512 Architects & Engineering Professionals

Was 9/11 an Inside Job?

  • Yes, the buildings were controlled demolitions with the Terrorists used as decoys.

    Votes: 56 71.8%
  • Yes, Osama Bin Laden is actually a CIA operative. That's why everyone lets him escape all the time.

    Votes: 17 21.8%
  • Yes, the Republicans are evil and the whole thing was used to hide and delay a huge stock market cra

    Votes: 11 14.1%
  • No, it was Ishmael and you can clearly see him throwing people out the windows. Nobody jumped.

    Votes: 16 20.5%
  • No, the buildings were just ready to fall down anyway....chipboard!

    Votes: 8 10.3%
  • SusyQ controlled the terrorists with her blowjobathic powers.

    Votes: 11 14.1%

  • Total voters
    78
The mistake you are making here by considering the two as equals is called an Equivocation Fallacy. They only seem equal to you and you alone; and only because of lack of education or bias on your part. They are not equal at all.
Did the 1975 fire have an airplane crash precede it?

That did the following:
Instantaneously ignite multiple high temperature 900-1300C jet fuel fires that would cause concrete spalling and cracking on several floors?

Remove; destroy passive fire prevention that was intended to protect the steel in the event of a fire?

Destruction, of active fire abatement methods, such as water sprinkler system?

Have fires over 4 floors that were alight over the whole area of those floors, at the same time?

No the two situations are in no way comparable and the 1975 fire gives us no president as what we should have expected to have happened in 2001. This has, also, been explained to you multiple times by multiple people. It adds nothing to your argument and only detracts from your character.

I am taking this as an attempt to shift the argument. Let’s stay on track huh?

Woof!

1. The fire prevention was not fully installed in 1975. (asbestos).

2. There was NO sprinkler system installed in 1975, this was added after that fire, along with other improvements to try and stop fires spreading between floors through wire passages.

3. You're full of shit , as usual, and the poll clearly shows YOUR view is in the minority.
 
You could answer that yourself. What is the melting temperature of aluminum?

You can Google, I know you can.

You’re just flailing about and going of topic.

Woof!

Really? Jet fuel can melt aluminum and keep it in a liquid state for months? 100 days? This must be some crazy kerosene that doesn't burn up or evaporate, but magically stays on fire for 100 days.
 
1. The fire prevention was not fully installed in 1975. (asbestos).

2. There was NO sprinkler system installed in 1975, this was added after that fire, along with other improvements to try and stop fires spreading between floors through wire passages.

3. You're full of shit , as usual, and the poll clearly shows YOUR view is in the minority.

All of this is yet further off topic. Look don’t you wanna find the source of the steel/Iron in the dust? That is so important to your Nuke theory.

We can return all the rest of this stuff later if you like.

Let’s stay focused.

Woof!
 
All of this is yet further off topic. Look don’t you wanna find the source of the steel/Iron in the dust? That is so important to your Nuke theory.

We can return all the rest of this stuff later if you like.

Let’s stay focused.

Woof!

Listen, man, I wasn't even there. All I know is that there was some weird shit that went down that does not add up.

This ABC news report specifically mentions vaporized steel:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LW6b8JF5ls
 
Really? Jet fuel can melt aluminum and keep it in a liquid state for months? 100 days? This must be some crazy kerosene that doesn't burn up or evaporate, but magically stays on fire for 100 days.

I believe I have already said that it does. Only, a few posts ago in fact.

The melting point of aluminum is around 650C, Jet fuel burns at 800-1300C. So what.

The temps in the pile were in some spots up to 1000C if I remember correctly. So what.

You ask easy questions, I know you can Google.

Woof!
 
Last edited:
Listen, man, I wasn't even there. All I know is that there was some weird shit that went down that does not add up.

This ABC news report specifically mentions vaporized steel:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8LW6b8JF5ls

Now we are back to you tube and another fuck-wit reporter who is making a story about something he knows nothing about.

Are you really interested in the "the Truth" do you really wanna find out what happened? You want a clue to your mystery?

Google wiki Fly Ash, read, read the link on the same page to concrete and come back and tell us what you find.

Woof!
 
Now we are back to you tube and another fuck-wit reporter who is making a story about something he knows nothing about.

Are you really interested in the "the Truth" do you really wanna find out what happened? You want a clue to your mystery?

Google wiki Fly Ash, read, read the link on the same page to concrete and come back and tell us what you find.

Woof!

No, the reporter specifically states:

"The EPA did find spotty levels of asbestos, a sample on a police car turned out dangerous, another sample a couple of blocks away not dangerous. But most interesting, in the mix, they're looking,they think, at specks of steel that used to be beams and elevators, marble from the lobby floor and facings, so what were once the strongest architectural elements in the two towers were pulverized, large portions turned into clouds, ...

If some of the hardest materials were vaporized, how to account for all the paper...? "

The EPA found steel in the dust.
 
No, the reporter specifically states:

"The EPA did find spotty levels of asbestos, a sample on a police car turned out dangerous, another sample a couple of blocks away not dangerous. But most interesting, in the mix, they're looking,they think, at specks of steel that used to be beams and elevators, marble from the lobby floor and facings, so what were once the strongest architectural elements in the two towers were pulverized, large portions turned into clouds, ...

If some of the hardest materials were vaporized, how to account for all the paper...? "

The EPA found steel in the dust.

Turd what do I have to say to convince you that I am not interested in a You Tube video of some fuck-wit reporter that doesn’t know what he is talking about.

Show me a report from an accredited verifiable source and I will read it.
I have just shown you how wrong you can be doing what you do, but you continue. Why? What is it ignorance, stubbornness? What?

How's your wiki search going, what is fly ash and what do they do with it?

Woof!
 
Turd what do I have to say to convince you that I am not interested in a You Tube video of some fuck-wit reporter that doesn’t know what he is talking about.

Show me a report from an accredited verifiable source and I will read it.
I have just shown you how wrong you can be doing what you do, but you continue. Why? What is it ignorance, stubbornness? What?

How's your wiki search going, what is fly ash and what do they do with it?

Woof!

Fly ash contains very little iron. It's mostly silicon and oxygen. The reporter was quoting directly from the EPA. Are you saying he made it all up? The EPA found "specks of steel from beams and elevators" in the dust, something that surprised them.
 
Fly ash contains very little iron. It's mostly silicon and oxygen. The reporter was quoting directly from the EPA. Are you saying he made it all up? The EPA found "specks of steel from beams and elevators" in the dust, something that surprised them.

Now we are back to the same problem we had with the quantities of steel used and recovered from the wtc site.

At this point I really don’t know how the amount of Iron in the concrete matches up to the amount in the dust and neither do you.

It is only one source of what could have been in the building other sources would include all steel particles in the concrete from the time of construction. They were pouring concrete at the same time as cutting/welding the columns. So it is most likely that there was a reasonable amount, in the concrete from there. Plus any from modification repairs, retro fits to the building. A whole range of places where iron dust would be in the steel building. The Iron in the dust came from the concrete and the building.

No he didn’t make it up. However, I certainly don’t take it as credible what a reporter writes, says. For the very obvious reason that they are apt to make mistakes, very big ones when dealing with technical issues that they don’t understand. It happens over and over.

Do you have the actual words/report from the EPA?

Woof!
 
Last edited:
• Astaneh-Asl said steel flanges "had been reduced from an inch thick to paper thin." [3]

• At a recycling center in New Jersey, he saw 10-ton steel beams from the towers that "looked like giant sticks of twisted licorice." [4] He showed the San Francisco Chronicle a "banana-shaped, rust-colored piece of steel" that had somehow "twisted like toffee during the terrorist attack." [5]

• He noted the way steel from the WTC had bent at several connection points that had joined the floors to the vertical columns. He described the connections as being smoothly warped, saying, "If you remember the Salvador Dali paintings with the clocks that are kind of melted--it's kind of like that." He added, "That could only happen if you get steel yellow hot or white hot--perhaps around 2,000 degrees." [6]

• In an interview in 2007, Astaneh-Asl recalled, "I saw melting of girders in [the] World Trade Center." [7]

• He found a foot-long twisted shard of steel that was "like a piece of bread, but it was high-strength steel." He commented, "I haven't seen anything like this [before]." [8]

• He came across "severely scorched [steel] members from 40 or so floors below the points of impact [by the planes]." [9]

• The fireproofing that had been used to protect the WTC steel also showed evidence of extreme conditions. In some places it had "melted into a glassy residue." [10]

• Astaneh-Asl saw a charred I-beam from WTC Building 7--a 47-story skyscraper that collapsed late in the afternoon of 9/11, even though no plane hit it. "The beam, so named because its cross-section looks like a capital I, had clearly endured searing temperatures. Parts of the flat top of the I, once five-eighths of an inch thick, had vaporized." [11]

http://shoestring911.blogspot.com/2008/02/engineer-sees-evidence-of-extreme.html

There you go, eyewitness expert structural engineer testimony.


Edit:

It takes plasma torch temperatures to melt and glassify asbestos:

http://www.europlasma.com/asbestos-melting-unit_33.html
 
Last edited:
• Astaneh-Asl said steel flanges "had been reduced from an inch thick to paper thin." [3]

• At a recycling center in New Jersey, he saw 10-ton steel beams from the towers that "looked like giant sticks of twisted licorice." [4] He showed the San Francisco Chronicle a "banana-shaped, rust-colored piece of steel" that had somehow "twisted like toffee during the terrorist attack." [5]

• He noted the way steel from the WTC had bent at several connection points that had joined the floors to the vertical columns. He described the connections as being smoothly warped, saying, "If you remember the Salvador Dali paintings with the clocks that are kind of melted--it's kind of like that." He added, "That could only happen if you get steel yellow hot or white hot--perhaps around 2,000 degrees." [6]

• In an interview in 2007, Astaneh-Asl recalled, "I saw melting of girders in [the] World Trade Center." [7]

• He found a foot-long twisted shard of steel that was "like a piece of bread, but it was high-strength steel." He commented, "I haven't seen anything like this [before]." [8]

• He came across "severely scorched [steel] members from 40 or so floors below the points of impact [by the planes]." [9]

• The fireproofing that had been used to protect the WTC steel also showed evidence of extreme conditions. In some places it had "melted into a glassy residue." [10]

• Astaneh-Asl saw a charred I-beam from WTC Building 7--a 47-story skyscraper that collapsed late in the afternoon of 9/11, even though no plane hit it. "The beam, so named because its cross-section looks like a capital I, had clearly endured searing temperatures. Parts of the flat top of the I, once five-eighths of an inch thick, had vaporized." [11]

http://shoestring911.blogspot.com/2008/02/engineer-sees-evidence-of-extreme.html

There you go, eyewitness expert structural engineer testimony.


Edit:

It takes plasma torch temperatures to melt and glassify asbestos:

http://www.europlasma.com/asbestos-melting-unit_33.html

And there you go again, same mistake again or an even an attempt to mislead. Do you really have any interest in the Truth do you?

A 911 site full of miss quotes really doesn’t help your case. If you could find a report where Dr. Astaneh-Asl actually puts his name to those things it would greatly help your case. Can you???

If you can't verify this claim, it is wrong. End of story.

The word "vaporized" is an artifact of the reporter, not from Dr. Astaneh-Asl himself. You can ask him if you like. Reporters don't neccessarily understand the scientific implications of vaporization. The steel in question is, beyond any doubt, an example of eutectic melting (as it says on your photo title), which occurs at temperatures in the 600-900 oC region, and thus cannot be due to thermite or Nukes. It can, however, happen in an ordinary fire, if the right chemicals are present.

In other writings or report actually writen by him that I have read he is quite adamant in his opinion that the collapses, all of them, were not caused by any covert explosives, incendiaries, or other mystery devices.

NIST treats examples of the eutectic effects in NCSTAR1-3C, particularly section 6.3.4.

It isn't known if this effect is common in large structure fires, and all the examples we have appear to have taken place after collapse. I believe there is a small but non-zero additional hazard presented by this effect, which is not being followed up on as far as I know. But no great mystery. The phenomenology absolutely rules out thermite or Nukes.


Woof!
 
Last edited:
And the official reason for the amounts of sulphur needed to create these novel eutectic reactions which have never been observed in building fires before, including the 1975 WTC fire:

acid rain

That's right folks, RAIN caused the fires burning for over 100 days to turn hardened and UL tested structural steel to swiss cheese. I'm not making this up, this is the official explanation.
 
And the official reason for the amounts of sulphur needed to create these novel eutectic reactions which have never been observed in building fires before, including the 1975 WTC fire:

acid rain

That's right folks, RAIN caused the fires burning for over 100 days to turn hardened and UL tested structural steel to swiss cheese. I'm not making this up, this is the official explanation.

So you wish to continue with this complete and utter nonsense.

Really, I cannot give a better explanation than the one that BlackShanglan gave you the last time you tried this little trick. It was absurd then and it is absurd now. So it will quote her/him/it

Originally Posted by TurdFergeson
Now you are a liar. You insulted my reading comprehension abilities. Liar .

So you really are LT! It's delightful to see you again, my dearest. I've missed your "you're a lying lying liar lying lies!" gambit.

Your reading comprehension skills are quite clearly not up to par in your treatment of that article. Given that you keep throwing out mis-readings of it under the heading of "proof," anyone attempting to explain what's wrong with your analysis has no choice but to deal with the source of the problem. If you choose to rely upon a skill, even so basic a skill as reading, as part of your argument, you must accept that people will point out when you mis-apply the skill, or indeed apparently fail to apply it in any way. In the adult world of reason, we learn to accept that a critique of our reasoning or our professional skills is not a personal insult in and of itself. It's an opportunity to do better.


Quote:
Wrong. Eutectic reactions, or the "eutectic point", is simply the point at which metals melt, or become liquid. It has nothing to do with how much heat is involved, since all metals melt , or have different "eutectic points".
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eutectic_point

The presence of eutectic reactions means the steel was melted. Period.

Ah, I knew it was coming! No good debate of this particular level of informed skill is complete without a citation from wikipedia.

Now, I am not an unreasonable horse, and I have a decent regard for the feelings of my fellow beings. I shall therefore assume that your reading comprehension was superb when you encountered this particular article, and that the post above is simply a typo, as may happen to any person without a slightest slight to his or her character, even if it happens to be a typo occupying the entire paragraph. For your source does clearly state:


The melting point of a mixture of two or more solids (such as an alloy) depends on the relative proportions of its ingredients. A eutectic or eutectic mixture is a mixture at such proportions that the melting point is as low as possible, and that furthermore all the constituents crystallize simultaneously at this temperature from molten liquid solution. Such a simultaneous crystallization of a eutectic mixture is known as a eutectic reaction, the temperature at which it takes place is the eutectic temperature, and the composition and temperature at which it takes place is called the eutectic point.


(1) Eutectic mixtures, points, and reactions are all terms used to mixtures of materials.

(2) Eutectic mixtures directly affect the melting point of the substances involved (i.e., they change the temperature at which they melt). You might also note the derivation of the word cited in the article: "The term comes from the Greek eutektos, meaning 'easily melted.'"

(3) No one is arguing whether or not the steel melted, or whether or not there was a eutectic reaction. What we're trying to point out to you is what both of your sources have told you: the presence of a mixture of materials (in this case, the addition of sulfur to steel) lowers the melting point of the material. See how that ties into points 1 and 2?


Well that makes zero sense. Par for the course. You now say things like sea breeze and acid rain collected on the steel BEFORE the fires started? It somehow crept into the buildings? Unlikely to the extreme.

(BTW, this is NOT about 9/11, this is about eutectic reactions in general).


Unless, of course, the building had, I don't know, ventilation systems or something? Doors? Something else that rendered it less than airtight?

Still, I admire your ingenuity. I like the way you've repeatedly ignored very simple, likely, and obvious sources of the sulfur and focused on the ones that seem to you to be the most far-fetched. I can see that this has done much for your pursuit of your theory as a whole, but the stubborn traditionalist in me feels bound to point out that those two things were the last things mentioned in the article and given the least weight by the author. I hate to be repetitious, but I can see that you haven't quite noticed this the last few times I posted it -


"We may have just the inherent conditions in the atmosphere so that a lot of water on a burning building will form sulfuric acid, hydrogen sulfide or hydroxides, and start the eutectic process as the steel heats up," Biederman says. He notes that the sulfur could also have come from contents of the burning buildings, such as rubber or plastics."


So - high atmospheric sulfur (that which itself causes acid rain), burning rubber or plastics, or anything else sulfur-containing in the buildings that was afire. I realize that these are not as glamorous or fertile a soil for your derision as the image of acid rain pouring down inside the actual building, but they have the advantage (or perhaps you'll think disadvantage) of being quite likely.
.

Woof!
 
Last edited:
Nope, acid rain caused the steel to melt.

It's a first.

In 1975 there was no eutectic reaction because , um...acid rain didn't exist then.

You win.
 
Last edited:
The jet fuel was all gone, burnt off in around 15 min. There is no evidence extreme temperatures. The absolute max temperatures are of the order of 1300C with the average fire temperatures 600 to a little over 1000C..

You've never posted any evidence supporting temperatures anywhere near that high in the buildings themselves. The material evidence from the steel beams that were analysed showed that the maximum was far less than that.

... nothing more is needed and definately no Nukes.

Now there's where you have a problem, because despite the lack of evidence for high temperatures in the buildings themselves, not even close to what you claimed, it's a different case entirely for the basements and underground. It's already been shown quite well that molten steel and iron, still hot and liquid, was a major problem 7-8 weeks after the collapses. I hate the idea of nukes, but the batshit loony is correct on this. How can you explain this without nukes of some sort being used down in the basements? Don't simply pretend the molten metal didn't exist, because it did, so tell me a rational reason for it without the use of nukes? Can you?
 
And the official reason for the amounts of sulphur needed to create these novel eutectic reactions which have never been observed in building fires before, including the 1975 WTC fire:

acid rain

That's right folks, RAIN caused the fires burning for over 100 days to turn hardened and UL tested structural steel to swiss cheese. I'm not making this up, this is the official explanation.

That's bizarre. When NIST and the USA govt liars made up these explanations, did they drop some LSD first?

Sulphur could be explained by use of conventional explosives, and some forms of thermite.
 
You've never posted any evidence supporting temperatures anywhere near that high in the buildings themselves. The material evidence from the steel beams that were analysed showed that the maximum was far less than that.



Now there's where you have a problem, because despite the lack of evidence for high temperatures in the buildings themselves, not even close to what you claimed, it's a different case entirely for the basements and underground. It's already been shown quite well that molten steel and iron, still hot and liquid, was a major problem 7-8 weeks after the collapses. I hate the idea of nukes, but the batshit loony is correct on this. How can you explain this without nukes of some sort being used down in the basements? Don't simply pretend the molten metal didn't exist, because it did, so tell me a rational reason for it without the use of nukes? Can you?
Molten steel and iron was a major problem? I missed that part.

There's a video of a guy in fireman gear saying that they can't put too much water in some areas since the steam would keep them from seeing what they're doing. It's a nice bit of video, with some soothing music edited into it. Doesn't really seem like a major problem to him.
 
If it wasn't, then why try to cool it down?

Secondly, what's your explanation for there being any at all 2 months after the collapses?
Haven't you heard? The steel was heated in office fires, fell through the air which stoked it thousands of degrees, then was covered in insulating debris and ash.
 
Has anyone explained how "nukes" or other explosives in the basements of the buildings caused them to collapse from the impact areas of the planes?
 
Back
Top