Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
SeanH said:
Did the Academy pay for it?


I dunno

What difference does it make?

Even if they DIDNT, they approved it, it was PART of the GIVE AWAY package THEY gave EVERYONE :cool:
 
busybody said:
I dunno

What difference does it make?

Even if they DIDNT, they approved it, it was PART of the GIVE AWAY package THEY gave EVERYONE :cool:
If they paid for it, it works. You don't understand how the carbon offsetting thing works, do you?
 
Sure I do

It means if YOU have money

you can BUY credits from NEGROZ in the JUNGLE that has no emmissions

and YOU can spew SHIT without showing a footprint

:rolleyes:
 
ma_guy said:
... Let me ask you this - Which would be easier, have less financial impact and be better for the enviironment in the long run:

a.) The guy that is raising a family of 4 on a $30K/year salary retrofitting his entire house to reduce his carbon footprint by 5% or

b.) Al Gore, who is a multi-millionaire, moving to a much smaller and energy efficient house and reducing his carbon footprint by 3000%.


Whether or not someone "lives green within their lifestyle" is NOT the question. Not only is it not the question, it is an idea that can't even be defined. It is a nice fuzzy way to laying the blame for environmental problems at someone else's feet. Want to waste more energy? Simply redefine your "lifestyle" and it suddenly becomes ok!

The question is "What is the persons total impact on the environment?"

False dilemma. Try again.

As an example of what the 30K person can do, many people have their water heater thermostats turned up too high. Typically, they can be turned down without any noticeable effect when it comes to washing and bathing, other than you turn the cold water on less because you can stand the hot water better. Turning down a water heater thermostat by a very small amount can reduce an electric bill quite a bit. I dare say it can reduce many electric bills by 5%. No retrofitting of an entire house is involved at all.

There are many little things that can be done to make a home more energy efficient. As you need to replace older appliances, buy energy efficient ones you can afford. Etc, etc.

Hyperbole is fun, but not if you want to be taken seriously.
 
busybody said:
Sure I do

It means if YOU have money

you can BUY credits from NEGROZ in the JUNGLE that has no emmissions

and YOU can spew SHIT without showing a footprint

:rolleyes:
Actually, most of the offset progs are in South America. They're planting trees, carbon fixers, that were destroyed during the rape of the 80's.
 
sexy-girl said:
... but the truth is people don't need to change their lifestyle all that much and industries don't have to be ruined to be more environmental

there's a lot scaremongering by the anti climate change people about the huge sacrifices the environmentalists want people and industries to make

they do that because they're scared because climate change issue can be tackled with sensible choices ... i guess they think it is easier to win the argument of climate change being false if they make the whole issue more frightening

Bingo.

In fact, it's to peoples own benefit to be more responsible. As in my water heater example, use less electricity ... pay the utility less of your paycheck. Most things will pay for themselves over the longterm, if not the shortterm.

But the real problem is that it's Al Gore saying this. This just won't do for many closed-minded Republicans and conservatives, no matter how much may be legitimate about the things he says and recommends.
 
Pookie said:
False dilemma. Try again.

As an example of what the 30K person can do, many people have their water heater thermostats turned up too high. Typically, they can be turned down without any noticeable effect when it comes to washing and bathing, other than you turn the cold water on less because you can stand the hot water better. Turning down a water heater thermostat by a very small amount can reduce an electric bill quite a bit. I dare say it can reduce many electric bills by 5%. No retrofitting of an entire house is involved at all.

There are many little things that can be done to make a home more energy efficient. As you need to replace older appliances, buy energy efficient ones you can afford. Etc, etc.

Hyperbole is fun, but not if you want to be taken seriously.

I didn't say there was nothing the person living on $30K/yr could do. I very clearly asked "Which would be easier, have less financial impact and be better for the enviironment in the long run" - none of which you addressed. Reducing one's electric bill by 5% also doesn't automatically equate to a 5% reduction in their carbon footprint. The footprint is a measurment of the energy consumed - not what one pays for that energy.

If there is hyperbole there it belongs to you. While you are at it, you should look up the concept of a "false dilemma" as a logical fallacy. You've misapplied that was well.
 
Last edited:
ma_guy said:
... Al Gore has made himself into an icon for the greenies and what the article does open up is the question of whether or not he walks the walk or if he's just another talking head.

The article is very sloppy in it's conclusions too. It doesn't consider many things when making it's comparisons. Its agenda is more clear than any of its comparisons.

Hold him accountable, sure. He should practice what he preaches. But c'mon, dude. This article is about as nonpartisan as a State Of The Union address. About the only thing this "research organization" is "committed to achieving" is quite clear too.
 
Pookie said:
The article is very sloppy in it's conclusions too. It doesn't consider many things when making it's comparisons. Its agenda is more clear than any of its comparisons.

Hold him accountable, sure. He should practice what he preaches. But c'mon, dude. This article is about as nonpartisan as a State Of The Union address. About the only thing this "research organization" is "committed to achieving" is quite clear too.
Hello? It's comparing a place that employs 34 people with a retirement bungalow? More lies from wingnuts.
 
SeanH said:
If they paid for it, it works. You don't understand how the carbon offsetting thing works, do you?

I'll bet it's a handy way to get campaign contributions.
 
I find it deeply disturbing that he uses so much energy while preaching at us.

I've replaced all the electric bulbs in my house, installed weather stripping and additional insulation, turned the thermostat down in winter and up in summer and traded in my big car for a small car. It doesn't sound like Al Gore has even taken these small steps since his electric bills have been increasing, not decreasing.

Where is his integrity? I have a friend who has known all the presidents since Reagan. He said Reagen and the Bushs' were gentlemen who treated people well and the Clinton's and Gores treated people like they were serfs.
 
RightField said:
I find it deeply disturbing that he uses so much energy while preaching at us.

I've replaced all the electric bulbs in my house, installed weather stripping and additional insulation, turned the thermostat down in winter and up in summer and traded in my big car for a small car. It doesn't sound like Al Gore has even taken these small steps since his electric bills have been increasing, not decreasing.

Where is his integrity? I have a friend who has known all the presidents since Reagan. He said Reagen and the Bushs' were gentlemen who treated people well and the Clinton's and Gores treated people like they were serfs.
Didn't read the thread, huh?
Moron.
 
ma_guy said:
I didn't say there was nothing the person living on $30K/yr could do. I very clearly asked "Which would be easier, have less financial impact and be better for the enviironment in the long run" - none of which you addressed.


It's a waste of time to address it other than as a ridiculous question to answer with the choices you've given. You're creating an extreme option for shock value. The average 30k person doesn't have to "retrofit" their house to reduce their energy consumption by 5%. Far from it.

ma_guy said:
Reducing one's electric bill by 5% also doesn't automatically equate to a 5% reduction in their carbon footprint. The footprint is a measurment of the energy consumed - not what one pays for that energy.

True, but this "research" organization's in depth analysis involved not much more than comparing electric bills in their article. It's ridiculous to attempt to draw conclusions based on what they presented.

I think Gore is recommending a specific amount we all should try to save. It doesn't mean he believes all have the resources to do it. For most people, being smart about conservation and energy use is very desirable, and keeps money in their pockets. "Smart" to me (and I believe Gore too) doesn't involve going broke to reduce your carbon footprint as much as you can feasibly do.

ma_guy said:
If there is hyperbole there it belongs to you. While you are at it, you should look up the concept of a "false dilemma" as a logical fallacy. You've misapplied that was well.

I don't see where I've exaggerated at all. But feel free to point it out, if you desire.

As to the false dilemma, I did misapply it. The point I should've made is that the option for the 30k dude was silly at best. I provided you with a few reasonable options to your option of "retrofitting" a house in order to attempt to achieve whatever goal is set. Sure, it'll be easier for someone with more money. It'll be easier for someone making 40K, 50K, etc. The question has no meaningful value. However, there are many many more people making 30k than there are multimillionaires in mansions. So, which is easier? What is the impact of the "30k people" vs. all the "millionaires in mansions" on the environment? But then, why does it have to be one versus the other? Why can't it just be everyone doing what they can within their means without having to change the way each lives much, if at all? Is Al Gore advocating that the 30k people go broke to become become energy efficient? Pffft.

Being energy efficient, etc. doesn't have to require going broke or changing your lifestyle much, if any at all ... not if you use your head.
 
Last edited:
SeanH said:
Hello? It's comparing a place that employs 34 people with a retirement bungalow? More lies from wingnuts.

It's Al Gore. He is the debil, doncha know?
 
RightField said:
I find it deeply disturbing that he uses so much energy while preaching at us.

I've replaced all the electric bulbs in my house, installed weather stripping and additional insulation, turned the thermostat down in winter and up in summer and traded in my big car for a small car. It doesn't sound like Al Gore has even taken these small steps since his electric bills have been increasing, not decreasing.

So, if the energy he uses might happen to cost more per KWH possibly, would that assuage your deeply disturbed mind? Other than the bottom line of his utility bills, what more do you know about his energy usage that would cause you to become so "deeply disturbed". I have no clue from what's been presented what his real energy requirements are, and if he's being efficient with his use. Do you have the details?
 
Pookie said:
So, if the energy he uses might happen to cost more per KWH possibly, would that assuage your deeply disturbed mind? Other than the bottom line of his utility bills, what more do you know about his energy usage that would cause you to become so "deeply disturbed". I have no clue from what's been presented what his real energy requirements are, and if he's being efficient with his use. Do you have the details?

I agree. Gore should be able to use all the power he wants and can afford. And isn't that the same message he's delivering?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top