Another inconvenient truth

Status
Not open for further replies.
Ham Murabi said:
I agree. Gore should be able to use all the power he wants and can afford. And isn't that the same message he's delivering?
Didn't read your own thread, did you, retard?
 
SeanH said:
Didn't read your own thread, did you, retard?

Don't recognize sarcasm, do you, retard.
It helps explain why you don't recognize Gore's "do as I say, not as I do" hypocrisy.
 
Ham Murabi said:
Don't recognize sarcasm, do you, retard.
It helps explain why you don't recognize Gore's "do as I say, not as I do" hypocrisy.
You got the shit kicked out of you.
Why do you try another? Oh, yeah, I kicked the shit out of you on guns. Try that, again. Moron.
 
What a strange twist this thread is. The GeeBee's defenders of the down-trodden and unwashed tree-huggers jumping to the defense of the ultra-rich elitists.

Next they will be saying Teddy can have a drink or 10 because that's his standard of living.
 
Pookie said:
It's a waste of time to address it other than as a ridiculous question to answer with the choices you've given. You're creating an extreme option for shock value. The average 30k person doesn't have to "retrofit" their house to reduce their energy consumption by 5%. Far from it.

I did no such thing and you know it. In fact you conceed the point farther below in your response.

True, but this "research" organization's in depth analysis involved not much more than comparing electric bills in their article. It's ridiculous to attempt to draw conclusions based on what they presented.

They didn't claim there research was "in-depth" - that's another red herring on your part. They listed what his energy (gas and eletric) was and compared it to the national average. Your attempt to make it into something more than that is one exanple of your hyperbole. They also show that his useage has been increasing.

As to the false dilemma, I did misapply it. The point I should've made is that the option for the 30k dude was silly at best. I provided you with a few reasonable options to your option of "retrofitting" a house in order to attempt to achieve whatever goal is set.

You listed a few options that would reduce some electric consumption. They hardly make up much of anything however. You've obviously never owned an older home and had to pay the utilities on it.

Sure, it'll be easier for someone with more money.

Thank you for conceeding the point. ;)

It'll be easier for someone making 40K, 50K, etc. The question has no meaningful value. However, there are many many more people making 30k than there are multimillionaires in mansions. So, which is easier? What is the impact of the "30k people" vs. all the "millionaires in mansions" on the environment?

The question isn't all of the people making $30K vs. all of the millionaires. It is a question of what the average household is being asked to do vs. what the one person doing the asking is doing. As you've conceeded above, it would be easier on Al Gore's wallet to retrofit his home than it would be for someone making $30K. In fact, it should be well within Al Gore's ability to move completely "off the grid" and eliminate any commercial electrical power use at all. But he isn't doing that.

But then, why does it have to be one versus the other? Why can't it just be everyone doing what they can within their means without having to change the way each lives much, if at all?

It doesn't have to be one vs. the other. But the fact the Gore is so outspoken on the issue and claims to be moving to alternative enery suppliers and "doing his part" and yet the evidence is that his total consumption continues to rise. You don't see any hypocrisy in that? Why isn't he doing what is within his means?

Is Al Gore advocating that the 30k people go broke to become become energy efficient? Pffft.

Another red herring and more hyperbole on your part. No, he isn't asking people making $30K to go broke. He isn't using the money/resources he has readily available to do what he can to cut his own energy use either.

Being energy efficient, etc. doesn't have to require going broke or changing your lifestyle much, if any at all ... not if you use your head.

Apparently someone needs to tell Al to start using his.

"The environmental crisis (leads me to) conclude that I have not gone nearly far enough. The time has long since come to take more political risks ... We must make the rescue of the environment the central organizing principle for civilization ... We can believe in (the) future and work to preserve it, or we can whirl blindly on, behaving as if one day there will be no children to inherit our legacy. The choice is ours; the earth is in the balance."

Well I will agree with Al there. He hasn't gone far enough...
 
DavidJericho said:
What a strange twist this thread is. The GeeBee's defenders of the down-trodden and unwashed tree-huggers jumping to the defense of the ultra-rich elitists.

It is a bit odd isn't it?
 
Funny how a debate over Gore being a hypocrite turned into an argument over the reality of "Global Warming". :rolleyes:

If you can't win the argument, change the subject...
 
I think we ought to do everything we can to cut down on our use of fossil fuels. I think we ought to do it in a global way so that China and India do it also and it should be done in a smart and prudent way. Lets start with Al Gore's house. Can anybody donate some flouresent bulbs to him?
 
What the fuck is all of this? Who cares whether Gore or Bush is the greener? And who declared Messenger Season?

It's irrelevant whether you're in agreement with Gore's Oscar speech or with Bush's 2006 State of the Union speech, because they both told us the same thing.
 
spiderrand said:
Funny how a debate over Gore being a hypocrite turned into an argument over the reality of "Global Warming". :rolleyes:

If you can't win the argument, change the subject...

Exactly.
 
Ham Murabi said:
I agree. Gore should be able to use all the power he wants and can afford. And isn't that the same message he's delivering?

I'm sure people with a finger in one of their ears, or mindlessly chanting "Gore's the debil" loud enough probably do hear something like that.

Is that what you hear?
 
ma_guy said:
I did no such thing and you know it. In fact you conceed the point farther below in your response.

Sure you did. Has Gore suggested that people on 30k go out and "retrofit" their house? You presented the option for shock value alone. If you were even attempting to be serious with the discussion, you would've recognized that people can accomplish much, and actually save money in the short and longterm, by doing some very simple things in their homes. But do carry on. I recognized the partisan bullshit with the opening post. Far be it for me to rain on your parade.

ma_guy said:
They didn't claim there research was "in-depth" - that's another red herring on your part. They listed what his energy (gas and eletric) was and compared it to the national average. Your attempt to make it into something more than that is one exanple of your hyperbole. They also show that his useage has been increasing.

I know they didn't claim it. But I typically expect such from a "nonpartisan research" organization that is serious about their mission. My bad.

ma_guy said:
You listed a few options that would reduce some electric consumption. They hardly make up much of anything however. You've obviously never owned an older home and had to pay the utilities on it.

Cute how you left out this part of my quote (I've added some bolding so you might see it past your blinders")

"I think Gore is recommending a specific amount we all should try to save. It doesn't mean he believes all have the resources to do it. For most people, being smart about conservation and energy use is very desirable, and keeps money in their pockets. "Smart" to me (and I believe Gore too) doesn't involve going broke to reduce your carbon footprint as much as you can feasibly do."


ma_guy said:
Thank you for conceeding the point. ;)

You're welcome.

ma_guy said:
The question isn't all of the people making $30K vs. all of the millionaires. It is a question of what the average household is being asked to do vs. what the one person doing the asking is doing. As you've conceeded above, it would be easier on Al Gore's wallet to retrofit his home than it would be for someone making $30K. In fact, it should be well within Al Gore's ability to move completely "off the grid" and eliminate any commercial electrical power use at all. But he isn't doing that.

But again, the question is just silly. It's easier for someone making 31k to do things than someone making 30k. Duh. The more money you have, generally things do become easier. Yeah, it's easier for Gore to do it. So freakin' what? What is your point? You have an article that looks at his utility bills in complete isolation of anything else. The thread was nothing more than an attempt to smear Gore on some flimsy evidence by a "research organization" that is a complete joke. So again, it's easier for Gore. So what?


ma_guy said:
It doesn't have to be one vs. the other. But the fact the Gore is so outspoken on the issue and claims to be moving to alternative enery suppliers and "doing his part" and yet the evidence is that his total consumption continues to rise. You don't see any hypocrisy in that? Why isn't he doing what is within his means?

I don't see enough evidence to make any such judgment about any alleged hypocrisy. That's my freakin' point. It would be silly for me to make a judgment like that based solely on his electric bills without knowing a lot more details, especially considering the context this all was presented in by this "nonpartisan" organization. The only real evidence I see is people jumping to conclusions with little facts to base it on.


ma_guy said:
Another red herring and more hyperbole on your part. No, he isn't asking people making $30K to go broke. He isn't using the money/resources he has readily available to do what he can to cut his own energy use either.

Exactly. Fight fire with fire. Fight hyperbole for hyperbole. Fun game, huh? Can I pick the next person to smear with little evidence? Huh? Huh? Can I?


ma_guy said:
Apparently someone needs to tell Al to start using his.


Really? Based on just his utility bills? Cool. You'd fit in nicely at that research organization, dude. Just sayin'.
 
debunking a rather lame debunking
Since the Tennessee Center for Policy Research broke the story about Al Gore’s energy consumption Monday afternoon, a predictable pattern of counter-stories followed: the TCPR is illegitimate, the information is a lie, it doesn’t matter because the underlying story of global warming is still real, his energy consumption isn’t really that bad . . .

It’s on this latter point that I can lend some background. An example of that line of thinking is this from The Anonymous Liberal:

The press release claimed that Al Gore’s home in Nashville consumed 221,000 kilowatt hours (kWh) of electricity last year compared to a national average of 10,656 kWh per household. . . . The 10,656 number comes from data published by the Department of Energy. But it’s an average of all households nationwide (including apartment units and mobile homes) and across all climate regions. As it turns out, the region in which Gore lives–the East South Central–has the highest per household energy usage of any climate region in the country, a good 50% higher than the national average quoted in the press release (I assume this is due to the combination of cold winters and hot, muggy summers). So that’s misleading in and of itself.

Moreover, Gore lives in a large home (10,000 sq. ft.). If you look at the data, it’s clear that Gore’s energy usage per square foot (even assuming the 221,000 kWh number is accurate) is well within the average range for his climate region. . .

But is that true?

The Krumms are fortunate enough to live in a relatively nice section of West Nashville, just like Al Gore. We moved in to our house in late 2002, just like Al Gore. We then began a major renovation of our home, just like Al Gore. We also have a large home, although it’s only about half the size of Al Gore’s. So let’s do some math.

Rather than taking the TCPR at its word about the Gores’ energy consumption, lets rely instead upon documentation provided by Nashville Electric Service just today. It shows that in the last twelve months he consumed 194,250 KWH of energy, ranging from a high of 22,619 KWH in August to a low of 12,098 in December. That compares with our annual energy consumption of 35,215 KWH. Accounting for home size, the five members of the Krumm household consumed 7.34 KWH per square foot over the last twelve months. During the same period, Mr. and Mrs. Gore used 19.43 KWH per square foot–nearly three times our family’s energy consumption.

Okay, so maybe he has electric heat. We should then compare gas bills to get a complete picture.

Unfortunately, I don’t have access to his gas bills, but since the TCPR has proved itself worthy with its accurate portrayal of the electrical data, let’s just take their numbers.

They claim (via Drudge) that the Gore household used $6,432 worth of gas in 2006, ranging from a monthly high of $990 to a low of $170. By contrast our gas bill was only $1,137 last year, with a monthly range from $33 to $205.

Again, accounting for size, in 2006 the Krumms spent 24 cents per square foot to heat our home and water, and to cook our meals. The Gores spent nearly triple that amount: 64 cents per square foot.

But wait there’s more. That’s just the main house. When you add in the Gore’s pool and pool house ($6,528 last year) they paid $1.30 per square foot for gas–more than five times what we spent during the same period just a few blocks away.

I mentioned the renovations that both the Krumm and Gore houses recently underwent. Mary Mancini called the Gore’s home improvements “modest.” Umm . . . from someone (in the construction industry, btw) who lives in the neighborhood and daily ran by his house, let me just tell you that there was nothing modest about the renovations to the Gore household.

According to public records the Gores have pulled 13 construction permits since buying their home in June of 2002. Firms pulling the permits include: a swimming pool company, an audio-visual installer, and a number of electrical, mechanical, and plumbing firms.

We pulled ten permits during the same period. But even that’s misleading, because while we pulled all of our permits through the city of Nashville, since the Gore’s live in Belle Meade, they only pulled sub-permits through Nashville. Their construction and demolition permits would have been generated in Belle Meade, making their total number of permits even larger. I say all this to say that the Gore’s home renovations were NOT modest.

Still, in spite of the fact that the entire Gore home was under renovation for over a year, they didn’t apparently incorporate significant energy-saving ideas into the design–at least not until now. The result is that they spent several hundreds of thousands of dollars on home improvements but still have a house that will consume a million dollars worth of energy over the length of a thirty year mortgage–a cost which is three to five times higher than what it should be, even accounting for the size of his large home.

I think that you have to go back to the forged 60 Minutes documents to find another example of a story that broke so quickly and so thoroughly, but was so viciously denied–against all evidence–by partisans who refused to believe the facts.

And the facts are this. Four and a half years ago Al Gore bought a large home and made it larger, but did very little to reduce his own energy consumption. Instead, he spent the same time telling you how to reduce yours.
 
WOW, lots of lefty email about the Al Gore story, charging lies, "swiftboating," and smears. Hmm. Is the story a lie? Well, there's this:


Kalee Kreider, a spokesperson for the Gores, did not dispute the Center's figures, taken as they were from public records.


"Swiftboating" seems to mean the disclosure of truths that are, er, inconvenient for Democrats. Likewise "smears." And, actually, in lefty blogland parlance these days, "lies" pretty much come out the same way. All definitions are permitted the definer, so long as they are clear, but don't expect me to be impressed with this batch.



Plus, perspective from Les Jones: "Our electric and water bill was $79.68 and our natural gas bill was $75.72. Gore is using roughly 2000% of the energy of our family of four in a house that's roughly 600% bigger, so basically three times as much energy even after adjusting for square footage. Does he have a 24 hour disco or something?"
 
Kalee Kreider, a spokesperson for the Gores, did not dispute the Center's figures, taken as they were from public records.



Kalee Kreider, a spokesperson for the Gores, did not dispute the Center's figures, taken as they were from public records.



Kalee Kreider, a spokesperson for the Gores, did not dispute the Center's figures, taken as they were from public records.


Kalee Kreider, a spokesperson for the Gores, did not dispute the Center's figures, taken as they were from public records.
 
MORE ON CARBON OFFSETS, at The Economist: "I find it hard to believe that Mr Gore has actually reduced his carbon output 'as much as possible'—and if Mr Gore so believes, I invite him to take a train up to New York, where I will show him what a more carbon efficient lifestyle looks like. The carbon offsets, on the other hand, sound like a very reasonable plan. That is, they did until I began thinking about them. . . . Obviously, the same is true of individual conservation efforts. Thats why any attempt to abate global warming has to be massive. Huge numbers of people in the rich world have to fly less, drive less, consume less, and live in smaller houses. If Mr Gore really wants to encourage this (as I do), then he should try leading by example. "

Read the whole thing.
 
You LEFTISTS

have shown yourself for what you are

HIPPO CREEPS of the FIRST ORDER
 
spiderrand said:
Funny how a debate over Gore being a hypocrite turned into an argument over the reality of "Global Warming". :rolleyes:

If you can't win the argument, change the subject...

It's even funnier that since the Right has no argument when it comes to global warming, they change the subject to Gore's personal energy use.

When you can't discredit the message, discredit the messenger.
:rolleyes:
 
You have twisted yourselves into all shapes to explain away SHEER HYPOCRACY

going as far as to suggest that RICH ELITISTS like the Gores

would actually employ LITTLE PEOPLE in their homes to ANSWER PHONES about the movie

What utter trash

You all cant have the trait of shame in you, otherwise you would be so ashamed of yourselves that you would never appear here again
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top