Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ulaven_Demorte said:
Apparently, only those scientists that are "approved" and back the administration's position on Global warming, polar Ice melting, and polar bears are allowed to voice "their opinions" in public meetings.
No, they are just the ones designated as the "official spokesmen."
 
vetteman said:
Yep, somebody said, "can't we all just get along", a couple of stanzas of "We are the world", and they started humping in the interest of racial and cultural diversity..sniff..it makes you feel all big inside.

Makes me 'hard' just thinking about it.

Ishmael
 
MakersandIce said:
No, they are just the ones designated as the "official spokesmen."

Bullshit, read the article. They are not allowed to speak publicly about their opinions, only the "approved" spokesperson, who "understands tha administration's stance on global warming. polar ice melts, and especially polar bears" are allowed to speak. the others are only allowed to voice their opinions in private, when no media is around.
The prohibition on talking about these subjects only applies to public, formal situations, Hall said. Private scientific discussions outside the meeting and away from media are permitted and encouraged, he said.
So talk about it all you want, so long as nobody hears you or reports that you disagree with the stated opinion of the government.

It's the "Ministry of Truth" that Orwell spoke of in "1984".

You're full of shit, it has nothing to do with getting politics out of science, Ishmael. It's injecting politics directly into the middle of scientific debate. Only those scientists that agree with the administration's views on ecological topics are allowed to voice their opinions in public and on the record.
 
Ulaven_Demorte said:
Bullshit, read the article. They are not allowed to speak publicly about their opinions, only the "approved" spokesperson, who "understands tha administration's stance on global warming. polar ice melts, and especially polar bears" are allowed to speak. the others are only allowed to voice their opinions in private, when no media is around.
So talk about it all you want, so long as nobody hears you or reports that you disagree with the stated opinion of the government.

It's the "Ministry of Truth" that Orwell spoke of in "1984".

You're full of shit, it has nothing to do with getting politics out of science, Ishmael. It's injecting politics directly into the middle of scientific debate. Only those scientists that agree with the administration's views on ecological topics are allowed to voice their opinions in public and on the record.

And your point is?

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
And your point is?

Ishmael

The mere fact that you have no issue with this Orwellian control over "scientific findings" is quite telling.

The point is that the government should not be censoring speech or scientific debate at public meetings to be sure that the message remains "on topic" and in keeping with the views of the current leadership.
 
Ulaven_Demorte said:
The mere fact that you have no issue with this Orwellian control over "scientific findings" is quite telling.

The point is that the government should not be censoring speech or scientific debate at public meetings to be sure that the message remains "on topic" and in keeping with the views of the current leadership.

"Orwelliian?" In what respect? Surely you can explain.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
"Orwelliian?" In what respect? Surely you can explain.

Ishmael

Surely you can see that Government control of the message scientists are allowed to put forward in public has a very Orwellian "research Department" or "Ministry of Truth" tinge to it.

Then again, maybe you can't.
 
Ulaven_Demorte said:
Surely you can see that Government control of the message scientists are allowed to put forward in public has a very Orwellian "research Department" or "Ministry of Truth" tinge to it.

Then again, maybe you can't.

No, I can't. I can certainly see where the government, or any other employer, would frown upon un-scientific opinions. On the other hand, the opinions that you and yours cleave to have been funded by government monies.

Soooooo, what are you and the press talking about? Hmmmmmm?

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
No, I can't. I can certainly see where the government, or any other employer, would frown upon un-scientific opinions. On the other hand, the opinions that you and yours cleave to have been funded by government monies.

Soooooo, what are you and the press talking about? Hmmmmmm?

Ishmael

Ah, so the government, or any employer, can determine arbitrarily that findings by scientists that they disagree with are "unscientific" and thus subject to censure and that one can't, not shouldn't, can't express a dissenting view in public.

That is this administration's and Exxon-mobil's view exactly. Censure any science that disputes what you wish to portray as "fact", exclude anything resembling actual scientific debate in favor pushing the views of the administration's talking points on any particular subject.

George Orwell was only off by about 20 years.
 
Last edited:
Ulaven_Demorte said:
Ah, so the government, or any employer, can determine arbitrarily that findings by scientists that they disagree with are "unscientific" and thus subject to censure and that one can't, not shouldn't, can't express a dissenting view in public.

That is this administration's and Exxon-mobil's view exactly. Censure any science that disputes what you wish to portray as "fact", exclude anything resembling actual scientific debate in favor pushing the views of the administration's talking points on any particular subject.

George Orwell was only off by about 20 years.

That isn't what I said, nor is it the parameters of what the government has said. Is it?

Ishmael

PS And I'm not the one swallowing the line of the bureaucracy, am I?
 
Ishmael said:
That isn't what I said, nor is it the parameters of what the government has said. Is it?

Ishmael

PS And I'm not the one swallowing the line of the bureaucracy, am I?

Thats exactly what the government has said, you didn't read the article.

Listed as a "new requirement" for foreign travelers on U.S. government business, the memo says that requests for foreign travel "involving or potentially involving climate change, sea ice, and/or polar bears" require special handling, including notice of who will be the official spokesman for the trip.

The Fish and Wildlife Service top officials need assurance that the spokesman, "the one responding to questions on these issues, particularly polar bears" understands the administration's position on these topics.

Two accompanying memos were offered as examples of these kinds of assurance. Both included the line that the traveler "understands the administration's position on climate change, polar bears, and sea ice and will not be speaking on or responding to these issues."

The prohibition on talking about these subjects only applies to public, formal situations, Hall said. Private scientific discussions outside the meeting and away from media are permitted and encouraged, he said.

In other words, only the approved spokesman will be making ANY public comments regarding these issues. Any other scientists with opposing views are to hold their tongue unless they are in private meetings away from the media.
 
Last edited:
Ulaven_Demorte said:
Thats exactly what the government has said, you didn't read the article.



In other words, only the approved spokesman will be making ANY public comments regarding these issues. Any other scientists with opposing views are to hold their tongue unless they are in private meetings away from the media.

In other words, every Tom, Dick, and Harry aren't government spokesmen.

Show me where the scientific papers proscribed.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
In other words, every Tom, Dick, and Harry aren't government spokesmen.

Show me where the scientific papers proscribed.

Ishmael

No, in other words, you will keep your mouth shut unless you repeat verbatim the administration's views on global warming, sea ice, and especially polar bears. If you have a view that is in opposition to that you will not speak about or respond to these issues except in private, away from any media.

They are censuring scientists, plain and simple.
 
Ulaven_Demorte said:
No, in other words, you will keep your mouth shut unless you repeat verbatim the administration's views on global warming, sea ice, and especially polar bears. If you have a view that is in opposition to that you will not speak about or respond to these issues except in private, away from any media.

They are censuring scientists, plain and simple.

That isn't what the article says.

Ishmael
 
Ishmael said:
That isn't what the article says.

Ishmael

The hell it doesn't.

If scientists expecting to attend a meeting do not give the government "assurances" that they will respond as the administration wishes them to on questions regarding global warming, sea ice, or polar bears or refrain from public discussion at all.. They will simply be denied the opportunity to attend.

Only those scientists who agree to stay "on topic", at least publically, or remain silent will be allowed. In effect muzzling any dissent from scientists in public meetings on the international stage. Heaven forbid if those assurances are given and a scientist then has a change of heart and does speak their mind, likely they would not only be removed from future travel but likely removed from their position as well.

Thats not keeping politics out of science, thats dictating science by political means. It's the same tactic that this administration has taken with regards to diplomacy, Do as I say or else.
 
Ulaven_Demorte said:
The hell it doesn't.

If scientists expecting to attend a meeting do not give the government "assurances" that they will respond as the administration wishes them to on questions regarding global warming, sea ice, or polar bears or refrain from public discussion at all.. They will simply be denied the opportunity to attend.

Only those scientists who agree to stay "on topic", at least publically, or remain silent will be allowed. In effect muzzling any dissent from scientists in public meetings on the international stage. Heaven forbid if those assurances are given and a scientist then has a change of heart and does speak their mind, likely they would not only be removed from future travel but likely removed from their position as well.

Thats not keeping politics out of science, thats dictating science by political means. It's the same tactic that this administration has taken with regards to diplomacy, Do as I say or else.
Dude. Why. Do. You. Bother???

It isn't worth your time or energy. If you are looking for diversions... try ping-pong.
 
Ulaven_Demorte said:
The hell it doesn't.

If scientists expecting to attend a meeting do not give the government "assurances" that they will respond as the administration wishes them to on questions regarding global warming, sea ice, or polar bears or refrain from public discussion at all.. They will simply be denied the opportunity to attend.

Only those scientists who agree to stay "on topic", at least publically, or remain silent will be allowed. In effect muzzling any dissent from scientists in public meetings on the international stage. Heaven forbid if those assurances are given and a scientist then has a change of heart and does speak their mind, likely they would not only be removed from future travel but likely removed from their position as well.

Thats not keeping politics out of science, thats dictating science by political means. It's the same tactic that this administration has taken with regards to diplomacy, Do as I say or else.

You have the script then? Surely you can post it, right?

You're full of shit. :) No, really, you're full of shit. What it says is simply this, "You have the right to free speech, you do NOT have the right to express, or represent yourself, as an official spokesman/woman for the government.

Do you have a problem with this?

Ishmael
 
mscreen said:
Dude. Why. Do. You. Bother???

It isn't worth your time or energy. If you are looking for diversions... try ping-pong.

Pong is boring.

I'd rather play beat the conservative over the head with facts. :D
 
Ishmael said:
You have the script then? Surely you can post it, right?

You're full of shit. :) No, really, you're full of shit. What it says is simply this, "You have the right to free speech, you do NOT have the right to express, or represent yourself, as an official spokesman/woman for the government.

Do you have a problem with this?

Ishmael

Bullshit.

What it says is, you are allowed to your own opinion, but are not allowed to voice that opinion in a public conference unless you agree to express only the approved opinion of the administration on these subjects. You have freedom of speech, as long as you say only what we want you to.

Only the "approved spokesman" is to be allowed to respond AT ALL, the rest are to remain silent unless in private meeting with no media present. They will offer no statement or respond to any questions publicly concerning global warming, sea ice, or polar bears. We aren't talking about keynote speakers here, we're talking about offering ANY opinion other than the 'approved message' in a public meeting.

say it with me... censorship.
 
Last edited:
Ishmael said:
No, it isn't. It's an attempt to strip politics from science. Apparently those addicted to street theater are incensed.

Yes little UD, there is global warming. That is NOT the issue. The issue is whether that warming is anthropogenic.

And species come and species go. The Polar bear is moving further south and interbreeding with the brown bear. Now, in the human species this would be seen as a milestone. A true signal that discrimination was ending. An evolution of sub-species into the true homogenous race/culture that many are trying so hard to achieve.

However, in the case of the polar bear this is seen as a pollution. So, is the brown bear polluted by the polar bear blood, or is the polar bear polluted by the brown bear blood. Just which specie gets to carry the card that allows them to vote? How do we take the census?

Could it be that we're seeing evolution in action? Or are you a 'creationist?'

Seems to me the bears have found a strategy all on their own.

Ishmael
This is the first time I've ever seen a reference to cross-species breeding referred to as "pollution". Did you make up that part?
 
phrodeau said:
This is the first time I've ever seen a reference to cross-species breeding referred to as "pollution". Did you make up that part?
He must think all children were conceived like you were.
 
phrodeau said:
This is the first time I've ever seen a reference to cross-species breeding referred to as "pollution". Did you make up that part?

He's trying to make a case of the loss of polar bear habitat as somehow a good thing and somehow compare it to interbreeding between differing races of humans.

The problem with his logic is that he's trying to compare interracial breeding with interspecies breeding.

It's not exactly the same thing now is it? Brown bears and Polar bears are not simply the same kind of bear with different colored fur. :rolleyes:
 
phrodeau said:
This is the first time I've ever seen a reference to cross-species breeding referred to as "pollution". Did you make up that part?

Referred to? Fuck off furry foot. If you can't read, don't comment.

Ishmael
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top