Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
vetteman said:
I'll do that Pereg, I just happened by it when was searching GW. Ran into the Petition Project and noticed the La Jolla address for cover letter:

http://www.oism.org/pproject/index.htm
Cool...this was a fairly notorious even when it happened. many of the signatories were misrepresented as scientists and a lot of them expressed regret that they had signed the thing. Seitz is an interesting character.
 
Peregrinator said:
Funny how that works, isn't it? Back when I used to bother with this particular argument, Ish always told me to follow the money. Then when I did and found Exxon behind almost all of the denial crowd, all of a sudden it became about the science. As if an NSA grant carries a clearer and less slanted agenda than Exxon money does.

Wrong Perg. My point is, and always was, you can't discredit the science based on the source of the funds. I've NEVER posted that, "Well, the government paid for that, it's bullshit." All I've ever said is that the government has an agenda too. And I've never denied Exxon et al didn't either, have I? Everybodies trying to sell something.

In other words Perg, I've attacked the science, not the source of the funding. The funding attack is uniquely an attribute of the left. Kill the messenger, ignore the message. And do you realize how weak that attack is?

For the most part, here at Lit, the debate has degenerated to "Me consensus, you Exxon." How pathetic is that Perg? Hmmm?

Ishmael
 
Vette: There's no question that Seitz has credentials, but I think this is somewhat telling:

Shortly before his retirement from Rockefeller University in 1979, Seitz began working as a paid permanent consultant for the R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company, advising their research program.

By 1989, the CEO of R.J. Reynolds, William Hobbs, concluded that "Dr. Seitz is quite elderly and not sufficiently rational to offer advice." [2] However, in 1994, Seitz authored a report published by the George C. Marshall Institute, of which he was a founder and chairman of the board, entitled "Global warming and ozone hole controversies. A challenge to scientific judgment." In a broader discussion of environmental toxins, he concluded "there is no good scientific evidence that passive inhalation is truly dangerous under normal circumstances." [3]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frederick_Seitz

Too old to be of any use to a tobacco company in 1989.
 
Peregrinator said:
You know, I didn't even have to click the link to know what canard you were referencing. Check it out:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oregon_Petition

There are a hundred other discussions of this particular piece of fraudulent nonsense. No offense intended, Vette, but this thing was just an awful piece of nonsense. Don't take my word for it; google "oregon petition project" and read a little about it.

From the wiki link, above:

Wiki is NOT gospel Perg. It's just another opinion.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
Wrong Perg. My point is, and always was, you can't discredit the science based on the source of the funds. I've NEVER posted that, "Well, the government paid for that, it's bullshit." All I've ever said is that the government has an agenda too. And I've never denied Exxon et al didn't either, have I? Everybodies trying to sell something.

In other words Perg, I've attacked the science, not the source of the funding. The funding attack is uniquely an attribute of the left. Kill the messenger, ignore the message. And do you realize how weak that attack is?

For the most part, here at Lit, the debate has degenerated to "Me consensus, you Exxon." How pathetic is that Perg? Hmmm?

Ishmael
I'm not going to bother to dig up the quotes where you posted as counterevidence of the trustworthiness of the current climate science that I should "follow the money." I remember it; if you don't, maybe you should go back and read your own stuff again. The whole thrust of your argument at the time was that the "consensus" side was fueled by a need for funding and that therefore they were only publishing results that agreed with the agenda of their funding sources. After the whole Exxon funding nearly all the denial crowd came out, you changed your tune.

Hardly "uniquely an attribute of the left;" you did it, too, and so has everyone else who says that Kyoto was "a plan to give our money to China" and similar shit. Environmentalists are communists. Same crap; they must not be "real" scientists because they obviously have a leftist agenda.

It's completely pathetic; that's why I usually don't bother with the subject these days. If it weren't you and Vette I was posting with right now, I probably wouldn't have posted in the thread at all.
 
Ishmael said:
I have two years of links pooks. Get over it yourself.

Ishmael

Two years of links and still no girlfriend ?

Must be Clinton's fault.
 
Peregrinator said:
I'm not going to bother to dig up the quotes where you posted as counterevidence of the trustworthiness of the current climate science that I should "follow the money." I remember it; if you don't, maybe you should go back and read your own stuff again. The whole thrust of your argument at the time was that the "consensus" side was fueled by a need for funding and that therefore they were only publishing results that agreed with the agenda of their funding sources. After the whole Exxon funding nearly all the denial crowd came out, you changed your tune.

Hardly "uniquely an attribute of the left;" you did it, too, and so has everyone else who says that Kyoto was "a plan to give our money to China" and similar shit. Environmentalists are communists. Same crap; they must not be "real" scientists because they obviously have a leftist agenda.

It's completely pathetic; that's why I usually don't bother with the subject these days. If it weren't you and Vette I was posting with right now, I probably wouldn't have posted in the thread at all.

I DON'T deny Perg. You assume that the source of some money is 'cleaner' than others. I don't make that mistake. If you are truly impartial then you must question ALL sources. To try to point that out to you WAS the thrust of the funding argument. I'm sorry you missed the point.

And Exxon isn't funding nearly all. When you focus on Exxon you miss the broader picture. There are many funding counter research, Exxon is but one that is contributing. Perhaps, in the interests of liberty and freedom, you'd like to silence their voice.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
I DON'T deny Perg. You assume that the source of some money is 'cleaner' than others. I don't make that mistake. If you are truly impartial then you must question ALL sources. To try to point that out to you WAS the thrust of the funding argument. I'm sorry you missed the point.

And Exxon isn't funding nearly all. When you focus on Exxon you miss the broader picture. There are many funding counter research, Exxon is but one that is contributing. Perhaps, in the interests of liberty and freedom, you'd like to silence their voice.

Ishmael
C'mon, Ish. Do you REALLY think that the NSA has as clear and focused an agenda as Exxon-fucking-Mobil? Isn't it obvious that one has a very clear focused agenda and one has at best a very fuzzy sort of leaning agenda? And don't you think the current admin would be fucking delighted if all the NSA grantees came out and said that gw was bullshit?

No, I don't want to silence their "vote," wjhatever you mean by "vote," mr "science isn't consensus." They can spend their money on whatever they want, but if they spend it on marketing to "create doubt that gw is anthropogenic," then they should be exposed as doing exactly that, just like the tobacco companies were.
 
Peregrinator said:
C'mon, Ish. Do you REALLY think that the NSA has as clear and focused an agenda as Exxon-fucking-Mobil? Isn't it obvious that one has a very clear focused agenda and one has at best a very fuzzy sort of leaning agenda? And don't you think the current admin would be fucking delighted if all the NSA grantees came out and said that gw was bullshit?

No, I don't want to silence their "vote," wjhatever you mean by "vote," mr "science isn't consensus." They can spend their money on whatever they want, but if they spend it on marketing to "create doubt that gw is anthropogenic," then they should be exposed as doing exactly that, just like the tobacco companies were.

Do you think they don't? On what do you base that assumption? Government is crisis driven Perg. Always was, always will be. Crisis=expansion=power. The formula is ancient and first codified by Machiavelli. The financials speak for themselves Perg. Global Warming is a growth industry today. I sure as hell wouldn't bet my future on it though. Having a resume' built on global warming is like putting all your money on one horse in one race.

The 'Pros' are trying to buy the pot hoping no one will call the bet. The fact that the bet is being called is pissing them off so they are resorting to trying to the 'dirty the money' approach. Damn Perg, if that doesn't tell you something what will?

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
Do you think they don't? On what do you base that assumption? Government is crisis driven Perg. Always was, always will be. Crisis=expansion=power. The formula is ancient and first codified by Machiavelli. The financials speak for themselves Perg. Global Warming is a growth industry today. I sure as hell wouldn't bet my future on it though. Having a resume' built on global warming is like putting all your money on one horse in one race.

The 'Pros' are trying to buy the pot hoping no one will call the bet. The fact that the bet is being called is pissing them off so they are resorting to trying to the 'dirty the money' approach. Damn Perg, if that doesn't tell you something what will?

Ishmael
You have a much more cynical view of scientists than I do, I guess.

Gotta go for a while...have a great night. Good chatting with you again.
 
Peregrinator said:
You have a much more cynical view of scientists than I do, I guess.

Gotta go for a while...have a great night. Good chatting with you again.

That's right Perg. They're human beings just like you and me. They have mortgages and families and car payments too. Their welfare is based on their ability to generate revenue. They like their fine wine and righteuos weed, stimulating discussions and status. Most even have rationalized the 'truth' of their research. In other words Perg, they're just human.

Ishmael
 
I think much of the cynicism, with either side or source, comes from the fact that their positions are so hard, extreme and unyielding. As biased as the arguments are here, there is more dialogue occurring between opposite positions here than there is in the scientific community.

There is no benefit to associating with those that have differing opinions of their own. Particularly where professions and livelihoods are at stake. It only weakens the apparent strength and acceptance of their arguments to rub elbows with dissenting opinions.
 
Ishmael said:
The financials speak for themselves Perg. Global Warming is a growth industry today.

Just ask Algore and his selling carbon credits to himself from a company he owns.

Check out ecotality.com:

Gore is chairman and founding partner of Generation Investment Management, LLP. That's a boutique international investment firm that invests other people's money for a fee in the stocks of green companies. So when Al Gore beats the drum for possible future global warming he's also drumming up business, and he's profiteering from hyping the global warming crisis.

“In a nutshell, Algore consumes large amounts of carbon-based electricity while he trumpets the global warming crisis that drives up the value of green companies like the one in which he invests in their stocks, and carbon offsets are a dodgy way for someone to claim to be carbon neutral even as they consume large amounts of carbon based energy. The notion that selling carbon offsets actually helps the environment is taken as a given by those who sell them and by those who buy them. But at this point it's unproven. While some bloggers and pundits have likened carbon offsets to the indulgences of pre-Reformation Catholic church, sold to the wealthy so they could continue to sin, the writer of the blog The Virginian says that carbon offsets are more like the sumptuary laws of medieval times, laws that regulated and reinforced social hierarchies and morals through restrictions on clothing, food, and luxury expenditures. The bottoms line is that this company that Algore buys his carbon offsets from is owned by Algore. He's investing in himself. He's not losing any money at all in this, and nobody else can buy offsets from this company except Algore.”

Oldest rule there is...follow the money.

Nice Machiavelli reference, Ish.
 
Slider69 said:
Just ask Algore and his selling carbon credits to himself from a company he owns.

Check out ecotality.com:



Oldest rule there is...follow the money.

Nice Machiavelli reference, Ish.

Thank you slider. Say hi to the mrs for me.

Ishmael
 
vetteman said:
I don't think you can discard the study on the basis of it's underwriters, otherwise we could sit here and say things like, everything out of the Ford Foundation, the Mellon Foundation, the Institute for policy Studies, the MacArthur, Rockefeller, Carnegie, and Brookiings foundations, etc., is all a bunch of liberal BS.
I'm willing to discount anything from either side of the debate that isn't peer-reviewed hard science published in a highly regarded professional journal if you are.
 
Peregrinator said:
I'm willing to discount anything from either side of the debate that isn't peer-reviewed hard science published in a highly regarded professional journal if you are.

Have enough qualifications in there Perg? LMAO

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
That's right Perg. They're human beings just like you and me. They have mortgages and families and car payments too. Their welfare is based on their ability to generate revenue. They like their fine wine and righteuos weed, stimulating discussions and status. Most even have rationalized the 'truth' of their research. In other words Perg, they're just human.

Ishmael
Ffs, Ish. You say you were a scientist; how many times did you and your colleagues sit down and say, "We might not be able to afford the rent if we publish this; we better lie, skew the data, and come up with something the last person to give us a grant likes?"

I know a whole bunch of researchers in several different fields, and they all draw perfectly liveable salaries without taking grant money home.

Besides which, specific to gw, if you came up with something the NSF didn't like, you could always whistle up Exxon, who would be more than happy to fund you, right? That's IF you were as mercenary as you imply all scientists are.
 
Ishmael said:
Have enough qualifications in there Perg? LMAO

Ishmael
What's wrong with them? You want to consider science that isn't peer reviewed? Science that's published in the Weekly World News? Which qualification don't you like?
 
Ishmael said:
Wrong Perg. My point is, and always was, you can't discredit the science based on the source of the funds. I've NEVER posted that, "Well, the government paid for that, it's bullshit." All I've ever said is that the government has an agenda too. And I've never denied Exxon et al didn't either, have I? Everybodies trying to sell something.

In other words Perg, I've attacked the science, not the source of the funding. The funding attack is uniquely an attribute of the left. Kill the messenger, ignore the message. And do you realize how weak that attack is?

For the most part, here at Lit, the debate has degenerated to "Me consensus, you Exxon." How pathetic is that Perg? Hmmm?

Ishmael
More lies. How many times have you posted that scientists are just chasing government grant money? You are turning into a parody, Ishtard.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top