Books you could re-read for the first time

HordHolm

Literotica Guru
Joined
May 23, 2020
Posts
1,376
There's a podcast and youtube channel I quite often listen to/watch (The Rest is History), and they asked a question recently which I thought might be interesting here: which three books would you love to re-read again for the first time?

I'll go first...

1. I, Claudius, by Robert Graves. I read it in my early teens, and whilst I was already historically inclined, this one hit the precise spot necessary to give human interest, humour, drama and plausible detail. Yes, it's historical fiction, not straight history, and though I know a lot more now about the period in question and I can see the liberties Graves took, I still regard it as a masterpiece of the genre.

2. Clochemerle, by Gabriel Chevallier. Not well known in the English-speaking world, this is a French satirical novel (and no, I didn't read it in the original. Sadly my French is at the "Ou est la poste?" level). It is set in a 1920s village, in which a wily mayor puts forward a plan to erect a urinal in front of the village church, and follows the chaos that ensues. Again, a book I read in my mid-teens, and one which made me realise that, yes, you can really write that if you want.

3. Flashman at the Charge, by George Macdonald Fraser. I came relatively late to Flashman (I was in my late twenties), when a friend handed it to me and said, simply, "you NEED to read this." This is volume 4 of the series, which is the fake autobiography of a Victorian hero, who is in fact a philandering coward with all the morals of an alley cat (though he is occasionally braver than he knows), and it follows Flashman as a cavalry officer in the Crimean War. This book made me feel dizzy with its brilliant depiction of historical events (Fraser did his homework), surrounding a fictional character. Up there with Graves when it comes to historical fiction.
 
I'll give this some more thought, but I just wanted to say that the Flashman Papers were right up there as soon as I saw the thread title.
 
Dune
There is so much in it that each time (7 so far) it almost is like the first time.

The Princess Bride
So fun.

Neuromancer
This comes with a caveat: I wish I could read it again for the first time, but in the early 1990s again, not today.
 
Every single Terry Pratchett book.

Also, Jurassic Park, The Princess Bride (like Britva, amazing book), and the Wess'har series by Karen Travis (great sci-fi, lots of interesting twists and very cool aliens).
 
I love The Rest is History! So good.

Yes, I think on this... though, to be honest, I re-read favourite books all the time.
 
I love The Rest is History! So good.

Yes, I think on this... though, to be honest, I re-read favourite books all the time.
Re-reading my OP I didn't make their point clear enough - they were referring to the idea that the first time you read the book it has that perfect impact, one that can't be replicated. But yes, I dust off favourites all the time.
 
Every single Terry Pratchett book.

Also, Jurassic Park, The Princess Bride (like Britva, amazing book), and the Wess'har series by Karen Travis (great sci-fi, lots of interesting twists and very cool aliens).
If it had been the four books you could re-read, Mort by Pratchett would be there. That was an eye-opener. It had only just been released, and I'd never heard of him. Anyway, I was sitting in a mate's car while he was doing something, and he was taking forever over it, and there was Mort sitting on the dashboard, and so I picked it up, and OMG!!
 
Ones that were completely unlike anything I'd ever read before. Ones where the first reading was a revelation. Of late I've reduced my library (because of repeated house moves) to an essential minimum, and among those that remain I can see three that were such overwhelming first reads:

Keri Hulme, The Bone People
Toni Morrison, Beloved
Milan Kundera, The Unbearable Lightness of Being

And a fourth one, Roald Dahl's Matilda, because I only knew him from his adult short stories like Kiss Kiss.
 
If it had been the four books you could re-read, Mort by Pratchett would be there. That was an eye-opener. It had only just been released, and I'd never heard of him. Anyway, I was sitting in a mate's car while he was doing something, and he was taking forever over it, and there was Mort sitting on the dashboard, and so I picked it up, and OMG!!
If I'd been paying attention, I would've noticed the whole "three books" thing 😅 Sorry, I was excited by the prospect of memory wiping Pratchett's oeuvre and the pure joy of rereading it all.

Sorry, other authors, all three are Pratchett. And by sorry, I mean not even a little bit.

1. Small Gods. One of the most perfect books I've ever read. A pure joy to read.
2. Guards! Guards! My first Pratchett book, read it in 8th grade. Ruined fantasy for me, blew my 13-year-old mind.
3. Jingo. Just a fun book. A brewing war, two armies, one officer to stop it all.
 
If I'd been paying attention, I would've noticed the whole "three books" thing 😅 Sorry, I was excited by the prospect of memory wiping Pratchett's oeuvre and the pure joy of rereading it all.

Sorry, other authors, all three are Pratchett. And by sorry, I mean not even a little bit.

1. Small Gods. One of the most perfect books I've ever read. A pure joy to read.
2. Guards! Guards! My first Pratchett book, read it in 8th grade. Ruined fantasy for me, blew my 13-year-old mind.
3. Jingo. Just a fun book. A brewing war, two armies, one officer to stop it all.
Small Gods is genius. Sometimes, a non-Pratchett reader will ask me for a recommendation, and this is my go to.
 
A lot of the books that come to mind wouldn't have the same impact now as they did when I first read them.

The Sword of Shannara in the early 80s when I was gasping for epic fantasy? Mindblowing! Now, it would be distinctly meh. A Stainless Steel Is Born when I was a snarky teen? The perfect book! Now? Still enjoyable, but I no longer identify with Slippery Jim diGriz.

But... I'll say The Spanish Bride by Georgette Heyer, which I'd probably appreciate more knowing that it's a true story, that large parts are quoted directly from the diaries of the people involved, and that Harry and Juanita Smith were in fact totally awesome in real life.

Next, Joe Abercrombie's First Law, for bringing people who feel real into the realm of fantasy.

And third, just to show off my literary snobbism, the Middle English Breton Lays, to hopefully give me the push I need to reread all those chivalric romances I spent so much time studying at uni.
 
Ones that were completely unlike anything I'd ever read before. Ones where the first reading was a revelation. Of late I've reduced my library (because of repeated house moves) to an essential minimum, and among those that remain I can see three that were such overwhelming first reads:

Keri Hulme, The Bone People
Toni Morrison, Beloved
Milan Kundera, The Unbearable Lightness of Being

And a fourth one, Roald Dahl's Matilda, because I only knew him from his adult short stories like Kiss Kiss.
I have the Trunchbull's voice down to a tee - at least according to my daughter.
 
But... I'll say The Spanish Bride by Georgette Heyer, which I'd probably appreciate more knowing that it's a true story, that large parts are quoted directly from the diaries of the people involved, and that Harry and Juanita Smith were in fact totally awesome in real life.
She would perhaps (from the afterlife) regard it as her best book, as that's what she always wanted to do, deep historical realism, and yes, after you've had the nice warm bath of Arabella or Devil's Cub or whatever (books I adore), The Spanish Bride is a much stronger dose, and a good example of 'this is how you write when you're serious about writing'.
 
Number one is Joyce's Finnegans Wake. I do re-read it, in whole or part, every year, and each time is, in whole or part, like the first time I read it. There's always something new to discover in language and thought.

Second for me is Melville's Moby Dick. Again, always something more to see. I've been reading it and thinking it since I was eight, when my Uncle gifted me with a copy he had "borrowed" from the library some fourteen years earlier.

Third is difficult; I have three candidates. Barth's Giles Goat-Boy is there, as is Joyce's Ulysses, but I'm going with Melville again, this time The Confidence-Man: HIs Masguerade. Published on April Fool's Day, it is a complex description of the confidence man as all of us.
 
Good Omens.

The Painted House by John Grisham

"Es muss nicht immer Kaviar sein" by Johannes Mario Simmel

Thought I might swap that for 'The Fifth Season' by NK Jemisin, if we're only talking about books written in English.
 
Matilda

The Diary of Anne Frank

And, I know it gets hate, but American Gods.
 
Good Omens.

The Painted House by John Grisham

"Es muss nicht immer Kaviar sein" by Johannes Mario Simmel

Thought I might swap that for 'The Fifth Season' by NK Jemisin, if we're only talking about books written in English.
Good Omens is a book I recommend frequently. And have had to buy 6 copies over the years because I've leant it to people who never return it :cautious: I refuse to let even my family have my current copy.

And, I know it gets hate, but American Gods.
American Gods is amazing. Show, meh, bounced partway through season 2. Book, great. Gaiman is a masterful fabulist.
 
Tom Jones, by Henry Fielding. Only read it once. I liked his complex and comedic view of humanity.

Anna Karenina, Tolstoy. I read it 44 years ago and haven't re-read it since.

The Peloponnesian War, Thucydides. One of the biggest influences on my love of history.
 
Tom Jones, by Henry Fielding. Only read it once. I liked his complex and comedic view of humanity.

Anna Karenina, Tolstoy. I read it 44 years ago and haven't re-read it since.

The Peloponnesian War, Thucydides. One of the biggest influences on my love of history.
My dad kind of forced Tom Jones on me in my early 20s. I agree with you and Fielding's complexity (such a well plotted book), and his comedy. The other thing I took away was the realisation that people 250 years ago could see absurdity in the same way us 'moderns' do.
 
My low brow tastes of books that could never hit me again the way they did the first time.

Juliette- Marquis De Sade

Off Season-Jack Ketchum, cult following for its brutality but especially one scene and...if you know, you know.

Girl with a Dragon Tattoo.
 
Back
Top