I’ve had a complicated time with how my wife and I discuss our fantasies. We’ve been together 11 years. For the first half of that, she would just talk about very, very, very vanilla fantasies as far as her desires. She’s basically limited us to lights out, bed time, in the bedroom, in bed, missionary only, absolutely no talking, gotten over with as quickly as possible, so her wildest “taboo” ideas were things like “what if we did it in the morning instead”. Then a few years ago, she started sharing some actual more out there fantasies, things like experimenting with another woman. That didn’t change anything in reality for us, but we got some good mileage out of talking about those fantasies and I thought things were looking positive. Then her interest in these fantasies seemed to ebb, and when I asked about it, she admitted she made them all up, said she had no fantasies, and felt when I asked about fantasies I was trying to fix her and she was happy the way she was.
On my part, I’ve shared my fantasies and now I’m sure doing so is going to come back to haunt me. From the start I’ve shared my fantasies and desires, because that just seems to make sense to do with one’s sexual partner. I held back a bit at first on the more out there ones, but when I thought she was starting to open up, I did as well, thinking we were on the same page. Obviously when she admitted to lying about having fantasies, I suddenly felt very self conscious about what I opened up to her about. But the cats out of the bag, so I continued being honest and open. But now if I talk about my fantasies or desires, she just shuts down. Like mentally removes herself, just sits there silently and unresponsive, like I’m not saying anything and in fact not there at all. And in hindsight, I realized even when she was lying about fantasies and things were looking good, when I was sharing mine she never once asked follow up questions or in any way expressed an interest in learning more, and she never asked about mine in the first place other than a very perfunctory, insincere “and you?” after I asked about hers
On my part, I’ve shared my fantasies and now I’m sure doing so is going to come back to haunt me. From the start I’ve shared my fantasies and desires, because that just seems to make sense to do with one’s sexual partner. I held back a bit at first on the more out there ones, but when I thought she was starting to open up, I did as well, thinking we were on the same page. Obviously when she admitted to lying about having fantasies, I suddenly felt very self conscious about what I opened up to her about. But the cats out of the bag, so I continued being honest and open. But now if I talk about my fantasies or desires, she just shuts down. Like mentally removes herself, just sits there silently and unresponsive, like I’m not saying anything and in fact not there at all. And in hindsight, I realized even when she was lying about fantasies and things were looking good, when I was sharing mine she never once asked follow up questions or in any way expressed an interest in learning more, and she never asked about mine in the first place other than a very perfunctory, insincere “and you?” after I asked about hers