Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
vetteman said:
Opposing the Propaganda Ministry leads to the firing wall.

This isn't the Propaganda Ministry vette, it's a religious inquisition.

Ishmael
 
I thought that the world was warming, but the question was whether the cause was man-made or not. Is that the point we're still on? An ancilliary question was whether cow farts caused more pollution than SUV's and whether cow farts are man-made or not.
 
RightField said:
I thought that the world was warming, but the question was whether the cause was man-made or not. Is that the point we're still on? An ancilliary question was whether cow farts caused more pollution than SUV's.

Depends on whether you're a member of the Church of It's All Mans Fault or not.

Ishmael
 
vetteman said:
Opposing the Propaganda Ministry leads to the firing wall.
You mean you bought that?

No mention of any "suppressed" scientific studies, or even descriptions of what those guys were working on. No mention of past accomplishments, either.

And of course, these are voices of Academia. How much credence do you give them?
 
THE HORROR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Surprising New Arctic Inhabitants: Trees Andrea Thompson
LiveScience Staff Writer

LiveScience.com

Sun Mar 11, 11:45 AM ET



Rising temperatures fueled by global warming are causing forests of spruce trees to invade Arctic tundra faster than scientists originally thought, evicting and endangering the species that dwell there and only there, a new study concludes.

ADVERTISEMENT

Tundra is land area where tree growth is inhibited by low temperatures and a short growing season. In the Arctic, the tundra is dominated by permafrost, a layer of permanently frozen subsoil.


The only vegetation that can grow in such conditions are grasses, mosses and lichens. Forests of spruce trees and shrubs neighbor these tundra areas, and the boundary where they meet is called the treeline.


In summer, the permafrost thaws, and the tundra becomes covered in bogs and lakes, allowing a unique habitat for plants. Climate change, meanwhile, has extended the summer warming season and promoted tree growth, causing the treeline to encroach on the tundra.


By looking at tree rings, researchers reconstructed a 300-year history of tree density and treeline position. The results show trees can creep up on the tundra faster than previously thought.


“The conventional thinking on treeline dynamics has been that advances are very slow because conditions are so harsh at these high latitudes and altitudes,” said Ryan Danby of the University of Alberta. “But what our data indicates is that there was an upslope surge of trees in response to warmer temperatures. It’s like it waited until conditions were right and then it decided to get up and run, not just walk.”


While in many places the idea of more trees is a good one, this Arctic takeover endangers species like caribou and sheep that thrive in the tundra, as well as the native people who depend on these species for their survival.


The details of the study are published in the March issue of the Journal of Ecology. Danby plans to continue his research as a part of the International Polar Year research effort.
 
SOCIAL STUDIES
Global Warming: The Convenient Truth
By Jonathan Rauch, National Journal
© National Journal Group Inc.
Friday, March 9, 2007

In October, British Prime Minister Tony Blair called for "radical international measures" to curtail greenhouse-gas emissions, and fast. "We can't wait the five years it took to negotiate Kyoto," he said. Apparently, 2012 is too late. In hopes of taking stronger steps, however, many U.S. environmentalists want to defer any legislation until President Bush is out of office. Apparently 2007 and 2008 are too early. That gives us precisely three years -- 2009, 2010, and 2011 -- to save the planet.


Climate change is real and deserves action, but the problem is nowhere near as overwhelming as the rhetoric commonly suggests.







All right, that was a cheap shot. I couldn't help myself. Something about the global-warming debate encourages overheated rhetoric. To listen to Blair, former Vice President Gore, and many other political figures and environmental activists, you would conclude that global warming is an onrushing cataclysm and that prevention requires all of us to take radical steps right away.

A fairer assessment would be many degrees cooler. It would hold that climate change is real and deserves action, but that the problem is nowhere near as overwhelming as the rhetoric commonly suggests, and the solutions nowhere near as difficult. As problems go, in fact, climate change appears to be one of the most convenient that humankind has ever faced.

Last month, the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change announced [PDF] that the Earth is definitely warming and that human emissions of greenhouse gases (principally carbon dioxide) are almost certainly an important cause.

We have a problem. But what sort of problem?

A crisis, Blair says. "It is not in doubt," he said in October, "that if the science is right, the consequences for our planet are literally disastrous." He was commenting on a recent British government report (popularly known as the Stern Report) on the economic effects of warming. In The Baltimore Sun, Bryan Mignone, a science and technology fellow at the Brookings Institution, cites that report's conclusion with alarm: "The damage associated with warming under a 'do-nothing' policy is likely to be 5 percent to 20 percent of global gross domestic product, an outcome to which the word 'catastrophic' would seem to apply."

Not so fast. Other analyses come up with cost figures more like 3 percent of GDP, but leave that aside. Reanalyzing the Stern Report, Yale University economist William Nordhaus recently noted that a "high-damage" scenario might reduce global GDP by almost 14 percent in the year 2200. On the Stern Report's own assumptions, "This means that per capita consumption would grow from $7,800 today to only $81,000 in 2200," instead of $94,000 (in today's dollars). That's not good, but it hardly seems catastrophic.

The IPCC says that the world would continue to warm for decades even if all human greenhouse-gas emissions were to magically stop tomorrow, which of course they won't. In testimony last month before a House of Representatives panel, Kevin Trenberth of the National Center for Atmospheric Research said, "The 2007 IPCC report makes clear that even aggressive mitigation would yield benefits many decades in the future, and that no amount of mitigation can avoid significant climate change."

Carbon dioxide both accumulates and dissipates in the atmosphere very slowly. Because the stock of greenhouse gases already present in the atmosphere dwarfs any one year's emissions, and because any one year's emissions can be changed only slightly, stabilizing greenhouse gases is like turning an aircraft carrier, only much slower. Annual emissions might be stabilized toward midcentury, and atmospheric concentrations at some point after that; but sharp turns are impossible and short-term effects minuscule.

That would be cause for alarm in an emergency. And many people talk as if there were one. "We need to act soon, before we reach a tipping point," Sen. Barbara Boxer, D-Calif., said at a hearing in January. Echoing Blair (as is his wont), David Cameron, the leader of Britain's Conservative Party, recently told reporters that the "big question" is, "Are we going to act before it's too late?"

Actually, there is no "too late," because there is no particular CO2 target and no particular date by which it must be met. And there is no emergency. An emergency is a "now or never" situation, but climate change is a "now versus later" situation. Immediacy trades off against efficiency.

"What we do now makes a difference for the future," says Gerald Meehl, a senior scientist at the National Center for Atmospheric Research. "The longer we wait, the worse the problem gets." On the other hand, the more precipitously we act, the more we disrupt the economy. A coal-fired electric plant lasts 40 to 60 years; gradually replacing dirty old plants with clean new ones is much more efficient than abruptly decommissioning old plants and replacing them with -- well, with nothing, because electric plants take years to build. Besides, the best carbon-cutting technologies are still in development. "We know from experience the length of time it takes to develop and implement new technologies in the electricity sector," says Revis James of the Electric Power Research Institute. "That's about 20 to 25 years."

This argues not for passivity, and not for delay, but for gradualism: setting up policies that will tighten the screws on greenhouse-gas emissions over the next few decades. The convenient truth about global warming, then, is that radicalism is as pointless as it is impractical. Slow-but-steady is not only the easiest approach; it is also the most effective.

Just as conveniently, the most efficient way to get started is also the simplest, albeit not the easiest politically: tax carbon emissions. "At around $30 per ton of CO2 over a 25-year horizon, experts seem to think this is the kind of price that will encourage the kind of technologies that are necessary," says Billy Pizer, an environmental economist at Resources for the Future, a Washington think tank. That would translate into an additional 27 cents or so on a gallon of gasoline and about a 20 percent increase in residential electricity bills (more like 34 percent for industrial users). Unpleasant, but hardly radical. Perfectly do-able, in fact.

Fortuitously, a carbon tax could also reduce the U.S. budget deficit and the geopolitical leverage of sinister "petrocracies" such as Iran, Russia, and Venezuela. Policy prescriptions don't come any more convenient than that.

Because significant warming is already baked into the cake (excuse the expression), climate change for at least the next 50 to 100 years will be a problem to be managed, not solved. Managing it will require mitigating whatever harms it causes: adaptation, in the standard parlance. This, too, turns out to be remarkably convenient. Few, if any, of the problems that climate change seems likely to exacerbate -- flooding, storms, drought, tropical disease, habitat loss, extinction -- are new or exotic. To the contrary, they are already front and center on the developmental and environmental agendas.

Roger Pielke Jr., a University of Colorado professor of environmental studies, points out that many communities around the world are already maladapted to their climates. (Just ask New Orleans.) In the 1990s, he notes, extreme weather events caused more than 300,000 deaths; malaria currently kills between 1 million and 2.6 million people a year. Climate change will affect those problems, but on the margins. Pielke cites a study finding that the global population at risk of malaria would double by 2080 without global warming; climate change increases malaria risk by a further 7 percent.

Climate change, then, is a reason to do more of what makes sense anyway: reduce coastal vulnerability and strengthen homes to minimize hurricane damage, improve public health and develop drugs to fight malaria, and so on. There is nothing radical about any of this. No rethinking of capitalism is required.

Given how neatly adaptation dovetails with the sustainability agenda, and given its immense potential to relieve whatever human suffering that global warming causes, one might think environmentalists would tout it to the skies. Some do, but many seem to believe that reducing harm distracts from the real job, which is to reduce emissions.

In a blog post last year (at gristmill.org), an environmentalist named David Roberts made the point with startling candor. "In an ideal, abstract policy debate, sure, I'd say we should boost our attention to adaptation," he wrote. "But in the current political situation, I don't want to provide any ammunition for the moral cretins who are squirming frantically to avoid policies that might impact their corporate donors."

This is like denigrating HIV treatment and blocking condom distribution in order to discourage promiscuity. And it is every bit as callous and irresponsible. Where climate change is concerned, the truth -- and this truth really is inconvenient, or at least sad -- is that too many activists and politicians mistake panic for virtue.


-- Jonathan Rauch is a senior writer for National Journal magazine, where "Social Studies" appears. His e-mail address is jrauch@nationaljournal.com.
 
:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: NY TIMES PLANS HIT ON GORE, NEWSROOM SOURCES TELL DRUDGE: 'Scientists argue that Gore's warnings are full of exaggerated claims and startling errors'... Reporter William Broad filing the story, 'A CALL TO COOL THE HYPE'... Developing...
 
busybody said:
:rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: :rolleyes: NY TIMES PLANS HIT ON GORE, NEWSROOM SOURCES TELL DRUDGE: 'Scientists argue that Gore's warnings are full of exaggerated claims and startling errors'... Reporter William Broad filing the story, 'A CALL TO COOL THE HYPE'... Developing...

CYA piece?

Ishmael
 
I actually believe that Algore does MORE harm to the cause then good

Yes, a great many flock to him and believe him to be THE GORACLE, but those are committed to the cause anyway


But he does turn off the fringes and so many others

I HATE Algore
 
busybody said:
I actually believe that Algore does MORE harm to the cause then good

Yes, a great many flock to him and believe him to be THE GORACLE, but those are committed to the cause anyway


But he does turn off the fringes and so many others

I HATE Algore

Let it go BB. Rather, let him go. Hell, encourage the SOB. I'm tempted to send a check just so he'll make even more outrageous claims. The sooner that happens, the sooner the whole religious movement will fall on it's ass and all the scientific parasites will be looking for other hosts.

Ishmael
 
:p :p :p Let No One Say God Has No Sense of Humor

Global warming "awareness" trek to North Pole called off due to frostbite:

MINNEAPOLIS - A North Pole expedition meant to bring attention to global warming was called off after one of the explorers got frostbite. :D :D :D :D
 
If you have what the rest of us like to think of as an actual life, you may be unaware not only that 2007 is the 25th year of The Weather Channel, but that Hollywood Democrats - as witnessed in TWC’s two new miniseries celebrating this 25th anniversary: “100 Biggest Weather Moments” AND “Epic Conditions” - are in bigger trouble than they’d thought.

I toss two names into the hat here as evidence of this: Hollywood Democratic fundraiser and environmental activist Laurie David, who’s married to Larry David of “Curb Your Enthusiasm,” and actress Jennifer Garner, who looks pretty when running around in front of weather.

Now even as a Republican, of course I believe in global warming: there’s just too much scientific evidence, just as I dislike seeing even conservative Republicans starting arguments against evolution. It doesn’t make either side look particularly smart.

But although Laurie David was on hand at The Weather Channel’s winter press tour promoting “100 Biggest Weather Moments” (and, of course, discussing global warming), you could practically feel the hostility against her. And the room was filled with press people - you know, the sort we’d expect to be on her side anyway.

But she got snappish at even the blandest questions tossed her way, such as: “Isn’t this just another normal weather cycle?”

“I urge you to see ‘An Inconvenient Truth,’” David responded irritably. “Because Al Gore addresses that beautifully. In charts.”

Oh, just what we need - charts. OK, then. Both “Epic Conditions” and “100 Biggest Weather Moments” premiere this month.

“And by the way, I have extra DVDs in my bag, so I’d love to give you one when I’m done.”

Mrs. David was no more helpful when asked about global warming costs, which you’d think by now would be a pretty basic question she’s encountered.

“Well…I don’t know…I can’t answer that specifically…but there’s a Stern report that just came out in London that addresses that completely,” she said. “But the costs of not dealing with this problem is going to be so much greater than the cost of dealing with it…”

Which are, basically, that Laurie David has no idea about dollar figures so stop pestering her already. Not the most effective way to get your message across, but maybe that’s just my opinion.

My other favorite Weather Channel moment - as long as we’re talking about the 100 Biggest Ones - was when someone asked what, exactly, Jennifer Garner had to do with all this? Why was she one of the talking heads in the documentary? I expected maybe to hear something about outrunning a tornado, for instance. But no, the answer was much better.

“We kept hearing from people over and over again that their first iconic image of a twister was from ‘The Wizard of Oz,’” said TWC’s programming vp Kaye Zusmann. “That was a very scary moment for them, and though you don’t see it here[ital — CS] I would like to say that Jennifer actually did play a tornado in her elementary school’s production of ‘The Wizard of Oz’ and she was still traumatized by that.”

That, as you can imagine, brought down the house. Or at least everyone stopped pretending to take all this seriously and began counting down the minutes… or at least the biggest ones remaining… to lunch.

Still, I did manage to get in one incredulous question of my own, about someone saying in one of the new Weather Channel mini-series that the Challenger Disaster was the first time we’d realized, collectively: “Wow, Mother Nature is so much more powerful than we are.”

I wondered what The Weather Channel people meant by that, since the Challenger had happened at least decades after the Johnstown Flood, the Great Dustbowl, and a lot of other Weather Moments that affected more lives, on a vastly more miserable and bigger scale, than even the photographically rich Challenger.

“I think that might have been that person’s opinion,” said TWC’s hurricane expert Steve Lyons carefully. “It definitely wasn’t mine.”

So…a bit of a stretch then?

“I guess my generation is kind of ‘What happened when JFK got shot,’ suggested TWC’s on-camera meteorologist Paul Goodloe, equally carefully. “So it’s kind of like one point in time you can say, ‘I know where I as when I heard about the Challenger exploding.’”

Well, I know where I was too - in my kitchen, watching TV - but I don’t think that makes this a particularly Epic, or even Biggest, moment.

Then someone asked if The Weather Channel had ever shown anything that supported global warming skeptics. Kaye Zusmann said she couldn’t really hear the question, someone else referred the questioner to a new series (which premiered in fall) called “The Climate Code,” that tries to present all viewpoints.

Then we all really did begin counting down the biggest minutes until lunch.
 
VIN SUPRYNOWICZ: Calming hysteria, one zealot at a time


Last week, we ran a sampling of fan mail on my latest expose of the "global warming" hysteria.

Let's stipulate once more that I do not side with a "no-global-warming crowd" -- if there really is a sizable group of such folks. For the most part, this is a debate between:


-- A bunch of superannuated children who want to shut down Western industrial civilization to propitiate their Earth goddess and save a few polar bears -- oblivious to the fact this would price motor cars, fresh fruit and central heating out of the reach of the average person;

-- and those of us who agree some minor, cyclical climate warming is going on, while contending it shows no evidence of being catastrophic, and that man's activities make such a tiny contribution to the phenomenon that any attempt to alter this outcome by driving different vehicles or mandating expensive windmills is unlikely to prove any more effective than throwing salt over your shoulder.

Now let's examine the other side, as a fellow I'll call True Believer No. 1 writes to complain:

"1) It is true that the Earth's weather has a built in fluctuation between warming and cooling and I seem to remember that it is on about a 1,500-year cycle. However, that cycle is a very mild one and does not even begin to explain the fact that a 5,000-year-old ice shelf had disappeared in Antarctica along with a 10,000-year-old one. If this warming were simply part of the 1,500-year cycle those ice shelves would not have broken up.

"2) When an article's author starts making ridiculous claims or resorts to absurdities in an attempt to make a point his credibility quickly goes to zero. The First Amendment reference is a perfect example. No real journalist would try to associate environmentalism with religion, especially not in the way this author has.

"3) Your article misrepresents conclusions by credible scientists. From (the Suprynowicz column): 'What's more, scientists at Ohio State University announced Feb. 12 that Antarctic "temperatures during the late 20th century did not climb as had been predicted by many global climate models." In fact, they went down. ...'

"From the actual report: 'It's hard to see a global warming signal from the mainland of Antarctica right now,' he said. 'Part of the reason is that there is a lot of variability there. It's very hard in these polar latitudes to demonstrate a global warming signal. This is in marked contrast to the northern tip of the Antarctic Peninsula that is one of the most rapidly warming parts of the Earth.'

"Should I continue?"

Gracious. Where to start?

1) Indeed, it appears the major ice shelves in Antarctica did not disappear during previous periods of global warming more severe than now forecast -- from 1,100 to 2,300 years ago, and from 4,000 to 6,000 years ago. (See the elephant seal entry of Dec. 20, 2006, at www.spectator.org/dsp_article.asp?art_id=10778.) So there's no reason to assume they're going to melt now.

Dr. Wibjörn Karlén, emeritus professor (physical geography and quaternary geology), Stockholm University, admits, "Some small areas in the Antarctic Peninsula have broken up recently, just like it has done back in time. The temperature in this part of Antarctica has increased recently, probably because of a small change in the position of the low pressure systems."

But Karlén clarifies that the "mass balance" of Antarctica is positive -- more snow is accumulating than melting off. When Greenland and Antarctica are assessed together, "their mass balance is considered to possibly increase the sea level by 0.03 mm/year -- not much of an effect," Karlén concludes.

2) Environmentalism is now inculcated in the government schools, into kids too young to bring any skepticism to its mantras, very much in the way the Catholic Church (and others) understand the benefits of having children memorize various catechisms so they can be "confirmed" in the faith before a maturing skepticism kicks in during the teen years. In this regard -- and in the fury unleashed on nonbelievers -- environmentalism functions precisely as a religion, being promoted by government agencies in violation of the constitutional ban on any government establishment of religion.

3) The fact that most scientists (including those at Ohio State) now feel obliged to dance around uttering politically correct caveats when they stumble on inconvenient anti-global warming evidence -- lest they put their careers in danger by declaring the emperor has no clothes -- was the main point of my original column. The OSU press release clearly states:

"Last year, Bromwich's research group reported in the journal Science that Antarctic snowfall hadn't increased in the last 50 years. 'What we see now is that the temperature regime is broadly similar to what we saw before with snowfall. In the last decade or so, both have gone down,' he said."

Read it again. Antarctic temperatures have gone down.

Things do not become "absurd" merely because we haven't thought them through. Our ideas are not proved right by the fact that those who expose the mass delusions of crowds at first appear "absurd" to those who cling to the old paradigm.

Meantime, speaking of polar bears, The Wall Street Journal reported Jan. 3 that the population of the polar bear increased from 5,000 to more than 20,000 over the past 50 years.

But the ice is melllting! It's melllting!


Vin Suprynowicz is assistant editorial page editor of the Review-Journal and author of the book "The Ballad of Carl Drega," (2002) of which the fourth chapter is titled "Mean Greens: Environmentalism As a State Religion." See www.LibertyBookShop.us.
 
Keep those articles coming, I enjoy reading this thread.

It was nice and warm today too!
 
RightField said:
Keep those articles coming, I enjoy reading this thread.

It was nice and warm today too!

81 here today - a record. Beats the shit out of 55 and windy, which we'll probably get next March - or later this month.
 
The hard core believe. Look at LovelyNice's 9-11 thread. Everyone lies...

But, can we be honest, as men of reason, and just think about this for a moment.

Algore might be making a mistatement now and again but that's the sort of thing a "thinking" person looks past when it comes to bettering the conditions of life for the average man. Just because our leader makes a few mistakes, doesn't mean the cause isn't right and just. It doesn't make him a liar leading a misguided quest based upon faulty data, and his own simple, backwards notions of right and wrong, it just makes him more human, like the rest of us...

;) ;)

I don't see Rush Limbaugh giving up his Jet to clean up my kid's air!

:mad:
 
Cap’n AMatrixca said:
The hard core believe. Look at LovelyNice's 9-11 thread. Everyone lies...

But, can we be honest, as men of reason, and just think about this for a moment.

Algore might be making a mistatement now and again but that's the sort of thing a "thinking" person looks past when it comes to bettering the conditions of life for the average man. Just because our leader makes a few mistakes, doesn't mean the cause isn't right and just. It doesn't make him a liar leading a misguided quest based upon faulty data, and his own simple, backwards notions of right and wrong, it just makes him more human, like the rest of us...

;) ;)

Yeah buddy, that's exactly what I want. Cool the place down and put the means to keep myself warm out of my reach.

The religious assholes don't have a clue as to what they're about.

Ishmael
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top