Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
vetteman said:
You might add the economy into that as well. What do you mean," at little to no cost", don't be silly. I guess you think that business and the American people aren't regulated, taxed, harrassed and governed by enough thousands of activity inspectors already eh?

And when they are actually caught, how big are the fines in relation to their profits? You and I both know that often, the cost of those fines don't deter polluting as it is less expensive than complying with the existing pollution laws.
 
vetteman said:
You might add the economy into that as well. What do you mean," at little to no cost", don't be silly. I guess you think that business and the American people aren't regulated, taxed, harrassed and governed by enough thousands of activity inspectors already eh?
Yeah, things would be so much better if everywhere was run like it is in Bhopal.
 
vetteman said:
I don't know if that is true or not, but why would that be logic for more unenforced regulation?

I didn't say we needed "more unenforced regulation" in my post. Unenforced implies they aren't caught. I was talking about the fines they get when they are caught.

And how does anything you're asking really address my original post? From a strict risk management perspective, the logical conclusion is to reduce pollution.
 
vetteman said:
Do you really mean to compare the industrial practices of India to that of the United States?
That seems to be what you're arguing for. And let's not forget that Union Carbide, cunts that they are, are a US company.
 
vetteman said:
Well, to the extent that a judge enforces the regulations by imposing certain levels of fines seems to me to be more a function of goverment than industry. As far as your original post goes I merely added a different level of concern that seemed to be missing from the two perspectives you presented.

In which case you haven't told me of any "liberty" that you would be losing.
 
vetteman said:
It comes in many forms Zip. It might be the amount of travel I can engage in, the amount of road travel, mileage, they may tax the amount of miles one drives, etc., it may mean I have to purchase an electric mower, added taxes and fees may reduce my disposable income and therefore limit my ability to pursue happiness, I don't know, but certainly you realize that every regulation reduces your liberty in some fashion. There are all kinds of limits that can be placed upon your liberty by others deciding what's best in your behalf.

I don't see those are liberties. They are abilities based on your earning potential and budgeting. Unless the government is restricting the mileage each person can drive, then you haven't lost any liberties at all.

And they are not deciding what is best on your behalf, they are doing it based on everyone's behalf, which consequently includes poor people too. Unless your arguing that your (or a business) has more of a right to make a profit than everyone else does to a healthy environment (which includes reduced health care spending) I don't see your argument holding weight.
 
Ham Murabi said:
Now I'll offer my own. You're a fool if you believe creating a worldwide recession, or depression, is going to change the climate.
May I add here that if you think reducing carbon emissions will have either of those effects than you're not paying attention to what people are actually doing?
 
It strikes me that some people can have too may "liberties". Take the right to bare arms; and then people wonder why they get sunburnt. The right to a non-electric mower? Never heard of that one ... ;)

Let's invent a time machine and travel ahead a century or two just so we can know for sure how things will pan out.

The future: the last working computer in the world sputters to life and our ancestors prepare the case against us.

Exhibit A: our self-righteous online diatribes.

The verdict: I can almost hear the mob repeatedly screaming "DORK! DORK! DORK!" as they stamp on the heads of their selfish ancestors. The jubilant ululation as those tasty brains spill out is ear splitting. :)





editor's note: the last working computer, amazingly still with a working internet connection, is located in what used to be Al Gore's home. Also, the time machine only works once.
 
I find it interesting that it's only in the US that this is a Left vs Right issue.
 
vetteman said:
It's more fundamnetal than that to me, I question your authority and judgement for doing it in the first place. You want to impose those strictures here let's vote on it.

As long as there's more than you two guys voting on this otherwise I suspect it will be a draw. :)

I wonder what the turnout would be for such a vote? My money's on no more than 38%. ;)
 
SeanH said:
I find it interesting that it's only in the US that this is a Left vs Right issue.

It seems to be a 'cultural' thang. Look on the bright side, at least they haven't been sidelined by the promise of a "third way"©.
 
vetteman said:
There are a lot of things here you might find interesting, like for instance the lack or need for panic.
Oh, I've always found the US interesting. People that feel no qualms about putting profits before lives are fascinating. In the same way as serial killers.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top