in great detail, where everything points directly to coming energy wars.

I'll say it one more time: 9/11 was a preemptive strike to delay or stop Bush from invading Iraq and occupying it FOREVER because of it's oil reserves.
I hadn't seen you say that before, but you do realize that 1) there was no impending invasion of Iraq at the time, and 2) the attacks caused, not averted that invasion, and 3) no one behind the attacks had any great affection for Iraq--and certainly could not have been moved to dissuade action against it in such bold measure or at all. Right?
 
I hadn't seen you say that before, but you do realize that 1) there was no impending invasion of Iraq at the time, and 2) the attacks caused, not averted that invasion, and 3) no one behind the attacks had any great affection for Iraq--and certainly could not have been moved to dissuade action against it in such bold measure or at all. Right?

Ah, but there was an impending invasion. The now-infamous "Downing St. Memos" prove Bush , et al, were planning it even before Bush was elected!

2. The attacks caused the invasion of Iraq? Saddam had nothing to do with 9/11. We invaded Iraq because of "WMDs", and Saddam's failure to comply with UN resolutions.

3. How do you know Al Q wasn't aided by nations who did not want us to invade Iraq and sit on those massive oil reserves for the indefinite future?
 
Last edited:
Ah, but there as an impending invasion. The now-infamous "Downing St. Memos" prove Bush , et al, were planning it even before Bush was elected!

2. The attacks caused the invasion of Iraq? Saddam had nothing to do with 9/11. We invaded Iraq because of "WMDs", and Saddam's failure to comply with UN resolutions.

3. How do you know Al Q wasn't aided by nations who did not want us to invade Iraq and sit on those massive oil reserves for the indefinite future?
I'm out, Batshit.
 
I see lots of black smoke, and very little actual flames.

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/wtc_fires_dsnc1775A.jpg

Black smoke always means a smoldering "cool" fire.
http://www.historycommons.org/events-images/632_eutectic.jpg
http://www.wtv-zone.com/caseman/3/ani/laughdog.gif

Really, Turd???? Pray tell us what was causing all the smoke that was billowing from the buildings raising hundreds, if not thousands of feet in the air? Could it have been fire ya think? What could cause that volume of smoke if it wasn't large scale office fires? Don't worry LN couldn't think up an excuse as to what was causing all the smoke either. You gonna ignore it like she did?

Firstly, I don't see any black smoke in that photo. Do you? I can see the bright orange glow of fires burning and greyish smoke. Not that it matters any way.

http://i153.photobucket.com/albums/s232/Bad_Doggie/oilwell1.jpg

To use an obvious example above, oil wells burning in the open atmosphere are about as well-ventilated as possible, yet leave choking plumes of dark, black smoke, and routinely heat steel structures enough for them to deform and collapse.

Your assertion is overly simplistic. Smoke coloration is dependent on the combustion products, and the actual fire temperature may vary considerably from its centre to its edge. Even if smoke colour could be used to estimate the average fire temperature, it would be impossible to estimate the maximum fire temperature from a gross evaluation of smoke colour.

Any how, on a building the size of WTC that is full of air and surrounded by air which can now enter the building via the gapping hole in its exterior, what do you think was consuming that copious volume of Oxygen rapidly enough to cause Oxygen starvation? Would you describe a fire that could do that to be a small scale fire?

Look the answer to your mystery is in the title of the photo you keep posting.

I’ll make it easier for you. historycommons.org/events-images/632_eutectic.jpg

Look up Eutectic reactions and tell us what you find. Then post the report,( that you have seen before but didn’t understand), from Drs Jonathan Barnett ,Ronald R. Biederman and Richard D. Sisson Jr on the WTC steel and tell us what they say.

I am feeling generous today. I know you can’t find it in amongst your thousands of posts.

Here’s the thread Anyone who hasn't seen it this is a funny thread, full of Turdisms. Well worth a read.

Here’s the article

Good luck, your answer to your mystery is right there.

Woof!
 
Last edited:
On the melted steel theory...

FACT: Jet fuel burns at 800º to 1500ºF, not hot enough to melt steel (2750ºF). However, experts agree that for the towers to collapse, their steel frames didn't need to melt, they just had to lose some of their structural strength--and that required exposure to much less heat. "I have never seen melted steel in a building fire," says retired New York deputy fire chief Vincent Dunn, author of The Collapse Of Burning Buildings: A Guide To Fireground Safety. "But I've seen a lot of twisted, warped, bent and sagging steel. What happens is that the steel tries to expand at both ends, but when it can no longer expand, it sags and the surrounding concrete cracks."

http://popularmechanics.com/

http://911review.com/pm/markup/index.html
That’s right, the mystery will be cleared up when Turd comes back with his info on eutectic reactions.

Steel has lost 40% of its strength at 550°C and will continue to rapidly descend from there.

Normal office fires regularly produce temp of 1000C http://forum.literotica.com/showthread.php?p=24914329#post24914329



http://i153.photobucket.com/albums/s232/Bad_Doggie/tempcurve.jpg

Woof!
 
Last edited:
I agree, there seems to be speculation even among experts about exactly how much steel was in the towers, or even what each tower weighed in total. Regardless of that, there is evidence of significant missing steel in at least the 10's of thousands of tons, and proof of vaporized steel in the dust. Steel was vaporized, period. Impossible from jet fuel or collapse "pulverization". Concrete, yes. Steel decking and beams and columns and trusses, no.
Well, ok, but where is this evidence you keep mentioning? Why haven’t you posted it after being given ample opportunity to?

Seeing as you are claiming that “10's of thousands of tons” is missing I would have thought that you had some reliable, verifiable evidence of this fact and seeing as you have been claiming it for the past 18 months or so I would have thought that you would have had it at your finger tips! Especially, as it is the reason you give as to why you believe your Nuke theory. Even over-looking the other practical and logical reasons why it couldn’t possibly work.

But, you don’t have any evidence of missing steel do you? You have no idea how much steel was actually removed. Or any idea what quantity of steel was actually contained in the dust.

There is no speculation amongst experts regarding the structural steel, NONE. They all say 200 000 tons as you found out. If you had bothered to look at what NIST say you would’ve seen they even give a breakdown of the amounts. What they don’t list is how much other steel was in the buildings, like; stair hand rails, fire doors, water tanks, fuel tanks etc, etc, etc.

So at this point we are at a bit of an impasse in proving your Nuke theory. We know how much structural steel, 200 000 tons, were in WTC 1&2 combined and we have a conservative estimate of 230 000 tons including WTC 7. Hell lets go for broke and use a higher realistic figure of 240 000 tons for all three buildings. See I can be generous too.

But, we don’t know how much was actually removed or should even be expected to be removed.
WotDa we gonna do???

How about we take a revolutionary out of the box approach and find a report or an article by the people who were actually responsible for the clean-up operation?

Before planning the potentially unwieldy cleanup project, officials needed to estimate the dimensions of the task they faced. Early numbers emerged from a computer program that the Army Corps of Engineers uses to gauge the debris created by natural disasters like hurricanes.
Hastily adapted to the World Trade Center, the calculations predicted that the site contained 308,900 tons of steel, 351,000 tons of concrete and a total of 1,051,000 tons of debris over all, said Beau Hanna, an Army Corps expert on debris. .

American Iron and Steel institute.

Wow look at that TURD they calculate that it should be expected to remove 309 000 tons of steel from the WTC site. Christ going by your previous article that means that some 141 000 tons of steel must have been vaporized????? 141 000 TONS. These must have been big Nukes.

But, wait a minute we haven’t verified exactly how much was removed.

How about we take our revolutionary out of the box approach a step further and actually see what the people who were responsible for inspecting, preserving and documenting the removed steel say. Not You Tube, not some un-verifiable news article but the people were actually responsible for the task. WaDaYa fink they should know? You could have checked there. WaDa they say?

Of the estimated 1.5 million tons of WTC concrete, steel and other debris, more than 350, 000 tons of steel have been extracted from Ground Zero and barged or trucked to salvage yards where it is cut up for recycling. Salvage yard operations are shown in Figures D-1 through D-3.

FEMA

Well WaDaYaNo, they say more than 350 000 tons of steel were recovered. Opps that is more, much more than we were expecting huh if the Nukes vaporized it all? And matches reasonably well with the amount that was calculated should have been found for the four buildings WTC 1,2,5,and 7.

So at the end of our quest to find out how much steel was vaporized we can say none. NO 10s 000 tons of steel were vaporized, NONE. It’s all there and then some. It’s just a figment of your imagination.

We can figure out the why the Iron appeared in the dust (it didn't come from the structural steel) and the appearance of melted steel when you post on eutectic reactions. Your answer to your questions is right there. If you understand it this time.

Woof!
 
Last edited:
Jet fuel fires? Or collapse pressures? Or the magical "falling beams blast- furnace effect" theory?

I remember it all well, I just don't believe any of those theories. Case in point:

Actual controlled demolitions where tons of high explosive linear shaped cutting charges are used have never produced such effects. Building fires far worse than on 9/11 have never produced such effects. (see 1975 WTC fire).

Thet leaves one explanation for the extreme heat-related anomalies: exotic demolition devices. Russian black market pure fusion SADMs. :eek:

The jet fuel was all gone, burnt off in around 15 min. There is no evidence extreme temperatures. The absolute max temperatures are of the order of 1300C with the average fire temperatures 600 to a little over 1000C, nothing more is needed and definately no Nukes.

You do know that the energy release by the collapse of one the towers was between 25-50% of the energy released when the bomb was dropped on Nagasaki don’t you.

You think that kind of energy release could do it, do ya?

Woof!
 
Last edited:
And the 1975 WTC fire burned for over 4 hours and melted windows. No steel was "weakened". No steel was vaporized or had "eutectic reactions".

Drop a steel beam 1000 feet onto another steel beam. Will either beam turn to dust? Impossible.

Your estimates of steel removed include other buildings which were demolished due to extreme damage.

Eutectic reactions cannot explain the significant concentrations of steel in the 1 million tons of dust. (In roughly the same concentrations as was in the buildings compared to everything else that turned to dust, including a large number of people)
 
Your estimates of steel removed include other buildings which were demolished due to extreme damage.
That’s correct. They estimate 309 000 tons for the buildings (including WTC 1&2 the largest contributors by far) that were demolished. In fact they removed 350 000 tons so they removed all the steel that was in the buildings and then some. The "and then some" includes the 1400 vehicles that were also destroyed. We can see the estimate of what should have been there matches the quantity removed very, very well.

So, none of the steel was missing vaporized, disappeared, vanished or other wise. It was all there and accounted for.

You were just too lazy or incompetent to establish this fact and have just been making up your nuke nonsense based on what exactly???

Woof!
 
Drop a steel beam 1000 feet onto another steel beam. Will either beam turn to dust? Impossible.
Nope, of course not, it would be ridiculous to suggest that. Who, apart from you, is suggesting that they would?

You may get a small puff of oxidized surface dust but that would be it. The beams would both still be there and there masses would not have significantly changed.

Ooooooh haaaaaang on, I think I get your problem. Where do you think the Iron in the dust came from??? From the structural steel????(apart from any surface oxidization) No surely not????

Sorry, but if you think that you get another laughing dog!

http://www.wtv-zone.com/caseman/3/ani/laughdog.gif

Most of it didn’t come from the structural steel at all. Any ideas where else it could have come from Mr Construction expert???

Woof!
 
Eutectic reactions cannot explain the significant concentrations of steel in the 1 million tons of dust. (In roughly the same concentrations as was in the buildings compared to everything else that turned to dust, including a large number of people)
Again, who is suggesting that Eutectic reactions have anything to do, what-so-ever, with the steel (more like Iron) that was found in the dust?

If you could stick to one topic and follow it through to a conclusion this kind of confusion would be avoided.

Eutectic reactions are the explanation as to why some of the beams had a melted “Swiss cheese” appearance. That you claimed were evidence of high temperature Vaporization. It is quite amazing that you couldn’t figure this out, especially as it was in the title of the actual photo that you used to claim it was evidence of high temperatures and vaporization.

Eutectic reactions are not a sign of high temperature, in fact the converse. A Sulphur Iron Eutectic reaction will take place in the temperature range of between 500 and 800C.

Around 900C is the temperature at which a steel-sulphur eutectic melts. Therefore on the piece of steel in the photo you posted a lot of the eutectic survived, and this part cannot have reached much more than 900C. Your photo evidence proves you wrong. There were no high temperatures and no vaporization.

900C is a wholly credible number in an ordinary office fire. But, not for Thermite or Nukes which would have had to have been much higher, sorry.

Woof!
 
And the 1975 WTC fire burned for over 4 hours and melted windows. No steel was "weakened". No steel was vaporized or had "eutectic reactions".
The mistake you are making here by considering the two as equals is called an Equivocation Fallacy. They only seem equal to you and you alone; and only because of lack of education or bias on your part. They are not equal at all.
Did the 1975 fire have an airplane crash precede it?

That did the following:
Instantaneously ignite multiple high temperature 900-1300C jet fuel fires that would cause concrete spalling and cracking on several floors?

Remove; destroy passive fire prevention that was intended to protect the steel in the event of a fire?

Destruction, of active fire abatement methods, such as water sprinkler system?

Have fires over 4 floors that were alight over the whole area of those floors, at the same time?

No the two situations are in no way comparable and the 1975 fire gives us no president as what we should have expected to have happened in 2001. This has, also, been explained to you multiple times by multiple people. It adds nothing to your argument and only detracts from your character.

I am taking this as an attempt to shift the argument. Let’s stay on track huh?

Woof!
 
That’s correct. They estimate 309 000 tons for the buildings (including WTC 1&2 the largest contributors by far) that were demolished. In fact they removed 350 000 tons so they removed all the steel that was in the buildings and then some. The "and then some" includes the 1400 vehicles that were also destroyed. We can see the estimate of what should have been there matches the quantity removed very, very well.

So, none of the steel was missing vaporized, disappeared, vanished or other wise. It was all there and accounted for.

You were just too lazy or incompetent to establish this fact and have just been making up your nuke nonsense based on what exactly???

Woof!

"According to FEMA, more than 350,000 tons of steel were extracted from Ground Zero and barged or trucked to salvage yards where it was cut up for recycling. Four salvage yards were contracted to process the steel."

The total amount of steel from both towers AND all the buildings like WTC 6, 7, 4, etc that were demolished is more than 350k tons. Not to mention the vehicles that you mention.

Was there significant steel in the dust? According to news reports, yes:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LW6b8JF5ls
 
Back
Top